|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 29, 2006 5:51 am
Xellos_Inverse Island of Moreau Xellos_Inverse Could you check out my profile again. I changed alot. Looking much better. The name is fine now, and you've offered a bit more insight into his head. Just to help you out, try writing out what happened to his family, or why does he have a hard time making friends. The more you delve into your characters head, the better, more believable the character will become. You still have offered no explaination for the ball and chain. Or how he heard about the island, nor did you address the fact that its a phyisical imposibity to get to the island in a rowboat. Okay. I went though and redid more. Talked more about his family and why he was in jail. I also went ito more about how he would get to the island and how he found out about it. Just a note - the height on your bolded profile doesn't match the description (though 6'3" sounds more likely than 6'11") I like the addition that he's taken the fall for people - a glimpse at a kinder side of Michael than just a bully and a thief. The less information from the guard also is more reasonable - though you might (reccomendation, not requirement, but it would help flesh out the character) explain why/how Michael formed the bond with the guard - which also might give more insight into why Michael escaped. Perhaps the guard was affiliated with/a plant of Feral Labs itself and essentially instructed to keep an eye out for prisoners with no strong ties that they could field towards the island. But yeah, the only thing really left unanswered then is how he escaped jail, if you wanted to delve into it. The character's come a long way from the initial concept, and I think is much more solid and believable :3 The only other word of caution, and I know you've heard this, is that a few islanders may feel that you are stepping on toes with going from the convict/gangster-sort into a big cat. But at least, if Michael washes ashore and Moreau doesn't know who he is/his past - he is more likely to get a predator serum than if Moreau knew of his violent past.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 29, 2006 6:03 am
sailornorthstar Official Critique Request Gaia Username: sailornorthstar Character Name: Aurora Eveningstar Serum Animal(s): Golden Lion Tamarin Quest Thread: http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2478101I fixed a lot of it up thought how she gets to the island is a little iffy since i am still trying to get it to work First off, I see you've changed the haircolor to a more natural one - very cool - that was one of the main snags of believability in the first draft. You might want to take some of the background through a spell-checker, but overall the concept is much more fleshed out with insight into her parents and the naming scheme. My only other comment is that Athena is quite young to be working for an espionage agency. I know that the CIA at least prefers that operatives be at least 25 before any work like that. I don't know what organization that you wanted to have her working for, but most don't recruit out of High School. The revision on the entry to the island sounds good. Though the rain jacket seems out of place kindness if she's about to get shot by the men. Other than those minor crits, the character seems good smile
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 29, 2006 8:43 am
Sorry, WerewolfKin - I have to skip ya due to the pagination error. Hopefully it resolves itself soon >< [ astra ] Official Critique Request [postrevision 1] Gaia Username: [ astra ] Character Name: Thanatos Lagurs Serum Animal(s): cannibal spider Quest Thread:updated parts: - made him bipolar, took away all drugs minus the occasional alcohol - made him arachnaphobic XD - made more conflict with family over him being gay with his family, and how it sort of tore him apart - made him more placid, when he's not hypomanic. often hides from all the issues he can't face >3> lub ! heart heart Hi astra, I like the bipolar disorder angle better than the OD on drugs. From what I've seen of people with bipolar disorder, they can be the nicest, most gregarious people one day, or if something sets them off that could be minor, or just catch them on a bad day and they can chew your head off OR lapse into serious depression and feelings of low self esteem. Which I do think works for the concept. I can fully understand the enjoyment of playing a character becoming that which they fear. But do keep in mind that it has been done at least once (more depending on if you count a hydrophobe becoming an aquatic animal). Many people don't like spiders, but there is a distinct difference between a dislike/hatred and a downright phobia of them. Phobias are uncommon, irrational fears that can paralyze an individual and make them unable to deal with the situation. Much more than your standard "eek" reaction. I will say that the nickname and the depressive side of the personality waves 'teenage goth poetry'/emo flags at me, and I have seen concepts of a similar nature done very badly. I will also caution another gay male character - don't get me wrong - I certainly have nothing against them - but don't fall into the fangirl trap that is very prevalent on Gaia that makes the character cute/emo and clingy and altogether unrealistic in the ignoring the social repercussions that Gaia, the wonderful place that it is, shields most people from. A few final modifications on the 'getting to the island' suggestion-wise: whomever he talked to likely doesn't know the full story of the island (almost no one on the mainland does) and the question regarding animals woudln't have come up. The charity house is a good 'in' - in fact, one of the best ways in might very well have been Thanatos talking to someone about wanting an opportunity to start fresh or get out of the business. Maybe someone even in the scene and not a newbie who had themselves heard about a private community that the charity house interviewed for. Maybe the individual even was rejected themselves, but decided to suggest it to him. A note on the exotic markings - they only pertain to real-world animal patterns, so spirials wouldn't really be an option.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 29, 2006 11:49 am
Quote: I like the bipolar disorder angle better than the OD on drugs. From what I've seen of people with bipolar disorder, they can be the nicest, most gregarious people one day, or if something sets them off that could be minor, or just catch them on a bad day and they can chew your head off OR lapse into serious depression and feelings of low self esteem. Which I do think works for the concept. X3 yea, i was inspired by uh. one of my friends who's bipolar, though she's medicated. i figgered there was enough drugness ^^; especially after realizing how many use X3Quote: I can fully understand the enjoyment of playing a character becoming that which they fear. But do keep in mind that it has been done at least once (more depending on if you count a hydrophobe becoming an aquatic animal). Many people don't like spiders, but there is a distinct difference between a dislike/hatred and a downright phobia of them. Phobias are uncommon, irrational fears that can paralyze an individual and make them unable to deal with the situation. Much more than your standard "eek" reaction. D: true. didn't really think of it that way. instead of having that phobia, i think i'll tone it down to the point where he just obsesses over cleanliness. 3nodding Quote: I will say that the nickname and the depressive side of the personality waves 'teenage goth poetry'/emo flags at me, and I have seen concepts of a similar nature done very badly. XD;; yea, by far very emoemo. He's very emoemo himself, when he gets out of control (since he doesn't really know that he's bipolar) i think i will keep the teeny bopper emo ness because he is that two weeks out of two months. i'll try not to pull it off horribly. ^^;Quote: I will also caution another gay male character - don't get me wrong - I certainly have nothing against them - but don't fall into the fangirl trap that is very prevalent on Gaia that makes the character cute/emo and clingy and altogether unrealistic in the ignoring the social repercussions that Gaia, the wonderful place that it is, shields most people from. D: i did try to make some social repercussions, he doesn't even talk to his family anymore because of it, same to anyone he called a friend during childhood. i think i will revise the gay though, D: maybe slightly -questioning- but not...flamboyant and willing. XD like. *thinks of how to describe it* not even bisexual, but still performs for men because he's gotta :[ *light bulb*Quote: A few final modifications on the 'getting to the island' suggestion-wise: whomever he talked to likely doesn't know the full story of the island (almost no one on the mainland does) and the question regarding animals woudln't have come up. The charity house is a good 'in' - in fact, one of the best ways in might very well have been Thanatos talking to someone about wanting an opportunity to start fresh or get out of the business. Maybe someone even in the scene and not a newbie who had themselves heard about a private community that the charity house interviewed for. Maybe the individual even was rejected themselves, but decided to suggest it to him. omg. *hug* you totally saved my a** right there. XD i had no iiideeaaa what to do there still, and i think i have an idea now! heart Quote: A note on the exotic markings - they only pertain to real-world animal patterns, so spirials wouldn't really be an option. awww. whee oh well. xd *toddles off to revise <3*
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 29, 2006 8:31 pm
WereWolfKin Official Critique RequestGaia Username: WereWolfKin Character Name: Kaelyn Murassi Serum Animal(s): Binturong (nonmorphic) Quest Thread: http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2536936I changed how she got to the island and added why she would become a binturong (though the why she would become a binturong needs some help) And no one would miss her for about a year so it is good for Moreau too. *hopes it is better* There isn't a great deal of elaboration on the character, but that is fine - not all characters need to be 100% fleshed out in the concept stage - I know sometimes that comes through roleplaying, and there doesn't seem to be any gaping holes or aspects of her past that don't make senes. However, my primary concern is that after reading the character, save for her nationality and not being diabetic she reminds me a good deal of Kim. We do already have two pretty enthusiastic video-game girls on the Island between Kim and Awen. I know that that has gotten to be more of a trend now-a-days (*feels old* but still, a true Gamer girl is more rare than I think most guys wish). I do like the aversion to animals in general - that's different. We will still need to figure out how Feral Labs got wind of her, though an entry scenario isn't always necessary ahead of time, given some methods of acquisition come with pre-packaged reason. This reason makes more sense than Moreau inviting a computer programmer specifically (which could be pretty bad judgment on his part given the security), but as it stands she would probably have had to had a run in with Feral Labs or some association thereof if you want her to be handpicked. Otherwise her profile, even with an uneasiness around animals, wouldn't be found among a huge populace. And of course there is the issue of her leaving - even on a scholarship - and her parents never be able to communicate with her.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 29, 2006 8:57 pm
Marshall_Green I'm going for the Seal of Approval...No, not like Dude seal but...Y'know what I mean! I made it a bit more clear on WHY Marshall was picked for the Island, so you can just read the end of his History thing. Official Critique Request Gaia Username: DecayingThorn Character Name: Marshall Green Serum Animal(s): Emperor Penguin Quest Thread: ]http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2475101HI DT, I still really like the character. He's very believable and has a lot of developed personality. The only hitch with the method to the island is still that Feral Labs makes a LOT of money. It woudln't be worth the risk to them to 'disappear' a webcomic who has a family (and if he has a webcomic than there has to be a following of people who would notice him missing) in exchange for the cut of the royalties on the character that he would have made. I do think that the earlier suggestion would work well - and make sense why they would risk disappearing him if Marshall did threaten a lawsuit after approaching the heads directly for changing the character and cutting his creative control - disappearing him before the threat ever saw light. And that would provide an issue for Marshall - the one time he stood up for something he believed in getting bit for it. Essentially, especially if Feral Labs has their fingers in CC, then like any network they would have had basis for inspriation for their cartoons. People who would be getting royalties off of whatever the characters were. Why would they single out Marshall to kidnap, someone who might be in the public eye?
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 2:03 pm
Sayuri_Nitta Not live in per se, but they can become what are known as 'patrons' for Geisha..basically they take on all the financial burdens, and may or may not reap the 'benefits' from such a relationship. A patron would conceivably set a Geisha up in a place of her own that he would visit...so if it was approached this way, Sayuri being taking to the Island would be seen as going to live somewhere her patron has paid for, and if she didnt return they would presume that they had fallen in love and that Sayuri no longer wanted to work in the flower and willow world. I think that would work? XD Yes, it makes a lot of sense to me that a high-up in Feral Labs might offer to be her patron. Especially if he lived far away, possibly abroad, it would make sense that he would set up a place for her stay.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 2:08 pm
Xellos_Inverse Official Critique Request Gaia Username: Xellos_Inverse Character Name: Xellos Inverse Serum Animal(s): Puma Concolor Quest Thread:http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2475159&page=1Okay. xp I've put more into how he got out and alittle more about the guard, changed the height. Hopefully this will be the last time. I'm going for the seal. Hopefully it won't be too much longer before I get it! Thank you for this board it's really helped me to build my character and get to know what your looking for in a belevable characer. Everything's looking a lot better. I guess I can't -force- you to change the shackles thing >.> But it seems really... unrealistic/cheesy. Otherwise, everything seems to be coming together very nicely. I still think delving alittle more in his past might help you continue to develop him more. But thats just a suggestion, not a requirement. :3
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 2:13 pm
Nita MacNeal Official Critique Request Revised! Gaia Username: Kimie Kitty Character Name: Nita MacNeal Serum Animal(s): Red Panda Quest Thread: http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2475119I know it says temp closed, but I just made a couple of revisions. In particular, I reworked how Nita gets to the Island, and I added a bit more insight into her family and personal history. Sounds good. I would even say the SA program was sponsered by Feral Labs. They have way ways to "dissapear" people when they never come back. This what happened with Ambrose, kind of, with his medical study. You see, Feral Labs is sneaky like that... they would ACTUALLY sponders SA programs,,, probably 50 or so a year all ove rthe country. So it doesn't look THAT suspicious if they only gace out 1 and then that 1 person didn't come back.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|