KuraiKitty
In which game?
Stats-wise, general usage, personal preference, personality, flexibility, or Support potential?
Specifics, we need them. QFT
There have been fast red Cavaliers (Kent), fast green Cavaliers (Lance), powerful red Cavaliers (Noish), powerful green Cavaliers (Sain), serious red Cavaliers (Kent), serious green Cavaliers (Kyle), upbeat red Cavaliers (Forde), and upbeat green Cavaliers (Alec).
The whole red/green Cavalier dichotomy has been assigned in every way possible considering the trope. It's been changed up enough that you can no longer say these are the qualities of the red, and these are the qualities of the green. The more games in the series you've played, the more obvious this is.
Generally speaking however, I guess I'd go with green if I had to have all the green Cavaliers or all the red ones.
FE1/11: I'm honestly indifferent in this one.
FE4: Alec has pursuit. Noish doesn't
FE5: ...can't comment... YET (I'm assuming I'll go with Kain though)
FE6: Lance doubles first ;3
FE7: Sain's Strength growth is enormous here and he still doubles without any problems, so I take him over the 'fast' of the two.
FE8: It's FE8, so it's riduculously easy regardless of who you use ;/
FE9/10: Oscar wins this one for me just because of that fabulous Earth Affinity more than anything else.