xRedcell
Sinister Potato
xRedcell
I'm very interested to see your sources.
xxx
EDIT: Admittedly it's not a scientific study, but I've grown to respect this man to the point that I take his word as law, his interests are clearly in educating his viewers and he has proven he has a vast amount of experience and knowledge in training and dieting. Plus the man is walking results ffs.
I could say anything I want if I had a populated fan page, but unless it is backed by a study it's not valid. I'm not trying to downplay who you look up to, but all information conveyed should have a source otherwise I simply can't condone it. A different YouTube fitness icon you should take a look into is "Scooby1961". He lists his sources and offers all information and work outs for free. But the information you passed out in this thread simply doesn't make any biological sense.
Being as Scooby is the self proclaimed "King of Broscience", accompanied with the fact that he bans any commentors with conflicting thoughts or facts to those in his videos, I'm going to say it's safe to assume his videos are extremely biased, even if they are sourced. Jason Blaha aka Ice Cream Fitness is easily more knowledgeable and has cited sources in the past, given the fact that he publishes numerous videos a day I will excuse the lack of source for the video in question. Allow me to retort to your no "biological sense" remark, it is widely accepted that in order to grow, we need nutrients, if our caloric intake is the exact same value as our caloric usage we have 0 leftover calories, meaning 0 nutrients are absorbed, therefore in order to grow, a caloric surplus is required. [I don't intend to cite any sources, I'm giving advice to a teen girl, not submitting my thesis] Teens go through puberty -where the majority of growing takes place- and without a caloric surplus, the necessary nutrients aren't going to be available to form new tissue (grow). I mention the reproductive system specifically because that is one of the main/important parts that are developed during puberty whereas height can be ignored essentially. I'm astounded that you can't see the logic here, you don't need to know the first thing about biology to understand that.
SP.