Welcome to Gaia! ::

gonk
Maul is partially right. I also meant that there's nothing saying the seers can't just lie to us to screw around with our heads. they could find out an important role, and tell us something completely different just to mess with our heads and create mass chaos.

You make a fair point I-Minh but here's how I see things.

*On one page you said I was a credit to the thread because I voiced my opinion, on the next you gave a quote which proved the opposite, which is it?

* The quote above was indeed lacking evidence and opinion, and I will ensure that I back up all future claims with as much solid proof as I can.

*. People shouldn't voice just any opinion that they have. Random speculation will lead to chaos and the lynching of valuable member.

*. People should voice their opinions, along with solid evidence when they think that they are making even a slightly accurate assesment of the situation. IE: Your accusation of Koosei, though lacking in conclusive proof, did have a solid backbone and was worth pointing out. Where as someone who says "I think he/she is the wolf, because they haven't been posting" is an accusation with little evidence and does little to aid us. So, take time to gather evidence (but not too much) then present the evidence to everyone when the time is right.

*With regard to your accusation of Koosei, I disagree in parts. Koosei has been on the thread more than alot of people, doing just what you asked: Voiceing her opinion. When someone talks and discusses as much as she does, there are bound to be certain times when her words can be seen as suspicous, simply for the fact that she is more noticable than everyone else. Perhaps you are right about Koosei, but I think that you should first appreciate someone who is voiceing her opinion openly (which, as tatsuman said, makes her a target for all parties.)

*People who talk on the thread more, and voice intellegent opinions are more likely to be killed or lynched, it's a sad fact. We can perhaps determine that if someone was killed that had been suggesting things, then this is evidence that they were right. But is it? Perhaps that person was utterly wrong, but was killed as a distraction?

Anyways, I hope that was all clear (I type whilst I think, so sometimes it gets mixed up a bit). And to clarify, I think you are right for the most part, but I disagree on a few points. One final thing, being Gonbes sister. Is being Gonbes sister a benefit or not? I'm not accusing you or her of anything, but I do imagine you would be able to garner some ideas based on the things Gonbe says (ie: she says something irrelevant, but you pick up a clue from it). Of course, I don't know if you even live together, but I think it's a imporatant thing to clarify.

Vote Count:
Koosei: 1 (I-minh)