Welcome to Gaia! ::

I honestly don't believe in either one of the polls. To me, harry potter is a good story, about good kids helping each other out. But, that's me. And i know where i stand with God and being a christian. I know my boundries like any other person. This, i do not believe is a bad thing for my relationship with Jesus. However, they aren't just unharmfull children's stories either. They could be very harmfull, to some kids. I think it's great for some parents not to let their kids watch harry potter. Because it is witchcraft, and it is very clear in the bible that witchcraft is wrong. But if you know that it is wrong, and do not allow the potentually harmfull stuff to get into your system, and start believing in this, i think it is alright. Call me evil, but i don't look at the witchcraft, i just look at the cute lessons(and that cute ron! wink ) and see a good story line. I have felt no guilt by God in watching them. But, i did think that the 3rd harry potter movie was really dark, and do not like it very much at all. But i do like the 1st and 2nd. And, to be perfectly honest, i am going to see the 4th. I love the books, too. Lots of people will disagree but, as i said before, it's not an issue to me. I will probably not let my children watch harry potter, until they are older, and can realize that witchcraft is wrong, but that doesn't mean the movie has to be "evil".

Its been that way for quite sometime. Even before our time. But this is how life is. I see several movies, what makes them good to me is probably story. Im not for or against harry potter, but like everyone I know its bad too some good to others. This agrument will never end, and I see no point too it. Why are christians agruing amognst themselves for some non sense that man creates and not focus on the glory of God.

i dont like the new pope but harry potter has a lot of devilish things in it!!!

What you're saying is kind of like if God gave you the power to heal people and when that person said "how'd you do that?" you just say "I'm amazing" or something like that, that doesn't glorify God. If God gives you the ability to shoot fireballs, cool, but use it to glorify God, not for a selfish reason.

If you ask me, I think there is too much fuss made on the subject.

I have just finshed reading the sixth HP this morning, and overall it was really good.

But that is not the point.

HP shows a story of good over evil, that kindness, love and friendship conquer over hatred, greed, murder, and fear.

I think the church is taking the magic aspect of HP to much to heart, instead of focusing on its message, which is not "BE A WITCH" or "FOLLOW THE DEVIL" but that good takes over evil anytime.

All my friends love the HP books, and none of them have ever said to me:

"The books are cool. I want to be a witch/wizard now."

I am a devout christan, don't get me wrong. To me, the HP storyline just shows the battle of Hell and Heaven but just in a different way. biggrin

God has not commanded us to stay away from divination, only divination that uses some power other than him (or humans with the spiritual gift of prophecy) to tell the future/past/present.

I must say, at the time a prophecy is said, how would one be able to tell it's a prophecy, and not of a divinatory nature?

Whoa there. Reality check, people. Harry Potter is a work of fiction whose sole purpose is to tell a story. It is not advocating witchcraft; it is simply laying forth an entertaining plot. If you wish to follow the sort of logic that demonizes any piece of fiction that doesn't conform exactly to biblical proscriptions then you wind up saying that it's bad for Christians to read Faust because the plot revolves around a man making a deal with the Devil. If you can't read a book that depicts witchcraft, then you definitely shouldn't read a book about a man making deals with Satan. Likewise you would have to say that Christians shouldn't read The Grapes of Wrath because some of the things that the character Jim Casy says in that book are far more subversive to the Christian faith than anything contained in Harry Potter. A Connecticut Yankee In King Arthur's Court by Mark Twain is openly disparaging of the Christian faith and probably shouldn't be read either. Kurt Vonnegut's Slaughterhouse-Five shouldn't be read by Christians either by your logic, nor should Hemmingway's A Farewell to Arms because it includes a character saying "All thinking men are atheists." Catch-22 should be avoided by Christians at all costs, they shouldn't read anything written by Baruch Spinoza, nor Shakespeare's MacBeth (and probably a lot of other Shakespearian plays), nor The Iliad and the Odyssey because they contain pagan rituals.

In fact, why not just throw out all literature other than the bible, just to avoid even the possibility of reading non-Christian thoughts? C'mon. God didn't make you stupid so don't act like you are. Reading about people using magic may make a small child go "Ooh neat!" and spend a little time in the backyard waving a stick around pretending to cast spells but that's it. This stuff is supposed to be fun. If God had wanted a race of people that did nothing by praise him and contemplate his dictates then he would have made robots instead of men. You're supposed to use at least some portion of your life to enjoy yourselves. Harry Potter won't turn you from God anymore than Faust will and if your faith is so weak that it would turn you to witchcraft then maybe you should ask yourself whether or not you're actually a Christian.