Welcome to Gaia! ::

Lucky Cannon - I agree with you dude he's got the look, some okay ring work, and pretty good promo skills but like you said he lacks the "it" factor people want nowadays

Alex Riley - Good in ring competitor, Great on the mic like The Miz, has the "it" factor but only one problem with him and its the fact that he is a Heel WWE has far to many of them and hardly any good Face characters that the fans can get behind so I say unless he's a face he shouldnt be signed right away to a brand

Eli Cottonwood - Ah the monster of the group he has some okay ring skills, okay mic skills, and somewhat of the "it" factor and he could do what they we're trying to do with Shad before his Heel (told ya) turn and make him be a big guy with something the fans can like but he will most likely be turned Heel after a few months plus there is already too many giants in WWE

Husky Harris - Good ring work, decent mic skills but problem is he is more of a Tag competitor in FCW with his brother Bo Rotundo and like you said he isnt the kind of guy who really makes you want to watch him

Kaval - If WWE is serious about pushing smaller guys then this man right here is the one to push dont do to him what they did to Bryan Danielson where they have him lose every match and then fire him he has the same potential Bryan had and still has he is capable of being both Face or Heel good on the mic, excellent in ring skills, and definitely has the "it" factor

Micheal McGillicutty - ah Mr. Perfect Jr. not in a disrespectful way but he shouldnt be on this show he should already be on the main roster and he would have been if his partner in The Fortunate Sons stable Brett DiBiase hadnt gotten injured both would be with Ted right now so I dont think he should win not because he doesnt deserve it but because he is basically guaranteed a spot on the main roster

Percy Watson - First they split up The South Beach Party Boys by signing Darren Young up to season 1 but now they bring Percy up to be in season 2 awesome he has good in ring skills, great mic skills, and definitely has the "it" factor plus he brings the fans into his matches also he looks like Steve Urkel on steroids WWE you want a good African American wrestler to push no one better the "Showtime" Percy Watson even Micheal Cole as a Heel (once again told ya) likes Percy Watson

Titus O'Neill - ok ring work, okay mic skills, has some "it" factor but just like with Husky Harris he doesnt really come as a guy you want to watch every single week

Overall these rookies arent half bad but arent all that good hopefully WWE makes better choices this time around with these guys and who knows if The Nexus continues after this season is over then maybe these guys could be the hero's opposing the villian's of NXT but to my vote it goes to these men right here

"The World Warrior" Kaval (Catchy aint it)

"Showtime" Percy Watson

Micheal McGillicutty