Welcome to Gaia! ::

Naruto: The Path of the Shinobi

Back to Guilds

A Naruto Roleplay 

Tags: Naruto, Roleplay, Ninja, Jutsu, Shinobi 

Reply ♻ OOC Archives
[Sunagakure] Suna Chat۞ Goto Page: [] [<<] [<<] [<] 1 2 3 ... 471 472 473 474 475 476 ... 494 495 496 497 [>] [>>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Hinote Tosatsu
Vice Captain

Eloquent Lunatic

PostPosted: Thu Nov 08, 2012 4:17 pm


Luo1304
Hinote Tosatsu
Luo1304


You need to use the incantation for sand pit, unless you have a bonus I'm not seeing to allow you to skip that. (Unlikely, sine I think Ushio is the only other way than Ichibi to get that right now, outside of talents.)

/is being cheeky because you said we need to enforce incantations better =p

Besides that, I have a good idea for my next post, so I'll get it up tomorrow. Not really in the mood tonight.

Side note on a side note... I'm too lazy to go digging right now, but is Ushio a single element bloodline? I know you require water to be the first element, but are you allowed more? Can't remember.

Hey, cheekiness aside we do indeed need to enforce this even if it's me who needs to be reprimanded haha. I'll add it in to where he speaks.

And no it isn't a single element bloodline, it just requires that your primary element be suiton. Wait, why would I be walking around this guild since literally it's beginning with three elements if the clan I created was a one element clan? Wouldn't that strike you as odd/answer your question?


That falls under me being too lazy to look it up though. I don't think I've ever actually looked at Luo's elements... Or even his profile for that matter. o.o
PostPosted: Fri Nov 09, 2012 2:54 pm


Luo1304
Hey, cheekiness aside we do indeed need to enforce this even if it's me who needs to be reprimanded haha. I'll add it in to where he speaks.


I was going to write my post as if you'd already edited (You haven't yet.), but when I got to that portion of my post I realized I didn't need to hear at all for what I was doing, and it worked out way better anyways. XD

Also, "Tomorrow is another day.". Also see "Tomorrow is tomorrow but never today.". Or, "Tomorrow never comes.". Is it obvious what I'm doing yet? XD

Sorry about missing my own deadline. I got caught up in other stuff.

Hinote Tosatsu
Vice Captain

Eloquent Lunatic


Cobra_X
Crew

Aged Gaian

PostPosted: Wed Nov 14, 2012 11:03 am


Luo1304

Hinote Tosatsu


Sorry Luo, but with all do respect, I take issue with your most recent post in the fight. There are a couple of things that you didn't account for:

1. No handseals or Incantation for that Satetsu nijutsu... Constructs might not require handseals, but Satetsu ninjutsu do.

2. Shooting 3 inches to the right of Shinji's heart would maybe clip his left pectoral muscle... it wouldn't even hit a lung, much less stop or slow his approach/attack. through and Through shots don't create impact enough blow-back impact to stop an approach and I can argue whether Shinji would even register such a thing between all the other pain his body is going through and his disconnect from the real world.

3. Sorry, but you can't just rewind the fight to invalidate my attacks so you can get another attack off. This is especially true when using the technique you did requires hand seals. There is just no way you can pull that off fast enough after having launched two attacks (Sand Pit + Kunai/Shuriken control) when Shinji is moving at AA rank speed.
PostPosted: Wed Nov 14, 2012 11:26 am


I'd like a full list of all of Jishaku's benefits and bonuses. Most are evident, but some, such as profession benefits are not, and given the fact that reading back through the fight he's been using jutsu with no seals or incantation the entire time, I do rather need to see what benefits make that possible. I am aware that there is a ninjutsu specialist benefit that removes handseals on jutsu of sufficient rank below you, but it doesn't remove incantation, nor does it effect S rank jutsu. Besides that, I can't even be sure that's the one you have.

Hinote Tosatsu
Vice Captain

Eloquent Lunatic


iKaze Arashi

Married Exhibitionist

8,550 Points
  • Forum Sophomore 300
  • Person of Interest 200
  • Friendly 100
PostPosted: Wed Nov 14, 2012 11:28 am


Well then, the battle certainly has gotten wtfcrazy in the past couple of days.
PostPosted: Wed Nov 14, 2012 12:34 pm


Cobra_X


Hinote Tosatsu


Luo1304


Alright, I'll address it: Exactly who made this AA, AC, AB speed rank thing? I've never seen a system for it in the guild, and you guys seem to be making it up as you go along. Can I see the documentation? Otherwise, you really can't claim that your A rank speed is faster than someone else's A rank speed. Especially you, Cobra. Despite the fact that you have Konaga augmentations, and despite the fact that your a speed type, you are still a C rank. Even if this AD, AC thing were valid (which, to my knowledge, is not), there is no way your speed could possibly be AA, which I will assume is the fastest possible before S rank.

Gregar828
Vice Captain


Cobra_X
Crew

Aged Gaian

PostPosted: Wed Nov 14, 2012 1:00 pm


Gregar828
Alright, I'll address it: Exactly who made this AA, AC, AB speed rank thing? I've never seen a system for it in the guild, and you guys seem to be making it up as you go along. Can I see the documentation?

Take it up with Hinote, he's the one that told me I was AA rank when I used the skill, I'm just going by his construction. I remember asking the same thing, but I don't see it written down either. However, if me, Hinote, and Luo are acting on the same premise (which we are) , there is no real issue.

Gregar828
Especially you, Cobra. Despite the fact that you have Konaga augmentations, and despite the fact that your a speed type, you are still a C rank.

You forgot my talent...

C-rank + Speed = B-rank Speed ... + Talent, which gives me another speed boost in combat when my adrenaline kicks in, A-rank.

...then Double my speed with Chakra Speed. The math supports my speed and I'm doing everything legally based on what has been approved in the standard approval processes.
PostPosted: Wed Nov 14, 2012 1:49 pm


Gregar828
Cobra_X


Hinote Tosatsu


Luo1304


Alright, I'll address it: Exactly who made this AA, AC, AB speed rank thing? I've never seen a system for it in the guild, and you guys seem to be making it up as you go along. Can I see the documentation? Otherwise, you really can't claim that your A rank speed is faster than someone else's A rank speed. Especially you, Cobra. Despite the fact that you have Konaga augmentations, and despite the fact that your a speed type, you are still a C rank. Even if this AD, AC thing were valid (which, to my knowledge, is not), there is no way your speed could possibly be AA, which I will assume is the fastest possible before S rank.


Would you prefer that he run at AA, which is faster than A but not as fast as S, or at SSSSS? The so far undocumented but thankfully adhered to system prevents bonuses from jumping full ranks once they pass A, so that instead of someone running at SSSSS speed and being basically invincible for it, they instead increase ranks within the rank. AE is equal to A+, AD is A++, meaning AE is A with one bonus rank, while AD has two bonus ranks.

It wouldn't take any time at all to write up official documentation if you'd like. Just point out where such information should be placed and it'll be done by tomorrow night.

Hinote Tosatsu
Vice Captain

Eloquent Lunatic


Gregar828
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Wed Nov 14, 2012 2:38 pm


Hinote Tosatsu
Gregar828
Cobra_X


Hinote Tosatsu


Luo1304


Alright, I'll address it: Exactly who made this AA, AC, AB speed rank thing? I've never seen a system for it in the guild, and you guys seem to be making it up as you go along. Can I see the documentation? Otherwise, you really can't claim that your A rank speed is faster than someone else's A rank speed. Especially you, Cobra. Despite the fact that you have Konaga augmentations, and despite the fact that your a speed type, you are still a C rank. Even if this AD, AC thing were valid (which, to my knowledge, is not), there is no way your speed could possibly be AA, which I will assume is the fastest possible before S rank.


Would you prefer that he run at AA, which is faster than A but not as fast as S, or at SSSSS? The so far undocumented but thankfully adhered to system prevents bonuses from jumping full ranks once they pass A, so that instead of someone running at SSSSS speed and being basically invincible for it, they instead increase ranks within the rank. AE is equal to A+, AD is A++, meaning AE is A with one bonus rank, while AD has two bonus ranks.

It wouldn't take any time at all to write up official documentation if you'd like. Just point out where such information should be placed and it'll be done by tomorrow night.


A draft in the crew chatroom, please, but you're missing my point. You can't make up a system on the fly like this, then makes claims about who is faster based on it.

@Cobra: .......I'm sorry, what? So, your Konaga augmentation gives you +1 rank speed, you have two passive speed bonuses (Right now, that talent counts as passive) then you use another augmentation to DOUBLE your speed? And you're a chuunin? Forget overpowered, this is just getting stupid. I'm not even gonna go into how on earth you use two separate augmentation jutsu on the same limb(s) and keep them both active.
PostPosted: Wed Nov 14, 2012 3:56 pm


Gregar828
Hinote Tosatsu
Gregar828
Cobra_X


Hinote Tosatsu


Luo1304


Alright, I'll address it: Exactly who made this AA, AC, AB speed rank thing? I've never seen a system for it in the guild, and you guys seem to be making it up as you go along. Can I see the documentation? Otherwise, you really can't claim that your A rank speed is faster than someone else's A rank speed. Especially you, Cobra. Despite the fact that you have Konaga augmentations, and despite the fact that your a speed type, you are still a C rank. Even if this AD, AC thing were valid (which, to my knowledge, is not), there is no way your speed could possibly be AA, which I will assume is the fastest possible before S rank.


Would you prefer that he run at AA, which is faster than A but not as fast as S, or at SSSSS? The so far undocumented but thankfully adhered to system prevents bonuses from jumping full ranks once they pass A, so that instead of someone running at SSSSS speed and being basically invincible for it, they instead increase ranks within the rank. AE is equal to A+, AD is A++, meaning AE is A with one bonus rank, while AD has two bonus ranks.

It wouldn't take any time at all to write up official documentation if you'd like. Just point out where such information should be placed and it'll be done by tomorrow night.


A draft in the crew chatroom, please, but you're missing my point. You can't make up a system on the fly like this, then makes claims about who is faster based on it.

@Cobra: .......I'm sorry, what? So, your Konaga augmentation gives you +1 rank speed, you have two passive speed bonuses (Right now, that talent counts as passive) then you use another augmentation to DOUBLE your speed? And you're a chuunin? Forget overpowered, this is just getting stupid. I'm not even gonna go into how on earth you use two separate augmentation jutsu on the same limb(s) and keep them both active.


Firstly, I didn't make it up on the fly. It's just adding numbers (... Letters.) to what is already there, and stopping it from jumping straight to S.

Secondly, as I said, it's just using what is there. It counts existing bonuses. If two people of equal rank fight, they have equal power. if one has a higher bonus than the other, they have greater power. We just added values to that.

Hinote Tosatsu
Vice Captain

Eloquent Lunatic


TvIaMsOqTuHeYz

Dangerous Loiterer

PostPosted: Wed Nov 14, 2012 4:58 pm


Hey Hinote, using the unwritten system we've talked about a couple of times since the beginning of Cobra's intervention into the fight could you answer something for me:

If someone were capable of going AA Rank in speed, would they need to go up only one more level ( AS ) or two ranks ( ASE ) to be equal to S Rank?

Also, it isn't that difficult a system, I'd be happy to write out a system for it in my spare time. The above question is the only thing that is conflicting about it, and then we wouldn't have to deal with explaining things like this to new members.
PostPosted: Thu Nov 15, 2012 5:44 am


Gregar828
@Cobra: .......I'm sorry, what? So, your Konaga augmentation gives you +1 rank speed, you have two passive speed bonuses (Right now, that talent counts as passive) then you use another augmentation to DOUBLE your speed? And you're a chuunin? Forget overpowered, this is just getting stupid. I'm not even gonna go into how on earth you use two separate augmentation jutsu on the same limb(s) and keep them both active.

I can admit that the term 'doubled' can be confusing, but it has always been the same thing. What it actually does is double your bonus... as augmentations take what you have and makes it stronger.

So, I have 2 passive bonuses, +1 from Speed Type and +1 from Talent... augmenting my speed then doubles that bonus to a total of +4 bonus... which puts me well in the range stated earlier. I'm not doing anything outside of what has always been done.

Chakra speed is being used on his legs... Chakra Blade is being used on his hand... how is that two augmentations on the same limb?

If you think that is overpowered, then you should have said something earlier when the bloodline was submitted and the jutsu evaluated. But beyond that you're not even trying to understand the negative consequences of what Shinji is doing.

In return for being able to act like a Jounin+ shinobi for about 3-4 posts, he is not only going to suffer the consequences of being in the hospital, helpless and in pain for over a week... but he's running the risk of dying. If you were to take the time to ACTUALLY read the bloodline and understand the negative consequences of the powers the Konaga clan has and the rolls I'm rolling on every post, you might see how balanced the system actually is.

I'm tired of you jumping to conclusions and pointing the finger at me. Take some time, read my bloodline and educate yourself before you start slinging insults, calling my bloodline, and by extension, myself "Stupid". I've worked very hard to balance the extreme power with a variety of negative consequences and I've had several people congratulate me on a job well done with it.

Cobra_X
Crew

Aged Gaian


Gregar828
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Thu Nov 15, 2012 10:40 am


Cobra_X
Gregar828
@Cobra: .......I'm sorry, what? So, your Konaga augmentation gives you +1 rank speed, you have two passive speed bonuses (Right now, that talent counts as passive) then you use another augmentation to DOUBLE your speed? And you're a chuunin? Forget overpowered, this is just getting stupid. I'm not even gonna go into how on earth you use two separate augmentation jutsu on the same limb(s) and keep them both active.

I can admit that the term 'doubled' can be confusing, but it has always been the same thing. What it actually does is double your bonus... as augmentations take what you have and makes it stronger.

So, I have 2 passive bonuses, +1 from Speed Type and +1 from Talent... augmenting my speed then doubles that bonus to a total of +4 bonus... which puts me well in the range stated earlier. I'm not doing anything outside of what has always been done.

Chakra speed is being used on his legs... Chakra Blade is being used on his hand... how is that two augmentations on the same limb?

If you think that is overpowered, then you should have said something earlier when the bloodline was submitted and the jutsu evaluated. But beyond that you're not even trying to understand the negative consequences of what Shinji is doing.

In return for being able to act like a Jounin+ shinobi for about 3-4 posts, he is not only going to suffer the consequences of being in the hospital, helpless and in pain for over a week... but he's running the risk of dying. If you were to take the time to ACTUALLY read the bloodline and understand the negative consequences of the powers the Konaga clan has and the rolls I'm rolling on every post, you might see how balanced the system actually is.

I'm tired of you jumping to conclusions and pointing the finger at me. Take some time, read my bloodline and educate yourself before you start slinging insults, calling my bloodline, and by extension, myself "Stupid". I've worked very hard to balance the extreme power with a variety of negative consequences and I've had several people congratulate me on a job well done with it.


Are you really trying to pull the "You should've said something before it was approved!" argument? See, THIS is why I'm so tough on MY applications (which, by the way, does not include bloodlines. I admit, I have some say, but I have never been the official bloodline moderator, and therefore, do not get the final yes or no). Besides, the stupidly overpowered part came from the fact that your talent was approved (and the fact that chakra speed affect that bonus), so that argument isn't entirely valid in the first place.

Oh, come on. Run the risk of dying? As the RPer, you're not gonna let him die because he used up too much chakra. Be realistic.

I've read the Konaga bloodline. Despite the drawbacks, I still consider it overpowered. It was kind of acceptable, but with that talent you now have, its beyond overpowered. +4 ranks to speed? Upper A rank speed as a Chuunin? You cannot possibly consider that acceptable in any way.
PostPosted: Thu Nov 15, 2012 11:47 am


Gregar828
Are you really trying to pull the "You should've said something before it was approved!" argument? See, THIS is why I'm so tough on MY applications (which, by the way, does not include bloodlines. I admit, I have some say, but I have never been the official bloodline moderator, and therefore, do not get the final yes or no). Besides, the stupidly overpowered part came from the fact that your talent was approved (and the fact that chakra speed affect that bonus), so that argument isn't entirely valid in the first place.

Well I'm sorry if you don't like it... but I followed the rules. You may think its stupid and overpowered, but it might just be that all I'm doing is showing you flaws in your system. My argument is entirely valid in all parts. I made the applications, the applications were approved, the applications synergize.

If you want to change it, then come together with some moderators and enforce a change, but as is, I'm working within the confines of the system. So either come down with an official ruling, or accept it for what it is.


Gregar828
Oh, come on. Run the risk of dying? As the RPer, you're not gonna let him die because he used up too much chakra. Be realistic.

Again, a fundamental misunderstanding of the bloodline. First off, it's not a lack of CHAKRA... its a Stamina issue... and the fact remains that once I go into the Raging Spirit and lose control and pass out... the bad guy can drop a spear in my head and I could do nothing to stop him.

I call that a risk of death via overuse of my augmentations.


Gregar828
I've read the Konaga bloodline. Despite the drawbacks, I still consider it overpowered. It was kind of acceptable, but with that talent you now have, its beyond overpowered. +4 ranks to speed? Upper A rank speed as a Chuunin? You cannot possibly consider that acceptable in any way.

I consider it acceptable in that it can only be achieved for a brief period and it physically harms my character with possibly dire consequences afterward. If its something he could do without batting an eyelash, that's one thing... but there are large consequences to using multiple augmentations per post as Shinji has been doing for back to back posts...

ALSO, I've been lucky with my rolls recently, which make it seem more overpowered then it is. AND YET... in this fight against a Jounin, I'm still clearly not the victor, and will soon burn out. If I had already murdered him and 2 other Jounin, but I haven't. ATM, Shinji is no more powerful or effective then your average Bijuu. the only difference is my character has a HEAVY burden of having to roll and deal with RP pain constantly, even when outside the battle.

Cobra_X
Crew

Aged Gaian


Hinote Tosatsu
Vice Captain

Eloquent Lunatic

PostPosted: Thu Nov 15, 2012 11:50 am


Going back and actually looking at the talent (This is something we all should do before arguing over things.), the speed bonus from the talent does not apply to actual speed, and thus would not directly affect the augmentation either. The talent only allows those bonuses when attacking. That doesn't mean that so long as it's part of an attack the person can run faster, but that their punches, or kicks, or whatever else, are faster.

So, removing the talent (And it's doubled effect.), Shinji is capable of running at AC rank speed, entirely due to the Konaga augmentation, which I believe also only lasts for one post. Otherwise his base speed is B. And if you think that is OP, so is Yamatano, and anyone else with the Speed type.

If you want to continue this argument Greg, you will be fighting for the removal of Speed type, your bloodline's speed bonus, and the Raijuu, because they all lend bonuses to speed that could thus be considered OP.

Regardless, with his current stats and using the speed augmentation, Shinji is still faster than Jishaku, which I believe was the original point of this argument, before it got to the line of calling characters, bloodlines, and talents OP.

Also, thanks for adding into this whole bit that I'm stupid as well. That was great.
Reply
♻ OOC Archives

Goto Page: [] [<<] [<<] [<] 1 2 3 ... 471 472 473 474 475 476 ... 494 495 496 497 [>] [>>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum