Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply Main Forum
Custom Profile Contest: [Contestant Ballots] Goto Page: [|«] [<] 1 2 3 ... 5 6 7 8 9 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Is it helpful to be able to view the ballots?
  Yes, very.
  No, not at all.
  A little.
  What is a "ballot?"
View Results

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline
PostPosted: Mon May 22, 2006 5:10 pm


Cali Soca:
"Minish Cap"

Judge "N"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Cali Soca
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
NO
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
NO

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
YES

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
YES
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
YES

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
YES
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
YES

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
YES
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
NOTHING
What is the best feature of this profile?
THE WHOLE PROFILE

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
9.5
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "F"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Cali Soca
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
yes
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
no

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
yes

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
yes
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
well... they're both about link...

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
yes
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
yes

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
yes
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
the graphics all have potential, but they're not very good right now. Some of them are too wide, some aren't tall enough, and they don't all seem flow well
What is the best feature of this profile?
it's a decent layout

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
5
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "O"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Minish Cap by Cali Soca
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
Yes.. and no.
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
Yeah.. Zelda is quite popular too..

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
Yuppers.

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
Yes
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
nintendo games.. Just got a snippet of it.. I think so...

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
Yes.. Not a lot.
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
Not really

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
Yes.. Just I don't like it when I have to scroll a lot. sweatdrop
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
COuple graphics problems. The h2 headers are a bit bigger than the sections themselves. Fix up your graphics.
What is the best feature of this profile?
You put your avatar on the tree trunk. ^^'

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
6
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "C"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Cali Soca "Minish Cap"
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
Yes, many, many times.
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
No.

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
Yes.

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
Yes.
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
Very much so.

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
Hidden items, link hover, positioning...
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
Everything matches.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
Yes.
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
The details and quilt headers stick out/run over onto the profile a little. All the headers are exactly the same (except for length in some cases) which makes it a little bland. It's not very exciting.
What is the best feature of this profile?
The header is nifty. The profile is like a big ad for the game, complete with a preview-presentation-thing in the multimedia of a new Zelda game for the...eh..."Wii." XD I actually like that quality. It's different...kind of. It's fun to look at.

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
8
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?
I saw a lot of potential for this profile. I think a lot more could have been done to make it look more like a video game or something like that; maybe it would have been more exciting that way. Other than that, I do like what has been done so far, especially all the small customizations. Keep at it!!


Average Rating = 7.13

Popularity = 6 votes
PostPosted: Mon May 22, 2006 5:11 pm


pyroflea:
"Pyroflea"

Judge "N"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
pyroflea
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
NO
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
NO

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
YES

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
YES
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
NO

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
YES
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
NO

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
NO
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
ITS TO BUSY LOOKING TRY FOR A THEME NEXT TIME
What is the best feature of this profile?
THE HEADER

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
6
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "F"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
pyroflea
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
no
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
no

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
yes

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
yes. effing autostart
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
i didn't watch it once I stopped it

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
none that i can see
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
i don't really get how the blue goes with orange and red...

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
not really... everything seems just thrown together. good job on attempting to move things though
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
direct the flow a bit better, instead of letting it seem like chaos
What is the best feature of this profile?
the background is pretty cool

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
3
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "O"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
pyroflea by pyrolfea
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
NOpe.. Not really.
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
Nope.. Barely know what this theme is exactly about.

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
Umm... It doesn't seem to be linking anywhere though...

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
yes
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
It feels very random on the theme itself.

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
Yes.. I think.
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
The status bar clashes. It looks all professional. ... But the status bar.. Seems a bit off from the theme itself.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
Not really. No very well organized.
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
Maybe try to work on the organization.
What is the best feature of this profile?


On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
6
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "C"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
pyroflea "Pyroflea"
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
Not exactly...
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
No...

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
Hmmm...the links on the upper half don't work for me at all, so, "no."

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
Yes.
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
There doesn't seem to be a specific theme...The video doesn't seem to have much to do with the profile...

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
There are some codes used, especially for the positioning and comments.
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
Everything seems to clash, actually.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
No.
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
The layout is a little "haphazard," with sections just anywhere on the page, no aligning or use of columns. The color scheme doesn't match very well.
What is the best feature of this profile?
I like that the status bar was changed and the way the comments are set up.

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
5
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?


Average Rating = 5.00

Popularity = 6 votes

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline
PostPosted: Mon May 22, 2006 5:13 pm


Haruki_jitsunin:
"Bleached out"

Judge "N"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Haruki_jitsunin
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
NO
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
YES

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
YES

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
NO
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
YES
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
YES

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
YES
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
TRY USING SOMETHING OTHER THAN CIRCLES FOR YOUR PROFILE BAR
What is the best feature of this profile?
THE LAYOUT

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
7
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "F"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Haruki_jitsunin
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
no
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
no

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
yes

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
no smile
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
n/a

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
yes
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
yes

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
yes
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
I really don't like this theme at all. I don't like the color scheme, I don't like the quality of the graphics, I don't like the opacity... it's well done, but I just don't like it.
What is the best feature of this profile?
it was done well

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
5
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "O"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Bleached out by Haruki_jitsunin
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
No.
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
ANother bleach theme! blaugh

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
Yes.

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
None
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
Lots of scrolling and stuff.
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
Nothing really clashes.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
YEs.
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
The background is too graphics heavy... I'm having a hard time scrolling down and up.
What is the best feature of this profile?
The graphics are great though. ^^

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
7.5
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "C"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Haruki_jitsunin "Bleached out"
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
No.
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
No.

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
Yes.

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
No.
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?


Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
There are some, especially postioning.
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
I suppose some things match better than others.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
Not really.
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
The transparent background for the friends, comments, and details sections was not the best idea; the text is rendered unreadable if I scroll down. Also, the see-through background for the about and journal sections just makes everything clash there.
The blue for the link hover was also a poor choice.
Blue and orange are compliments, but the color scheme does not work well here.
What is the best feature of this profile?
It's a decent start.

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
4
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?




Average Rating = 5.88

Popularity = 16 votes
PostPosted: Mon May 22, 2006 5:15 pm


[!Cactuar!]:
"Timeless River"

Judge "C"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
[!Cactuar!] "Timeless River"
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
No.
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
Yes.

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
No. The necessary links like "ignore," "pm" and "view posts" are all missing.

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
No.
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?


Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
Yes, especially positioning.
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
Everything matches.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
Kind of.
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
I would definitely add the missing links--at least the necessary ones. Also, adding a little about yourself in the "about" section would be nice.
What is the best feature of this profile?
It's pretty original.

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
6.5
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "O"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Timeless rive by [!cactuar!]
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
Nope.
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
*Sigh* This is the billionth Kingdom hearts theme I've seen. ^^'

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
Where is it anyways?

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
None..
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
SCrolling.
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
The footer wasn't changed.. The entire theme is black and white.. while the footer is bright blue. It attracts a lot of attention.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
Yes.
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
Theres this big gap at the bottom of the theme. Adjust the height of the content, and then remove the footer... or change it, and then move the footer upwards.
What is the best feature of this profile?
The layout is creative.

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
7.5
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "F"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
[!Cactuar!]
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
no
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
yes

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
missing status bar

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
no smile
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
n/a

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
yes
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
yes

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
yes and no
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
i understand why it's all in black and white... but i just really don't like black and white unless it's more vibrant... also another thing that might be cool wouldbe to use the characters in teh top header as the status bar images
What is the best feature of this profile?
it's original

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
5
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "N"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
[!Cactuar!]
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
NO
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
YES

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
NO

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
NO
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
YES
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
YES

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
YES
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
ITS A LITTLE PLAIN & THEME IS USED OFTEN
What is the best feature of this profile?
THE LAYOUT

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
7
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?



Average Rating = 6.50

Popularity = 5 votes

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline
PostPosted: Mon May 22, 2006 5:16 pm


DemonicCurse:
"Digital Forest"

Judge "N"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
DemonicCurse
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
NO
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
NO

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
NO

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
NO
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
YES
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
YES

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
YES
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
ADD A PROFILE BAR
What is the best feature of this profile?
VERY ORIGINAL & PUT TOGETHER WELL

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
10
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "F"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Demonic Curse
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
no
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
only once have I seen another WoW theme

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
no status bar

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
no smile
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
n/a

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
yes
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
yes and no. I think there are other things you could have done to make the other boxes fit in with the theme. Use the questlog for the about section. Make the comments look like the chat log maybe.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
yes
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
only the things I mentioned earlier about making it ALL look like it's part of the game
What is the best feature of this profile?
I love the wishlist and the equipped items

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
8
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "O"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Figital Forest by DemonicCurse
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
Nope.
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
Its a video game-like theme! This is the first time I've seen that. Extremely original.

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
I can't find the status bar.

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
None.
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
Yuppers.
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
The background is colorful.. But no clashing. Great job.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
Somewhat
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
The details box is a bit too small of the details section.
What is the best feature of this profile?
The wishlist is awesome!

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
7
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "C"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
DemonicCurse "Digital Forest"
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
No.
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
No.

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
No status bar.

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
No.
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?


Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
Link hover, positioning, hidden this and that...
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
Everything matches.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
Yes.
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
I think the whole thing, (rather than just a few sections), should have kept with the videogame-like theme. Also, even though most of us know the sections without the titles, I think that if you add one header, (like "Wishlist"), to identify a section, you should follow suit with the others, too. And the status bar, or course, should be there. At least the PM and Ignore options.
The links could be a little brighter as well.
What is the best feature of this profile?
It's original and nice to look at.

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
8
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?



Average Rating = 8.25

Popularity = 11 votes
PostPosted: Mon May 22, 2006 5:20 pm


Sado Yasutora:
"Sado Yasutora (Bleach Character)"

Judge "N"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Sado Yasutora
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
NO
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
YES

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
NO

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
NO
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
YES
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
YES

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
YES
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
ADD A PROFILE BAR & GET RID OF WHITE BEHIND COMMENTS
What is the best feature of this profile?
VERY CLEAN LOOKING

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
7
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "F"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Sado Yasutora
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
no
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
yes and no

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
no status bar

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
no smile
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
n/a

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
yes
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
yes

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
not really. it really really really bothers me how there are the boxes and they dont' seem to line up at all.
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
make everything line up and flow better
What is the best feature of this profile?
it's simple

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
6
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "O"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Sado Yasutora by Sado Yasutora
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
Not really/color]
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
There are two bleach themes in the contest.. I don't know what to think right now. But year.. Bleach themes are quite popular.

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
THe status bar cannot be found...

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
NOpe
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
Scrolling.
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
Nothing really clashes. Except for the bottom part of the profile... Really clashes.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
Yes
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
You mispelled undeniable... sweatdrop Also, the avatar is too big on your profile.
What is the best feature of this profile?
The background.

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
8
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "C"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Sado Yasutora "Sado Yasutora (Bleach Character)"
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
No.
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
Yes.

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
No, there is no status bar.

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
No.
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?


Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
Yes, like positioning, hidden items, scrollbars..
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
Everything matches.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
Yes.
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
It's really plain and flat. Besides the background, there isn't really much to behold. I would definitely add a status bar.
What is the best feature of this profile?
The positioning.

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
7.5
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?



Average Rating = 7.13

Popularity = 43 votes

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline
PostPosted: Mon May 22, 2006 5:21 pm


End Lightning Round: Girls vs Boys
Boys Team
PostPosted: Mon May 22, 2006 5:22 pm


Lightning Round: Girls vs Boys
Final Round

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline
PostPosted: Mon May 22, 2006 5:23 pm


From the Girls Team
Scooter Girl:
"T & A"

Judge "C"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Scooter Girl
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
Yes. Though the layout is nice, I have seen it before.
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
I can't say that I have seen this theme before; it's very specific to the user.

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
All of the standard links are plainly visible and easily accessible.

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
No.
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
Yes, there is some coding used.
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
Everything matches the theme, which, like most profiles, seems to be based upon the header and it's color scheme.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
Yes, it's put together very well.
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
I have nothing new to add, except that the color for the links when hovered over seems a little out of place when you get away from the blonde hair in the header. I'd also just like to reiterate that the corp links at the bottom weren't changed and it's a bit empty around the lower portion.
What is the best feature of this profile?
I still like the header art and the color scheme. Again, it's a very stylish profile.

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
9
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?


Judge "P"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Scooter Girl "T & A"
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
No
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
No

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
If this includes all Gaia provided areas for links...then no (explained below) Otherwise Yes.

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
No
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
Yes
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
Yes

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
Yes
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
Link Issue: The website link is being eaten a bit on both IE and Firefox.
Online Button: I absolutely adore your status bar! However, I did have a slight concerned with the online bar...some folks might not know what it is if their computer doesn't allow "alt" text. At first I was looking for your online bar until I realized it's placing, even though it is all together.
Comments Layering: In Firefox it is slightly difficult to tell what avi belongs to which comment without following the avi to the post. In IE the avis overlap depending on the size of the post. I love the way it looks now, but perhaps disabling the avis might give it a cleaner look.
What is the best feature of this profile?
The overall layout rocks. The avi art at the top of the profile forces the eye to not automatically assume a standard layout. It really makes the person want to explore the rest of the profile to see what else is different. Very nice choices in color and design.

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
9.6/10
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?
N/A

Judge "N"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
SCOOTER GIRL
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
NO
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
NO

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
YES

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
NO
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
YES
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
YES

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
YES
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
MAYBE A DIFFERENT BACKGROUND COLOR I SEE IT USED IN THE HEADERS BUT NOT ENOUGH TO TIE IT TOGETHER
What is the best feature of this profile?
ITS ALL AROUND VERY BEAUTIFUL

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
10
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?




Average Rating = 9.53

Popularity = 44 votes
PostPosted: Mon May 22, 2006 5:24 pm


From the Boys Team
I heart:
"The inside of my brain"

Judge "N"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
I HEART
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
NO
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
NO

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
YES

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
NO
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
YES
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
YES

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
YES
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
MAYBE ADD SOMETHING EXTRA AT THE BOTTOM
What is the best feature of this profile?
VERY ORIGINAL

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
8.5
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?

Judge "P"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
I heart "The inside of my brain"
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
No
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
No

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
Yes

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
No
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
Yes
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
Yes

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
Yes
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
Layering: There are some layering issues in IE. The comments section is oddly spaced from the top and it's width is a little to large.
Broken Image: In IE there also appears to be a broken image toward the bottom of the profile.
What is the best feature of this profile?
Overall really nice profile. I'd have to say the artwork creates a really unique effect. The color choices are also brilliant! Everything compliments each other very well.

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
9.2/10
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?


Judge "C"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
I heart
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
--Have you seen this type of layout many times before?
No, the layout is very original.
--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)
I can't say that I have. It's very personal.

Please look at functionality:
--Can you access all the standard links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
Yes; all the standard links are easily accessible.

Please look at creativity:
--Is there any multimedia?
No.
--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?
N/A

Please look at technique:
--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)
Yes, there is some coding used.
--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to the implied main theme, or are there things that clash?
I'm not too sure what the theme is, but just looking at the color scheme, mostly everything appears to match pretty well.

Please look at structure:
--Is the profile put together well overall?
For the most part, yes.
_____________________________________________________________
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
I will reiterate that I'd like to see a bit more about the user. And the bottom lacks the interesting feel that the top has.
What is the best feature of this profile?
The status bar is original and I do like the images in the upper portion.

On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?
7
_____________________________________________________________
Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?


Average Rating = 8.23

Popularity = 32 votes

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline
PostPosted: Mon May 22, 2006 5:25 pm


End Lightning Round: G vs B
Final Round
PostPosted: Sat Jun 17, 2006 6:58 am


New for Round 6: There will be a point system used in the ballots to help judges rate each contestant's profile.

The point system was created to calculate each judges' rate for them.
In the past, judges had been filling in phrases like, "Everything in the profile was perfect!" Yet, the judge only gave the contestant a rate of 9.5/10. Why subtract .5 if everything was "perfect"?? The point system will help make judging more accurate. 3nodding

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline
PostPosted: Tue Jun 27, 2006 3:24 pm


Round 6:
Originality of Theme
PostPosted: Tue Jun 27, 2006 3:29 pm


Pink Haired Pirate
"Taste The Rainbow"

Judge Q
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Taste the Rainbow
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
#1--Have you seen the theme many times before?
No Yes = +0 No = +0.5
#2--In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?
Yes No = +0 Yes = +1

Please look at functionality:
#3--Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily?
Yes No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1

Please look at creativity:
#4--Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?
Yes No = +0 Yes = +2

Please look at technique:
#5--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme?
Yes No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1
#6--Are there things that clash with the theme?
No Yes = +0 No = +2

Please look at structure:
#7--Is the profile put together well overall?
Yes No = +0 Yes = +2.5
_____________________________________________________________
What is the best feature of this profile?
I like the fact that it is quite colorful and is a constant throughout the profile.
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
Not at all

ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".

#1 =0.5
#2 =1
#3 =1
#4 =2
#5 =1
#6 =2
#7 =2.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 10.0

_____________________________________________________________
Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers.
I found this entry to be simple and yet the simplicity of it all was all the more charming to make it a perfect score.


Judge "C"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Pink Haired Pirate "Taste The Rainbow"
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
#1--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme)
No. Yes = +0 No = +0.5
#2--In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?
Yes. No = +0 Yes = +1

Please look at functionality:
#3--Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
Yes. No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1

Please look at creativity:
#4--Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?
Yes. No = +0 Yes = +2

Please look at technique:
#5--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme?
Yes. No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1
#6--Are there things that clash with the theme?
No. Yes = +0 No = +2

Please look at structure:
#7--Is the profile put together well overall?
No and yes, but I have to stick with no. There are some things I noticed that could be a little better put together. The avatars in the comments area overlap in some places. It took me a while to realize that the white "bubbles" in the headers were actually letters because they were so tiny. No = +0 Yes = +2.5
_____________________________________________________________
What is the best feature of this profile?
The status bar, cursor and backgrounds are all very cute.
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
See above (#7).

ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".

#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1.0
#3 = 1.0
#4 = 2.0
#5 = 1.0
#6 = 2.0
#7 = 0.0
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 7.5

_____________________________________________________________
Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers.


Judge "N"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Pink Haired Pirate
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
#1--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme)
0.5 Yes = +0 No = +0.5

#2--In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?
1 No = +0 Yes = +1

Please look at functionality:
#3--Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
1 No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1

Please look at creativity:
#4--Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?
1.5 No = +0 Yes = +2

Please look at technique:
#5--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme?
1 No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1

#6--Are there things that clash with the theme?
2 Yes = +0 No = +2

Please look at structure:
#7--Is the profile put together well overall?
1.5 No = +0 Yes = +2.5

_____________________________________________________________
What is the best feature of this profile?
Though there is much animation and art it was still kept clean looking with good use of soft colors and nice background.
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
Maybe make the layout a little more original.

ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".

#1 = 0.5
#2 = 1
#3 = 1
#4 = 1.5
#5 = 1
#6 = 2
#7 = 1.5
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 8.5
____________________________________________________________
Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers.

Average Rating = 8.67

Popularity = 4 Votes

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline

Passion_Dragon

 
Offline
PostPosted: Tue Jun 27, 2006 3:30 pm


zabby91
"Black Soul"

Judge "Q"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
Black Soul
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
#1--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme)
Yes Yes = +0 No = +0.5
#2--In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?
Yes No = +0 Yes = +1

Please look at functionality:
#3--Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
Yes No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1

Please look at creativity:
#4--Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?
Yes No = +0 Yes = +2

Please look at technique:
#5--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme?
Yes No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1
#6--Are there things that clash with the theme?
Yes Yes = +0 No = +2

Please look at structure:
#7--Is the profile put together well overall?
No No = +0 Yes = +2.5
_____________________________________________________________
What is the best feature of this profile?
The picture on the left can be seen at all times when you scroll down or up.
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
Yes, I don't like you have have to scroll up or down to look at the About, Friends, etc.

ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".

#1 = 0
#2 = 1
#3 = 1
#4 = 2
#5 = 1
#6 = 0
#7 = 0
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 5

_____________________________________________________________
Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers.
This profile could've been done correctly where you don't have to scroll up or down within the scroll to see anything. Then same of the pictures were covered up when you wanted to scroll up or down. So, this profile gets what it deserves.

Judge "C"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
zabby91 "Black Soul"
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
#1--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme)
Yes. Yes = +0 No = +0.5
#2--In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?
Yes. No = +0 Yes = +1

Please look at functionality:
#3--Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
Yes. No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1

Please look at creativity:
#4--Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?
Yes, it looks like it. No = +0 Yes = +2

Please look at technique:
#5--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme?
Yes. No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1
#6--Are there things that clash with the theme?
No. Yes = +0 No = +2

Please look at structure:
#7--Is the profile put together well overall?
I have to say no, not really. The layout is standard. There is too much going on. It's nice to add in some special effects, but it would be nice if they flowed a little better throughout the profile. The sections are transparent, I guess, and the same background flows through them, which clashes a lot with the other background pictures (even though they are the same theme). No = +0 Yes = +2.5
_____________________________________________________________
What is the best feature of this profile?
It's all the same theme.
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
See above (#7).

ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".

#1 = 0.0
#2 = 1.0
#3 = 1.0
#4 = 2.0
#5 = 1.0
#6 = 2.0
#7 = 0.0
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 7.0

_____________________________________________________________
Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers.

Judge "N"
["THE BALLOT"]
"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:
zabby91
_____________________________________________________________
Please look at originality:
#1--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "Kindom Hearts" theme or "Final Fantasy" theme)
0 Yes = +0 No = +0.5

#2--In your opinion, was the theme presented in an original way?
1 No = +0 Yes = +1

Please look at functionality:
#3--Can you access all the standard Gaia links easily? (Example: "view guilds/store," "view all friends/comments," "PM/Trade.")
1 No = +0 "Some" or "A few" = +0.5 Yes = +1

Please look at creativity:
#4--Would you say that a lot of thought was put into the creation of the profile theme?
1 No = +0 Yes = +2

Please look at technique:
#5--Does everything (headers/fonts/cursors/backgrounds/etc.) seem to relate to or match the implied main theme?
1 No = +0 "Some things" or "A few things" = +0.5 Yes = +1

#6--Are there things that clash with the theme?
2 Yes = +0 No = +2

Please look at structure:
#7--Is the profile put together well overall?
1 No = +0 Yes = +2.5

_____________________________________________________________
What is the best feature of this profile?
The idea and header are very nice.
What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?
I don't like you can see where the images begin and end. It's to choppy looking.

ADD TOGETHER THE SCORE FROM EACH QUESTION HERE. Add in the score even if it was "0".

#1 = 0
#2 = 1
#3 = 1
#4 = 1
#5 = 1
#6 = 2
#7 = 1
TOTAL SCORE/YOUR RATING = 7
_____________________________________________________________
Please put any and all questions, concerns or suggestions HERE. Judges, also use this space to elaborate on any of your answers.


Average Rating = 6.33

Popularity = 4 Votes
Reply
Main Forum

 Goto Page: [|«] [<] 1 2 3 ... 5 6 7 8 9 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
More
Get GCash
Offers
More
Get Items
More Items
More
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
  • Guilds
    fan clubs for the stuff you love
  • Chat
    chat in real time with other Gaians
  • Art Arenas
    browse & rate gaian art galleries
  • Clans
    play zOMG with others
More
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
More
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
More
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum
More