Welcome to Gaia! ::

Debate/Discuss Religion

Back to Guilds

A guild devoted to discussing and debating different aspects of various world religions 

Tags: religion, faith, tolerance, discuss, debate 

Reply Religious Debate
Homosexuality Goto Page: [] [<<] [<] 1 2 3 ... 43 44 45 46 47 48 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

WickedRentSpringAwakening

PostPosted: Mon Mar 08, 2010 9:24 pm


rmcdra
Captain_Shinzo

But then technically, that would make such a place a whole new type of government system. A theocracy if you will. Democratic countries should atleast keep laws and religion separate.
The Red Scare act still slightly pisses me off, too... stare
I'm not to fond of the Red Scare either. It's just as paranoid and delusional as this 2012 and Nibaru garbage that's floating around now.


Mass hysteria, and in the history of the US we have had, as examples of mass hysteria: Witches, communists, terrorists, gays, 2012, Y2K to name a few. When people are scared they are more willing to hand over their freedoms to the government and that will lead to a powerful central leader, hence McCarthyism, and hence W's terrorist witch hunt known as the Patriot Act.
PostPosted: Mon Mar 08, 2010 9:58 pm


WickedRentSpringAwakening
rmcdra
Captain_Shinzo

But then technically, that would make such a place a whole new type of government system. A theocracy if you will. Democratic countries should atleast keep laws and religion separate.
The Red Scare act still slightly pisses me off, too... stare
I'm not to fond of the Red Scare either. It's just as paranoid and delusional as this 2012 and Nibaru garbage that's floating around now.


Mass hysteria, and in the history of the US we have had, as examples of mass hysteria: Witches, communists, terrorists, gays, 2012, Y2K to name a few. When people are scared they are more willing to hand over their freedoms to the government and that will lead to a powerful central leader, hence McCarthyism, and hence W's terrorist witch hunt known as the Patriot Act.
Yeah it's highly manipulative since it takes advantage of the ignorance and fears of the populous and it's the abuse of one's power of authority. I think we are getting off topic now.

Anyway back to homosexuality. It's not against nature as popularly believed since we have studies by the APA and other credible psychological authorities that it is part of normal sexual development. To say that it's against nature is just as ignorant to say that nature supports homosexuality since the male prostate is one p***s length from the a**s. There have also been studies disproving the lies about homosexuality being interrelated with *****, bestiality, or any other abusive sexual practices.

Though there are some religions that are against homosexuality, we have been shown that in Judaism and Christianity the interpretations of scripture being against homosexuality is a result of appeals to tradition and a misunderstanding of the source language and contexts of the canonical texts.

And in the United States there is a separation of church and state. So while churches reserve the right to not offer a religious marriage to homosexuals, there is no reason for secular marriage to have such a restriction. If gay marriage is going to destroy anything, it's going to destroy the close ties that religious and secular marriage has had in the United States which shouldn't be there if there is supposed to be a separation of church and state.

rmcdra

Loved Seeker

11,700 Points
  • Forum Sophomore 300
  • Partygoer 500
  • Contributor 150

caeruleus5765

PostPosted: Mon Mar 08, 2010 11:16 pm


WickedRentSpringAwakening
caeruleus5765
Working that which is unseemly... perhaps this doesn't mean sex but rather lacking others consideration. (Definition of unseemly from Princeton.edu) Such as gay rape, or making out in public where children can watch. I know I wouldn't want someone making my kids gay.


I draw the line here. To say that gay couples may not make out in public, but straight couples can is wrong. There is no basis in logic for that. Plus, you can't make kids gay. Being gay is being attracted to someone of the same sex, it's not something you can force on someone.

And Jesus said that all of the laws of the prophets are summed up in loving others, I'm not getting that at all from the laws, most of them are pretty much against loving others.

Well it seems to me that people don't want their kids seeing that. They don't understand it so it frightens them. If your in a community that feels this way, I think it's only respectful to not do it in public. I mean, we can make out anywhere. Does it really have to be done in a place that would upset people?

Then again. I'm not the type of guy who's into public displays of affection anyway, so that sacrifice would be easy for me. This might be harder for other gay guys.

I agree that it's not fair, but even crazy people deserve respect.
PostPosted: Mon Mar 08, 2010 11:39 pm


caeruleus5765
WickedRentSpringAwakening
caeruleus5765
Working that which is unseemly... perhaps this doesn't mean sex but rather lacking others consideration. (Definition of unseemly from Princeton.edu) Such as gay rape, or making out in public where children can watch. I know I wouldn't want someone making my kids gay.


I draw the line here. To say that gay couples may not make out in public, but straight couples can is wrong. There is no basis in logic for that. Plus, you can't make kids gay. Being gay is being attracted to someone of the same sex, it's not something you can force on someone.

And Jesus said that all of the laws of the prophets are summed up in loving others, I'm not getting that at all from the laws, most of them are pretty much against loving others.

Well it seems to me that people don't want their kids seeing that. They don't understand it so it frightens them. If your in a community that feels this way, I think it's only respectful to not do it in public. I mean, we can make out anywhere. Does it really have to be done in a place that would upset people?

Then again. I'm not the type of guy who's into public displays of affection anyway, so that sacrifice would be easy for me. This might be harder for other gay guys.

I agree that it's not fair, but even crazy people deserve respect.
It's disrespectful for them to not attempt to understand something because it's different to them. If parents don't want their children being exposed to people making out in public in general, then yeah, I understand that. But for someone to get upset because the couple is homosexual, they are the ones who need to be respectful. They are the ones who need to learn tolerance.
Kids don't become gay by being around gay people. And what kind of message is that parent sending by basically saying "Get out of here, I don't want you to turn my son gay!" What will that child learn about homosexuality? How will he treat gay people in the future? Or even, what if he grows up to be gay? If coming out wasn't going to be hard enough, his parents have already convinced him that it's a bad thing and there's something wrong with him.
No, that way of thinking needs to be changed. Too many people say "No, no, there's nothing wrong with homosexuality! I'm tolerant! Just don't put it where I can see it because it makes me uncomfortable..."
Respect is one thing. Really, I'm all about respect. But most people need to be pushed a little or they'll never change.

brainnsoup
Crew

Dapper Shapeshifter


rmcdra

Loved Seeker

11,700 Points
  • Forum Sophomore 300
  • Partygoer 500
  • Contributor 150
PostPosted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 1:04 am


brainnsoup
caeruleus5765
WickedRentSpringAwakening
caeruleus5765
Working that which is unseemly... perhaps this doesn't mean sex but rather lacking others consideration. (Definition of unseemly from Princeton.edu) Such as gay rape, or making out in public where children can watch. I know I wouldn't want someone making my kids gay.


I draw the line here. To say that gay couples may not make out in public, but straight couples can is wrong. There is no basis in logic for that. Plus, you can't make kids gay. Being gay is being attracted to someone of the same sex, it's not something you can force on someone.

And Jesus said that all of the laws of the prophets are summed up in loving others, I'm not getting that at all from the laws, most of them are pretty much against loving others.

Well it seems to me that people don't want their kids seeing that. They don't understand it so it frightens them. If your in a community that feels this way, I think it's only respectful to not do it in public. I mean, we can make out anywhere. Does it really have to be done in a place that would upset people?

Then again. I'm not the type of guy who's into public displays of affection anyway, so that sacrifice would be easy for me. This might be harder for other gay guys.

I agree that it's not fair, but even crazy people deserve respect.
It's disrespectful for them to not attempt to understand something because it's different to them. If parents don't want their children being exposed to people making out in public in general, then yeah, I understand that. But for someone to get upset because the couple is homosexual, they are the ones who need to be respectful. They are the ones who need to learn tolerance.
Kids don't become gay by being around gay people. And what kind of message is that parent sending by basically saying "Get out of here, I don't want you to turn my son gay!" What will that child learn about homosexuality? How will he treat gay people in the future? Or even, what if he grows up to be gay? If coming out wasn't going to be hard enough, his parents have already convinced him that it's a bad thing and there's something wrong with him.
No, that way of thinking needs to be changed. Too many people say "No, no, there's nothing wrong with homosexuality! I'm tolerant! Just don't put it where I can see it because it makes me uncomfortable..."
Respect is one thing. Really, I'm all about respect. But most people need to be pushed a little or they'll never change.
Sound like those people need to repent which from what I understand is translated from a Greek word literally meaning "to think again" or "re-think".
PostPosted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 5:26 pm


caeruleus5765
WickedRentSpringAwakening
caeruleus5765
Working that which is unseemly... perhaps this doesn't mean sex but rather lacking others consideration. (Definition of unseemly from Princeton.edu) Such as gay rape, or making out in public where children can watch. I know I wouldn't want someone making my kids gay.


I draw the line here. To say that gay couples may not make out in public, but straight couples can is wrong. There is no basis in logic for that. Plus, you can't make kids gay. Being gay is being attracted to someone of the same sex, it's not something you can force on someone.

And Jesus said that all of the laws of the prophets are summed up in loving others, I'm not getting that at all from the laws, most of them are pretty much against loving others.

Well it seems to me that people don't want their kids seeing that. They don't understand it so it frightens them. If your in a community that feels this way, I think it's only respectful to not do it in public. I mean, we can make out anywhere. Does it really have to be done in a place that would upset people?

Then again. I'm not the type of guy who's into public displays of affection anyway, so that sacrifice would be easy for me. This might be harder for other gay guys.

I agree that it's not fair, but even crazy people deserve respect.

But that is the entire reason why gays should have equal rights. Children are scared of this because they are used to straight relationships. If gays were more of a accepted kind of people in today's society, children being frightened wouldn't be a problem.
Kids in the 1800s used to think blacks of any kind were out-worldly and strange. Now today, they are equal.

Besides, seperation of church and state should still be used today.

Captain_Shinzo

6,250 Points
  • Member 100
  • Gaian 50
  • Dressed Up 200

Captain_Shinzo

6,250 Points
  • Member 100
  • Gaian 50
  • Dressed Up 200
PostPosted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 5:28 pm


rmcdra
Captain_Shinzo

But then technically, that would make such a place a whole new type of government system. A theocracy if you will. Democratic countries should atleast keep laws and religion separate.
The Red Scare act still slightly pisses me off, too... stare
I'm not saying they shouldn't. I was just trying to say that Rome was a bad example, though they did have a pretty good system set up for their time. I think present day England or France would be a better example of separation of church and state, though I could be mistaken on that too.

I'm not to fond of the Red Scare either. It's just as paranoid and delusional as this 2012 and Nibaru garbage that's floating around now.

Well, when I said during Jesus's time, I never exactly gave a location. That might have been a problem.
PostPosted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 9:34 pm


Captain_Shinzo
Captain_Shinzo
gohst13
Captain_Shinzo
gohst13
brainnsoup
Oh, I know, I agree with you. I'm just adding my opinions.
Though I wouldn't get my hopes up for an unbiased, objective reason why we shouldn't legalize gay marriage. I don't think one exits.
There is no logical unbiased opinion on a subject like this. Even Captain_Shinzo has to agree with this. With a subject like this all people can really do is act the way they think they should. People seem to do what they have deluded into being right...

The point was that there is no reason for Homosexuality being wrong as you said.
But even if you said, as I have read
"People just need to follow their gut."
Problem is, that is pretty wrong.
As I have stated, way way back, people thought blacks should stay segregated in building and facilities. A vast majority thought this. But just because they think this doesn't make it right.
Get what I am saying? If there is no reason to keep homosexuals from marriage, than why do it?
Yes I get what you're saying Shinzo, and oddly I agree with you. But again it doesn't matter if it's right or wrong. People do what THEY believe is right, it doesn't exactly mean that it's right to everyone else. It's about opinion, not mush else.

Well if it's about opinions then opinions can get thrown away for all I care. People can't give me a true reason why homosexuality is wrong. If all they tell me 'it's just not right' than it may be an opinion, but it doesn't make it fact. For all I know, homosexuality is not morally wrong because it does not harm anyone. In thus case, it is a fact and not an opinion. Besides, we don't believe in the opinions of science.

Still waiting for your reply.
well i'm sorry that i can't get on everyday like so many others... and when did i say that I thought it was wrong to be gay. i've answered your question as well as i posibly could and you still aren't satisfied... that's not much of my problem anymore stare  

HatelessHeart

5,100 Points
  • Flatterer 200
  • Peoplewatcher 100
  • Contributor 150

rmcdra

Loved Seeker

11,700 Points
  • Forum Sophomore 300
  • Partygoer 500
  • Contributor 150
PostPosted: Tue Mar 09, 2010 10:27 pm


gohst13
But again it doesn't matter if it's right or wrong.
Then there can be no justice.
Quote:
People do what THEY believe is right, it doesn't exactly mean that it's right to everyone else.
So if this is true and I say you are wrong how can you prove me wrong? Let me give you another example, if I believe that raping babies is right and I could make it legal to do would I be right to do so?
Quote:
It's about opinion, not mush else.
Opinions are worthless if there's nothing to back them up.
PostPosted: Wed Mar 10, 2010 5:03 am


I don't know if this was already adressed [I suppose it probably was seeing how many pages there are], but it doesn't make sense for Christians to quote Leviticus as a "proof" against homosexuality. These laws have never been meant for the gentiles; they were given specifically to the Hebrews and it is very clear from the context of the book.

Ametrin


Tiina Brown

Friendly Sentai

PostPosted: Wed Mar 10, 2010 10:20 am


Luz Melian
I don't know if this was already adressed [I suppose it probably was seeing how many pages there are], but it doesn't make sense for Christians to quote Leviticus as a "proof" against homosexuality. These laws have never been meant for the gentiles; they were given specifically to the Hebrews and it is very clear from the context of the book.

They should have read Hesekiel (or however his name is spelled in English) as well, but it seems they kept those non-commandment laws anyway, maybe because they considered them older than the Commandments ......
PostPosted: Fri Mar 12, 2010 6:41 pm


gohst13
Captain_Shinzo
Captain_Shinzo
gohst13
Captain_Shinzo

The point was that there is no reason for Homosexuality being wrong as you said.
But even if you said, as I have read
"People just need to follow their gut."
Problem is, that is pretty wrong.
As I have stated, way way back, people thought blacks should stay segregated in building and facilities. A vast majority thought this. But just because they think this doesn't make it right.
Get what I am saying? If there is no reason to keep homosexuals from marriage, than why do it?
Yes I get what you're saying Shinzo, and oddly I agree with you. But again it doesn't matter if it's right or wrong. People do what THEY believe is right, it doesn't exactly mean that it's right to everyone else. It's about opinion, not mush else.

Well if it's about opinions then opinions can get thrown away for all I care. People can't give me a true reason why homosexuality is wrong. If all they tell me 'it's just not right' than it may be an opinion, but it doesn't make it fact. For all I know, homosexuality is not morally wrong because it does not harm anyone. In thus case, it is a fact and not an opinion. Besides, we don't believe in the opinions of science.

Still waiting for your reply.
well i'm sorry that i can't get on everyday like so many others... and when did i say that I thought it was wrong to be gay. i've answered your question as well as i posibly could and you still aren't satisfied... that's not much of my problem anymore stare

If you post, you obviously having a point.
You said that it is technically all about opinions.
However, as RMCDRA has said, opinions are nothing without a reason to believe in it.
If you have nothing to say, then where else could your argument stand?

Captain_Shinzo

6,250 Points
  • Member 100
  • Gaian 50
  • Dressed Up 200

freelance lover

PostPosted: Wed Mar 17, 2010 8:14 pm


I have yet to have anyone give me proof where it says anywhere in the Bible that homosexuality as it exists today is sinful.

That being said, even if it is sinful, the government has no right to prohibit homosexuals from getting legally married. It's legal, not religious. The politician's personal faith shouldn't make a difference, they should be advocating for the people they represent, which includes equal rights for homosexuals and all.
PostPosted: Wed Mar 17, 2010 9:42 pm


freelance lover
I have yet to have anyone give me proof where it says anywhere in the Bible that homosexuality as it exists today is sinful.

That being said, even if it is sinful, the government has no right to prohibit homosexuals from getting legally married. It's legal, not religious. The politician's personal faith shouldn't make a difference, they should be advocating for the people they represent, which includes equal rights for homosexuals and all.


That's basically we're I'm at. As a Christian I have yet to see biblical support backing the stance that homosexuality is a sin and like you said, if it is than it still has no bearing on the legal status of gay marriage in the US since religion is not a source that can be used to force certain laws on anyone.

Semiremis
Captain


Eltanin Sadachbia

Fashionable Nerd

9,950 Points
  • Friendly 100
  • Person of Interest 200
  • Invisibility 100
PostPosted: Wed Mar 17, 2010 11:34 pm


Hey! At least there are some Christian organizations who don't judge, and know that a person's sexual identity is that person's own concern.

Episcopal Church Accepts 2nd Openly Gay Bishop

YAY! Go Episcopalians!
Reply
Religious Debate

Goto Page: [] [<<] [<] 1 2 3 ... 43 44 45 46 47 48 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum