Welcome to Gaia! ::


I'm confused on the passe compose and the imparfait.

I'm so confused over the imparfait's use of progressive actions....

Il etait dans la rue, QUAND Il a vu un chien.

Something like that^.

But it gets confusing when it says stuff like:

Il etait une fois une jolie jeune fillie qui travaillait comme vendeuse dands un magasin de chaussures. Elle ________ (NE PAS AIMER) pas son patrong parce qu'il etait mechante. Il ____ (Adorer) l'argent, et, lui, il ______ (Gagner) d'argents mais les vendueses qui _____ Travailler.


For all those blanks, apprently, you use Impf'.
I'm so confused why. It like, couldnt you say he LIKED money.
I think that'd be like saying, he LIKED it, but he doesnt anymore, and since theres no indication of that, I guess, its wrong. But its confusing, cause' what would that translate to? He was liking money? He used to like money? ---- I have no clue.
Assistiance?
Imparfait is used when there is an habit. it's a fact, she didn't start dislinking her boss, she disliked him for a long time and still dislike him when the story takes place.

The passé composé answer the question "what happened?"
and the imparfait answer the question " What was going on when it happened?"

and it's "patron" and well he is a man so it's "méchant". And you say "de l'argent".

I hope I helped you... smile

O.G. Seeker

Yes, it's quite complicated to explain it to a foreigner, I understand it's not easy...

Let's take your example : "He liked money".
If you were using the passé composé, "Il a aimé l'argent", that would mean you're talking now of a man who used to like money but he doesn't anymore.
So the correct tense is l'imparfait, "Il aimait l'argent". Because you're telling a story about a man who liked money (during all the time of the story).

Let's take the other example : He saw a dog in the street".
Passé compsé : "Il a vu un chien dans la rue". This means that he saw a dog once, at a given moment (like "this morning", or "when he left his home"...).
Imparfait : "Il voyait un chien dans la rue". This would be used about someone who saw the dog several time, for instance "everyday, he used to see a dog in the street", or "anytime he used to leave school early..."

Is it clearer for you ?
Ah Oui, I understand now.


Merci!

Quick Reply

Submit
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum