Welcome to Gaia! ::

Fire Emblem Forever

Back to Guilds

Together We Ride! 

Tags: Fire Emblem, Roleplay, Nintendo, Video Games, Anime 

Reply Plot, Character & Pairing Discussion Forum
Best/Worst in the Series-Round 60(Will be back Sunday) Goto Page: [] [<<] [<] 1 2 3 ... 28 29 30 31 32 33 ... 53 54 55 56 [>] [>>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Paranoia_favorate

5,400 Points
  • Bunny Spotter 50
  • Bunny Hunter 100
  • Bunny Hoarder 150
PostPosted: Mon May 09, 2011 4:54 pm


The Lolwut Pear
Changed my vote to Tron, nothing better than a badass cyberpunk spell that puts you in mind of some sort of badass robot. cool

But my vote for worst remains the same, everyone else gets normal personal weapons (Luke's Sword, Cecil's Sword, Ryan's Bow, etc) then.. Bord'n'cord' Axe. Come on, IS for one, my name isn't even capitalized, and for two, we are the only one with a stupid joke name of a personal weapon. D<

Also @ Lughnasadh: It's traditional Gaelic tongue (Lu-na-sad-ah).
I can agree with you on the Bord'n'Cord Axe. Though Lughnasadh will always be weird to me. though thanks for the pronunciation of that.
PostPosted: Fri May 13, 2011 1:58 pm


Gespenst is the ultimate Dark Tome. Wanna know what it translates to? Its German for "Ghost". So essentially, we're ghosting a person?

Luce is italian for light...just...


Even weirder is Armads, y'know, Hector's ultimate weapon? Turns out its named after a sword...weird...

Best: Ereshkigal. When you realize what this means, its the perfect fit for Nergal to use. Both Nergal and Ereshkigal were part of Mesopotamian mythology, and ruled over Irkalla as husband and wife respectively. Yes, this means that Nergal is using his wife to attack you. This is also a part of this mythology, as Nergal was said to have been an aggressive god (he was later used as the name for Mars in Babylon). This could possibly mean that he once had a wife, and he's using her spirit to attack people with.

Honorable mention: Nosferatu. It's derived from the word "Nosoforos" which means "Plague carrier". Fitting, isn't it, since it saps the life from enemies?

Worst: Reinfleche. At first, I thought it was a cool name...until I read what it meant. Reinfleche is literally "Nothing Arrow" in french. So...we're not shooting anything at anyone?

Dishonorable mention: Falchion. This is supposed to be a sacred sword. Because you can't find a falchion anywhere? A Falchion is literally a type of sword

Respectful Student

5,000 Points
  • Beta Explorer 0
  • Beta Gaian 0
  • Beta Contributor 0

xDemonhornzx

Fluffy Bear

22,650 Points
  • Battle Hardened 150
  • Beta Gaian 0
  • Perfect Attendance 400
PostPosted: Fri May 13, 2011 2:08 pm


Nice call on the Falchion. I just suddenly realized that it's a pretty lame name for a sacred blade...
PostPosted: Fri May 13, 2011 5:49 pm


Best: Durandal. Why you ask? Because it is the unbreakable sword of the primary protagonist in The Song of Roland which is an epic and gory medieval Frankish poem.

Worst:Ragnell. it has the word rag in it... 'nuff said.

Great General Wallace


Manic Martini

PostPosted: Fri May 13, 2011 10:55 pm


Great General Wallace
Best: Durandal. Why you ask? Because it is the unbreakable sword of the primary protagonist in The Song of Roland which is an epic and gory medieval Frankish poem.

Worst:Ragnell. it has the word rag in it... 'nuff said.


Irony of Durandal being unbreakable: Durandal only has 20 uses. Ragnell never breaks.
PostPosted: Fri May 13, 2011 11:26 pm


Manic Martini
Great General Wallace
Best: Durandal. Why you ask? Because it is the unbreakable sword of the primary protagonist in The Song of Roland which is an epic and gory medieval Frankish poem.

Worst:Ragnell. it has the word rag in it... 'nuff said.


Irony of Durandal being unbreakable: Durandal only has 20 uses. Ragnell never breaks.


I don't think he was talking about the actual in-game Durandal being unbreakable, rather the poem where the Durandal being unbreakable. Although it is indeed ironic that the Durandal is breakable. The fact still stands that he probably picked the Durandal in the context of the poem rather than the game itself. Then again, FE is known for their ironic twists of literature references (ie: Ishtar being a good, loyal lover, Ogma [as much as it pains me to spell his name without the U in it] definitely not being of high education a god of it alone, Kain being the red headed [assumed the more serious] Social Knight when he should be evil and downright twisted, Lachesis ending life rather than measuring it [xD], etc)

The Lolwut Pear

Mega Fatcat

12,650 Points
  • Invisibility 100
  • Megathread 100
  • Elocutionist 200

Manic Martini

PostPosted: Fri May 13, 2011 11:53 pm


The Lolwut Pear
Manic Martini
Great General Wallace
Best: Durandal. Why you ask? Because it is the unbreakable sword of the primary protagonist in The Song of Roland which is an epic and gory medieval Frankish poem.

Worst:Ragnell. it has the word rag in it... 'nuff said.


Irony of Durandal being unbreakable: Durandal only has 20 uses. Ragnell never breaks.


I don't think he was talking about the actual in-game Durandal being unbreakable, rather the poem where the Durandal being unbreakable.


Yeah. That's why it's ironic.
PostPosted: Sat May 14, 2011 9:58 am


Respectful Student
Worst: Reinfleche. At first, I thought it was a cool name...until I read what it meant. Reinfleche is literally "Nothing Arrow" in french. So...we're not shooting anything at anyone?


Fire Emblem Wiki
It appears as though the name of this weapon, comprised apparently of the French rien, "nothing", and fleche, "arrow", is a misrepresentation of Royalefleche, meaning "royal arrow", which would have been more in keeping with the names of the Regal Blade, Basilikos and Rex Hasta. Interestingly enough, it could also have rather easily meant to be called Roifleche, meaning "king arrow", or Reinefleche, meaning "queen arrow".

Nomad Rath
Vice Captain

Dedicated Guildsman


Marshmallow Kitty
Crew

Adorable Senshi

11,825 Points
  • Bunny Spotter 50
  • Elocutionist 200
  • Magical Girl 50
PostPosted: Sat May 14, 2011 4:47 pm


I still think Reinfleche sounds cool.

Best: Amiti. I DESTROY YOU WITH FRIENDSHIP Also because it is an unbreakable Brave Sword.

Worst: Falchion. As stated previously, a falchion is not a special kind of sword. It's like naming your sacred blade BROADSWORD or RAPIER or SHORT SWORD.
PostPosted: Sat May 14, 2011 5:18 pm


Respectful Student
Worst: I had a tough time with this one. Mainly because most prepromotes of note are really only useful in Hard Mode and tend to suck up experience if you get them too early (See: FE7 Marcus who only gets 3 exp from killing a brigand). I don't exactly hate most of the prepromotes, but I had a lot to consider when figuring out the worst one. I heard a lot about Zealot from FE6, but I haven't played that one and cannot really say anything for him. I considered Vaida from FE7, because she is heavily outclassed by Heath and most of the Pegasi.

Dishonorable mention to any of the Prepromoted Assassins...at least they can kill something (Silencer, however unreliable) and survive for a while in enemy terratory


This is from last round, but omg, when I read this, I spat out my drink. ......Uh. Have you SEEN Vaida? Go look again and tell me with a straight face that she is somehow heavily outclassed. People may say Heath is better and he may be, but she is a flying tank and nowhere close to being worst prepromote.

Also, dishonorable mention to prepromoted assassins? Really? :/

Carry on.

Nomad Rath
Vice Captain

Dedicated Guildsman


The Lolwut Pear

Mega Fatcat

12,650 Points
  • Invisibility 100
  • Megathread 100
  • Elocutionist 200
PostPosted: Sat May 14, 2011 5:47 pm


If we're aloud to late ragerant then I call upon my Raddy rant, which is REALLY REALLY late, but it bugged me how people hate him.

To those who said Raddy is the worst Swordfighter, uhh... so having 10% more STR and DEF growth than Nabarl is a bad thing now? :/ Unless I'm going crazy, Swordfighters usually need STR and DEF like there's no tomorrow, and Raddy has it, Nabarl doesn't. Also, his base stats are one level lower than Nabarl's, BUT Nabarl starts at Lv. 3, Raddy starts at Lv. 1, so in theory two levels later, Raddy will already surpass Nabarl's bases. Concerned about his LCK? He's a Swordfighter, he'll naturally get anyway upon promotion into a Swordmaster. So all and all, the only thing Nabarl has is a C rank in swords, five chapter head start (which you can easily bench him and give his kills to a more deserving character like Doga who has the tendecy to fall behind, so he'll probably need as much early EXP as possible and save Nabarl's Kill Sword for a more appropriate part in the game.) and I guess an ascetics advantage (if you're into pansy long haired wusses), but other than that Raddy has a bright future compared to Nabarl who without powerful sword favouring on his behalf, all he'll be doing is tickling the enemies later on.

Then again, reclassing Est into a Swordfighter pretty much makes everything null as she'll nuke the map here and back.
PostPosted: Sat May 14, 2011 7:23 pm


....Well, the post I was quoting directly was only on the last page, and the first time I saw it, soooo....

Nomad Rath
Vice Captain

Dedicated Guildsman


Chaotic Houndoom

PostPosted: Sat May 14, 2011 9:35 pm


Just don't drag arguments out for too long ok?
PostPosted: Sun May 15, 2011 5:08 pm


Wait, are we bringing up every grievance we have with people’s choices now? I have SO much to say, from Eirika not being the worst Lord UNIT even if she has such a terrible character, to Nolan not winning best Fighter and one person going so far as to say he’s terrible (I’d write off him not getting it to not enough people playing FE10, but saying he sucks is just so wrong on so many levels), to Rebecca beating FE10 Shinon for Best Archer, to numerous specific posts that make me either facepalm or doubletake or cause some other sort of reaction of surprise or shock.

But if I were to address everything, I’d never be done, and it would be rather pointless, so I’ll just pick up on Rath’s and Maji’s posts! ;D

@Rath: Totally agree. I’d almost PREFER Vaida to Heath since he has as awkward joining time and Vaida doesn’t require a promotion item. Besides, being ‘outclassed’ doesn’t make you bad. Oujay is ‘outclassed’ by Dieck, but he’s still great. Erk is basically ‘outclassed’ by Pent, but he’s still a good Mage. Heck, picking Isadora as worst because she’s outclassed by every other Pally doesn’t make her the worst prepromote. Shouldn’t you be looking at the prepromotes against each other as prepromotes, rather than everyone against the other units of that class? But I digress.

@Maji: Some of the comments made about Radd were ignorant, I completely agree. And he’s certainly not the worst in the series. But your argument in favor of him is pretty biased and unfair to Navarre, too.

Navarre comes five chapters sooner than Radd. This can only be a good thing for Navarre and only be comparatively worse for Radd. Navarre having a C Rank (instant Might boost says hi) is something he has over Radd’s D Rank and always will (especially coupled with his five chapter lead in availability – quicker access to B and A ranks means quicker access to even better Might boosts). Additionally, looking at the averages, Radd will not have surpassed Navarre’s bases with two level ups. He’ll be a bit lucky to simply be HITTING them. He theoretically could surpass them, but he could also theoretically still be below them, so the chance that he might have them higher seems like a poor reason to promote his use. And 10% difference is not that enormous a different. Certainly not enough to say Navarre will be s**t later on and Radd will be kicking a**.

Don’t let Navarre touch a single enemy just for the sake of comparison? That’s going out of your way to tilt things in Radd’s favor because in reality, there’s plenty against him. If you plan on using Radd and not using Navarre, that makes sense, but if you plan on using Navarre you’re GOING to be using him for those chapters he’s there before Radd shows up. And he’ll only be getting better during that time, increasing the distance between him and Radd. Don’t use Navarre because you want to feed someone else like Draug? If you’re not using Navarre and are using Draug, okay. Otherwise, that’s not going to be the case. If someone plans on using Navarre, they’re going to use him, and when you’re comparing him against another character, it’s expected that you’ll compare him being used instead of doing absolutely nothing. So if Navarre is being compared to Radd, Navarre shouldn’t be neglected just to make Radd look better. Oh, and in comparing Radd and Navarre, because of Navarre’s level lead and availability lead, it’ll be a lot later in the game when Radd finally manages to catch up with a leveling Navarre and then actually surpass him. Meanwhile, Navarre is presumably yielding better results for at least the better portion of the game. Of course, if Navarre is 'tickling' enemies during the catch up game, that means Radd is, too, if not doing worse.

Radd is definitely not the worst in the series, but trashing Navarre isn't the reason why.

Of course, if you’re using Est in the first place, I guess availability means s**t and it’s just a ‘who has the biggest growths-p***s’ competition

Manic Martini


Chaotic Houndoom

PostPosted: Sun May 15, 2011 5:21 pm


Well you know whats up next topic is the best/worst Est Archtype

Serenes Forest
Ests include Est from FE1 and 11, Corpul from FE4, Sara from FE5, Sophia and Zeiss from FE6, Nino from FE7, Ewan and Amelia from FE8, Tormod from FE9, and Pelleas from FE10.


Damn it FD you spoiled it!
Reply
Plot, Character & Pairing Discussion Forum

Goto Page: [] [<<] [<] 1 2 3 ... 28 29 30 31 32 33 ... 53 54 55 56 [>] [>>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum