|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Mar 28, 2006 2:31 am
Moofuls Official Critique RequestGaia Username: Moofuls Character Name: Thomas Brinley Serum Animal(s): Forest Cobra Quest Thread: http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2475217And on his birthday, too 8D Okaay, no earthly idea how he's getting to the island just yet. I had an idea a while back, but decided it wasn't exactly plausible. So very much open to suggestions on that <3 There're a few tweaks here and there I've been considering... But we'll see what you have to say and go from there :3 Everything that you have looks good so far. As for how he got the island... I'll think up some ideas. You have it pretty open ended. The problem being he has a lot of connections to the "real" world, being he would play soccer and has an average family. Maybe... his bus with his team was in a terrible accident - only a few survivors. In the chaos, if Feral Labs was one of the hospitals/medical teams in the response, they could easily whisk someone away unnoticed, and say they were killed in the accident?
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Mar 28, 2006 2:36 am
Sayuri_Nitta Official Critique Request Gaia Username: Sayuri_Nitta Character Name: Sayuri Satoharu Serum Animal(s): Blue Tang Fish Quest Thread: http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2524428I'd like some critique of what I have so far...I was going to use my old Sayuri char, but after talking it over with a friend, and fleshing out another direction I decided I really didnt want to do angst XD I dont know yet how she is getting to the Island...just want some feedback for what I have so far =) Again, everything looks good so far. Though, just on a personal note, 99% of roleplay characters are orphans. In this case, it seems rather superfluous. If she was such a klutz as you came, her mother might become ashamed of her? Anyway, just something to think on, thats really the only thing I could think to say. I think the klutzy geisha is awesome. As for ideas on how she got to island. If a higher up in one of Feral Labs Japanese devistions got wind of a this girl that was brining shame on her geisha house, he could easily suggest Moreau take her in, since they would probably jump on the oppurtunity to get 'rid' of her, and not ask too many questions?
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Mar 28, 2006 2:41 am
Dragoncat85 Official Critique RequestGaia Username: Dragoncat85 Character Name: Raven Cordal Serum Animal(s): Bengal Cat Quest Thread: http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2476642 (This is my quest in this guild) She's still in the rough. If she has alot of detail it's because she's me except for the name and other stuff that are diffrent. Character: *stamp* All's well. As for how she got to the island. How you describe it now seems more like a job offering than a subject, so I would suggest some rethinking. Perhaps she signed up for a medical study? Those tend to pay well. Though a note - watch your grammer, punctuation, and sentence structure. I noticed a lot of run-on sentences in your quest thread. And you need to look at some of the formatting in your first post. It says a lot to us when a first post is following the rules exactly or not. 3nodding
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Mar 28, 2006 2:44 am
WereWolfKin Official Critique RequestGaia Username: WereWolfKin Character Name: Kaelyn Murassi Serum Animal(s): Binturong (nonmorphic) Quest Thread: http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2536936How she gets to the island is very vague, but it is just a rough idea. And the character is in the rough stages of construction. If what I have down needs to be changed I want to knw before I create the rest of her. ^^ If it doesn't need changing what I currently have down for her is definate. Whats there on the character all seems fine. I do think how she got to the island needs some rethinking. Feral Labs wouldn't go out specifically looking for computer programmers as subjects.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Mar 28, 2006 2:55 am
First of all, I don't know if this was intential or not, but just for reference the name (because its not a common one) Alphonse was the name of the dorctor in the original novel The Island of Dr. Moreau. As for the character... thats quite a listing of traits there. sweatdrop Generally speaking, in leau of making a character that seems over the top I would reccomend sticking with Albinism OR AS. The most problematic part of this is the way he got the island. You mention he wrote two books, but only one dealing with lycanthropy. Well, there are THOUSANDS of books written dealing with lycanthrophy, so it makes little sense to me that Moreai would single Alphonse out from one book. Secondly, "Alphonse was flagged as a person who might take well to the concept of transformation." To be frank, Moreau doesn't CARE if they will take well to it or not. If anything, Moreau is a masochist and likes it LESS when they do. Quote: It was at this time that Dr. Moreau's intents were revealed to Alphonse, whom had two choices. He could either become a subject willingly, or become a subject by force Moreau never gives people the choice. Quote: Alphonse would have to be permitted to write a Sci-fi/Horror "story" about the island, and publish it under a fake name Moreau would never agree to that, either. He could write it... Moreau might even "publish" it - for the islanders. And, about the animal. Why a Jackal/Maned wolf cross? What would be the point to that? Quoted from the front page: Quote: Also keep in mind that for the combinations and additional features, there generally has to be an in-character reason the staff would choose to add these features to a character (like testing aggressiveness on personality with Chubb's combination, or attempting to create a 'dragon' with Zachary). Some of the strange combinations without a specific reason in mind, in general, is just very inplausible and breaks the feel of the island. I would suggest you do some reading in the Guild, especially the Duplexes. Get a feel for the characters and how the island workds a bit better though reading some of the RPs.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Mar 28, 2006 2:59 am
Evan Yorke Island of Moreau Generally everything seems fine with her background/personality. I would like a little more insight as to way she dropped out of aschool so close to finishing it. She doesn't seem like the kind of character that would normally just drop out because some guy was spreading rumors. *nod* I've been meaning to add to why she dropped out, and writting up some more on her history. Island of Moreau Also, I would like a name for "the boy" blaugh Then I'll have to think of one, for ya! xd I was planning on just leaving him as a no-namer, but if it's a name you want, then a name you shall get. Island of Moreau As for how she got to island needs some work. Sabin Duvert would have no direct contact the outside world, and there is nothing particularly singular about Evan that would draw his attention anyway. There are plenty of programs Feral Labs uses as guises to get people here. If she likes adventure, perhaps she signed up for one of the "free" vacations Feral Labs hosts (charitable fundraisers, of course ^_~). Maybe there was one that was advertised more like a safari than a cruise that seemed "adventurous" to her? Yeah, this is the part I've been having the most difficulty with. 'Cause I think it would be awesome for Duvert to "take her under his wing," and toy with her. I just can't find anything that would give him reason to, apart from, "She's just a nice girl?" Anyway, I have a lot of little notes and stuff, that I'll need to sort through and write as an idea for the Sabin thing. Maybe I'll have to get into contact with Sabin through AIM or PMs and discuss it further, before I write anything concrete. After all, Sabin could use some minions! xd As for HOW she gets on the island, I think I worked it out. I'll post the revised bio when I'm done, and everyone seems to have had their turn. Your suggestions and crit are mucho appreciated! biggrin We're concerned about your basically asking an NPC to play favorites with you. Sabin, nor any of the staff, chose OOCly who they will "take under their wing" and who they won't. RP is the main deciding factor there - and how Sabin reacts to your character will depend completely on IC interactions. Dr. Duvert, with the rare exceptions (Zach) does not choose potential islanders anyway. Moreau handles it personally, with Aubrey's help.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Tue Mar 28, 2006 3:54 am
I like the added note on her appearance in the striking similarities to her mother, a point of frustration for her father and another explanation of the man's verbal abuse after her death in seeing Kikue as a constant reminder. It is also interesting to see the music in her life as the common thread of her different 'lives' - from child in London, to Japan, after her mother's death - it is the one common activity and I could see it very much being a catharsis and a "safe place" more than any location for her. which would explain why even though she was coached into the skill as such a young child why she did not resent it. The injury, then, is such a blow to her - and makes sense why she would rebel against her father with this last straw to try to repair it. It is a loss of her identity as much as anything else. It also makes sense that since her father wouldn't pay for the medical research that she went to smaller clinics - Feral Labs sponsors some of the low-cost urban clinics that she could have visited and got onto their radar. I like the feigned death, though do be wary it is VERY difficult to falsify an identity of a deceased person, especially shy of complete immolation of the body and forging dental patterns convincingly. Especially when murder is an issue, as coroners would do pretty thorough examinations of the body. But yes, falsifying a death, framing the father who would be known to have been abusive and drunk, and quite possibly unaware of his own actions works well into the story. You could just have her go missing, and the tabloids picking up the story (think Jean Benet Ramsey) and most people would blame the father. It also makes sense Moreau would want to test regenerative propertis of damaged limbs- beyond just lost ones. The only question that comes to mind with this reasoning is the selection of a snow leopard - felines have very different frontpaws/hands than humans - the claw digit giving an awkwardness when it woudl come to manipulation. - as opposed to something like a monkey, lemur or raccoon-relative that have comparitively dexterous hands. If you want to go with the snow leopard, then SHE Might think that she went for reconstructive surgery, but in essence she was just easy to disappear.
|
 |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|