Welcome to Gaia! ::

The Island of Dr. Moreau Quester Central

Back to Guilds

 

 

Reply The Island of Dr. Moreau Questor Central
Official Character Critique Depot - TEMP CLOSED Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 ... 20 21 22 23 [>] [>>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Island of Moreau
Captain

PostPosted: Mon Mar 27, 2006 10:11 am


David Wolfenbrother
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: David Wolfenbrother
Character Name: David Barnhill
Serum Animal(s): Raven
Quest Thread: ]http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?page=1&t=2476386#53025714


Such a man with no ties would be a good choice for Moreau. However, I did noticed a lack of how or why he was brought to the island. How would be have known about Feral Labs, etc? An idea thats comes to mind is perhaps if he got really sick or injhured, beyond anything he could fix himself, perhaps he would checked himself into (or brought to, if he was found) one of Feral Labs low-cost clinics since he would obviously have no health insurance. Then they would need to intice him to the island at some point.

There seems to be a few holes in the backstory that, while it wouldn't be required, I'd love to see some explaination for. Why was David so buffered/detatched from the rest of his family? Perhaps his parents marraiage was not approved of by the family?

Also, what -in particular- set David off to be so extreme. I have experienced a family torn apart by an excepted death, and yes, family swoops in like vultures. But a rough as things got, nothing sent me wanting to run into the hills and abandon society as a whole. Perhaps explain more that his love of nature/camping was in his blood and a very important to him beforehand.

Also, just a personal suggestion, perhaps if his parents were killed in more diliberate way? Like grusomely murdered? Something that also helps ingrain in David's mind that society/people are evil or otherwise "not worth it."

And, that said, ne prepared to face the RP challenges of playing such an introverted character. I've seen many examples where people claim to have such detatched characters, but then like two days into the RP the charactes are drinking and haveing a grand-ol time. It would be interesting to see this archtype played well for once.
PostPosted: Mon Mar 27, 2006 10:16 am


Rabid Jigglypuff
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: Rabid Jigglypuff
Character Name: Alec Derring
Serum Animal(s): Tiger Shark
Quest Thread: ]http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2475137


*stamp* Everything seems fine with Alec. HOW he got to the island seems a -bit- shakey to me, but really I can't think of a more appropiate way so I say its fine for now. If we get struck inspiration we'll let you know. But overall, good to go!

Love the character design, btw.
User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.

Island of Moreau
Captain


Island of Moreau
Captain

PostPosted: Mon Mar 27, 2006 12:00 pm


Marshall_Green
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: DecayingThorn
Character Name: Marshall Green
Serum Animal(s): Emperor Penguin
Quest Thread: ]http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2475101


The background behind him seems well thought out and the character is very believable. The idea of him being a webcomic artist really works.

While I can see Feral having some pockets in CC and such, really Marshall wouldn't be giving them motivation or reason to take him to the island. Especially in silence. Now, if for the first time in his life he stood up to like a boardroom (but nothing to public it would end up in a newspaper) they might "take him out of the picture".

Marshall could be brought to the island then the public would be told he was working on the writing for the show and he could drop off the public eye like many animation creators. It would likely be years before anyone would think to ask.

Doing this to him also would be an interesting role play challenge because the one time that he stood up for himself (especially with how hard that probably was) he ended up... well screwed for it.

Overall, Island Approved. Moreau just needs a motivation.
PostPosted: Mon Mar 27, 2006 1:02 pm


Island of Moreau
Kimie Kitty
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: Kimie Kitty
Character Name: Nita MacNeal
Serum Animal(s): Red Panda
Quest Thread: ]http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2475119


Nita seems pretty much ready to go. Yay for lesbian/bisexual women characters! She seems bookish and cute.

I noticed you have two different ideas for how she got to island. Personally, I want to avoid castaways/rescues/plane crashes as MUCH as possible. Just because realistically speaking, those would be pretty rare. Its kind of the "cop out" way we can default for characters that we can find no other way to reasonably get them here. Since Nita is a college student, I can think of many other ways that could work, including something very similar to the idea you had about a study abroud program. We've had several of those already, like Timothy and Hargun.

My only question would be what is her current relationship with her parents or brother like? Generally Moreau tries to take people with no strings, unless there is something terribly unique abuot them
I'm not really fond of the castaway thing, either. That was more of a half-assed addition... I think I had some reason at the time, but darned if I can remember it now. xd

Studying abroad would be much more IC for her, or perhaps joining the Peace Corp? That would explain being away for a long time and a lack of communication with the States.

As for her family, she is on pretty good terms, but if she were abroad/Peace Corp, there'd be the expectation of her being rather MIA for months on end. Also, they're not exactly well-off, so they wouldn't be able to launch a full-scale search for her (once they realized how long it had been without any news). Point though, I'll add a bit about her family, and I'm leaning towards a Peace Corp scenario. 3nodding

Kimie Kitty

Gracious Gekko


Island of Moreau
Captain

PostPosted: Mon Mar 27, 2006 1:27 pm


Lewin Edwards
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: DarkenedHorizons
Character Name: Lewin Edwards
Serum Animal(s): Black-Backed Jackal
Quest Thread:http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2501226

I'm still a little leery of giving him a genetic defect--I want him to be interesting, but not OMGIMSOSPECHUL!--so if you think it's a little excessive, just let me know. I'm willing to rewrite most of the rest, though I'd like to keep the HIV in--it helped shape who he is, in part. ^^


Very interesting. We were just discussing yesterday how, despite the excessive amounts of gay/bi men in online RPGs how hardly any of them have family issues or diseases.

I like the addition of HIV, however I'm unsure how Moreau or Aubrey would handle having an HIV positive subject interacting with other subjects. So prepared for some RP challenges as (IC)Staff might be prejudice again him "contaminating" their precious other subjects.

However, Moreau would pounce on the oppurtunity to test how/if they could cure the disease with gene therapy.

As for the ocular albinism - its to you whether you want to keep it or not... but you've developed a well-rounded, fleshed out character and history, I don't think you NEED it to be "special." In the end, personally, it just kind of tacked on. But again, sometimes genetic defects just happen. So its completely up to you if you want to keep or not.

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.
PostPosted: Mon Mar 27, 2006 1:41 pm


Joshua Rivers
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: Poufy Werewolf
Character Name: Professor Joshua Rivers
Serum Animal(s): Giraffe-taur
Quest Thread: http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2479332

I might nitpick his history later, but what I have down now is really the important parts.


Very interesting! First of all, I've been very happy to see more and more people creating characters over the age of 25. Personally, I would love to see Josh be a few years older. Perhaps 45? But thats just a personal thing. Older, intelligent men = sexy.

Wow, okay so I just gave away that its not Hige writing this critique. Oh well.

Anyway, history sounds good, though I'm brainstorming some ways that could make it... pop alittle more. Like..why was he laid off from his old job? Just cut downs? Generally teaching has AMAZING job security.

Just an idea I'm throwing out... I would -suggest- making the how he got to the island a bit more, hm, personal? Instead of Feral Labs just having open advertisements for a teaching profession, i'm thinking... maybe one his colleagues at the public university had some ins with Feral Labs. Like he was a researcher and only taught part-time. But he heard one of Moreau's wackly outskirt projects needed a professor. Knowing Josh was down on his luck and figuring a tropical gig might be the vacation he needs, suggests he go to the company and inquire further?

Again, just an idea that came to mind. The poor guy honestly just trying to help XD Ooops.

As for the animal - very very interesting. The idea of a giraffe in half-moon glasses makes me giggle. The mute thing is interesting, too, but be prepared for the challenge!

Island of Moreau
Captain


Marshall_Green

PostPosted: Mon Mar 27, 2006 3:15 pm


Island of Moreau
Marshall_Green
Official Critique Request
Gaia Username: DecayingThorn
Character Name: Marshall Green
Serum Animal(s): Emperor Penguin
Quest Thread: ]http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=2475101


The background behind him seems well thought out and the character is very believable. The idea of him being a webcomic artist really works.

While I can see Feral having some pockets in CC and such, really Marshall wouldn't be giving them motivation or reason to take him to the island. Especially in silence. Now, if for the first time in his life he stood up to like a boardroom (but nothing to public it would end up in a newspaper) they might "take him out of the picture".

Marshall could be brought to the island then the public would be told he was working on the writing for the show and he could drop off the public eye like many animation creators. It would likely be years before anyone would think to ask.

Doing this to him also would be an interesting role play challenge because the one time that he stood up for himself (especially with how hard that probably was) he ended up... well screwed for it.

Overall, Island Approved. Moreau just needs a motivation.
^_^ Thank you very much. I have added a little more to his History. I believe the term "Its All Business" applies nicely...
Reply
The Island of Dr. Moreau Questor Central

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 ... 20 21 22 23 [>] [>>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum