Welcome to Gaia! ::

Black (African, American) Pride Guild

Back to Guilds

A place for ANYONE (no matter the race or national origin) can gather and discuss topics that are particular to Blacks on a global basis 

Tags: Black, Culture, Pride 

Reply Welcome! Introductions and Miscellaneous
IQ Test? Useful or not? Racially Biased? Hmmm

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Free
  Gold
View Results

Disruptive

PostPosted: Tue Jun 23, 2009 6:26 pm


Our educational society places a great amount of value on the ability for one to perform well on a standardized test of intelligence. Opportunities and benefits that result from acquiring such a skill has also increased. It appears that these tests hold the probability that they could be culturally biased, therefore perpetuate that socioeconomic inequalities are present in America today. When discussing measurements of results from studies interpreting the outcome of any group of people taking standardized tests, one must consider just what these tests claim to measure. Intelligence seems to be an extremely important trait for many people, but what is intelligence? This seemingly simple trait is increasingly becoming more difficult to define when scrutinized closely. Standardized test can be biased in favor of certain cultures; the scores from such tests can be misinterpreted to justify unfounded and prejudiced beliefs. Their message seems to be that who a person currently is, will be what they will become, and in the process, rob them of many of the opportunities and benefits of the ability to change oneself for the better.
I remember in middle school I was told I couldn’t be in the Gifted and Talented program because I scored 2 points lower on the IQ test than they required. At 9 years old I already felt the sense of inadequacy because I was smart – but not smart enough. As a result, I started not caring in my regular classes because they bored me and I saw that it didn’t really matter that much. The presumption of a claim that in fifty minutes you can evaluate and categorize a human being’s predestined capability in life is an abomination. I abhor the pretentiousness of the claim and the abuse of scientific method which it involves; there is a superiority which it creates and the sense of inferiority which it imposes. I argue that IQ test are not only a problem transracially, but they are an issue in of itself. Blacks are not the only race to suffer due to a stigma they have received from taking an IQ test. What does an intelligence test really accomplish? How can this test help people in the real world? In essence it can’t. But it can destroy the minds of children who were wrongly categorized – or categorized period.

Thoughts.. agreements? Disagreements? Feedback. :]
PostPosted: Wed Jun 24, 2009 9:37 am


My short answer is: Intelligence Quotient tests do not measure intelligence as a whole. They may give a very blurry picture as to how well a student may perform academically, but they are inaccurate in assessing a student's potential in life, therefore making them imperfect tools of intellectual measurement.

I say this despite the fact that in elementary school my own IQ test had a result of "genius-range" IQ, because there is no sure-fire way to measure human intelligence, nor human potential. How do you measure the IQ of a poor child in a less economically-developed country? Is a person exempt from being a "genius" simply because they have had no formal education or training (by developed nations' standards)? People who believe in IQ tests would probably say "yes," since supposedly the higher your IQ, the better your intellectual ability. neutral

Another flaw: IQ tests don't measure how creative, or even how wise you are.

Passion_Dragon
Crew

Reply
Welcome! Introductions and Miscellaneous

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum