|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Jan 23, 2011 10:02 am
I'm starting on a new story, and I wanna know what people think. Here's the prologue/first chapter: The scent of smoke wafted over me, sharp and acrid. It made my throat sting and my eyes water as I gazed up at the fiery sky. My breath came in shallow gasps and my chest burned. My brain was too sluggish and slow to register anything else. I don't know how long I laid there before dark blurry figures entered my vision and bent over me. One of the figures pressed a hand to my brow and muttered something to its partner. I closed my eyes then and drifted into unconsciousness. When I next woke, I found myself surrounded by darkness. I was lying on something soft and cushy with something heavy on top of me. Something cold and wet was lying on my forehead. I wanted to take it off, but I couldn't find the strength to lift my hand. The beginning of a question surfaced in my mind, but it vanished before I could grasp it. What seemed like an eternity later, a crack appeared in what I now realized were thick curtains surrounding the bed that I now laid in. The crack widened, letting in light with it, and a man stepped up to me. My gaze swept slowly up and down, memorizing his features out of long- standing habit. The man's shoulder-length blonde hair was neatly combed and flared outwards, framing his not unkindly face. His cheeks were slightly hollowed, his small dark eyes set midway back into his skull. His thin, pointed nose was ever so slightly off center and his clefted chin jutted out sharply. He wore a dark brown suit with a matching striped tie. Something about him appealed to me. I decided to trust him. The man broke the silence with a question: "What's your name?" "Nathaniel" I answered, wincing. Speaking had reawakened the soreness in my throat. The hoarseness of my voice caused the man to frown. After another few moments of silence, the man more-or-less introduced himself to me: "You can adress me as Mr. Taylor". I nodded and the man sat down on the edge of my bed, letting out a long and tired sigh as he did so. "Due to recent circumstances, which I do not care to elaborate on, I am to become your foster father". My mind was finally starting to speed up again, and I blinked. Foster father? What had happened to my real father? Images flashed through my mind: fire, people lying in the streets and half buried under rubbel, familiar faces. I blinked again and rubbed my eyes. Had I gotten caught in some freak accident or something? I couldn't remember. I slowly sat up and the wet thing, which turned out to be a dampened cloth, fell into my lap. Mr. Taylor reached over to remove it before speaking. "Your parents are gone, Nate." The nickname went completely unnoticed. Gone? As in dead? Strangely, the realization brought no emotion. The thought seemed distant, unimportant. "What happened?" Mr. Taylor sighed again, a deep, groaning sigh. "An accident happened. A horrible, frightening accident."
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Jan 23, 2011 6:47 pm
Here's my take on this. I tend to be a little harsh, but people tell me I give good advice.XCrimsonxEnvyX The scent of smoke wafted over me, sharp and acrid. It made my throat sting and my eyes water as I gazed up at the fiery sky. My breath came in shallow gasps and my chest burned. My brain was too sluggish and slow to register anything else. I like this beginning. It's mysterious and painful, and I want to know what happened.Quote: I don't know how long I laid there before dark blurry figures entered my vision and bent over me. I'm not entirely sure of the sequence of events here. Do the figures appear from a long way off and he sees them approach, as your structure suggests? Or does he only notice them as they are bending over him, or right before they do?Quote: One of the figures pressed a hand to my brow and muttered something to its partner. I closed my eyes then and drifted into unconsciousness. When I next woke, I found myself surrounded by darkness. I was lying on something soft and cushy with something heavy on top of me. Something cold and wet was lying on my forehead. I gather you're trying to keep suspense up here, but seriously, has the narrator never been on a soft bed, under a blanket, or had a compress placed on his head before? Even if the narrator just guesses at those things, it's so obvious it feels kind of demeaning to me, the reader, like you think I'm not smart enough to figure those things out before your "big reveal."Quote: I wanted to take it off, but I couldn't find the strength to lift my hand. The beginning of a question surfaced in my mind, but it vanished before I could grasp it. What seemed like an eternity later, [later than what?]a crack appeared in what I now realized were thick curtains surrounding the bed that I now laid in. The crack widened, letting in light with it, and a man stepped up to me. My gaze swept slowly up and down, memorizing his features out of long- standing habit. Why is this a habit? Is this a detail to be explained later? The man's shoulder-length blonde hair was neatly combed and flared outwards, framing his not unkind ly -the face is not doing anything, so use the adjective form- face. His cheeks were slightly hollowed, his small dark eyes set midway back into his skull. His thin, pointed nose was ever so slightly off center and his clefted chin jutted out sharply. He wore a dark brown suit with a matching striped tie. Something about him appealed to me. I decided to trust him. Overall, I like it so far. We have names, but little idea of characters yet, and a catastrophic event that I want to know more about. I would be sorely put out if that event was never expanded on.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Jan 23, 2011 6:59 pm
The man broke the silence with a question. "What's your name?" period, not colon. It's just dialogue. "Nathaniel" I answered, wincing. Speaking had reawakened the soreness in my throat. The hoarseness of my voice caused the man to frown. After another few moments of silence, the man more-or-less introduced himself to me: "You can adress me as Mr. Taylor". If you're going for proper/formal, use the word "may" I nodded and the man sat down on the edge of my bed, letting out a long and tired sigh as he did so. "Due to recent circumstances, which I do not care to elaborate on [right now?], I am to become your foster father". I want to know these circumstances. Yes I do.I imagine you're planning to reveal them later, though. My mind was finally starting to speed up again, and I blinked. Foster father? What had happened to my real father? Images flashed through my mind: fire, people lying in the streets and half buried under rubbel, familiar faces. I blinked again and rubbed my eyes. Had I gotten caught in some freak accident or something? I couldn't remember. I slowly sat up and the wet thing, which turned out to be a dampened cloth, fell into my lap. I'm okay with this clarification Mr. Taylor reached over to remove it before speaking. "Your parents are gone, Nate." The nickname went completely unnoticed. Not in first person, it didn't. If it's mentioned, it means the narrator noticed. Gone? As in dead? Strangely, the realization brought no emotion. The thought seemed distant, unimportant. "What happened?" Mr. Taylor sighed again, a deep, groaning sigh. "An accident happened. A horrible, frightening accident."
WANT MOAR!! First person is hard that way. You can't make third-person observations, and it's easy to slip up. Anyway, you grabbed my attention and I am intrigued with the story so far. Also, which editing style did you prefer? The one with quotes or just the blue text?
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Jan 23, 2011 9:25 pm
I don't mind harsh critique. It's helpful. And it's true that you're a good critic. I'm fine with either.
I've chosen to reveal the oh-so-catastrophic event in chapter 2, which is rather short at the moment because I've run out of ideas as to what should happen. >.<
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sun Jan 23, 2011 9:44 pm
Chapter 1 revised, take 1:
The scent of smoke wafted over me, sharp and acrid. It made my throat sting and my eyes water as I gazed up at the fiery sky. My breath came in shallow gasps and my chest burned. My brain was too sluggish and slow to register anything else.
I don't know how long I laid there before my mind finally registered the dark blurry figures bending over me. One of the figures pressed a hand to my brow and muttered something to its partner. I closed my eyes then and drifted into unconsciousness.
When I next woke, I found myself surrounded by darkness. I was lying down, but I felt like I was floating. After a few moments, I became vaguely aware of something heavy lying on top of me. The beginning of a question surfaced in my mind, but it vanished before I could grasp it. After what seemed like an eternity, a crack appeared in what I now realized were thick curtains surrounding a bed that I now laid in. The crack widened, letting in light with it, and a man stepped up to me. My gaze swept slowly up and down, memorizing his features out of long- standing habit.
The man's shoulder-length blonde hair was neatly combed and flared outwards, framing his not unkind face. His cheeks were slightly hollowed, his small dark eyes set midway back into his skull. His thin, pointed nose was ever so slightly off center and his clefted chin jutted out sharply. He wore a dark brown suit with a matching striped tie. Something about him appealed to me. I decided to trust him.
The man broke the silence with a question. "What's your name?" "Nathaniel" I answered, wincing. Speaking had reawakened the soreness in my throat. The hoarseness of my voice caused the man to frown.
After another few moments of silence, the man more-or-less introduced himself to me: "You may adress me as Mr. Taylor". I nodded and the man sat down on the edge of my bed, letting out a long and tired sigh as he did so. "Due to recent circumstances, which I do not care to elaborate on, I am to become your foster father".
My mind was finally starting to speed up again, and I blinked. Foster father? What had happened to my real father? Images flashed through my mind: fire, people lying in the streets and half buried under rubbel, familiar faces. I blinked again and rubbed my eyes. Had I gotten caught in some freak accident or something? I couldn't remember.
I slowly sat up and something fell into my lap. It was a dampened cloth. Mr. Taylor reached over to remove it before speaking. "Your parents are gone, Nate." The nickname barely registered. Gone? As in dead? Strangely, the realization brought no emotion. The thought seemed distant, unimportant. "What happened?" Mr. Taylor sighed again, a deep, groaning sigh. "An accident happened. A horrible, terrifying accident."
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Jan 24, 2011 9:28 pm
I like the changes you made. It really flows a lot better now, imo. I'm pretty sure it's spelled "rubble."
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Jan 24, 2011 10:53 pm
Oh yeah. Heh heh. "rubble" not "rubbel". I'm still trying to decide if I want to introduce more non-anonymous characters or if I just want to stick with "Nate" and Mr. Taylor for now...
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|