Welcome to Gaia! ::

Making fanaticism more obsolete

I am quite glad that Osama does not realize all he is saying is counter-productive as it only shows how violent he is and that he will only bring more suffering and war to everyone.

he is still effective enough to recruit thousands with those kinds of lies

People waking up to a person's true motives and acting to thwart them is not an overnight process. Yes at first not much happens but a bridge crumbles one stone at a time.

Is it? He has the entire population of muslims who are true to the faith against him, the only people he is managing to recruit are those who are brought up with his teachings in thier heads. I would argue that he's not really as effective as people think he is, Al Qaeda has been rather quiet recently, I realize that could mean he's just flying under the radar for now, but honestly I think that give it another several years and Al Qaeda will become obsolete.

Tell me what has Al Qaeda accomplished since 2001, not much at all just a few bombings. Most muslims know the difference between Islam's teachings and the teachings of Osama.

Osama will probably never be captured in my opinion, personally if I were him I'd be in Africa, terrorism is rampant in Africa and we are not looking for him there. Although even if he is in the middle east we will most likely never find him because there are simply too many places to look.

I fail to believe that Al Qaeda's status is dependant on the capture of Osama Bin Laden. If we do find him then what? Do you think his band of crooks will just give up? They will rescue him from prison or kill themselves trying. The capture of Osama Bin Laden will do absolutely nothing, for even if they couldn't liberate him someone would take his place. Your argument is flawed in saying that nothing will change until his capture.

Also you mentioned other countries schools teaching philosophies not too different from Osama's whether or not that is true I do not know, regardless we are talking about Al Qaeda. States with policies openly hostile to the United States' interests can be changed through official channels.

My determination that Al Qaeda is on its way to being obsolete is made by looking at the last 20 years and noticing the trend starting as of 2001. The drop off of the rate in attacks tells me that one way or another Al Qaeda is becoming obsolete, whether that be from lack of support at home or from preventive actions taken by governments around the world is debatable.

Yes there have been a few sporadic bouts of violence from them, as to be expected but overall thier effectiveness has plummeted.

Look at AL Qaeda's history, they don't do a lot really. They support other groups but their biggest things have been both World Trade Center attacks. There was eight years they kept to small scale stuff between 1993 to 2001, so if they follow that pattern they would strike this year. Don't assume that if they haven't done anything recently that they can't.

Actually he's a very effective leader, he leads a good number of people (I don't have the exact figure on hand) and his rhetoric is totally nuts. Yet people believe and follow him because he is a different path and he uses pathos.