Welcome to Gaia! ::

Which was crazier and how do you think the actors did in those rolls? I think this might be an interesting discussion about these two characters and how the actors did in their rolls and how they could have improved it.

First the book and comic book characters themselves. These materials are the guides and outlines where actors and people get their ideas for the villains. Personally I think the Joker is more insane then Bellatrix, though it is close, but to me she seems to have more purpose to her madness. She has reasons why she kills and harms, though she does so in excess and derives joy from it. She did it for the love and loyalty for Voldermort; Whereas The Joker committed his crimes just because he could do it. He wanted to watch others suffer just because. To see how low people could get just before they died, to see their 'true' weakness, was the reason The Joker did what he did. To me that is much more malicious. Both share a disregard for others, a want for power and were completely within their mental capacities to know the difference between right and wrong. So on the crazy scale between 1-10 I give Bellatrix a 9 and Joker an 10.

As for the actors of these characters I believe Helena Bonham Carter, did a very good job with her character. She got the hate and malice pretty well and her go at insanity, which is never easy to act, was good, but somehow I was more afraid of her anger, then her insanity and unpredictability. It was a very good performance though; I couldn't have done better, so I respect her acting in this role. I look forward to seeing her a little more in the last two movies to see how she ads a little more to the character. Though I understand that she is not a main villain, like the Joker, and her character was not as developed, it is still interesting to see her work.

For The Joker, where to begin? I believe Cesar Romero was the first actor who played The Joker in the original 'Batman'. You know the Adam West, ‘Batman’ shows. The POW, ZONK, CRASH! The T.V. show with the Bat Dance, the poor costumes, sets, and overweight characters. For being the first Joker he did well, though his acting, like all other acting at that time, was kind of over the top and hard to believe. But there is a saying, “[n]o one, ever paid to see under the top,” which is true. Cesar Romero stuck more to the side of The Joker who was more like a bully in clown make-up then a deranged, violent, sociopath who murders people, causes chaos and commits crimes for his own amusement. He really stuck with making The Joker seem comic bookish, more then a real criminal/villain. His make-up was to neat, to clean, he had too much reasoning, and his gangsters were overweight and rather comical in their fighting. But he did have a good Joker laugh and it was amusing to watch him.

Then there was the great Jack Nicholson in the 1989 film ‘Batman’. Now that is a Joker smile if ever there was one to emulate. He is the one I remember as my generation's Joker. He had the derangement in the acting and the character was getting more believable. Though it still was over the top, it had both the violent and the ridiculous. I was really afraid of him when I was young, now that I'm older it's not so scary, but still at least this Joker scared me, where as Cesar Romero never really frightened me. Yet again though his make up was too neat and clean, his hair was well kept, as was his suit and he had reasoning but not as much, it seemed. Though this time the fighting scenes where better and more believable.

Next voice actor, Mark Hamill, in the 1990’s ‘Batman: The Animated Series’ television series did very well. While he didn't have to act with his body, his voice was very good for the character of The Joker. Voice acting is just as difficult as real acting, just in different ways. I think he was a good choice for lending his voice, and his laugh was rather like Cesar Romero’s.

Finally now Heath Ledger, in the 2008 ‘Batman Begins’ sequel, ‘The Dark Knight’, was amazing. He had it. He truly went insane for the role (Edited out debatable or misconstrued information.) He got into the character so much he was scaring the staff on set; he had terrible nightmares and wouldn't sleep. I feel terrible he died; I would have liked to see him in another Joker role. He is the Joker to top them all. He was both the weird trickster and the horrible sociopath. The make-up, hair, and suit it was all believable. It was amazing and horrifying. His crimes as the original comic book Batman put it, "make sense to him alone." I won't go into detail to ruin any of the movie for those who have seen it, but I truly believe that if they have another sequel to Batman Returns, they have to get another criminal, other then Joker, because no other actor would do it the justice Heath Ledger did.

Wow this is long. If you make it to the bottom, go you! I really would like to hear what other people think about these two villains and those that played them.