English Elegance
diantichrist
Is forever my mind's image of Sherlock Holmes. Robert Downey Jr will never be Sherlock Holmes and I curse Guy Ritchie for destroying my most beloved fictional character.
Robert Downey Jr is a great actor, and I can see why they chose him to play Sherlock, since he has a history playing characters with that type of personality, but I do agree that those movies weren't very good. Basil Rathbone is a classic and undoubtedly the best, though as far as modern Sherlock goes, Benedict Cumberbatch does a very good job.
I enjoy three Robert Downey Jr movies: Tropic Thunder, Natural Born Killers, and Weird Science. Of the three I only consider Natural Born Killers to be great, and he isn't the star.
I don't know what roles he has played that bring to mind Sherlock Holmes personality, but I don't think that his Sherlock series conveys the personality of the original Sherlock character at all. Besides, my real complaint is that Guy Ritchie turned my beloved detective into a pseudo super hero.
I have nothing against Downey. Honestly, when I hear the name Robert Downey Jr the first thing that comes to my mind is him being so high on drugs that he broke into a strangers house and passed out in their (kids?) bed. Ahh......good time.