Welcome to Gaia! ::

Oh noes!
I thought I spoke my mind here.
gonk

I say keep the guild Private but put it into that thingy Yawg suggested, If we open the guild to the public so everybody can join then this place will turn chaotic and into a chatterbox look-a-like. I've seen it happen several times.
Yes it would grant us more members but do we want members that enjoy to RP and will stay active as well as true to the guild or do we want people running around utterly godmodding, giving a rats a** about the rules and start to pester the Site mods as well as others about donations or how they want to become mods.

I'd rather want decent people in here then those asking for my nitemare headband, trying to blackmail me to give it up too them, will cyber or...god forbid...use chat speak in an RP.

I have only been here for a few months but i think private would be better but it would be nice to have some other ppl in here so places dont stay desolate of new posts for months until somone finaly realizes its there and uses it for two minutes and we fall back to the same threads.