Welcome to Gaia! ::

Carry On, Supernatural

Back to Guilds

A supernatural guild for both the crazy and sane fans. ;D 

Tags: supernatural, winchester, sammy, dean, castiel 

Reply Carry On, Supernatural
ARCHANGELS.

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

asinwolves
Crew

Dapper Detective

PostPosted: Sun Nov 22, 2009 12:39 pm


Caps are fun. I've decided this.


On to my business!

So, I was thinking about the archangels, and I couldn't decide if there were four or what. My friend was saying in her game, they have four archangels, and under their character profile it says "One of the four archangels", so I looked it up.

Apparently there can be seven. xD I guess this s**t depends.

Well, in Christianity, Catholicism and Judaism and such, the three most referenced and well known (most don't have names, I guess. xD) are Michael, Gabriel and Rapheal.

Now, we all know by now that Supernatural makes it's own mythology. It'll blend and match til it likes what it's got for it's own storytelling. Because according to some myth, Uriel is an archangel. Which I guess could make sense within the show, but...Why would he be in the same garrison as Cas? Cas is clearly not one of the powerful or well known angels. I mean, Lucifer kinda had to ask his name. Gabriel clearly just rolled with knowing it, and Castiel just knew of him. Raphael and Castiel's knowing each other seemed to date back to the whole killing Cas incident, which really wasn't that long ago. And. >.> Well, that doesn't make Cas seem all that powerful...

It's clear the angels live in ranks. But when Castiel mentioned archangels, it wasn't when they met Uriel. He just called Uriel a specialist...(didn't he?)

So I'm going to assume...in Kripke's world, that angels that may be considered archangels are just higher up (I kinda view Heaven like a military. xD) and then you have archangels - which, I don't know how many of them there are, but so far, if we look at the most popular, we've met two and know of the third.

Does that mean those are the only ones? In Pagan myth, it's sad Lucifer was one - and I could see Kripke meshing those two myths for the sake of making Lucifer their brother - if all four of them were archangels, all four would be that close together, right?

Zacharias, who's clearly just delivering Micheal's messages and obeying orders higher than him xD, seems to react the Lucifer vs. Michael, apocalypse thing with a "They said it should happen, and it sounds good to me - then we don't have to care about you jerks. It's not like God's around anyway. razz " attitude. To me it seems like he's just doing what he's told, liking it, and not necessarily attached to the problem. Which makes me think he's not "close" to the archangels or God. That that's not his...group. razz They're not his PEOPLE. DOES THIS MAKE SENSE GUYS? XD I'm given the impression by his attitude, that while they're his heavenly brothers and they're more powerful and above him - he doesn't KNOW them.

Which is all very shallow compared to the feelings of the archangels we've met.

There's Raphael. He first of all seems lost and confused now that, in a metaphorical sense that's pretty much literal, he's been left at home alone basically in charge of himself as well as the rest of Heaven (considering his power and archangel rank, I'm sure he gets to be in charge. xD).

As far as he's concerned, daddy's dead. There's no order - and he's clearly saddened by this. D: He's in a bitchy mood, sure, but how would you feel if you were lost and confused and sure your father was dead? I'm sure that's the best explanation he's got for not having seen him taking any control over this situation just yet. So, he resorts to letting the apocalypse happen. What the hell else is there to do - it's not like it matters if it does anyway, you know. It was only a matter of time before Lucifer busted out anyway, so why not take care of it now - Michael had to take care of it before.

Then there's Gabriel. He was the most open with his feelings, so I have less to ramble about. xD But basically, he's very passionate about his family. I mean, don't ******** talk about them like that, okay, Dean? Damn. xD He even clearly does not hate humans. He's already proved he likes Sam and Dean, he lives among them and basks in their bad foods, naked women and still lives up to his angel duties and brings justice to dicks, just, in the most fun way he can think up. It's OBVIOUS he doesn't hate humans like Lucifer does.

He even just wants to go home - he's only hiding because he can't stand the fighting. That's why he wants the apocalypse - because that means there will be nothing left to fight about. He can go home and everything can be happy for him, you know.

Lucifer wants the apocalypse for almost the same reason. There's also the being powerful thing, because he has authority issues and needs to be the best. But he's passionate about his family like the other two. This is what makes me think those four know each other and are more family than say, Uriel or Zacharias.

Which is why I'm saying xD I think there's four of them only. It's generally the most popular thought - when you think archangels those are the four you think of.

They were for me at least. xD I didn't know half the other names on Wiki. Uriel was the only one I recognized, and I just can't convince myself that in Kripke's world, he's an archangel.

What I'm wondering is, other than Michael - do you think we'll be meeting any more of these powerful angsty brothers? xD

Also, as I wrote this (for no real reason other than it being on my mind), I noticed more connections to Sam and Dean. XD

Lucifer is Sam, and Michael is Dean.

...But so are Raphael and Gabriel, in a way. xD I mean, Raphael is convinced there's no point following the guidelines of some absent, probably dead father, so he acts out. >.> Sounds like Sam to me. xD

Gabriel cares about his family and wants the fighting to end, but is too scared to stand up to them and hides in the most human nonsense, like food and women and jokes. ...XD That totally sounds like Dean to me. razz

Like, everyone keeps pointing out that Sam and Dean are Michael and Lucifer, and it's their destiny on both ends to destroy each other and always fight and blah blah blah. But I think that's just who Sam and Dean COULD be. They don't have to turn out like Michael and Lucifer.

I think they could resemble a better two, if those two could set the example first. ;D If Raphael could get over himself after having time to think in the timeout Cas put him in - and if Gabriel can grow a pair and decide "Hm, maybe the apocalypse isn't the only way to solve our problems" - then Dean and Sam could also just as easily end up working together, rather than killing each other. Just because they're their vessels doesn't mean they have to live up to their example.

Act out your own play, you know.

All of that archangel is stuff leads me to the other thing on my mind. When Lucifer said there were five things the cult couldn't kill. Vee had the same first idea I had, which was the four horsemen. Which makes sense, those are powerful ********. I mean, shoot DEATH in the face? I can't imagine how well that would go.

The next thought I had was the archangels and God. Because it can't kill Lucifer, and I'd sure hope the cult can't kill God. xD But that would leave out the horsemen, which...I still can't see being killed by a cult.

Then I thought, hey, maybe the archangels count as one creature, considering they're all, you know, archangels. And then the four horsemen. But the problem with THAT is that I can't see it killing GOD, and God's not an angel or a horsemen.

So then there's, maybe the horsemen all count as the same thing. I mean, they're all different types of horsemen, but it's not like Michael, Gabriel, Raphael and Lucifer are all horribly similar other than being archangels. So then it'd be archangels, horsemen, God...xD Then I don't know.

We know Lucifer still counts as an angel - I mean, doesn't he? Or is he now something separate, giving us a fourth out of five things? I mean, I figure if he is he just doesn't have his wings or something that connects him to heaven. And he fell (cast out, same diff), but maybe he just got disconnected like Cas is - and then he was locked away and so he just had archangel powers in him, but wasn't able to reach Heaven any longer?

Either way, there's either one or two other things missing from it if any of that happens to be right. And it's bothering me. razz

I figure it's supposed to, otherwise Lucifer wouldn't have mentioned it. xD And he doesn't lie...but he does omit s**t from the truth, so he may have phrased it in a way to make it so like "D: Four other creatures?" when it doesn't necessarily mean how it could sound. >.>

xD That last part was confusing. razz I'm done rambling. It's out of my system now. I'mma go watch a movie.
PostPosted: Sun Nov 22, 2009 7:29 pm


I actually read all that.
Go me!

But now I have to go back through it all to comment, should have done that as I went along.

I'm with you on the military idea of the angels, they're warriors, makes sense to me. Although maybe it's because I live near army garrisons myself and it always conjures that image up. On the Uriel archangel thingy, if Uriel's an archangel, why was Anna his boss? What the hell does that make her? He was simply called a specialist, so I'm assuming he's just your basic angel with special training. A mercenary type angel, if you will. He seemed to be a smiter.

I don't think it's been implied that Lucy is an archangel in the show, he's just a bog standard angel who fell from grace. His powers came from his fury in hell. Or that's what I've got from it. To be honest, I'm going by what I remember from school when it comes to the religious thing - and I barely remember a thing, despite the fact I took an extra two years of religious education where I had four hours of it a week.

I see Zach as an asskisser. He wants to be higher up on the food chain and he'll follow orders to the letter if it means he gets there, not caring what happens in the process. If we look at his entrance in 'It's A Terrible Life', he appeared as management of the company (who's name escapes me at the moment) in this 'alternate' reality he created, which to me suggests that that's the kind of thing he's aiming for in heaven. Can angels get promoted? I guess with the carnage going on, anything's possible.

I get where Raphael's coming from (although I reckon we could make it all better with a pizza). If you look at how he's acting, he's grieving. As you've said, he's lost his daddy and all of that and now he's the boss. He's upset because Daddy's dead and he's pissed because he's now got to keep things in order. A clean slate would be so much easier.

Gabriel gets humanity. Of all the angels, he's the one who gets humanity the best. Like you've said, he wants the apocalypse to happen but at the same time, I see him as the one most likely to step in to stop it. I mean, sure, he gets to go back to heaven but considering what we've seen of him, don't you think he'd be likely to get bored without our sin and depravity to look over when he's back up there? At least that's what I get from him. (I point out I've only watched Changing Channels once, so there's a chance I've forgotten something he's said to us).

As I've said, my religious knowledge is limited but I can't see Kripke throwing out a whole ton of archangels. For starters, it would confuse the mythology too much. Sure, geeks can process more information than regular folk (a scientific fact I've just made up but when you think about it, it does have merit - another theory for another time) but having an assload of archangels is too much for us. That and having too many makes things too easy. Having a small number, like the ones we've been introduced to already, makes the battle for good harder. I wouldn't be surprised if we perhaps got one more on the good side to balance out the four horsemen.

I hadn't even thought about the parallel's between those lot. Nice spot there, Teeks! Gabriel and Raphael more represent the earlier stages of Sam and Dean's reconnecting, back in season one/two-ish. Whereas Michael and Lucifer are more who they were in season four, rather than season five. (I can't be the only one this bothers? The way the angels talk about Sam and Dean, it's like they're in a position now where they're backstabbing and betraying which isn't the case. They've done that, they're mending themselves now. Sure there's still an element of trust to be rebuilt and all but I personally can't say I'm seeing all this supposed friction between them. Or maybe I'm BLIND!)

I imagine the whole "Play your roles" thing is going to come back in the end, Gabriel playing his role and kicking ASSSSSSSS.

RIGHT! On with the next part, Colt-wise, I'm basically in agreement with you there. Horsemen all one thing, archangels, God but I think Lucy's a separate entity due to how twisted hell has made him. Although the fifth thing intrigues me greatly. (Chuck Norris perhaps?)

Am I done now? Can I go lie down and cuddle Sammy the bat?

a walking blasphemy
Crew

4,300 Points
  • Beta Forum Regular 0
  • Beta Citizen 0
  • Beta Critic 0

Danielle Metallicar Chase
Crew

4,800 Points
  • Member 100
  • Citizen 200
  • Person of Interest 200
PostPosted: Sun Nov 22, 2009 8:20 pm


Actually Lucifer was the most powerful of the angels and also the most beautiful, that's why he was arrogant enough to actually defy God. I think they might have said it in the show too...
PostPosted: Sun Nov 22, 2009 9:09 pm


@Vee:
Yeah, I'm pretty convinced they decided in the show Uriel wasn't one of the archangels. They're sticking to the most popularly thought of ones, it seems.

No, it hasn't really been implied Lucy was an archangel. I'm going by his attitude and his history and the way Gabriel talked about him and Michael, and Lucifer having been such a threat he had to be knocked down and locked up for an eternity. They just seemed to make a big deal out of him, whereas Anna...she fell and then they came after her head when she was threatening them later on.

Though that's also an idea, and very likely. Having grown that strong in hell from all the evil and whatnot. I never did any religious school or church and whatnot - it just always seemed to me Lucifer was the prettiest angel and one of the most powerful and right there with God. But, really, xD I don't actually know anything about this myth. Clearly, as I had to wiki the archangels. xD But it did only say Lucy was one in Pagan myth, not Christian or whatnot. So, he might not be. (Which really aids the cult theory xD God, Devil, Archangels, Horsemen, ....???)

Zach is definitely an asskisser. And I'm not sure about the promoting, but I can imagine it...might...happen? I think things generally stay the same up there. Like, I highly doubt you can become an archangel, I get the feelings those are the ones that have seen God and are special and whatnot. Like, handpicked kinda thing. Like, you can tell both Raphael and Gabriel believed there was one for sure - while Uriel wasn't even convinced there was one. Anna said there were...four who'd seen his face, right? She wasn't one of them - well, I imagine the archangels (and I've always been under the impression Lucy got to see him) saw him and don't have to run only on faith - but their purpose is more important.

Lovely how they're all failing their purpose, other than Michael, who seems just as prepared to destroy Lucifer. xD Raphael is running about letting s**t happen, upset about God, and Gabriel's run away from home. Really. xD One of the three most powerful hasn't even been IN heaven. Wow, that place is having issues. God and Gabriel have been missing, Raphael is throwing a temper tantrum, and Michael doesn't seem to be doing a damn thing other than waiting to play his part. He sounds fun. razz

I feel him, too. (I suggest Papa Murphy's, then the boys can go up to the heaven-grill and spend some quality time cooking it, as well.) The easy way out in his mind and Gabriel's mind is like you said, a clean slate. They don't have all this s**t to do with and can attempt to reorder things and be happy.

I don't think you've forgotten anything he's said. He clearly gets humanity and he obviously only wants it for his brothers. I think he'd be HORRIBLY bored. He seems to really enjoy humans and their life style - as far as I know (though, I read somewhere that they told Richard Speight Jr after he asked questions after checking out myth on Gabriel that they "don't so much go by any of that" in the bible) he's the one that kept in contact with the humans most in biblical stories - being the messenger and whatnot. He enjoys us too much to actually want to see us gone. He'll definitely have to come back and help Sam and Dean.

That'd be waaay too much, I agree. There really only needs to be the three. A small number is definitely the most reasonable. I actually like the three we've got. xD THOUGH, I can see that. xD Just one more to even things out. Though, a small part of me places God in that forth position. xD

*bows* Yes, well, I may just think far too much about Gabriel, and in the context of this, I had to think about Raphael. xD (I'm just a sad, sad fangirl, is all.) But dude, seriously. I know what you mean. Sam and Dean aren't like the were. I mean, they have problems, but they're trying to work on them. Maybe it's that the angels are pushing for the old similarities in order to prove a point. Maybe it's that it's supposed to still all be lingering there under the surface, but it hasn't come back up just yet. You're not blind, they're just horribly subtle if anything! xD

YES. I want Gabriel to come back and do this a** KICKING you speak of.

(I vote Chuck Norris as well. razz ) I like to think the Devil is a separate one. That makes it 1) so he's more important than just one of those three archangels, and 2) so there's only one thing missing from the list and the "OMFG, WHAT IS IT?" more epic than "What are those two things, now?"

XD GO. CUDDLE.

@Danielle:
I've always heard he was the most beautiful and whatnot, which is why I ranked him up there in my head with the other three. I dunno if I would ever call him most powerful though. I mean, Michael kicked his a** before, and they seem pretty sure he'll do it again (if Dean will take him...xD Which brings me to the whole other thing about why everything depends on vessels. xD)

asinwolves
Crew

Dapper Detective


Danielle Metallicar Chase
Crew

4,800 Points
  • Member 100
  • Citizen 200
  • Person of Interest 200
PostPosted: Mon Nov 23, 2009 6:27 am


Yeah, but Michael's power came from the sword, which came from God.
PostPosted: Mon Nov 23, 2009 7:31 am


Once again, real myth means nothing when it comes to Kripke's world. Seriously. xD They even told Richard when he asked them about all the Gabriel things he'd read that, "Yeaaah, we don't so much go by that." Things are bound to have their own differences.

Michael is an archangel. He's still powerful even without his sword. From what I can see, in this version, there's no actual sword, it's just a word that formed about his vessel. So if there's no sword, then it's obvious the legend is able to change a little. He's very powerful, he just needs Dean to kill Lucifer (which I guess means for whatever reason, angels DO need their vessels. I'm not understand this AT ALL, but okay). But it doesn't mean Dean's the power and can wield it himself, it means he can be used as a tool for Michael.

The only thing that bothers me about the idea of Dean doing it himself, is that it takes away from Sam, who's also important. He can't simply only have an evil purpose. Clearly Dean would need Sam. I think they're biggest challenge, and greatest importance is to just not become their vessels. But I can't see why Dean would have the power in his little human self to kill the devil all on his own. Micheal's Sword or not. A sword is only dangerous if there is somewhere there to use it - A sword doesn't wield itself.

Maybe God wants Michael to take Dean. If he gave Michael that vessel and whatnot. But there's always the new way to look at it - if you consider it's no longer just an inanimate sword, it's a person.

There are apparently vessels made for each angel. Specifically, it seems. Cas needed Jimmy. Michael HAS to have Dean, Lucifer NEEDS Sam (it's proof as his plan B is fading away). Angels don't jump around in bodies. Zacharias, Anna, Uriel - they all stayed in the same human form every time we saw/see them. If there's no sword, and all that means is Dean's a vessel - then there's a chance the legend is different, and this isn't some God-given gift to Michael, that Dean is just one of the few that can hold Michael.

Who did Castiel go to when he almost lost Jimmy? Jimmy's daughter. Who was supposedly going to brake the first seal, and be the righteous man and whatnot? John. He didn't. It wasn't his path to go on, but it doesn't mean he wasn't a working "sword" for Michael. It just meant he didn't give in and Dean is the most fitting otherwise. There's no reason we can't assume John couldn't have been Michael's vessel just as well.

Maybe it's different with archangels. I mean, Sam and Nick aren't related. And Nick's a plan B, meaning, he sucks and can't hold his power.

But does that mean everything's mapped out and the apocalypse couldn't have gone down before this? Have they known the thousands of years the Michael Sword legend existed that Dean Winchester would be it once he was born? That seems silly to me.

I don't think Dean's Micheal's POWER, is my point. I think Michael holds his own power, but Dean is a weapon. That's all a sword is. A sword is nothing without the power of the person using it. It's just a sword. It can't hurt anyone unless someone picks it up. And a sword is only as powerful as the person using it.

I have weak arms. If I picked up a sword, I wouldn't swing it very well, and I couldn't fight a sword fight with it. I'd lose. I could stab someone if they stood still and I rushed them. xD But I'm not powerful, therefore my sword would be less effective against someone else's sword.

Michael is this badass archangel that needs his sword to kick Lucifer's a**. All that means is that to- OH. I ******** GET IT. THE VESSEL THING. XD

Okay, so before, Michael and Lucifer were both in Heaven. There, Michael could kick Lucifer out and Lucy couldn't get back in. Now that Lucy is out of Hell, he can only reach Earth. As he is just a force on this human plain, he finds a vessel, which is almost like a way to channel is power. Contain it, and whatnot. Like his own sword. Well, Lucifer's so powerful - and it's this long awaited battle, that to fight him in this sword fight, Michael couldn't just come flying out of the Heaven's and stomp the Devil. That could assist the sword metaphor. Weapons add strength. I mean, when you wield a sword, you need to be physically strong as well as trained, but you know, the sword is also sharp and pointing and part of what kills the opponent.

So Micheal needs his sword to fight against Lucifer. Otherwise it's fists vs. swords, and that doesn't generally go down in the fists favor.

Sam and Dean, while both vessels, are...just humans without the angels using them. While I'm sure they'll play a large part in killing the devil (without becoming angel condoms, of course) I highly doubt Dean could simply do it on his own.

...That has nothing to do with what you said. XD But I think you suggested that Dean should be able to kill Lucy in Vee's thread, and that's what I was thinking of when reading your post, so that's kind of where my response went to. xD

My point is - If Dean is the sword, and that's the only strength Michael has, then well, it's silly to think Dean was there when Michael knocked Lucifer out in the first place - which is why I think Kripke's changed the legend quite a bit, and we can't go exactly by biblical knowledge.

asinwolves
Crew

Dapper Detective


Danielle Metallicar Chase
Crew

4,800 Points
  • Member 100
  • Citizen 200
  • Person of Interest 200
PostPosted: Mon Nov 23, 2009 8:12 am


Holy crap... you're funny, in a good way, and work hard to sell this to me. Well, I think I'm sold. You should think about being a lawyer.

Also, I'm pretty sure that in the show they said that for every generation there is a designated vessel for angels. So, Dean didn't have to be back there to kick Lucy's butt, so some other person who was Micheal's vessel was. Btw, great explanation for the vessel thing.

Again, I would say that: God knows it all and how everything happens, so he had this whole Dean and Sam plan from the beginning. But, since you've kind of proven that the show is making it up as they go, I can't even say anything.
PostPosted: Mon Nov 23, 2009 10:50 am


xD It's crazy, my argumentative paper took me three years to write.


Hmm, generations for vessels. I don't remember that, but I can see it. That makes sense. *wiggles fingers*

You know what's weird? I imagine he knows it all, but all the s**t the angels are spitting out might not have much merit to it at all. Especially Zacharias, who's clearly talking for someone. xD It's like, I think there's supposed to be a way, a path, set out for following. Like, something that looks like the future, and because of who they are, it's nearly set in stone.

It's like that in a lot of stories involving fate. You can escape your fate, but that s**t's hard to do, considering it's based on who you are. You really need to be able to step outside your own little box (which is something Sam is going to have trouble with) to change your own destiny. Otherwise Castiel's right, all paths lead to the same destination.

But that HAS to be relative. I mean, on a physical level more than a mental one.

They said from the beginning that nothing could've changed what happened with Mary, and Sam would've opened the seal, and all that "destiny" talk. It HAS to happen. Dean couldn't stop Mary.

But it was all physical. Dean couldn't stop Mary because while he knew he had to stop something, she's Mary. In the end, Mary didn't know what was coming and so she felt the only way to keep John was to make this deal. It seemed like her best bet at the time. She was scared and alone and being offered another chance. She was also young and naive when it came to the manipulation of Azazel. Dean could've tried all he wanted, but Mary was still Mary and unless she experienced something new and gained wisdom she never had before - all those paths would lead her to the same destination. She wasn't beyond her setting.

And it wasn't just her and him playing the forces in this - there are always other people still working at something. Azazel, for instance, had his mission. He wouldn't have changed his mindset on looking for those children no matter what happened, so he was going to push Mary 'til he had her.

One of them needed to give in for the destiny to change. (Omfg, I'm thinking about Harry Potter now. xD Guh, wtf.)

I'LL USE IT AS AN EXAMPLE. It said in that prophecy that both of them can't live while the other is alive. The only reason that prophecy was true was because Voldemort believed it was true. He pushed and pushed to make sure Harry was dead, and naturally, Harry had to fight back. If Voldemort simply didn't take that s**t to heart - if he weren't the kind of person to fear infants and be afraid of losing power - then Harry and Voldemort COULD have existed together. It was that they wouldn't allow this to happen. They created their destiny - and simply because it was told to them.

Oedipus. His parents got rid of him because of what they heard would happen. Had they not feared the prophecy and kept him, or even heard the prophecy for that matter, I can't imagine he'd have grown up and done what he'd done. It was because he hadn't known.

What is up with this ignorance theme being related to all these prophetic stories? xD

If there's a stated prophecy, it takes away from free will. Which defeats the purpose God gave to humans. You create your own destiny. Just because, say, Chuck says it'll happen...we've already learned it doesn't have to happen that way. If Chuck and the angels can be surprised, well, it's clear they aren't omniscient. And if God "doesn't say anything about anything" then how do we know half of what the angels are pushing HAS to be true?

Dean doesn't believe it does. The angels seem to see a connection. Half of what they're doing almost seems...human, on their parts. They're acting out of selfish emotion - when they weren't supposed to have the free will that humans do. Weird. I think their freedom is something they don't notice, and I think God's absence has something to do with their ability to have it.

So maybe Sam and Dean weren't God's "plan", they just got caught up in the destinies Lucifer and Michael and the angels all created for themselves. Like with Mary or Harry, they were kind of forced into it by the opposing forces who believe they must fulfill some prophecy. But like with Zacharias' future - it's all just a plausible outcome, I think.

Sam is having trouble changing, but he knows his fate otherwise, and Dean and him are taking initiative to try and change it. They're being pressured, but so far they're not self-fulfilling their own destinies.

I don't think any of them, angels, humans, us - KNOW what God's plan is. I personally like to think God's sitting back and watching them all practice free will, as they think he's just abandoning them. If he was the one that brought out of Lucifer's way, I don't think it was so they could play the parts of vessels.

I think it was so they would have the chance to decide not to. And as for Cas coming back to life, if he's the one that did it - Cas is on the side of the boys, I think that would only reinforce that God isn't waiting for some angel-prophecy to be fulfilled, he's waiting to see if they can knock-it-off.

Doesn't he do that? I mean, he's always portrayed as "testing" his people. Not expecting them to do one thing, but giving them all the options. Family before temptation and anger and selfishness. It's very much what Kripke leans toward, and it seems to be a very God-like lesson. Did you know anger is actually addictive? Has anyone else noticed the biggest problem in the show is no one letting go of their anger or getting over themselves?

Like I said, their destinies can change if they would just change. They get so many chances.

Gabriel, for example, has been given his food for thought.

I think Lucifer's gone. Corrupted and lost and just too far gone to ever want redemption.

God's "plan", if anything, seems like it would be for people to create their roles, rather than play one's given to them (I was watching Gabriel shouting at them about playing their roles again. xD). Free will. There's the pursuit of happiness - in the form of kindness and love. Family and whatnot. And then there's selfishness and rage and hatred, which isn't real happiness but Lucifer pursues it, and Sam had been.

There's a lot of testosterone in this show. Really, it's a giant pissing contest between everyone, humans, angels, demons - if the ones destroying the world would get over themselves, things wouldn't be so bad.

So God knows all, but it's not about a planned destiny for them, it's about knowing what they'll decide, not what they're meant for.

Forgiveness is a fun thing that these "warriors" can't seem to learn. Probably why they don't recognize Sam and Dean's growing selves. Though, Sam seemed a little torn in Abandon All Hope. That boy needs a good slap in the face.

xD Destinies in this show is now starting to sound like some sort of very elaborate domino effect. xD

I don't know why I rambled about THAT. But all that suddenly came to mind and you know, I had to say it. xD

asinwolves
Crew

Dapper Detective


Danielle Metallicar Chase
Crew

4,800 Points
  • Member 100
  • Citizen 200
  • Person of Interest 200
PostPosted: Mon Nov 23, 2009 11:54 am


That makes a lot of sense. I also noticed that a lot of times when there's a prophesy, people become so obsessed with avoiding it that they walk straight into it. I also like how you said that the biggest thing about God is that he gives us free will- to human anyway, while the angels are just so hung up about what is supposed to be, they forget that humans have the will to chose. Like Sam and Dean, Gabriel expects them-- demands that they play their parts, and Dean (and Sam) are like "Screw you mofo! We've got a brain of our own and we do what we like."
They can chose to or not to do what ever the heck they want! And no one, not even God, can really make them. Because free will, was his gift to us-- and I think one of the reasons that angels dislike humans. Because we have free will and while they have to do what God or whomever's higher then them tells them to do.

Also, what you said about Chuck-- remember that episode where they just met him I think. And he had some sort of ground breaking prophesy, and Zachariah showed up and told him that if he tells the brothers, he will be punished.

I love how we have this whole philosophical discussion going on.
PostPosted: Mon Nov 23, 2009 1:13 pm


I'd join in here but I think I bust my philosophical fuse earlier today!

But I'm reading through here and you're making such good points. I totally love this place. Fangirling second, theorizing first.

a walking blasphemy
Crew

4,300 Points
  • Beta Forum Regular 0
  • Beta Citizen 0
  • Beta Critic 0

asinwolves
Crew

Dapper Detective

PostPosted: Mon Nov 23, 2009 3:02 pm


GUH, that made me MAD. Zacharias has no right to run about using (or silencing) Chuck for his apocalyptic shenanigans! These angels clearly have more free will than they think, because I kind have to agree with Anna on some of the s**t they're doing - does that REALLY sound like something God would order?

That, or he's actually missing (which I think is a little weird...if that's the case, I expect Kripke can shock me with a good explanation) and these self-righteous jerks are running about practicing free will now that no one's there to stop them.

I imagine they've just always known right from wrong and they get harsher punishment immediately for committing wrong, and to them, it's like they have less free will than a human. Where humans can ******** up and apologize, angels fall or whatever. Lucifer used his own free will to betray heaven. That had to have been back when God was still around.

That's why I call them a military. They're trained above the "civilians" for a higher purpose - which is why they don't have room to ******** up majorly and not get punished worse. They're supposed to stand professionally, ready to achieve their goals and protect humans from things like the devil and other nonsense beyond human control. Their job is important, and they're taking their roles for granted. They've lost sight of what good they're supposed to be doing. I guess that's the difficult part about being forced to serve and then realizing you don't want to - like Anna.

Or being trained to obey orders from an unknown source and then not being able to always find that source when you feel you need it most. It must be hard to be so used to a certain way of living and then having to decide to act out on their own, like Castiel or Raphael.

Then you have Zacharias who goes along happily with those above him out of an obsession for power - and Lucifer who fights his way to the top for the same reason. It's all a broken organization. The angels have forgotten their purpose out of too many reasons to count - each angel being different.

Anyway, I think Chuck had seen what the angels were up to. I like to think that's how Cas found out. Though, they never revealed that, so there's a chance it'll get brought back up and he'd seen something else. :O

Gabriel demanding them to play their parts...I honestly believe 1) he thinks it'll happen anyway, and he's trying to make them choose it now while they're okay instead of going through more painful s**t just to end up having to make that choice. 2) he's being selfish and just wants to go home to a family that's no longer fighting.

I actually thought he was the most friendly about the whole thing. xD Which is weird, since he threatened to trap them til they said yes and got snippy with them. But he genuinely seemed sympathetic that it was the "best" way. He just wasn't admitting that the "best" way was simply the easiest for him.

What I mean is xD I felt he was more suggesting it strongly, whereas Zacharias was doing his best to order them around even though it's a choice.

What's funny is - if it were "destiny" and "has to happen", you'd think it wouldn't have to be a choice. xD

(I totally didn't mean to defend Gabriel. xD I know what you mean, and I agree - the angels are very "DO IT" and it's like "...No." Almost like the angels are deadset on taking their free will away, but can't seem to. xD Which is frustrating - they're used to have more power than that, like over Cas. What? It worked for a little while on him. xD But Cas changing his mind again against a prophecy is proof angels are free to choose as well. xD They might just not have realized it.)
Reply
Carry On, Supernatural

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum