Welcome to Gaia! ::

neonascence

Back to Guilds

Musings on organic gardening, frugal living, the environment, self-sufficiency and whatever else strikes our fancy. 

Tags: gardening, environment, organic, permaculture, green 

Reply General Discussion
Serious reasons why vegans aren't taken seriously. Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Hugel

PostPosted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 10:19 am


[Kegan]
God Emperor Akhenaton
Veaganism is an unrealistic idea only possible to the few who live in a country that can supply all the nutrients to make it remotely possible.
Oh lord. I'm sure this has been addressed, but I can't wait to finish reading the thread.

You know that keeping animals is actually a lot LESS energy efficient than growing your food, right? Because what do those animals eat? A lot of grass, and in the US corn. Indeed they can break down those grasses in ways our human digestive system could not. But the same space of land used to support those animals could support at-least as many humans through the entire year, if used wisely, many more.

There's something called the food pyramid.
http://www.science-art.com/gallery/31/31_7112003035.jpg

Now, in some cases, like the habitats of sharks, there are exceptions, where the apex predators actually make up a lot of biomass, but that is because they are eating and contributing back so much. But that is not the state of our ecostystem. Our metabolisms are much higher and less efficient.

In the third world, if you could somehow afford to keep a cow or goat, you'd be keeping it alive for milk, and valuable offspring. That is a LUXURY.

And to anyone who would, though I haven't seen a single argument about it yet, state that b12 deficiencies are the real downfall of a natural vegan diet: Did you know that in the third world, lack of modern hygiene practices actually makes veganism completely sustainable, with no supplements? I found it fascinating.

As for me, I don't mind some eggs and kosher cheese. In-fact, I eat eggs every day.


Kegan do you have the article for that b12 deficiency? I want to read it.

The second part that you brought up that a third world lack of modern hygiene.... is fascinating, I wonder why and how. What are they eating that allows them to maintain such a diet.

Meat or anything of the sort is a luxury in any country that had a history of poverty. I remember my mother told me that when she was younger she could drink milk only once every two weeks, because it was so expensive. My grandfather grew up by the sea, and told me stories how they ate fish most of the time because it was much more plentiful and available than cows...and fish weren't under anyone's control because it was straight from the ocean.

Also...
This still has boggled me.
I once saw eggs in the grocery labeled "VEGETARIAN EGGS"
how is that?
PostPosted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 10:42 am


I don't have the article about the lack of b12 deficiency in the third world, it was a long time ago that I read it, but I believe the people they tested were in rural pakistan.
The secret I do remember.

Gut bacteria. Living in the guts of animals, and sometimes in the ground, there is a specific kind of bacteria that produces B12. Enough to sustain you and then some. In humans, and probably many other animals, however, the bacteria are too far down in the system for the b12 to be properly absorbed.

The secret? Fecal cross contamination.

And to adress your last question: Egg laying is part of a chicken's natural menstrual cycle. They'll keep laying them even in absence of a male. Those are the eggs you will buy in the store. In that sense most eggs you will ever see are vegetarian.

I for example am a Lactor-ovo vegetarian, and I believe that as long as the anima is not harmed, and the ends are sustainable, there is nothing wrong with eating the byproducts of other animal life.

I try to limit the amount of dairy I eat, though. I don't avoid it entirely, though. My reasoning behind that is that letting animals sustainably reproduce, you can continue manually milking an animal for months after it's offspring would have weened; however, he are keeping these cows constantly pregnant, back to back, so that we can continue to get our cheese fix. This just doesn't strike me as sustainable behavior, for a number of reasons.

Did you know that the process of making cheese removes whey, leaving the major component protein to be casein, which has been shown to have an opiate effect in humans. That means that cheese is mildly addictive. I for one don't mind a little kosher cheese, (free of animal rennet, which comes from boiled calf guts) sprinkled on top of a casserole, or ricotta(Curdled by vinegar) in my pasta sauce.

It's a luxury, and I try to moderate my intake, but it's also a good source of natural b12.

I remember reading somewhere that Spirulina, a common vegan b12 supplement, contains not only b12(Cobalamin), but "corrinoids" which test positive for the presence of b12, but may actually even hinder the absorption of real b12. The amount that is actually bioavailable was also under dispute last time I checked.

The thing is, it's really hard to test these kinds of things, because humans can store about 2 years worth of reserve b12 in them. So a vegan might think they're doing great for years, and then suddenly develop anemia and a nerve damage.


As it is, I see no real harm in eating eggs to get my b12. Once I move out and start doing the shopping myself I'll even go for the more expensive farmers market eggs, if I can find them. I hear they taste better, anyway.

[Kegan]

Nimble Cultist


Hugel

PostPosted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 10:56 am


Wow you certainly are informed. May I ask were you got all of that? Share some websites?

I've been slowly becoming less and less satisfied with my general biology degree as of late, and I'm trying to see if I can explore and educate myself in sustainability, but the topic is so broad I don't know where to start.

As for cheese as an addictive product. I did not know that. I always wondered about why when I had a cheese I'd go back for more. And my suitemate......she is most definitely a cheese addict. She eats a bit of cheese for almost every meal.

I've been hearing that the cheese market these days have been trying their best to push more product onto consumers since there has been such a higher demand for low fat milk that there's more cheese production in these last few years, because of the extra product they have left after lessening the fat in milk and there's not enough of a market for cheese. What do you think of that?

What about honey? Honey is food source for bees yet humans love it, it too is a luxury, and in some cultures a successful 'honey hunt' means a higher status for a man/men who manage to bring some home. (a male display of prowess for their own reproductive success). Without considering the current Colony Bee-hive collapse issue, do you think its alright to take some honey for our use if the bee population was healthy and abundant?
PostPosted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 11:25 am


My brain is a sponge, sadly sponges don't have works cited pages.

But I'm pretty sure you could find most of this on wikipedia
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia

Simply find something interesting, and look for the work it cites at the bottom of the page.

Sometimes it's really obscure books, but a lot of the time it's internet articles and encyclopedias.

From what I've read, hive collapse has really absolutely nothing to do with whether on not we take excess honey. There are two kinds of bee farms. Those who simply take all the honey and start fresh with a new colony the next year and those who keep and breed strong colonies, and leave enough to last the bees through winter.

Both of these groups would be affected though, since hive collapse seems to be a disease, like a parasite or a virus, and I read somewhere last year, while doing research for a paper, that people were seriously considering that it might be the pollen from genetically engineered plants, which produce their own pesticides, through some kind of cross contamination.

There are plants who are entirely toxic like that, several whose nectars cannot be made safe for human consumption. Tansy I believe, is one of these plants.

It doesn't seem like huge leap to me, for it to be possible that it may also be possible for honey to be toxic to the bees themselves.

Though pollen and nectar are two different things. Who knows. Not me. I'm not an apiculturist(Bee keeper).

[Kegan]

Nimble Cultist


sunsetsmile
Crew

PostPosted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 9:55 pm


"Hive collapse" is also, at times, simply a matter of the bees not returning to the hive, because they've found another place that they'd rather live. No one puts them in the walls of houses, etc.......they decide that they like it there, and just move!

Someday I'm going to have to read this entire thread. I'm so accustomed to finding verbal assaults in the vegetarian vs. omnivore "discussions" that I don't read them anymore.

I must disagree with a couple of things in a couple of the recent posts, though. There seems to be a common misconception that farmers do not take good care of their animals, which is simply not true. The farm is the business that feeds the farmer's family, and not taking good care of the animals is simply out of the question. In all your research, always be sure to check the opposing point of view, as well as who is providing funding for the particular project. Or as my Granddaddy always said, "Consider the source." Don't just assume that what you read is correct. Do your own research! Boots-on-the-ground, down-in-the-dirt research. The whole cholesterol-in-eggs-will-kill-you thing started with rabbits being forcefed eggs, of all things!
PostPosted: Wed Jan 12, 2011 10:19 pm


Well, it would be a little naive to assume that most farms are the image the word "Farm" invokes.

Most "farm" animals are kept in a factory setting. In our modern reality, farms are factories. Traditional farms are the UNCOMMON thing. It simply isn't affordable in the current state of the world, unless you're old money, or you have an established niche to market your goods. And if you can, good for you.

I'm no expert in it, really, as it's something subject to heavy biases, with two parties on either end feeling that they are very much right, it's hard to get straight answers. PETA will exaggerate and make sweeping generalizations, while the "farms" would never be that open about their practices, because the average American is (honestly) pretty naive.

Have you ever watched Dirty Jobs? There are at-least 2 episodes about cattle, pigs or whatever, and they take place in the most bleak looking places. Seriously. The animals aren't even really allowed to copulate... they jerk off a selected male pig and manually impregnate the females. (What a bummer.)

I personally just don't like the idea of eating another animal. It's luxurious behavior, and strikes me as wasteful, but mostly I'm just hyper-sympathetic. I project existential feelings on animals that maybe don't even have them. I'll never know though.

[Kegan]

Nimble Cultist


Satyr Prince

Tipsy Reveler

6,950 Points
  • Gender Swap 100
  • Partygoer 500
  • Conversationalist 100
PostPosted: Thu Jan 13, 2011 7:43 am


Hugel
Also...
This still has boggled me.
I once saw eggs in the grocery labeled "VEGETARIAN EGGS"
how is that?


this means the chickens were fed a vegetarian diet. lower quality feeds used in alot of factory farms often have chicken as an ingredient.
PostPosted: Thu Jan 13, 2011 8:39 am


Strega Mama
Hugel
Also...
This still has boggled me.
I once saw eggs in the grocery labeled "VEGETARIAN EGGS"
how is that?


this means the chickens were fed a vegetarian diet. lower quality feeds used in alot of factory farms often have chicken as an ingredient.


Free-range chickens have a lot of meat in their diet. Chickens will eat almost anything, just like humans do. Think not only bugs, but also mice, snakes (if the guineas didn't eat them after they beat them to death), even other chickens.

sunsetsmile
Crew


Hoshioni

10,900 Points
  • Treasure Hunter 100
  • Tycoon 200
  • Brandisher 100
PostPosted: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:22 pm


really b12 REALLY !

shesh b vitamins come together as a family in foods that contain b vitamins but there very sensitive to modern processing methods. and can easily be acquired in fruits. not our fault americans are ridiouclously picky.

beef , pork ,chicken, peas, corn, green beans, bread (70% bleached white) rice, gravy, onion, green peppers, red apples, grapes, orange juice, black eye beans, penut butter, batter, strawberry. salt pepper, soda, water, tomato

those are the food sourse staples of the diet for the household i live in and that is NO!-where near a complete spectrum of nutrients.

as for hygiene. its all in what your using, if your using aluminum waste water with petro-oil remains for cleaners. then i cant imagine how one is better off.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYXFOuV8t1w

imporantace of a high spectrum diet

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=51L0TlXxZ9U

this channel is neat
PostPosted: Thu Jan 13, 2011 4:31 pm


Hoshioni
b vitamins [...] can easily be acquired in fruits.
This statement does not apply to b12.

Vitamins are named for many reasons, but not because of where they come from.

The section of your post about hygiene is really a strange tangent. I was saying that these rural 3rd world vegans didn't get b12 deficiencies, I didn't say they were leading healthy lives.

Not that it matters if I reply, since you have blocked me, right? You're just replying to what you saw in a quote.

[Kegan]

Nimble Cultist


sunsetsmile
Crew

PostPosted: Thu Jan 13, 2011 5:51 pm


Be nice, guys....we're all friends here. Friends can disagree.
PostPosted: Thu Jan 13, 2011 6:23 pm


sunsetsmile
Strega Mama
Hugel
Also...
This still has boggled me.
I once saw eggs in the grocery labeled "VEGETARIAN EGGS"
how is that?


this means the chickens were fed a vegetarian diet. lower quality feeds used in alot of factory farms often have chicken as an ingredient.


Free-range chickens have a lot of meat in their diet. Chickens will eat almost anything, just like humans do. Think not only bugs, but also mice, snakes (if the guineas didn't eat them after they beat them to death), even other chickens.
oh yeah, that too! id almost forgotten about that, since in my head it was a non-issue.

Satyr Prince

Tipsy Reveler

6,950 Points
  • Gender Swap 100
  • Partygoer 500
  • Conversationalist 100

pirhan
Crew

PostPosted: Thu Jan 13, 2011 6:40 pm


sunsetsmile
Strega Mama
Hugel
Also...
This still has boggled me.
I once saw eggs in the grocery labeled "VEGETARIAN EGGS"
how is that?


this means the chickens were fed a vegetarian diet. lower quality feeds used in alot of factory farms often have chicken as an ingredient.


Free-range chickens have a lot of meat in their diet. Chickens will eat almost anything, just like humans do. Think not only bugs, but also mice, snakes (if the guineas didn't eat them after they beat them to death), even other chickens.

Once we moved some hay bales in the barn. The entire wall was crawling with mice. Once ousted from their hiding spot, the chickens and ducks ran and gobbled them up. You could see the bulge in the duck necks from the mice. I'd never seen anything like it. I tell the story sometimes and I don't think anyone believes that ducks and chickens eat mice.

Man, I wish I could tip your posts here.
PostPosted: Thu Jan 13, 2011 8:25 pm


sunsetsmile
Be nice, guys....we're all friends here. Friends can disagree.
I'm certainly not trying to be aggressive. I don't think anything I said could be read unkindly either. Maybe Dis-kindly or impassionately, like a robot.

[Kegan]

Nimble Cultist


Hugel

PostPosted: Fri Jan 14, 2011 6:22 am


pirhan
sunsetsmile
Strega Mama
Hugel
Also...
This still has boggled me.
I once saw eggs in the grocery labeled "VEGETARIAN EGGS"
how is that?


this means the chickens were fed a vegetarian diet. lower quality feeds used in alot of factory farms often have chicken as an ingredient.


Free-range chickens have a lot of meat in their diet. Chickens will eat almost anything, just like humans do. Think not only bugs, but also mice, snakes (if the guineas didn't eat them after they beat them to death), even other chickens.

Once we moved some hay bales in the barn. The entire wall was crawling with mice. Once ousted from their hiding spot, the chickens and ducks ran and gobbled them up. You could see the bulge in the duck necks from the mice. I'd never seen anything like it. I tell the story sometimes and I don't think anyone believes that ducks and chickens eat mice.

Man, I wish I could tip your posts here.

Wow, now that was interesting. I did not know that at all. The search for protein continues.

And here I thought I was shocked when I saw a squirrel eating a bird.

Piran, do you work on a farm or run one? Or is it just your own range of birds?
Reply
General Discussion

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum