|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 4:15 am
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 4:17 am
Crystal Silhouette:
"Crystal Rose" Judge "G" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Crystal Silhouette _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? No --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) Yes Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section? Yes --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yes Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? Yes --Is there any multimedia? No --If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/A Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? Yes everything matches --Does everything "flow" together? No _____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? The comment, friends and quilt area seem out of place and really takes away from the overall look of the layout. What is the best feature of this profile? The detail put into the header and area surrounding the user information On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile? 8 _____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Since the friends list is hidden remove that section altogether and since there is a lot of space left at the bottom move the quit section there. Judge "I" ~Judge I critiquing Layout Entry #2~ ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Crystal Rose_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?Nope.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)No, this one's nice and originalPlease look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes, I find if cool how she gave the layout a slight "crystaline" look to it to match her username. 3nodding --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?She said she's a dreamer and this layout has a certain 'dreamy' effect to it. Please look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?her avatar is NEXT to the details, not above them...--Is there any multimedia?no--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?N/APlease look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)Yes, there is variation, but unfortunatly, the techniques aren't compatible in Firefox, and can only be viewed in IEPlease look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?yes--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?Everything matches!--Does everything "flow" together?for the most part, but the main background seems a little out of sync. the rest of the layout has a sort of airy atmosphere to it, but the background is a little too pointed and symetrical and takes away from the light and airy effect a bit._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?that background needs to be softer... and I don't like how there's this gap at the bottom of the text in the about section to the bottom of the module... too much white space when you get down that far...What is the best feature of this profile?The header picture and detailsOn a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?8_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?It isn't user friendly, it only works properly in IE... Judge "E" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Crystal Silhouette "Crystal Rose" _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? No never --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) It's a blue rose, and no I haven't Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section? Oh yes, all sections have been personalized --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? I do, it's very serene and calm Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? yes, placement and color --Is there any multimedia? No, nor do I feel it's needed --If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? n/a Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Sizing, hidden items and link hover Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? Everything matches beautifully --Does everything "flow" together? Yes _____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? Hmm, probably the lower background, I'd put flowers instead of the 'bubbles'? What is the best feature of this profile? The details section, the placement and background really make it pop up On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile? 10 _____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Put titles on the sections ^^; Judge "H" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Crystal Rose_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?No.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)No.Please look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes.--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?YesPlease look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?Yes.--Is there any multimedia?No.--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?Please look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)Yes.Please look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?Yes.--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?Everything Matches--Does everything "flow" together?Yes._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?I would try to make it more compatible with firefox.What is the best feature of this profile?The HeaderOn a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?8_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?syntax for borders is
border: 'type' 'size' #'color' Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Crystal Silhouette, "Crystal Rose"_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? No.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) No.Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes, like the images in the header. All the sections are personalized.--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yes.Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?Yes, like the way the links react when the cursor hovers over them.--Is there any multimedia? No.--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/APlease look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes. See above about the links.Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes.--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? Everything matches.--Does everything "flow" together? Yes._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? I's add something to the massive white space at the bottom. Also, the font in the details section is a bit small and difficult to read because of the color.What is the best feature of this profile? The color scheme.On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?8.5_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? AVERAGE RATING 8.50
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 4:19 am
PrincessNeko:
"Legend" Judge "G" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: PrincessNeko _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? No --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) Yes Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section? Yes --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yes Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? Yes --Is there any multimedia? No --If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/A Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? Yes everything matches --Does everything "flow" together? Yes _____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? There's nothing I would change about this layout What is the best feature of this profile? The bg image of sailormoon is very pretty and the main bg is nicely done On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile? 9 _____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Change the main scroll bar to match the one in the comment section. Judge "E" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: PrincessNeko "Legend"
_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? No --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) I can't say that I have Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section? Yes, the 'online/offline' bar has been costumized --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yes, it's very well put together Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? Background, placement --Is there any multimedia? No --If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? n/a Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes, roll overs and scrollbars Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? The black background I feel clashes a bit --Does everything "flow" together? Mostly yes _____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? I'd have faded the main image into the background, not use a border What is the best feature of this profile? The rollover bar On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile? 9.5 _____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Again titles on the sections ^^; Judge "I" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:"Legend" by PrincessNeko_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?nope.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)well, save the fact that's it's anime, no.Please look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?yes, I like the toolbar buttons (such as pm me, add to friends, etc...)--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?kinda... again, it's hard to answer this type of question when I know nothing about the contestant.Please look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?those toolbar buttons, and the titles--Is there any multimedia?nope--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?N/APlease look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)yes, there's plenty of that...Please look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?yes. 3nodding --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?yup! it matches fine!--Does everything "flow" together? 3nodding _____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?I don't like how the left column isn't all that aligned, and that background to the right would prolly look better if it went around the entire profile, like a border.What is the best feature of this profile?I REALLY like that toolbar... you hover over it and the lil pics show up! mrgreen On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?7_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?I think I already spoke my mind, so no, nothing further... Judge "H" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Legend_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?No--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)Ive only one other sailor moon profilePlease look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?YesPlease look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?Yes--Is there any multimedia?No--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?Please look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)YesPlease look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?Yes--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?Matches Well--Does everything "flow" together?Yes_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?Theres nothing I don't really likeWhat is the best feature of this profile?Its all very goodOn a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?9_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: "Legend," PrincessNeko_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? No.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) Nope.Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes.--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yes. Apparently, Sailor Moon meant a lot to her.Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?I like the translucent sections and the icons for PM/friends/etc.--Is there any multimedia? No.--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/APlease look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes, there are plenty of codes to create special affects.Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes.--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? The tan color with the "parchment" type look and the fans off to the right matches, but then it doesn't. Maybe it draws attention away from the lovely picture in the center...?--Does everything "flow" together? Yes._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? I might add a little something subtle to match the blue in Moon's eyes. Perhaps center the profile and make the "fans-on-parchment" the border or change it to something else completely. I might do something about the negative space at the bottom. Maybe the sections could use some labels...What is the best feature of this profile? The picture is lovely and I like the icons. The pink text for the links is almost to difficult to read, but then again, it's as if it's the perfect color to match the picture. I also like the translucent sections and the positioning.On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?8.8_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? AVERAGE RATING 8.66
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 4:22 am
Empyreal Entity:
"Reves Celestes" Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Empyreal Entity, "Reves Celestes"]_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? No.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) No.Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes, all the sections contain personal touches.--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Definitely. The username and the style of the profile go hand-in-hand.Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?Yes. For example, the titles for each section are in French (?).--Is there any multimedia? No.--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/A.Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes. There is obviously a plethora of codes in use.Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes.--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? Everything matches.--Does everything "flow" together? Yes._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? Apparently this is becoming my pet peeve, but: there seems to be too much empty space on the right. It makes the profile uneven near the bottom in contrast with the top and mid-section.What is the best feature of this profile? The colors are rich and dreamy and different. The avatar art does a great job of setting the stage for the color scheme. The icons are nice as well.On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?8.9_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Judge "H" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Reves Celestes_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?Yes.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)No.Please look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?YesPlease look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?Yes--Is there any multimedia?No--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?Please look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)YesPlease look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?Yes--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?Matchs Well--Does everything "flow" together?Yes_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?Its pretty plainWhat is the best feature of this profile?The Avatar artOn a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?8_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Judge "I" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:"Reves Celestes" by Empyreal Entity_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?yes, I have seen this type once before...--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)no, that's quite impossible with her avi being the main theme! mad dPlease look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?well, the whole idea of it being about her avi is a MAJOR personal touch--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?yes, definitly, or at least her avi's personality! mad dPlease look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?yes, I like how the background is obviously custom made...--Is there any multimedia?no--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?n/aPlease look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)only the hidden avatar... which was replaced by ADORABLE avi art! whee Please look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?yes, very neat and orgnaized, not overdone!--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?everything matches! 4laugh --Does everything "flow" together?yup... love the stars that are throughout it_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?no, it's fine the way it is!What is the best feature of this profile?the avi art that just adds the 'welcoming' air about it... and cuteness... whee On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?10_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?nope! mrgreen Judge "E" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Empyreal Entity "Reves Celestes"
_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? Not many, I've seen a few --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) Nope Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section? Online/offline bar is costumized, as well as the speech bubble --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? I think so, it's very spunky Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? The use of avie art --Is there any multimedia? No --If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? n/a Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Hidden avatar/items Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? It matches --Does everything "flow" together? Yes _____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? Make the name of the user bigger What is the best feature of this profile? The avie art On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile? 9 _____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? No Judge "G" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Empyreal Entity _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? Yes --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) No Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section? Yes --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yes Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? Yes --Is there any multimedia? No --If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/A Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? everything matches --Does everything "flow" together? Yes _____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? I wouldn't change a thing What is the best feature of this profile? color scheme On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile? 9 _____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? No AVERAGE RATING 8.98
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 4:26 am
dawn_99:
"Rainbow Death" Judge "E" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: dawn_99 "Rainbow Death"
_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? Yes, can't say that often though--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) Not sure about the theme on this one, rainbow colors? sweatdrop Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?The header --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? I'd say soPlease look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?The titles of the sections --Is there any multimedia? Yes--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? Not at allPlease look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Just placement (centered) and switched from left to right Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Mostly yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? It does clash, the background is just too powerful, there's too many colors going on--Does everything "flow" together? No_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? The background is busy, maybe make it lighter What is the best feature of this profile? The friends section On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?7_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?No Judge "G" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: dawn_99 _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? Yes --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) No Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section? Yes --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yes Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? Yes --Is there any multimedia? Yes --If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? Yes Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? Some sections do clash with the layout --Does everything "flow" together? Yes _____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? The bg used in the friends section doesn't match the rest of the layout. The quote box overlaps the status bar, the status bar is unfinished and the header doesn't fit the theme of the layout. What is the best feature of this profile? The rainbow bg On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile? 7.5 _____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Fix the quote box so it's not over lapping and finish the status bar Judge "H" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Rainbow Death_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?Yes.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)No.Please look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?YesPlease look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?Yes--Is there any multimedia?Yes--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?Not ReallyPlease look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)YesPlease look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?Yes--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?Matches well--Does everything "flow" together?Yes_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?The Multimedia starting on its own, and the opacity on the about sectionWhat is the best feature of this profile?On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?8_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Judge "I" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:"Rainbow Death" by dawn_99_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?yeah, I've seen it a few times before--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)yes, the rainbow theme I've seen a few times before...Please look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?the banner perhaps--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?well, if you consider them a 'colorful person'...Please look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?not really...--Is there any multimedia?yes.--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?no... but it is kinda cute...Please look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)yes, some.Please look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?it's put together okay, but it could be better--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?well, it's all rainbowy...--Does everything "flow" together?kinda... not as well as it could though..._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?the font is way too light and hard to read, and I think the whole thing is just a bit overkill...What is the best feature of this profile?I'm not sure...On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?2_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?it needs to flow better, and tone it down a lil bit... though I'll certainly say it lives up to it's name, RAINBOW DEATH! Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: "Rainbow Death," dawn_99_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? Yes.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) No.Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes, the profile seems very personalized.--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Sure.Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?Yes, like the visitor counter.--Is there any multimedia? Yes.--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? Um...I'd have to say "no." It seems to have nothing to do with the profile.Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes, there's plenty of code in use to make non-standard effects.Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Can't go wrong with the standard layout; this layout looks like the standard one, just flipped horizontally.--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? It's seems like this theme is more "crazy randomness" than "ranbow death." Since the current title IS "Rainbow Death," yes, there are a lot of things that clash with that, including the background for the friends, and the black & white icons, and even the main header, featuring an anime girl and some Gaia pictures.--Does everything "flow" together? Not really._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? I would try arranging the layout so that it's unique, maybe make one consistant theme for the whole profile, and try to put in things that match that theme rather than throwing in just anything. I don't like the microscopic text in the about section. Also, I don't think the wishlist needed a scrollbar.What is the best feature of this profile? The background to the left and right extremities of the profile, since they actually pertain to "rainbows."On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?5.5_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? AVERAGE RATING 6.00
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 4:27 am
Luzipher:
"Demona" Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Luzipher, "Demona"_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? Yes.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) No.Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?...Yes, kind of.--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? I suppose it might.Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?Not really.--Is there any multimedia? No.--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/APlease look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes, there is code that produces a few non-standard effects.Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? No.--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? Nothing really matches. The different shades of red clash, the different types of seemingly unrelated pictures clash with each other...--Does everything "flow" together? No._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? It looks like a decent first try, but I would definitely encourage the contestant to give it another shot, playing with the code a bit, making the layout original, trying to find and stick with one theme and color scheme.What is the best feature of this profile? The background image behind the commenters.On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?3_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Judge "H" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Demona_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?Yes--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)NoPlease look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?YesPlease look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?No--Is there any multimedia?No--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?Please look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)NoPlease look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?No--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?Matches Well--Does everything "flow" together?No_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?Not as many pictures and no repeating of the backgroundWhat is the best feature of this profile?On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?6_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Judge "I" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:"Demona" by Luzipher_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?llots... it's the standard.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)kinda... not this specific character, but similar things....Please look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?not really--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?yeah I guess....Please look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?no--Is there any multimedia?no--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?n/aPlease look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)noPlease look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?no--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?it matches ok...--Does everything "flow" together?no. it's way too choppy._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?everything.What is the best feature of this profile?none that I can think ofOn a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?0_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?it looks like it was just thrown together, and this may be because the contestant is new to css coding... keep working at it, you'll get better! Judge "E" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Luzipher "Demona"
_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? Oh yeah--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) NoPlease look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes, the same image over and over again sweatdrop --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? SurePlease look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? The use of the Bucho avatar xd --Is there any multimedia? No--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? n/aPlease look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) color rollover, and glow, custom cursorPlease look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Not really --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? There's tons of things that clash, the backround, all the images he/she cramped into the about section--Does everything "flow" together? No_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? The background is too busy and it takes a while to loadWhat is the best feature of this profile? The comments section On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?6_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?Get rid of the header, serves no purpose. Judge "G" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Luzipher _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? Yes --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) No Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section? Yes --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yes Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? Yes --Is there any multimedia? No --If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/A Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? No --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? The header clashes with the rest of the layout --Does everything "flow" together? No _____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? Take out some of the images in the "About Me" section because it stretches the layout and makes the bg image repeat. Fix the bg comment images since they overlap eachother a little bit. What is the best feature of this profile? The bg image used for the about me section. On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile? 6 _____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Remove the grey bar going down the right side of the profile, remove the boarder around the footer and either change the color of the links in the footer or remove them. AVERAGE RATING 4.20
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 4:29 am
x[broken_heart]x:
"Colorfully Broken Heart" Judge "H" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Colorfully Broken Heart_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?No--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)NoPlease look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?YesPlease look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?No--Is there any multimedia?Yes--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?NoPlease look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)YesPlease look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?Yes--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?Matches pretty well--Does everything "flow" together?No_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?Comment section and i would either remove or just move the footer.What is the best feature of this profile?On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?8_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Judge "G" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: x[broken_heart]x _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? No --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) Yes Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section? Yes --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yes Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? Yes --Is there any multimedia? Yes --If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? No Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? everything matches --Does everything "flow" together? Yes _____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? The comments section is stretched out to far and once you play the multimedia it doesn't end and plays in a continuous loop What is the best feature of this profile? The bg used in the About section On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile? 6.5 _____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Finxed the comments section and if possible remove the white line on the left side on the comments. Judge "E" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: x[broken_heart]x "Colorfully Broken Heart"
_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? No--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) NopePlease look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?I'd say so, squigly lines, etc--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yeah, artsyPlease look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? The use of color and placement--Is there any multimedia? Yes--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? NopePlease look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Placement, link hoverPlease look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? The red links are had to read over the red background sections--Does everything "flow" together? Mostly yes_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? Not use the same colors from the background for the textWhat is the best feature of this profile? The about section On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?8_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? No Judge "I" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:"Colorfully Broken Heart" by x[broken_heart]x_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?kinda... it starts out like a regular layout, then the bottom modules are deleted, and it has an extended comment section--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)surprisingly no... neutral Please look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?yeah.--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?this question is so hard to answer! I don't know what the contestant's personality is!Please look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?the crayon drawings in the background--Is there any multimedia?yes.--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?no mad d it's about llamas... very amusing! mad dPlease look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)a lil.Please look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?yes, pretty good.--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?yeah, it matches alright.--Does everything "flow" together?for the most part_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?those odd corners of the comment boxes...What is the best feature of this profile?those backgrounds...On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?2_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?it needs a little more to it.. it's kind of scant... Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: "Colorfully Broken Heart," x[broken_heart]x_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? No, but all in all, what has been changed isn't very creative, except for the comments section.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) No.Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes, the art in the header.--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Perhaps, but there isn't a constant theme.Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?The art behind the top portion of the profile.--Is there any multimedia? Yes.--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? No...the "llama song" doesn't have much to do with a broken heart theme.Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) It looks like some experimenting with codes has been done, but no truly original effects have been created, aside from what appears to have been attempted in the comments section.Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? No.--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? There isn't really much to the theme, so that's difficult to determine.--Does everything "flow" together? No._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? It looks like a work-in-progress to me. I'd finish it, while tinkering with the codes to try to achieve more original effects to go with whatever theme is decided upon.What is the best feature of this profile? The multimedia doesn't start on it's own. The header is a good start for what the theme is supposed to be.On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?4.5_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? AVERAGE RATING 5.80
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 4:30 am
Elixate:
"Dream On" Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: "Dream On," Elixate_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? I believe I've seen it a few times now.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) ...What theme...? sweatdrop (There doesn't really seem to be a theme, so I guess I'll have to say "no."Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes, such as the itty bitty headers.--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? It may, but it's difficult to tell.Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?The absence of boxes, aside from the quote.--Is there any multimedia? No.--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/APlease look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes, like the link hover and invisible lines/boxes.Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes.--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? Everything in the profile matches...--Does everything "flow" together? Again, it all matches, I suppose._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? It's very...empty. The header is exciting and interesting and colorful and the rest of the profile is...not. It might just be me, but I can hardly read the text in the headers for each section. I would try to incorporate some of the "dreamy" pastels from the header into the rest of the profile somehow.What is the best feature of this profile? The header.On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?7.5_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Judge "H" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Dream On_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?Not really--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)NoPlease look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?YesPlease look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?Yes--Is there any multimedia?No--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?Please look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)YesPlease look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?Yes--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?Matches Well--Does everything "flow" together?Yes_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?I would make the comment section bigger.What is the best feature of this profile?On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?8_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Judge "I" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:"Dream On" by Elixate_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?no, I haven't.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)nope! mrgreen Please look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?avi art! --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?prolly...Please look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?avi art, and I've never seen that type of header before...--Is there any multimedia?no--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?N/APlease look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)yeahPlease look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?yup!--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?it matches!--Does everything "flow" together?yep._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?it's not aligned well in firefox browserWhat is the best feature of this profile?the header.On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?7_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?it's a tad scant, maybe tint the backgrounds a bit... Judge "E" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Elixate "Dream On"
_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? Nope--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) NoPlease look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section? Yes, the header has avie art --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yes stylishPlease look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? The use of placement--Is there any multimedia? No--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/aPlease look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Placement, sizingPlease look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? It matches--Does everything "flow" together? Yes_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? Too much white space sweatdrop What is the best feature of this profile? Header On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?8.5_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? No Judge "G" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Elixate _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? Yes --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) No Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section? Yes --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yes Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? Yes --Is there any multimedia? No --If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/A Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? everything matches --Does everything "flow" together? Yes _____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? That the quote box is overlapped by the about me bar and the link to view post. Also that the status bar is broken into 2 parts. What is the best feature of this profile? The header On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile? 8 _____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?
Fix the status bar or add a custom one and either move or remove the quote box. AVERAGE RATING 7.8
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 4:32 am
sugoii:
"Baby Gaara" Judge "G" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: sugoii _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? Yes --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) Yes Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section? Yes --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yes Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? No --Is there any multimedia? No --If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/A Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? everything matches --Does everything "flow" together? Yes _____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? The gray bar on the right side and the light blue font in the comment section What is the best feature of this profile? The dividers used in the about section On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile? 6 _____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? My only concern is that this is a fairly simple layout, that the gray bar going down the side wasn't removed and that the status bar wasn't changed to match the layout. Judge "E" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: sugoii "Baby Gaara"
_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? Yes, standard--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) I've seen a couple of Gaara profilesPlease look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Banner --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Not reallyPlease look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? The titles? --Is there any multimedia? No--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/aPlease look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) NopePlease look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? It matches--Does everything "flow" together? Yes_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? Too standard for this competitionWhat is the best feature of this profile? Nothing really stands out On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?7.5_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? No Judge "I" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:"Baby Gaara" by sugoii_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?yes, it's very similar to the 'blocks' setup gaia has.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)nopePlease look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?yes, like the banner at the top and the chi icon in the about section.--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?from what I can tell, not really, but at least she like's naruto, I guess?Please look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?yes, I love the thought bubbles that are used for the comment boxes! whee --Is there any multimedia?no--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?N/APlease look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)yes, and just enough too! whee Please look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?yes.--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? 3nodding --Does everything "flow" together?yep._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?The header picture gets monotonous... I see the same pic of gara everywhere I look! gonk What is the best feature of this profile?the fact that it's not overdone.On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?4_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?It needs a little more variotion, but kudos on not overloading it with stuff! mrgreen Judge "H" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Baby Gaara_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?Yes--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)NoPlease look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?YesPlease look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?No--Is there any multimedia?No--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?Please look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)YesPlease look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?Yes--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?Matches Well--Does everything "flow" together?Yes_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?Nothing it all goes well togetherWhat is the best feature of this profile?On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?8_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: sugoii, "Baby Gaara"_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? Yes.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) Nope.Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Yes, like the headers.--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? It's difficult to tell.Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?Not really.--Is there any multimedia? No.--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/APlease look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) There are a few codes being used to alter the profile from the standard code.Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? It's very neat.--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? Everything matches.--Does everything "flow" together? Yes._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? It's a bit boring. I would add some variety to the section headers, maybe add some images behind the commenters and friends, play with the layout a bit...What is the best feature of this profile? Everything matches.On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?5_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? AVERAGE RATING 6.10
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 4:33 am
Elindranyth:
"Simple Beauty" Judge "G" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Elindranyth _____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? No --Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) Yes Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section? Yes --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Yes Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? Yes --Is there any multimedia? No --If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/A Please look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? Yes --Does everything "flow" together? Yes _____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? there's nothing I would change What is the best feature of this profile? The coustom status bar On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile? 9 _____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? My only concern is when the gaia bar is down it completely crashes the layout. Judge "E" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: Elindranyth "Simple Beauty"
_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? No--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) NoPlease look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?Everything, the titles, the online/offline bar, placement --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? YesPlease look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative? Placement and background --Is there any multimedia? No--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/aPlease look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Hidden items, sizing, scrollbars Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes --Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? It matches--Does everything "flow" together? Yes_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? Get rid of the sidescrollingWhat is the best feature of this profile? Placement On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?10_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? No Judge "I" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:"Simple Beauty" by Elindranyth_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?nope!--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)no, it's unique to her avi.Please look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?yes! whee --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?kinda... again, I'm not such a good judge of this since I do not know the person...Please look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?it's very simplistic, but but the fact that it's all contained in the middle of the page like that is very creative in my opinion...--Is there any multimedia?no--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?N/APlease look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)not much of that, but I think there should be special note to the whole 'center box in the page' thing...Please look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?yes, very organized--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?yes--Does everything "flow" together?yes_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?it's a little TOO simplistic, it needs a bit more flavor to it...What is the best feature of this profile?the middle of the page box, I'd say...On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?7_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions?too simplistic, even just adding a different shade of green as a hover color to the links would make it look better... Judge "H" ["THE BALLOT"]"Entry Title" or Contestant Name:Simple Beauty_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before?No--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme)NoPlease look at uniqueness:--Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality?YesPlease look at creativity:--Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?Yes--Is there any multimedia?No--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile?Please look at technique:--Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.)NoPlease look at structure:--Is the profile put together well, overall?Yes--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme?Matches Well--Does everything "flow" together?Yes_____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like?NothingWhat is the best feature of this profile?The avatar artOn a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?9_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? Judge "C" ["THE BALLOT"] "Entry Title" or Contestant Name: "Simple Beauty," Elindranyth_____________________________________________________________ Please look at originality: --Have you seen this type of layout many times before? No.--Have you seen the theme many times before? (Example: "purple" theme or "Kiki" theme) No.Please look at uniqueness: --Has the contestant added personal touches to any section?The whole profile is pretty much one big personal touch.--Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? Definitely.Please look at creativity: --Are there little details that you notice that make the profile more creative?Yes, like the boxes around the friends.--Is there any multimedia? No.--If so, is it unique to the specific theme of the profile? N/APlease look at technique: --Does the contestant use different codes to achieve "special" effects? (Such as hidden avatar, hidden items, scrollbars, link hover, custom cursor, sizing, etc.) Yes! There's tons of code here and many non-ordinary effects.Please look at structure: --Is the profile put together well, overall? Yes, very.--Does everything match, or are there things that clash with the overall theme? Everything matches.--Does everything "flow" together? Yes._____________________________________________________________ What would you change about the layout or theme? Anything you don't like? I know the point is for it to be simple, but it's almost to the point of boring. The colors are very plain and the text is standard black. Granted, this also makes it easy to view, but I think I might add something to the actual profile that matches the wonderful art in the background.What is the best feature of this profile? The art & the fact that it's totally legible.On a scale of 1-10 (with 10 being the best and 1 being the worst) what would your rate be for this profile?9_____________________________________________________________ Any other questions, concerns or suggestions? AVERAGE RATING 8.80
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 4:34 am
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Wed Mar 15, 2006 4:35 am
[ xd Damn...exactly 2 hours later...I'm done~! xp At least I got other stuff done while I was posting ballots, so it didn't take me exactly 2 hours just to do that. sweatdrop ]
Some things I've learned just from the ballots this round:
I suppose I need to say that I don't expect our judges to give our contestants a rating any higher than 10 or any lower than 1; even though I know it's probably just going to be for emphasis, it's just not needed.
I think the following question wasn't a very good addition to the ballot: Quote: --Do you think the theme showcases the contestant's unique personality? [I'm not sure how I expected that to be answered. xp Of course the judges aren't friends with or even aquainted with some of the contestants, so that question would be fairly difficult to answer. I think what I meant to do was just inquire as to how well everything seemed to relate to the implied main theme. For example, if the main theme seems to be cherry blossoms, is everything related to that?
Perhaps I'll ask the question like that next time. razz ]
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Mon Mar 27, 2006 9:34 pm
Hmm...I always thought that it meant something along the lines of...did the profile have character?
There are definitely some profiles that don't show any of the user's personality. Then there are those which show them even though the user's personality may not be known beforehand through expressing either a talent for drawing, sharing likes and dislikes...that sort of thing...
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 5:32 pm
Maybe that's what I initially meant, lol. xd But I'm glad it was understandable to someone else but me. 3nodding Okie! Time to post ballots for R4!!!
(Winners will be announced shortly thereafter...hopefully. xp )
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu Mar 30, 2006 5:34 pm
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Reply
