Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply The Smallville Guild!
FiFs "Super"-Analytic (and frankly bizarre) Phantom Recap!

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Foetus In Fetu

PostPosted: Fri May 18, 2007 7:14 pm


l'Ouverture
Quebec. This is exactly what I needed after my French exam, thanks Smallville.

This scene was just a bit too hokey for my liking. We, as a society, are well past the point where seeing a frightened priest wave a crucifix at something alien or 'supernatural' in nature is considered either original or creative. It's cliché-tastic. So, the scene failed to set a suspenseful tone and, taken as a whole, it doesn't make a great deal of sense either.

So, this possessed old guy wounds Martian Manhunter. He hightails it. Lex busts on in and the Phantom escapes. Credits.

A Wizard Did It
Luthor mansion. Creepy music. Lex is talking into a mobile that looks very much like mine; I hope it isn't symbollic of his mental state or, at least, status re: supervillainy. In any case, Lionel is there. He is omnipresent. He is also clean-shaven and has had a haircut -- this is clearly a special occasion!

The main problem I had with this scene was that apparently Lionel materialised just to tell Lex that he looked worried and then leave to deal with his "more pressing matters" (manicure). It's a pathetic excuse to organise character interaction, but I don't begrudge a little Luthor to Luthor face-off. Luthor à Luthor, if you wanna go Quebecois.

"Ever since I put on this wedding ring," says Luthor the younger, "you seem to have an uncanny knack for being one step ahead of me." Lex, what do you mean, since you put on that wedding ring? Do you even watch Smallville? Lionel exists as a character just to be one step ahead of you and several other characters. He is the cement with which plot-holes are filled; in other words "a wizard" never "did it" just because Lionel did, if you catch my drift.

Lex trusts Lana. But not that she has the autonomy to make her own decisions, which is fine, because as I recall neither does Clark, Lionel, Chloe or in fact anybody on this show except for Jimmy. To recap: Lex doesn't think that Lana would spy on him without a little coaxing, and Clark doesn't think she would marry Lex without a little coercing, and in fact, according to the writers, they were both right. A wizard Lionel did it.

"I don't think you're gonna get rid of me that easily," says Lionel. 'You', ostensibly, is Lex, but English is one of those fantastically ambiguous languages where the both the plural and singular forms of addressing the second person are exactly the same. But even if they weren't, he might as well wink at the camera. We know he's not going anywhere.

Flying the Nest
Kent Farm. Martha is looking at a picture of Clark and some guy who died but whose death really accomplished very little in character progression for, well, anybody. Gone, but only remembered as the most wasted plot device in the history of this show; what an accolade. She always thought that Clark would fly the nest before her. We all did, Martha, we all did.

I liked this scene on the whole. My one problem was that I don't see that this year has really been all that hard for Clark. To compare: Lana has had her body and her mind violated, and been coerced into a marriage which for all intents and purposes she wanted to back out of; Chloe discovered that she was meteor infected, found her mother, and lost her mother. The rest of the cast has had assorted things happen to them, all of which have been more trying than sitting on your a** and whining about the wedding of your ex-girlfriend, who you broke up with, to your ex-friend. It would have been different if Martha had referenced the Zoners or Jonathan's death, but she didn't.

Longitude and Latitude -- No Duh.
The Talon. Lois is hard at work. Are we surprised? No, not really.

A lot of people go into journalism because they want to save the world -- uncover the truth, act as the facilitators of the people's right to know and occasionally shout down a few scientologists. Chloe, who wanted to be a journalist apparently all her life has more than once this season expressed hesitation over publishing anything that would get her into trouble with the Luthors (well, fair enough). She is now desperate to have Lois drop the case herself. That is the antithesis of what Lois Lane is about.

It also reminds me of a couple of scenes such as in Nemisis in which Chloe reveals or at least implies that she would be willing to let somebody die if she thought it was for the common good. She then acknowledged that this utilitarian take on bettering the world was not what Clark, as Superman, is about. I feel like they are trying to differentiate Chloe from Lois. That is partly what the half-assed, poorly executed "journalistic rivalry" storyline that never went anywhere was about. It also reminds me of scenes from Combat and Noir where the differences between Lois and Chloe investigative styles were highlighted. Just a thought.

Electricity Denatures Enzymes
Lab. Ah, "alien peptide sequences". Almost a step up from Wither on the rung of pseudo-science spectacular. But a little Biology 101: peptides are proteins. They are molecules. They are not alive. They'd be the same whether Titan was alive or not when you extracted them. Or were they denatured by electricity?

Wait, now it's alien DNA?

Okay, moving on.

2 + 2 = 5
Kent Farm. It would have been more polite for Lana to knock at the front door, but we just had to have the Clana Barn Scene of Doom. I was "moved" by this, physically -- digestively, even, but I am allergic to Clana. Some people are allergic to peanuts, what can I say?

The Clana relationship is the one thing on the show that defies all logic. Most things just defy a little bit of logic, but you know Clana is special. It's special. It has its own bizarro (take a shot) Clanarama-drama-llama-Lana system of logic, to which it completely and utterly does not adhere. There's no getting off this rollercoaster of craziness, you guys, so pass the sick bag because I am going to need it.

So, Smallville likes to waste screentime. It wasted a lot of screentime throughout the whole series, particularly season five and six, characterising Lana as somebody who hates anything that could be extra-terrestrial in origin and copped out on the payoff. She's okay with it, because Clark is not an alien. He is an intergalactic traveller.

The c-word: continuity.

Clark is fine with Lana going behind his back and finding all this stuff out by herself. Remember when Chloe was investigating Clark? Oh screw it. He's fine with it because it was Lana, whereas the rest of us would (and, hey, some of us do) feel violated.

Once again, there is nothing keeping Clana apart except for the hurdles they themselves are putting there. Are they hoping to compete in the Olympics? This is so arbitrary.

Sometimes, I Don't Even Think at All!
Luthorcorp. Once again, Clark thinks later. He actually would have killed Lionel without a little Martian intervention, but what's new? But check it out, you guys: he is wearing that obnoxious blue t-shirt and red jacket combo that used to symbollise something, so basically he tried to kill somebody and Smallville implied it was the Supermanly thing to do. Nice one.

Mansion. Lana is leaving Lex. I'm surprised she didn't send him an e-mail. Lex hits Lana. He is losing it. Whatever.

Luthorcorp. Exposition. This would have been a nice place to characterise Clark as somebody for whom the ends don't justify the means. Instead, he is confused. You're always confused, Clark: it's hardly a headline. So, the only good thing I could pull out of this scene in terms of characterisation was that, in true think first, act later style, Clark was willing to go straight after the phantom himself. To reach for the Kristin Kreuk connection, and be all Wizard of Earthsea here: he should have considered what would happen if he lost control of his body. It's not like it's never happened before.

You know, with all the time Clark spends at the Daily Planet, he could probably get a job there.

Deathly Dam of Doom
Reeve's dam. Lois Thinks on her feet. Lois kicks a**. Lois beats a guy up even after being stabbed in the gut. Lois, don't pull the knife out!

Metropolis. Clearly a fakeup. Whatever. Either way, revenge is immediately more important to Clark than finding the phantom.

Reeve's dam. The Chloe/Lois scene was better executed than I thought it would be. At least the tears weren't green.

Lab. Alien peptides! Those must be some huge-a** peptides (and/or DNA) for Mad Scientist #0 to identify them under a light microscope. They could at least have had him swill around some test tubes, or denature it using electricity. I'm serious. Well, I would have been a little fairer on the pseudo-science, but the dealbreaker for my suspension of disbelief was really the idea that the phantom knew how to operate a thumb scanner. That was incongruent, not to mention cheesy. How many tacky horror clichés can they stuff into a single episode, has anybody been keeping count?

Now Clark is going to kill Lex. Whatever. He's also the kind of person who will just stand there in the event that a body-snatching Phantom Zoner turns up. But was it pareidolia, or did I see the Superman symbol as the phantom rushed Clark? That was bizarre (take a shot). I wonder if they are purposefully getting these Superman references backwards because it is the Bizarro episode.

No, actually, I'm pretty sure they just throw them in wherever these days. Speak of the devil. Goodbye, Bizarro, goodbye.

So, to sum up: everybody is in peril except Lex, who is in custody, and characters who look like Clark. That, and everybody who looks like Clark but could be construed as Not!Clark can fly. Gotta love the loopholes.
PostPosted: Sat May 19, 2007 12:48 pm


A lot of things that I disliked deal with Lana this season. It takes me all back to one year ago in Vessel and how she is totally different now.

Lana isn't supposed to be totally open to the idea of aliens especially Kryptonians after Zod. And yes, remember, she does know what Krypton is. The second Lex showed her his powers, she backed away, repulsed and said," They turned you into one of them." Of course she did accept him after but her reaction was still acceptable.

Now, oh, Clark's from Krypton too. But I'll react by kissing him because it isn't like he lied to me for six years or anything.. wait...

Oh Lana, remember this?

Lana: You don't trust me. You've never trusted me, have you? I don't know how I could have ever loved you.

One year later....

I've always loved you.

SaberFireTiger
Crew


nobletiger

PostPosted: Sat May 19, 2007 3:30 pm


...And always will" (continued from Saber's previous post)

Oh the irony! But hey it's Smallville, when did they ever care about logic rolleyes

I also like how Clark deliberately 'forgot' to tell Lana that he arrived on Earth in the meteor shower that killed her parents rolleyes
PostPosted: Sat May 19, 2007 3:56 pm


I just hate that last year even when Lana was with Lex, Clark hesitated at every moment when he thought about harming Lex even though he was the vessel for Zod and could save the world. Now, Clark will burst into Lionel's office and savagely murder him for no reason other than he threatened Lana into marrying Lex.

SaberFireTiger
Crew


Foetus In Fetu

PostPosted: Sat May 19, 2007 4:32 pm


And have Smallville imply that he is moving towards his destiny while doing it!
PostPosted: Sun May 20, 2007 12:15 pm


Foetus In Fetu
And have Smallville imply that he is moving towards his destiny while doing it!


What is that, do I hear Milton Fine in the backround? "You must kill Lionel Luthor!" A year late but you finally got around to it!

SaberFireTiger
Crew


DestineChaos

Dangerous Lunatic

PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2007 1:42 pm


O.o I'm half interested to see what you'd rant about had you ranted about the other 131 SV episodes as you did this one... None the less it was--a fun read?
PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2007 2:03 pm


DestineChaos
O.o I'm half interested to see what you'd rant about had you ranted about the other 131 SV episodes as you did this one... None the less it was--a fun read?


I don't think she would rant about all of them, just the bad ones, which is the majority lately. sweatdrop

SaberFireTiger
Crew


Foetus In Fetu

PostPosted: Tue May 22, 2007 2:55 pm


Yeah. I used to be totally placid re: Smallville. I thought I'd go all out for the season finale, though.

DestineChaos
None the less it was--a fun read?

I think I'll... take that as a compliment.
PostPosted: Wed May 23, 2007 12:11 pm


[url=http://www.devotedfansnetwork.com/forum/showthread.php?t=38000&page=2&pp=&conly=0]Devoted to Smallville[/url]
[Steven DeKnight] said that the writers gradually wrote a deliberate contrast between style and ethics and overall approach between the two budding journalists and cousins.

Hey, I called that.

I
I feel like they are trying to differentiate Chloe from Lois. That is partly what the half-assed, poorly executed "journalistic rivalry" storyline that never went anywhere was about. It also reminds me of scenes from Combat and Noir where the differences between Lois and Chloe investigative styles were highlighted. Just a thought.

Foetus In Fetu


SaberFireTiger
Crew

PostPosted: Wed May 23, 2007 1:57 pm


Chloe doesn't do much investigating anymore. We see her at her desk most of the time now.
PostPosted: Wed May 23, 2007 5:38 pm


Thanks FiF! I really enjoyed reading this!!! 3nodding

fredrickevilcow


DestineChaos

Dangerous Lunatic

PostPosted: Thu May 24, 2007 5:14 pm


razz lol I ment no offense by; It was really fun to read.
PostPosted: Sun Jun 10, 2007 5:01 pm


SaberFireTiger
Chloe doesn't do much investigating anymore. We see her at her desk most of the time now.


That totally bums me out like no other. I mean she was ALWAYS investigating no matter what he status was. Now it just seems like she keeps cleaning up the dirty work for Clark. It really doesn't make me happy. Though she is a good Side kick....

`Chloe Sullivan`

Reply
The Smallville Guild!

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum