Welcome to Gaia! ::

The Stephenie Meyer Guild™

Back to Guilds

 

Tags: Twilght, Vampire, Jacob, Edward, New mon 

Reply Stephenie Meyer Guild
Edward or Jacob? Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Edward or Jacob
  Edward!!!
  Jacob!!!
View Results

Isabella Brooke Hart

PostPosted: Tue Dec 25, 2007 12:46 pm


Dr[[Acula]]
tiffany aka tink
Dr[[Acula]]
tiffany aka tink
Dr[[Acula]]

Lol, ohkay^-^
and i'm not starting a fight.
just a small debate.
dealio?
no meanness?!

2; not everything's going to kill her. she's not a doll. and she can handle her own.

7; no he's not. my proof? new moon.

10; you're a vampire. you're daddy and mommy are humans. can't stay with them forever. and mike, and all the kids from school? they aren't vampires. they're going to go away too.

11; Emily's very happy with her life.
even though she's got a scar, she's still in love, and has friends, and get's to socialize.

12; he is, but he's able able to control it when needed.


heart
*Smiles* Of course. Debates don't have to be mean.

2.) The expression "save me from myself" applies here. Plus the fact that she risks her life just being around him. *Shrugs*

7.) Yes he is. My proof: New Moon! =] (Meaning he never really left her, and her sub-concious knows it.)

10.) True, I'll admit. But what happens when you keep getting new scars from Jacob or his friends? And how to you explain that you love him to his imprinted?

11.)True. But Edward would never do that to her. Sure, he left her- but he would never hurt her. (Except if he were to turn her-which she wants)

12.) Ehh... I disagree. Only because of the forcefulness of him. And the fact that he doesn't like Edward. :/ .... I mean, Edward doesn't like him either, but he doesn't jeopardize (sp?) Bella or her feelings.

Question: I don't think this was ever discussed, that I know of, but do Werewolves die? (I know, silly question... Maybe I should read New Moon again.)

heart


2; but she's proven she can live with adventure, but without edward.
sure, she'll get banged up a bit. but nothing too bad.

7; i can see your point here. good counter!

10; bella's almost out of school. she can move in with Jake, and then Charlie wont see her that often. sure, once in a while he will, but not as often. and there's no certainty that Jacob will imprint on anyone.

11; but you can't keep friends for a long time.
sure you won't be scared. but you cant go out in the sun, or go to the beach. you're stuck with your "own kind"

12; i disagree with the feelings part.
he makes alice baby sit her to make sure she stays away from jacob!
how does tht show love?
if he really loved her, he should be confidant enough to let her see her best friend.


and, i think they can....
didn't one of them die in Eclipse?
Maybe?
Or...am i wrong?
*shrug*
i'll re read it, and find out.
i know they age.
and that billy[i think that's his name... jake's grandad(i don't like him-_-)] is super old.... so i doubt he'll be around for much longer
but i'm not sure if it says yes or no for sure.



heart

2.) True. I see your point there.
7.) Thank you =]
10.) True again, but Bella is a magnet for trouble. How is he always going to protect her if he causes trouble too?
11.)You could turn your friends. *Smiles* If you wanted to. And friends are easily replacable.
12.) He loved her. In Eclipse, protects her virtue. Jacob tries to force her.

Well I know they grow older when they're the human self... but I don't know if they only die because of being killed by a vampire or just... ever?
heart



Holy gosh, ma'am.
it's been a while.!
i'm sorry><
i haven't been online// on gaia much..

so here we go.

2/7=over. resolved/closed.

10; just because he causes trouble doesn't mean it's going to be for her. most of the time he's safe with her. or he's able to get her help fast, and they're able to have a good time while doing what they do. Edward though, he might protect her.. but say she does get hurt.. say she slices her arm open.. and he can't control himself, i mean, sure, he's proven himself before.. but never with a whole lot of her blood all over the place; nothing is certain.

11; but would that be fair? after hearing Rose's side and whatnot, knowing how some vampires feel about it.. would you feel right turning all your loved ones? what if they didn't want to? and replacing people just to loose them again can get very overwhelming.

12; she doesn't want he to 'protect her virtue' half the time! at least Jacob's willing to try and get what he wants. bella's the same way! she clings to edward while he's kissing her. she's trying to force him to go farther. he's just stronger. jacobs the same, but this time he's the stronger one. and hey, it did make her realize she loved him just as she does edward..


heart

Merry

Well hello ^_^ and Merry Christmas to you <3 And that's alright, I understand.

10.) But then again, nothing is certain that Jake won't hurt her. I mean Edward wants her blood, sure. But in Twilight, he admits near the end that he can control it. "An alcoholic drink". Even alcoholics can resist their desires. Sure he could slip up, but so could Jake if Bella ever says or does anything un-intentionally. It's all about control. Which both of them seem to have right now . I know Edward could slip up, but I'm saying so could Jake. Both easily.

11.) But she's willing to give it up. I would too, for true love. And wouldn't it be easier to be less attached to the world than to hide a secret from everyone? I mean, if I married a wolf, it would be hard to come up with explanations of why he's gone during the full moon, why he buys/wears new shirts all the time... this and that could go wrong... With Edward, they'll move away eventually. (Well they kind of have to if they turn Bella, since it's part of the agreement) But you wouldn't have to lie to anyone, you could live in peace, your (adopted) family would be there forever.

12.) Edward's a gentleman! He was born 1901, so he's not use to the oh-we're-not-married-but-we-still-can-sleep-together thing. I mean, yeah every girl gets tempted, but have you ever known a guy to say "No, I want to wait" ? Seriously! It takes guts to want to do something and know its not in your best interest. You know the saying "You don't know what you've got till it's gone"? Edward left his life long ago. He lost everything, including Bella at one point. So what's wrong with it? Although, I have to admit for Jake's sake, that being rough is a BIG turn-on. And that the kiss made her realize it, but still I'm with the vampires on this one.

Christmas

heart
 
PostPosted: Tue Dec 25, 2007 4:39 pm


Diinosaurs
Honestly Jacob's character disgusts me...

I like Edward just because he is way more mature. Although I would really like to see what happens if Bella picked Jacob, it would be totally unexpected.


yesh, i agree...

xXxHugAnEmoKidxXx


sweetxcandyxashy

PostPosted: Wed Dec 26, 2007 3:14 pm


hmmm.... i'd rather that bella went with edward... but then again there wouldn't really b a story if there was no jacob.... i'll have to think about it
PostPosted: Wed Dec 26, 2007 4:11 pm


Oh, yeah, sure, let the girl pick Jacob!
And when he imprints, let her be by herself!
In fact, maybe she'll become a cynical b***h like Leah!
That sounds wonderful!

neutral

Reels


Miss Megaboo

PostPosted: Sun Dec 30, 2007 8:12 pm


...If I would have been asked this question before reading New Moon and Eclipse, then I would have said Edward...But now that I've read the others, it's one of the toughest things I have to do! I CAN'T PICK!

I was always a loyal Edward fan and was kinda like "Jake...eh...A little kid" then from "oooh, hot...sexy...yummy Jake...I love him." Then I went to "oh I HATE JAKE." Then I cried for him in Eclipse...

I know a lot of you are having the same situation.

I don't exactly know who I like the best...If I could combine the two into a super sexy and ultimate being then I definately would....

But um...I think the best for me would probably be Jake. I'm too immature for Edward...Neither of them would like me, let alone like that, but I think I'd have a better chance with Jake most likely. sweatdrop

So anyway, I'm done with my ranting on that for now. And to answer your question...I gotta say Edward...Bella belongs with him...And I belong with Jake since I can't have both... crying emo
PostPosted: Sat Jan 05, 2008 8:24 pm


i lovelovelove edwardd!

and jacobs getting in the way of bella and edward
so i dont like him
xD

`OohDang_she LOVES him!


Kyoko-Poky

PostPosted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 12:36 pm


I'm my opinion, Edward's the better option. What would happen when Jacob changes heart for her and found his wolfly bond with some other girl?
PostPosted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 5:27 pm



Edward. :]

I chose "twilight" because of a VAMPIRE and a HUMAN GIRL.

That's what caught my attention.

Not werewolf.

I really wish that Bella's personality was... better though. I feel that she's sorta.. bratty.

But if Edward loves her... go for it.

Jacob might love Bella, but he might imprint with some other girl, then what?

Bella's heartbroken, and as much as I dislike her, I don't want Edward to suffer because of her selfishness.


x C o t t o n


katgems

Anxious Phantom

PostPosted: Tue Jan 08, 2008 2:33 am



well, me, Nazi and Dictator (my bestest friends) have this joke going.....
Nazi: Integra can have Alucard, and i will cry, but at least i'll get Maxwell
Dictator: Kagome can have Inu Yasha, as long as i get Sesshomaru
The Jew(me) : Bella can have Edward as long as i get Jacob.

so, that's the joke...
but, seriously, I DON'T KNOW!!
i mean, she's stuck with Edward either way, and even though Jacob is the greatest character of all time, in my personal opinion, Bella's already made her choice. i mean, she is geting MARRIED! so, either way, she's stuck. no matter who she chooses in the end


Reply
Stephenie Meyer Guild

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum