Welcome to Gaia! ::

So Nintendo has been considering making either a Majora's Mask remake or a Link to the Past remake. The thing is, they can't decide which one they should make (click here for more).

Which one would you want?

I havn't played either sweatdrop redface
I was never very good at the old Zelda game, so I never picked up any of the newer ones.

Considering they already have the resources from OOT 3D, Majora's Mask shouldn't take that long to make.

On the other hand, Link to the Past would have to be built from the ground up to be 3DS worthy (unless they release it as a 3D classic through the e-shop).
I would expect it to retain the same gameplay as the original, but update the graphics to make the best use of the 3D.

I've barely played Link to the Past and haven't even touched Majora's Mask, so both would be new to me.

Majora's Mask heart

Depending on how they do the Link to the Past remake, it could be far superior, however there are certain criteria that must be met in order to achieve such a high goal. For instance: What graphics would they use? Would it be a top-down game, or would they make it more OoT? If it was OoT-style, would they create new lighting/shaders/textures? How would they remodel the dungeons to mesh with the new style (if used)?

Majora's Mask is the safe bet, but not necessarily the best bet. It really just depends on how they do it.

Honestly, I'd prefer MM if they used a darker texture-set, something Twilight Princess-esque. It just works better than the brighter textures of OoT for the underlying story-line. Heck, if they wanna port TP that would be cool, too.