Welcome to Gaia! ::

Politicians of Gaia

Back to Guilds

A place for debates of political/social values and ideas 

Tags: Politics, debate, Conservtive, Liberal, Moderate 

Reply Debate Forum
low blows

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Twizted Humanitarian
Crew

PostPosted: Tue Aug 14, 2007 6:46 pm


Editing your own entry on Wikipedia is usually the province of vain celebrities keen for some good PR. But a new website has uncovered dozens of companies that have been editing the site in order to improve their public image.

The Wikipedia Scanner, which trawls the backwaters of the popular online encyclopaedia, has unearthed a catalogue of organisations massaging entries, including the CIA and the Labour party.

Workers operating on CIA computers have been spotted editing entries including the biography of former presidents Ronald Reagan and Richard Nixon, while unnamed individuals inside the Vatican have worked on entries about Catholic saints - and Sinn Féin leader Gerry Adams.

Meanwhile, an anonymous surfer from Labour's Millbank headquarters excised a section about Labour Students which referred to "careerist MPs" and criticisms that the party's student movement was no longer seen as radical.

And somebody from a computer traced to Democrat HQ edited a page on conservative American radio host Rush Limbaugh, calling him "idiotic", "ridiculous" and labelling his 20 million listeners as "legally retarded".

But the biggest culprit that the Scanner claims to have discovered is Diebold, a supplier of voting machines, which it says has made huge alterations to entries about its involvement in the controversial "hanging chad" election in the US in 2000. The company was criticised in the wake of the disputed results, but edits made by its employees on Wikipedia have included the removal of 15 paragraphs detailing the allegations.

"In August 2003 Walden O'Dell, chief executive of Diebold, announced that he had been a top fundraiser for George W Bush ..." the deleted text read. "When assailed by critics for the conflict of interest ... he vowed to lower his political profile."

The change, made two years ago, was quickly reversed and the culprit warned off for "vandalism". A Diebold official was not available for comment.

It is not the first time people have been found editing their own Wikipedia entries, which is considered a breach of etiquette on the site. Last year some US Congressional staff were found to be removing information they deemed unsavoury from the profiles of the politicians they worked for, and this year computer group Microsoft back-pedalled after it was revealed to have offered money to experts to "correct" entries about it on the site.

The Scanner, built by Virgil Griffith, a researcher at the California Institute of Technology, works by comparing 5.3m edits made on the encyclopaedia against the internet addresses of more than 2m companies or individuals.
PostPosted: Tue Aug 14, 2007 10:38 pm


Interesting, but not surprising. It is a powerful temptation to try and edit your history to make yourself look better. The United States does it all the time in history books - it's amazing the amount of inaccurate or biased facts found in them. I do not believe that this is right, but I understand why somethng like this would happen.

thenerdqueen


Twizted Humanitarian
Crew

PostPosted: Wed Aug 15, 2007 5:45 am


thenerdqueen
Interesting, but not surprising. It is a powerful temptation to try and edit your history to make yourself look better. The United States does it all the time in history books - it's amazing the amount of inaccurate or biased facts found in them. I do not believe that this is right, but I understand why somethng like this would happen.

lets see some examples
PostPosted: Wed Aug 15, 2007 3:26 pm


Waco.
Ruby Ridge.
Several presidential scandals.
Who was the call woman who released the list of congressman names that she worked for?

uryu ishida


thenerdqueen

PostPosted: Wed Aug 15, 2007 10:22 pm


Christopher Columbus
Pocahantas' and Powhatan's relationship with colonists
Helen Keller
Woodrow Wilson
George Washington
Ponce de Leon


Also covered up are some ideas in textbooks.

The class system (9 layers in America today)
Religion
The ideals behind Communism/Socialism
The fact that Africans landed in Mexico long before any Europeans.
PostPosted: Thu Aug 16, 2007 6:09 am


thenerdqueen
Christopher Columbus
Pocahantas' and Powhatan's relationship with colonists
Helen Keller
Woodrow Wilson
George Washington
Ponce de Leon


Also covered up are some ideas in textbooks.

The class system (9 layers in America today)
Religion
The ideals behind Communism/Socialism
The fact that Africans landed in Mexico long before any Europeans.


this can all be simply explained... do you honestly expect a HIGH SCHOOL textbook to give you ALL the information of our history?

Twizted Humanitarian
Crew


Verderbnis

PostPosted: Thu Aug 16, 2007 8:19 am


Wikipedia contains alot of hack'n'slashed-information. But the german wikipedia is not crippled so bad. I know alot of (independent) people writing for wikipedia, meeting at conferences, to provide a complete service for wikipedia and the users.

If you feel the need to correct articles, then do it, just write what I know, but drop your fingers of stating also opinions inside the article. The people want knowledge, not propaganda.
PostPosted: Sun Aug 19, 2007 12:34 pm


Jungle Soldier
thenerdqueen
Christopher Columbus
Pocahantas' and Powhatan's relationship with colonists
Helen Keller
Woodrow Wilson
George Washington
Ponce de Leon


Also covered up are some ideas in textbooks.

The class system (9 layers in America today)
Religion
The ideals behind Communism/Socialism
The fact that Africans landed in Mexico long before any Europeans.


this can all be simply explained... do you honestly expect a HIGH SCHOOL textbook to give you ALL the information of our history?

I hon't know about you, but I'd have liked to have my HS hstory texts not be quite so selective in what they explained... luckily I had some really good teachers that opted to go out, do some research, and filled in the gaps with supplemental information.

dronze


Twizted Humanitarian
Crew

PostPosted: Sun Aug 19, 2007 1:08 pm


dronze
Jungle Soldier
thenerdqueen
Christopher Columbus
Pocahantas' and Powhatan's relationship with colonists
Helen Keller
Woodrow Wilson
George Washington
Ponce de Leon


Also covered up are some ideas in textbooks.

The class system (9 layers in America today)
Religion
The ideals behind Communism/Socialism
The fact that Africans landed in Mexico long before any Europeans.


this can all be simply explained... do you honestly expect a HIGH SCHOOL textbook to give you ALL the information of our history?

I hon't know about you, but I'd have liked to have my HS hstory texts not be quite so selective in what they explained... luckily I had some really good teachers that opted to go out, do some research, and filled in the gaps with supplemental information.


thats what teachers are for the text book is intended as a supplement to the teachers classroom instruction.
Reply
Debate Forum

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum