The thing should have been scrapped and rewritten.
35%
[ 7 ]
I hope this answers my concerns like BioWare keeps saying it will.
5%
[ 1 ]
Total Votes : 20
Kraxys05
Offline
Posted: Tue Jul 03, 2012 11:47 am
Pilotslover
Kraxys05
Pilotslover
Kraxys05
They gave us more information that helped understand everything that happened. There are no more plot holes.
You're entitled to believe that, I can name at least one off the top of my head.
name it
Legion.
Or more specifically the geth/quarian conflict, the god child still doesn't acknowledge that the geth and quarians are working together by end of game.
Even though Tali clearly kills Legion if you choose it. And even though the Quarians kill ALL the Geth.
Even if you choose to save the Geth, what does it matter? He doesn't acknowledge it, because it doesn't happen.
Posted: Tue Jul 03, 2012 11:53 am
Kraxys05
Even though Tali clearly kills Legion if you choose it. And even though the Quarians kill ALL the Geth.
Even if you choose to save the Geth, what does it matter? He doesn't acknowledge it, because it doesn't happen.
Kudos on completely missing the point.
1 - Tali DOESN'T kill Legion in all the possible outcomes 2 - See above.
It matter because the god child thing dismisses the idea of organics working with synthetics, it completely ignores the fact that in certain games the geth SAVE the quarians.
Even though Tali clearly kills Legion if you choose it. And even though the Quarians kill ALL the Geth.
Even if you choose to save the Geth, what does it matter? He doesn't acknowledge it, because it doesn't happen.
Kudos on completely missing the point.
1 - Tali DOESN'T kill Legion in all the possible outcomes 2 - See above.
It matter because the god child thing dismisses the idea of organics working with synthetics, it completely ignores the fact that in certain games the geth SAVE the quarians.
"The created will always rebel against the creators."
Didn't the Geth do just that? It's not a plot hole. The STAR child mentions that if the Reapers are destroyed, the peace will not last. Suggesting that peace with synthetics will not be permanent.
And yes Tali does kill Legion. You missed that I said "should you choose it"
Posted: Tue Jul 03, 2012 12:14 pm
Kraxys05
"The created will always rebel against the creators."
Didn't the Geth do just that? It's not a plot hole. The STAR child mentions that if the Reapers are destroyed, the peace will not last. Suggesting that peace with synthetics will not be permanent.
And yes Tali does kill Legion. You missed that I said "should you choose it"
Yes it's a plot hole because he doesn't acknowledge that peace HAS been achieved, he completely ignores that synthetics and organics can live together and help each other, something backed up further by the synthesis ending.
And I said in all the possible outcomes. You obviously missed that.
"The created will always rebel against the creators."
Didn't the Geth do just that? It's not a plot hole. The STAR child mentions that if the Reapers are destroyed, the peace will not last. Suggesting that peace with synthetics will not be permanent.
And yes Tali does kill Legion. You missed that I said "should you choose it"
Yes it's a plot hole because he doesn't acknowledge that peace HAS been achieved, he completely ignores that synthetics and organics can live together and help each other, something backed up further by the synthesis ending.
And I said in all the possible outcomes. You obviously missed that.
What peace? The Geth and Quarians were at war in all 3 games. Yes if you upload the Reaper codes, then the Geth help you, but that's all you know. You don't know if after that the Geth resume all Gethy activities.
Its negligible...
Posted: Tue Jul 03, 2012 12:29 pm
Kraxys05
What peace? The Geth and Quarians were at war in all 3 games. Yes if you upload the Reaper codes, then the Geth help you, but that's all you know. You don't know if after that the Geth resume all Gethy activities.
Its negligible...
If you get the right combination of things
Shep gets informed that the geth have healed the quarians
.
Check the edit I just made, there are still 77 plot holes that that one forum has found.
What peace? The Geth and Quarians were at war in all 3 games. Yes if you upload the Reaper codes, then the Geth help you, but that's all you know. You don't know if after that the Geth resume all Gethy activities.
Its negligible...
If you get the right combination of things
Shep gets informed that the geth have healed the quarians
.
Check the edit I just made, there are still 77 plot holes that that one forum has found.
Some people just can't be pleased neutral
Posted: Tue Jul 03, 2012 12:39 pm
Kraxys05
Pilotslover
Kraxys05
What peace? The Geth and Quarians were at war in all 3 games. Yes if you upload the Reaper codes, then the Geth help you, but that's all you know. You don't know if after that the Geth resume all Gethy activities.
Its negligible...
If you get the right combination of things
Shep gets informed that the geth have healed the quarians
.
Check the edit I just made, there are still 77 plot holes that that one forum has found.
Some people just can't be pleased neutral
I wouldn't put it down to that, read some of the list, it's quite enlightening.
What peace? The Geth and Quarians were at war in all 3 games. Yes if you upload the Reaper codes, then the Geth help you, but that's all you know. You don't know if after that the Geth resume all Gethy activities.
Its negligible...
If you get the right combination of things
Shep gets informed that the geth have healed the quarians
.
Check the edit I just made, there are still 77 plot holes that that one forum has found.
Some people just can't be pleased neutral
I wouldn't put it down to that, read some of the list, it's quite enlightening.
That's all it is. Yes the game is not perfect, but even after all the free stuff and editing on the ending, people are still complaining.
Posted: Tue Jul 03, 2012 12:45 pm
Kraxys05
That's all it is. Yes the game is not perfect, but even after all the free stuff and editing on the ending, people are still complaining.
You're contradicting yourself.
You said before that there were no plot holes but now you're saying it's not perfect.
'All the free stuff' was them doing due diligence for their own screw up, this ending is marginally better then the first one BUT as far as game endings go, especially in a long running series, it's terrible; could you image if the guys at Ubisoft had ended Ezio's arc of AC with what is effectively LOL SPACE MAGIC?
That's all it is. Yes the game is not perfect, but even after all the free stuff and editing on the ending, people are still complaining.
You're contradicting yourself.
You said before that there were no plot holes but now you're saying it's not perfect.
'All the free stuff' was them doing due diligence for their own screw up, this ending is marginally better then the first one BUT as far as game endings go, especially in a long running series, it's terrible; could you image if the guys at Ubisoft had ended Ezio's arc of AC with what is effectively LOL SPACE MAGIC?
How did I contradict myself? They had to fix some plot issues didn't they? Therefore the game is imperfect, despite them fixing it.
Posted: Tue Jul 03, 2012 12:51 pm
Kraxys05
How did I contradict myself? They had to fix some plot issues didn't they? Therefore the game is imperfect, despite them fixing it.
You said there were no plot holes.
Then you said it 'is not perfect'.
To me that's something of a contradiction because to me a game cannot be considered not perfect if it has no plot holes (The graphics and gameplay in ME3 are pretty much on par with ME2 so no real complaints there, it's boring but it functions).
How did I contradict myself? They had to fix some plot issues didn't they? Therefore the game is imperfect, despite them fixing it.
You said there were no plot holes.
Then you said it 'is not perfect'.
To me that's something of a contradiction because to me a game cannot be considered not perfect if it has no plot holes (The graphics and gameplay in ME3 are pretty much on par with ME2 so no real complaints there, it's boring but it functions).
That's not a contradiction -.-
Posted: Tue Jul 03, 2012 12:57 pm
Kraxys05
Pilotslover
Kraxys05
How did I contradict myself? They had to fix some plot issues didn't they? Therefore the game is imperfect, despite them fixing it.
You said there were no plot holes.
Then you said it 'is not perfect'.
To me that's something of a contradiction because to me a game cannot be considered not perfect if it has no plot holes (The graphics and gameplay in ME3 are pretty much on par with ME2 so no real complaints there, it's boring but it functions).
That's not a contradiction -.-
Then explain what you mean. You can't say it has no plot holes and then say it's not perfect without acknowledging the plot holes.
How did I contradict myself? They had to fix some plot issues didn't they? Therefore the game is imperfect, despite them fixing it.
You said there were no plot holes.
Then you said it 'is not perfect'.
To me that's something of a contradiction because to me a game cannot be considered not perfect if it has no plot holes (The graphics and gameplay in ME3 are pretty much on par with ME2 so no real complaints there, it's boring but it functions).
That's not a contradiction -.-
Then explain what you mean. You can't say it has no plot holes and then say it's not perfect without acknowledging the plot holes.
They fixed whatever plot holes there WERE.....but that doesn't make the game perfect. Drop it because you're making me mad now.
