Welcome to Gaia! ::

zOMG! Chatterbox

Back to Guilds

Do you like zOMG? Do you like to chat? Then click here. It will be the best decision you make. Ever. EVER!!11oneoneone 

Tags: zOMG, Chatterbox, Landshark, Marshall, Animated 

Reply Serious Discussion
Abortion: for or against? Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Shiori Miko

PostPosted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 2:38 pm


Escther
Shiori Miko
Escther
After all, it's the woman's responsibility to take birth control

There's also things such as the male condom, rape, the new male birth control pill, the pull out method which is mostly considered a man thing. You get the idea.

Quote:
If she ends up pregnant, it'd be her fault, as she wasn't cautious enough to consider the circumstances.

Takes an egg AND sperm to make a fetus. And you CAN get pregnant while using birth control. Even if you're using the birth control perfectly.

Quote:
For all the parents know, it could be the next president or J.K. Rowling.

Or the next Hitler, Stalin, Meyer, etc.

It's the parents' job to correctly raise a child, and their behavior affects what their children do, as well as the environment. Instead of abortion, they could put a child up for adoption if they don't have the time or effort to take care of him/her.

And you completely ignored the fact you're putting the blame of the pregnancy completely on the woman even if she was doing her best to prevent pregnancy.

Pretty much everyone with a child tries to raise the the best way they can. You still get people the world would be better without. Neo-Nazis and the KKK have kids too.

Adoption is not a cure all. My ex was adopted and that seriously messed with his head. Not to mention how hard it is to actually adopt a child in this country, which is why some people adopt from other countries.
PostPosted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 2:47 pm


Divine_Malevolence
And, no, birth control is bad. ******** up your chemical balance is rarely positive, do take note of how most zombie movies start. And isn't it ******** up the water supply?
The very idea of birth control disgusts me. Just one more thing that might allow dumbasses to get off without any trouble. It costs less to not be a retard, and is much more effective.

You're only talking about hormonal birth control. There's several non hormonal options.

And people are going to have sex whether you like it or not. If the options are have everyone have tons of kids or birth control, I'm sure most would chose birth control.

Shiori Miko


Rayne Bloodstone

7,450 Points
  • Tycoon 200
  • Elocutionist 200
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
PostPosted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 3:09 pm


Escther
After all, it's the woman's responsibility to take birth control or what ever she's using if she wants to have sex. If she ends up pregnant, it'd be her fault, as she wasn't cautious enough to consider the circumstances.


Birth control doesn't always work and a woman doesn't always have sex of her own free will. You cannot put sole blame on the female.

Quote:
Aborting a baby would almost be like killing it. Sure, it's barely developed, but it still carries the genes of the parents, and aborting it would only eliminate another chance of having a great person. For all the parents know, it could be the next president or J.K. Rowling.


And for all you know, the kid could be the next rapist on the street that the police are hunting down. Sometimes I wonder if anyone even understands why people get abortions. A woman doesn't get (usually) an abortion just because she feels like it or doesn't even want the child. Maybe she can't care for it, maybe she is mentally unstable. Maybe the child was forced on her and maybe she is being forced to get it done.

Quote:
It's the parents' job to correctly raise a child, and their behavior affects what their children do, as well as the environment. Instead of abortion, they could put a child up for adoption if they don't have the time or effort to take care of him/her.


Adoption isn't a quick fix button.. A lot of kids don't get adopted. We had a thing on the news a while back where a girl that was 17 years old was going to be removed from the adoption center as soon as she was of age. She has no job, no one wants to adopt her, she has no family.. She is going to be homeless. So are you saying it's perfectly fine to bring a child into the world only to leave them out on the street in the blistering heat or the ice cold rain? Just because you didn't want someone to have an abortion?

And you know.. you can raise a child PERFECTLY.. and they might turn around and kill you just because they can. There is only so much the parent can do. Kids aren't robots, you can't put a program in them and force them to do your bidding and be how you want them to be.

So personally.. I am for choice. If you want to have an abortion, by all means do so. If you want to have the child, do so, but be damned ready to care for it. If you can't.. give the child to a family member or adoption but make sure you know exactly what can happen.
PostPosted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 8:23 pm


Depends. Unless the childs or mother's health is in great danger, I see no reason for abortion.
Rape? Give it for adoption. Don't kill it.

You can say what ever you wan't, but at the end of the day protection or not, you knew the risks. So man up and take responsability. Or women up. Or what ever you damn femmenists say.

That one night

Tipsy Grabber

10,250 Points
  • Megathread 100
  • Invisibility 100
  • Flatterer 200

Valheita

Vicious Nerd

10,900 Points
  • Timid 100
  • Nerd 50
  • Battle: Mage 100
PostPosted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 8:35 pm


Killing implies it's alive. I'd love to hear your justification for such a claim :3
PostPosted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 8:55 pm


Valheita
Killing implies it's alive. I'd love to hear your justification for such a claim :3
Fair enough. I have none, so uhh when is technically alive?

That one night

Tipsy Grabber

10,250 Points
  • Megathread 100
  • Invisibility 100
  • Flatterer 200

Calling Shenanigans

PostPosted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 9:35 pm


I'm pro-choice.
People with this view make me angry. When a woman is raped she should be allowed to terminate the pregnancy. It's not her fault that someone raped her and she got pregnant from it.

Also, what is a woman knows that she will die because of her pregnancy, and only an abortion will save her? What if doctors tell her her child will have a condition that may cause it to die after it's born? Why should she be forced to take that risk? It's her body, and no one should tell her what to do with it.

Birth control can fail. Is it a woman's fault that she thought her 99.9% effective birth control would be good enough? Is it her fault that a condom broke?
PostPosted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 9:42 pm


Shiori Miko
Divine_Malevolence
And, no, birth control is bad. ******** up your chemical balance is rarely positive, do take note of how most zombie movies start. And isn't it ******** up the water supply?
The very idea of birth control disgusts me. Just one more thing that might allow dumbasses to get off without any trouble. It costs less to not be a retard, and is much more effective.

You're only talking about hormonal birth control. There's several non hormonal options.

And people are going to have sex whether you like it or not. If the options are have everyone have tons of kids or birth control, I'm sure most would chose birth control.
Then usher in the non hormonal, and kill those who choose otherwise!
I do love the thought that killin' an option. Far too many possible negative consequences, but...... It's useful.

And I know they're gonna do what they're gonna do. But it can't really be that difficult to prevent in ways other than birth control.

Divine_Malevolence

Blessed Tactician

11,250 Points
  • Beta Contributor 0
  • Beta Critic 0
  • Contributor 150

Calling Shenanigans

PostPosted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 9:42 pm


That one night
Valheita
Killing implies it's alive. I'd love to hear your justification for such a claim :3
Fair enough. I have none, so uhh when is technically alive?

*jumps into conversation*
Abortions mainly happen within the first trimester, before the fetus is really developed.
I feel that is the fetus is developed to the point that it would be able to survive out of the mothers womb, then aborting it would be killing a life. But I'm pretty sure most abortions happen way before that point...
Edit:
Quote:
In almost all cases, because the fetus is not viable (able to live outside the womb) at or under 21 weeks, abortions can be done within the first 5 months.
PostPosted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 10:18 pm


Divine_Malevolence
Shiori Miko
Divine_Malevolence
And, no, birth control is bad. ******** up your chemical balance is rarely positive, do take note of how most zombie movies start. And isn't it ******** up the water supply?
The very idea of birth control disgusts me. Just one more thing that might allow dumbasses to get off without any trouble. It costs less to not be a retard, and is much more effective.

You're only talking about hormonal birth control. There's several non hormonal options.

And people are going to have sex whether you like it or not. If the options are have everyone have tons of kids or birth control, I'm sure most would chose birth control.
Then usher in the non hormonal, and kill those who choose otherwise!
I do love the thought that killin' an option. Far too many possible negative consequences, but...... It's useful.

And I know they're gonna do what they're gonna do. But it can't really be that difficult to prevent in ways other than birth control.

Most are more difficult or less effective than the very popular "Pill", which is probably why most women go for hormonal.

Shiori Miko


Daypaw

Hardened Member

PostPosted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 10:26 pm






Here is my stance.

If the woman is just being stupid and forgetting to take birth control or make the man wear a condom, I don't believe that a woman SHOULD get an abortion- but I'm still pro-choice and believe that the option should exist. If you don't want the baby, you can give it up for adoption. You don't need to kill a kid just because you're being an idiot and trying to have a good time. There's plenty of couples that would love to have a baby that for whatever reason can't have one of their own (fertility reasons, same-sex couple, what have you) and if you actually put some effort into finding someone that wants the kid before it's born there's a good chance the kid will never see the social care system and will have a happy life from the get-go.

In instances where the pregnancy is dangerous to the womans health and may do her physical or psychological harm, she was raped and became pregnant, the baby was conceived from incest, protection failed and the woman didn't have the ability to get to an alternative form of post-sexual contraceptive, or it is discovered that the child is going to be born with some sort of horrible disease that is going to SEVERELY damage it's quality of life forever or likely kill it within a few weeks/months/years? Then I can understand the need for an abortion and would absolutely not question the choice to have one. Those are all very good reasons.

All the same there was a girl in my high school physics class whom I overheard telling her best friend that she'd had eight abortions already so she shouldn't worry about the one that she was about to have. That's over doing it -____-;;



PostPosted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 11:14 pm


Daypaw


All the same there was a girl in my high school physics class whom I overheard telling her best friend that she'd had eight abortions already so she shouldn't worry about the one that she was about to have. That's over doing it -____-;;




I didn't know you could even have that many abortions. Are you sure she wasn't just talking about taking the morning after pill (which also really shouldn't be taken 8 times, but still...)?

Calling Shenanigans


CleoSombra
Captain

PostPosted: Fri Aug 13, 2010 11:51 pm


Calling Shenanigans
That one night
Valheita
Killing implies it's alive. I'd love to hear your justification for such a claim :3
Fair enough. I have none, so uhh when is technically alive?

*jumps into conversation*
Abortions mainly happen within the first trimester, before the fetus is really developed.
I feel that is the fetus is developed to the point that it would be able to survive out of the mothers womb, then aborting it would be killing a life. But I'm pretty sure most abortions happen way before that point...
Edit:
Quote:
In almost all cases, because the fetus is not viable (able to live outside the womb) at or under 21 weeks, abortions can be done within the first 5 months.


In states where abortion is allowed, abortion only happens when the fetus is 8 weeks or less. At 8 weeks, the embryo becomes a fetus.

It's also when the fetus can begin to feel pain, which is why I'm against any abortion that would be done after 8 weeks.

-----

Just a few remarks, as I'm really tired right now and stuff.

First off, I am pro-choice provided that the termination occurs prior to the 8th week.

Of course, I am against abortion as a form of birth control. Abortions cost around 300 dollars. A box of condoms costs 3.
However, most abortions are one or two time deals. The girls who get 5+ are the exception, not the rule.


Most people who are pro-life believe that life begins at conception and that all life is sacred. This is the principle behind pro-life. What I don't understand, however, is when people are pro-life but say "unless the baby is a product of rape." What, is a baby that is a product of rape some how less of a human? Yes, the mother didn't consent, but how does that justify the murder of a baby? (If pro-lifers equate abortion with murder, than no matter what the reason for termination is, it's still murder). The only exception I could understand is abortion on the pro-life side is when the woman's life is at risk.


To other remarks in this thread or to general arguments when it comes to the abortion debate:

If the argument against abortion is that it prevents a life from being created, then logically, whoever supports that argument should be against all forms of birth control (including the "pulling out" method). After all, if the sperm isn't being allowed to reach the egg, isn't that also preventing a life from being created?
PostPosted: Sat Aug 14, 2010 3:27 am


Divine_Malevolence
If they can't do it legally, they'll do it illegally. Which would make outlawing it completely pointless, and put people's lives at risk.

In the UK at least, this is one of the main reasons abortion became legal. A lot of people were paying really high prices for 'backalley' abortions, that could be really dangerous for the woman having it done, and they knew it wouldn't stop unless there was a safer legal alternative. The original 1966 version of the film Alfie is actually pretty interesting when discussing this, because it presents a view of backalley abortions from around that time. But I'm going a little off topic here.

Personally, I'm pro-choice. I do think that under normal circumstances women and their partners should do whatever they can to prevent pregnancy to begin with if they don't want a child, but the option should be there for them even if they don't; and obviously, there are circumstances where such things are out of the woman's control.

Saying that people should have the child and then put it up for adoption is... well, it's a tricky subject. Babies are much more likely to be adopted than older kids. So yes, the child that didn't get aborted might get picked up straight away and have a happy life, but that just means that other children have less of a chance of finding a foster family. Sure, I don't think that 'killing' an unborn baby for the sake of other kids is right, but the effects of pushing more kids into the adoption system should be considered.

Silly RiRi

8,150 Points
  • Brandisher 100
  • Peoplewatcher 100
  • Tooth Fairy 100

Fortuitous Feline

Sparkly Fairy

13,950 Points
  • Bunny Spotter 50
  • Bunny Hunter 100
  • Bunny Hoarder 150
PostPosted: Sat Aug 14, 2010 5:56 am


i am pro-choice, just because my beliefs are a bit complicated. i feel that if the child is a product of rape, abortion is a good option if the mother cannot handle the mental anguish of carrying the child. she's going to have mental anguish over the abortion, too, most likely, so it's a no-win, and i have complete sympathy.

if the fetus is found to have severe defects that will make quality of life horrible, and the lifespan very short, i am pro-abortion. for anyone that cares, i am also pro-assisted suicide for terminally ill people if they choose it and are of sound mind when making the decision. whole other bag of horror, though.

mentally unsound people who would have even more problems after a pregnancy, i also understand. but there's always the question of "to what degree?" and i don't have an answer for that.

like cleo said, after 8 weeks, that fetus feels pain, and any abortion after 8 weeks should not be legalized without some seriously extenuating circumstances.

you can do a private adoption, also, and choose the family that baby is going to. you aren't creating a homeless waif by letting someone adopt your baby. and newborn adoption rates are so, so much higher than adoption rates for older children. my aunt and uncle couldn't conceive and have done a private adoption twice so that they can have children. and my entire family is grateful to the mothers who decided to give their baby a life, and a good one.

making a bad call when drunk, birth control failing, just not using birth control, those are not reasons to abort, to me. you had sex willingly, deal with the ******** consequences. not wanting people to know about your sexual activity being the reason for aborting instead of letting your baby be adopted makes me so, so angry. you think you're grown up enough for sex? then you're grown up enough to deal with the natural result of sex. people will pay for the hospital bills and checkups if you're adopting out privately. money is a cop-out excuse. if i'd gotten pregnant as a teen, i decided before i was even having sex that i'd find a good family to adopt the baby.

TL;DR? this is my book on my complicated feelings regarding abortion.
Reply
Serious Discussion

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum