Leavaros
He would have never gotten published if not for his parents. Talent is something that should be apparent regardless of age, and the refinement of his writing should reflect that talent. Or his editor's talent.
While it may be very very true that he would not have gotten the book published without the help from his parents, I think it is unfair to say he is without talent.
Yes, the story is blatantly recycled and completely predictable for those of us who have read our way around the block a few times. But there are moments of talent in his work. In particular the characterization of the dragon and the interactions between Eragon and Saphira are enjoyable, personable even. While they are arguably sterotypical, it does show talent. Talent enough to captivate enough of his peers to become a bestseller.
It's not a book I prefer. I'll readily agree that Paolini will be a much better writer with age and refinement, but it's hard to dismiss him (particularly when he has sold so many books and so many people continue to read and enjoy them)
as a friend of mine once said, I suppose it doesn't matter whether or not he should have been published... he was and it worked. and I guess that counts for something
