Super shitty event, in my opinion. We could have definitely used more... reward at the end.
Sorry, but they engaged us, made us explore the events, but now we're going back and looking at it, we're realizing it didn't have much to it.
The halloween event shat on the X-Mas event, and I'm going to put all my eggs in the easter basket (Haha!) in terms of hoping how well they do.
Edit:
Why I personally think the X-Mas Event Sucked:
Points for Bumping/Talking were pretty low- Almost felt like the Korean MMO grind.
Very little explanation behind the event - Why did the X-Mas tree on the event page light up, and de-light...down? What was the number on top of the tree? Why were we destroying or fixing ornaments? Why were there different amounts of rewards? If this was such a grindy event (see previous point) why weren't there grindy rewards? Why no reward for 200 in either category?
Very little variation - Caroling, cool. The forum bumping, giving crappy items to the dumpster or gift-spamming people. Again, was very grindy.