|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 Posted: Tue Jun 27, 2006 3:31 pm
MrsAizuElric
"All you gotta do is /Smile!/" Judge "Q" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: All you got to do is smile_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) Yes Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?Yes No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")Yes No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?Yes No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? Yes No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?No Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? Yes No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? The way the links and buttons have been modified. What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? Yes, I don't like the way you have to scroll up and down to see the comments.ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0
#2 = 1
#3 = 1
#4 = 2
#5 = 1
#6 = 2
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 9.5
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers.It's a very intriguing profile of which I must say that alone with it's quilting image is quite interesting. Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: MrsAizuElric "All you gotta do is /Smile!/"_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) No. Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?Yes. No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")Some of them, yes. The "view posts" link in particular is missing. No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?Yes. No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? Yes. No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?No. Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? Yes. No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? The boxes are nice. What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? I would have liked to see a few more colors used from the art at the top.ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1.0
#3 = 0.5
#4 = 2.0
#5 = 1.0
#6 = 2.0
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 9.5
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers.The only concern I have is that it seems like there is a huge file or something used in the profile. Everytime I view the profile, if I try to do anything with the music player-thing, or even just closing the window, I get a lot of lag... Judge "N" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: MrsAizuElric _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) 0.5 Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way? 1 No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.") 0.5 No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme? 2 No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? 1 No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme? 2 Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? 2 No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? The layout and the art are beautiful. What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? The only thing I could see wrong was that your multimedia was not working. ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1
#3 = 0.5
#4 = 2
#5 = 1
#6 = 2
#7 = 2
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 9
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Average Rating = 9.33
Popularity = 19 Votes
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Jun 27, 2006 3:32 pm
Rithynia
"The colors of Rithynia" Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Rithynia "The colors of Rithynia"_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) No. Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?Yes. No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")A few. The "view posts" link, especially, is missing. No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?Yes. No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? Yes. No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?No. Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? Yes, for the most part. No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? I like that it is colorful, and side-scrolling is different. What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? It may just be my screen size, but the status bar buttons are tiny. There is much more room at the bottom than there needs to be. The whole thing looks like there is a film over it, making it cloudy and a little hard on the eyes.ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1.0
#3 = 0.5
#4 = 2.0
#5 = 1.0
#6 = 2.0
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 9.5
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "N" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Rithynia _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) 0.5 Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way? 1 No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.") 1 No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme? 2 No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? 1 No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme? 2 Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? 2.5 No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? Everything the whole profile is adorable. I love it! What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? Nothing. ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1
#3 = 1
#4 = 2
#5 = 1
#6 = 2
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 10
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "Q" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: "The colors of Rithynia" by Rithynia_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) No Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?Yes No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")Yes No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?Yes No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? Yes No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?No Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? No No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? The brightness of the colors What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? That cannot see the friendlist or comments at allADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1
#3 = 1
#4 = 2
#5 = 1
#6 = 2
#7 = 0
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 7.5
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Average Rating = 9.00
Popularity = 14 Votes
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Jun 27, 2006 3:34 pm
psytrance
"Psychedelia" Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:psytrance "Psychedelia"_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme)No. Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?Yes, because I have not seen the background, etc., used on any other profile yet. There is barely what I would call a "theme" here, though.No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality:#3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")Yes. No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity:#4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?No. I believe it was once stated on the profile that the background is from another source/not created by him, so, pretty much all he had to do was the positioning, which is the layout, not the theme. No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique:#5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme?I have to say no, because there isn't really much of a theme here. There's a header, a background and some sort of "static" effect when you hover over the status bar links. The multimedia at the time this judging was done had nothing to do with the profile, it seems. No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?LYes. The multimedia especially. But, like I said, it's difficult to find a theme in this profile.Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure:#7 --Is the profile put together well overall?No. The layout is decent, but the theme is lacking.No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile?I like the color scheme.What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?I would try to decide on a theme and make everything match that. The link hover behavior could be the same for most of the links, there could be some sort of static effect elsewhere on the profile to tie things in...Perhaps the colors of the scrollbars could be changed. The multimedia could match whatever the theme is. ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1.0
#3 = 1.0
#4 = 0.0
#5 = 0.0
#6 = 0.0
#7 = 0.0
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 2.5 / 10
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "N" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: psytrance _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) 0.5 Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way? 0.5 No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.") 1 No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme? 1 No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? 1 No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme? 1.5 Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? 2 No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? Graphics & Layout What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? It's a little boring. ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 0.5
#3 = 1
#4 = 1
#5 = 1
#6 = 1.5
#7 = 2
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 7.5
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "Q" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Psychedelia_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) No Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?Yes No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")Yes No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?Yes No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? Yes No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?No Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? Yes No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? The way the avatar is centered around the whole of the profile. What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? The scroll to go up and down to see the friends, comments and other things.ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = .5
#2 = 1
#3 = 1
#4 = 2
#5 = 1
#6 = 2
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 10
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Average Rating = 6.67
Popularity = 4 Votes
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Jun 27, 2006 3:34 pm
Elixate
"Summer, Baby" Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Elixate "Summer, Baby"_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) No. Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?Yes. No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")No. It appears as though all the links are there, but the "ignore" button is the only link on the status bar that seems to work. The "view posts," etc., links do work. No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?Yes. No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? Yes. No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?No. Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? More or less, yes. No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? The background. What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? The comments area is a bit too empty and bland compared to the top portion. The avatars overlap in some cases and it's terribly difficult to tell which comment goes with which avatar.ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1.0
#3 = 0.0
#4 = 2.0
#5 = 1.0
#6 = 2.0
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 9.0
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "N" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Elixate _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) 0.5 Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way? 1 No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.") 0.5 No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme? 1.5 No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? 1 No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme? 2 Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? 2 No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? Love the theme and clean look. What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?Your toolbar needs a little work. ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1
#3 = 0.5
#4 = 1.5
#5 = 1
#6 = 2
#7 = 2
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 8.5
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "Q" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Summer Baby by Elixate_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) No Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?Yes No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")Yes No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?Yes No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? A few things No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?No Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? Yes No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? The calming of a summer. What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? NoADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = .5
#2 = 1
#3 = 1
#4 = 2
#5 = .5
#6 = 2
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 9.5
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers.While looking at the background of the profile, I had enjoyed because it was as calm as a summerbreeze. Average Rating = 9.00
Popularity = 12 Votes
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Jun 27, 2006 3:36 pm
Elindranyth
"A Colorful Avy" Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Elindranyth "A Colorful Avy"_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme)No. Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?Yes. No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality:#3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")Yes. No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity:#4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?I will say yes, even though it is a little plain. It is very user-friendly, neat and easy on the eyes; everything is where you can find it, and there are a few "treats" for the person who stays awhile rather than thinking all they see at first is all there is to it. For example, the links in the status bar have a neat effect when hovered over and the multimedia is at the bottom. No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique:#5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme?Yes, as far as headers/fonts/backgrounds go. No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?Yes. The multimedia doesn't seem to have much to do with the profile. Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure:#7 --Is the profile put together well overall?Yes. No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile?See above. (#4)What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?Hmmm...the 3-column layout is a little over-used and I already mentioned the multimedia.ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1.0
#3 = 1.0
#4 = 2.0
#5 = 1.0
#6 = 0.0
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 8.0 / 10
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "N" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Elindranyth _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) 0.5 Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way? 1 No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.") 1 No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme? 1.5 No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? 1 No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme? 2 Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? 2.5 No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? The layout & toolbar. What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?Not much but maybe add a piece of art. ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1
#3 = 1
#4 = 1.5
#5 = 1
#6 = 2
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 9.5
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "Q" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: A Colorful Avi by Elindranyth_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) No Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?Yes No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")Yes No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?Yes No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? Yes No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?Yes Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? Yes No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? The organization of this profile. What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? No.ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = .5
#2 = 1
#3 = 1
#4 = 2
#5 = 1
#6 = 0
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 9
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Average Rating = 8.83
Popularity = 7 Votes
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Jun 27, 2006 3:37 pm
[Q]
"Narcisistic Sanctuary" Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:[Q] "Narcisistic Sanctuary"_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme)No. Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?Yes. It's a little empty, but is that to keep your attention on the movie? ^^No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality:#3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")I say "somewhat." The links can only be accessed by first clicking the "Profile Specific" link, which gives you a navigation window containing the standard links. No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity:#4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?Yes. The movie looks like it took a lot of work. No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique:#5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme?Yes, the headers and fonts and background seem to match. No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?No. Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure:#7 --Is the profile put together well overall?Yes. No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile?I like the "NavWindow" function. It allows the visitor to access TONS of info, (by way of links, however), and it's pretty unique. The movie is well done and interesting.What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?The scrollbars are visually distracting and the comments are cut off. Also, though the movie is the main focus of the profile, it auto-starts, which can be bothersome. Also, I couldn't figure out what the little bar in the upper left was for. It matches the one in the lower right, which controls the movie, but it doesn't seem to have a purpose.ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1.0
#3 = 0.5
#4 = 2.0
#5 = 1.0
#6 = 2.0
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 9.5 / 10
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "N" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: [Q] _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) 0.5 Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way? 1 No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.") 0.5 No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme? 2 No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? 1 No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme? 2 Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? 2.5 No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? The flash is awesome. What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?Nothing. ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1
#3 = 0.5
#4 = 2
#5 = 1
#6 = 2
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 9.5
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "Q" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Narcisistic Sanctuary by [Q]_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) No Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?No No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")Yes No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?Yes No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? Yes No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?Yes Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? No No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? There isn't anything What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? That you have to click a few times to where you want to go. The text is too small to read.ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = .5
#2 = 0
#3 = 1
#4 = 2
#5 = 1
#6 = 0
#7 = 0
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 4.5
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Average Rating = 7.83
Popularity = 6 Votes
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Jun 27, 2006 3:39 pm
Suyara
"Purple Love" Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Suyara "Purple Love"_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme)No. Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?No. No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality:#3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")Yes. No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity:#4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?No. Though skills vary, it looks like more time could have been spent making the theme really nice-looking. It doesn't seem like very much time was spent on perfecting the theme. No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique:#5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme?Yes. No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?No..everything's...purple. Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure:#7 --Is the profile put together well overall?Yes. Everything matches the purple theme and because the standard layout was used, the positioning of course is all correct.No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile?The changing picture on the bottom left. If the page is refresed, there may be a different picture there. It's a clean-cut, decent start and effort.What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?Like I said above, I believe more thought could have been put into it. It's not very exciting or interesting.ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 0.0
#3 = 1.0
#4 = 0.0
#5 = 1.0
#6 = 2.0
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 7.0 / 10
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "N" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Suyara _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) 0.5 Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way? 0.5 No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.") 1 No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme? 1 No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? 1 No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme? 2 Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? 2 No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? Love the color and multimedia. What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?Spice up the layout move some things around. ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 0.5
#3 = 1
#4 = 1
#5 = 1
#6 = 2
#7 = 2
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 8
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "Q" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Purple Love by Suyara_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme)Yes Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?Yes No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality:#3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")Yes No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity:#4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?Yes No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique:#5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme?Some things No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?No Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure:#7 --Is the profile put together well overall?Yes No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile?What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 =0
#2 =1
#3 =1
#4 =2
#5 =.5
#6 =2
#7 =2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING =9
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Average Rating = 8.00
Popularity = 3 Votes
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Jun 27, 2006 3:42 pm
[ponygon]
"Pear-pod" Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:[ponygon] "Pear-pod"_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme)No. Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?No, not really. No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality:#3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")No. The only standard links I see are the ones that pertain to the comments section. The necessary ones--ignore, PM, view posts--were omitted. No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity:#4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?No. It's very plain; a lot more could have been added to tie in the "pear-pod" theme; maybe even the generic "i-Pod silhouette" would have been a nice addition somewhere. ^^ No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique:#5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme?Yes. What little there is on the profile seems to match--the fonts/headers. No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?No. Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure:#7 --Is the profile put together well overall?Yes, besides the problems with the links. It's very uninteresting, but the stuff that IS there doesn't clash or overlap or anything. No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile?It simplicity.What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?It's very boring. There are links missing that every profile should have. Choose a different color for the links the profile does have.ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 0.0
#3 = 0.0
#4 = 0.0
#5 = 1.0
#6 = 2.0
#7 = 2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 6.0 / 10
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "N" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: [ponygon] _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme) 0.5 Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way? 1 No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality: #3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.") 0 No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity: #4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme? 1.5 No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique: #5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme? 1 No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme? 2 Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure: #7 --Is the profile put together well overall? 1.5 No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile? Very original theme. What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?The gray color for links is hard to see. Add a toolbar. ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1
#3 = 0
#4 = 1.5
#5 = 1
#6 = 2
#7 = 1.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 7.5
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Judge "Q" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Pear-pod by ponygon_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: #1 --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme)No Yes = +0 No = +0.5 #2 --In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?Yes No = +0 Yes = +1 Please look at functionality:#3 --Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")A few No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1 Please look at creativity:#4 --Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?Yes No = +0 Yes = +2 Please look at technique:#5 --Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme?Yes No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1 #6 --Are there things that clash with the theme?Yes Yes = +0 No = +2 Please look at structure:#7 --Is the profile put together well overall?Yes No = +0 Yes = +2.5 _____________________________________________________________ What is the best feature of this profile?What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".
#1 =.5
#2 =1
#3 =.5
#4 =2
#5 =1
#6 =0
#7 =2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING =7.5
_____________________________________________________________ Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers. Average Rating = 7.00
Popularity = 4 Votes
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Jun 27, 2006 5:36 pm
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Aug 22, 2006 8:36 pm
Round 7 This round, I will only be reviewing and rating the three winning profiles. Since there was an issue with the voting, I won't be listing the Popularity this time.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Aug 22, 2006 8:40 pm
rainingsugar
"Totally Pink" This profile is simple, yet cute and really eye-catching. It is total cuteness from the boarders and the corners to the faint swirls in the background and the bubbly letters that make up the headers. The multimedia is adorable as well--the music from it provides sweetness to the ears while viewers browse a compact, yet functional layout. The scrollbars seem to clash a little, though. Also, the profile is very sweet, but exciting it is not. Other than the multimedia and the tiny blip about the user in the about section, there isn't much else to take in; the profile probably doesn't hold one's attention for too long. Overall, I rate the profile 8.5 / 10.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Aug 22, 2006 9:03 pm
MrsAizuElric
"yOu AiN't GoT tHe magic touch BrOtHa" This profile is interesting to say the least. The color scheme uses complimentary colors that bring a cool feeling to the profile. The animated status bar adds a touch of originality and creativity, while the characters in the header simply make you want to know more. The shape of the layout is in itself fun and original. Beyond the top portion, though, things begin to get a bit average--other than the link list, there really is nothing new here that separates this profile from the others that are out there. My overall rating for this profile is 8 / 10.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Aug 22, 2006 9:22 pm
[Q]
"Trepanation" The coding, technique, organization and functionality in this profile are superb. From the multimedia/flash and innovative right-clicking feature, to the color scheme and layout, the profile is nicely done. It's look and feel makes it different from most of the other profiles out there. However, it does look a bit crammed in some areas and it took a few moments to locate an "off switch" for the music, which may prove a little frustrating to some visitors. I give this profile an overall 9.5 / 10.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Aug 22, 2006 9:23 pm
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
