Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply Pro-Life/Pro-Choice Discussion
Child Free - Your Thoughts? Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Jazzberry

PostPosted: Sat Jun 21, 2008 8:31 pm


divineseraph
I'll never really understand how one can have good experiences with a child yet be for abortion.

The idea that she means so much to you, yet had she come at the wrong time, she could be dead... It's just a very disturbing thought to me.

Sorry if it's a sore subject, but that's one of my biggest things about abortion, the irony of loving someone that was just a few months ago disposable tissue.


I don't know if that's really "ironic" so to speak, or if you just can't wrap your mind around it and think it's contradictory.

I don't know about Tia's feelings, so I'm not speaking for her, but a lot of pro-choice women aren't into the idea of having an abortion for one reason or another--so they wouldn't have thought of their pregnancy as 'disposable' tissue to begin with.

I'm not sure about my mom... hmmm. I know she's extremely pro-choice, always has been, and had three kids happily. Maybe their family planning freedoms when she was starting a family helped reinforce her views? God only knows.
PostPosted: Sun Jun 22, 2008 3:06 am


divineseraph
Their life should be determined by their selves and their selves only.
It's sad that most born humans don't even get a chance to determine their own lives - often even after becoming legal adults, due to the inability to deal with the problems of their childhood.

I think that controlling one's own life, and one's own body, is something that everyone should do, and be free to do. But it's hard for people to take on that responsibility, and the truth is that many born humans don't even seem to get the chance to try. Life is tough, and some people don't seem to see how they make it tougher on themselves (often by being unable or unwilling to take responsibility for their own lives).

WatersMoon110
Crew


divineseraph

PostPosted: Sun Jun 22, 2008 5:20 am


WatersMoon110
divineseraph
Their life should be determined by their selves and their selves only.
It's sad that most born humans don't even get a chance to determine their own lives - often even after becoming legal adults, due to the inability to deal with the problems of their childhood.

I think that controlling one's own life, and one's own body, is something that everyone should do, and be free to do. But it's hard for people to take on that responsibility, and the truth is that many born humans don't even seem to get the chance to try. Life is tough, and some people don't seem to see how they make it tougher on themselves (often by being unable or unwilling to take responsibility for their own lives).


That's equivocation though, I meant in the form of living or dying, rather than certain personal choices such as careers or personalities. Problems with childhood should not be an issue, because again, being alive and having the choice of life is better than being dead, by default.

Allow me to put it a different way- The only person who should decide wether one lives or dies is the person his or herself. Nobody else. Not the parents, not a doctor, not a friend.
PostPosted: Sun Jun 22, 2008 5:22 am


Jazzberry
divineseraph
I'll never really understand how one can have good experiences with a child yet be for abortion.

The idea that she means so much to you, yet had she come at the wrong time, she could be dead... It's just a very disturbing thought to me.

Sorry if it's a sore subject, but that's one of my biggest things about abortion, the irony of loving someone that was just a few months ago disposable tissue.


I don't know if that's really "ironic" so to speak, or if you just can't wrap your mind around it and think it's contradictory.

I don't know about Tia's feelings, so I'm not speaking for her, but a lot of pro-choice women aren't into the idea of having an abortion for one reason or another--so they wouldn't have thought of their pregnancy as 'disposable' tissue to begin with.

I'm not sure about my mom... hmmm. I know she's extremely pro-choice, always has been, and had three kids happily. Maybe their family planning freedoms when she was starting a family helped reinforce her views? God only knows.


Yes, and my idea is- To think, had she willed it, any of you or your siblings could be dead.

Not trying to make an emotional appeal, but that is the fact of the matter- she could have killed one of you legally, and you would have supported it.

But, she didn't and for that I am thankful. And I hope to be thankful for the lives of many more.

divineseraph


WatersMoon110
Crew

PostPosted: Sun Jun 22, 2008 11:34 am


divineseraph
That's equivocation though, I meant in the form of living or dying, rather than certain personal choices such as careers or personalities. Problems with childhood should not be an issue, because again, being alive and having the choice of life is better than being dead, by default.

Allow me to put it a different way- The only person who should decide wether one lives or dies is the person his or herself. Nobody else. Not the parents, not a doctor, not a friend.
What about when the person in question is unable to make that choice for themself, like if they are brain dead and on life support? I know many people have legal documents (can't remember which one) to deal with situations like that, but in cases where they don't? Should the family be allowed to decide, or should it be assumed they would want to live in that situation if they haven't specifically said otherwise?
PostPosted: Sun Jun 22, 2008 11:40 am


divineseraph
Jazzberry
I'm not sure about my mom... hmmm. I know she's extremely pro-choice, always has been, and had three kids happily. Maybe their family planning freedoms when she was starting a family helped reinforce her views? God only knows.


Yes, and my idea is- To think, had she willed it, any of you or your siblings could be dead.

Not trying to make an emotional appeal, but that is the fact of the matter- she could have killed one of you legally, and you would have supported it.

But, she didn't and for that I am thankful. And I hope to be thankful for the lives of many more.
It really doesn't bother me that my mother is Pro-Choice, and thus might have chosen abortion instead of having children. I mean, if my parents hadn't had sex that night, if they had sex a few minutes earlier or later, a different sperm might have fertilized the ovum and I wouldn't be here.

Personally, it worries me more that some women might only have children because they feel obligated to, or feel that they have no other choice than to do so. I hope that women who feel that way after carrying their pregnancy to term give the resulting children up for adoption instead of raising them but resenting them. And that those children get adopted into loving homes.

But, really, I think that most people do want to have children after they get pregnant (if not before). Even when it's a surprise. It doesn't seem to matter if they are Pro-Life or Pro-Choice, I think most couples are pretty happy about having a baby. And that is something that I think everyone can be thankful for!

WatersMoon110
Crew


divineseraph

PostPosted: Sun Jun 22, 2008 1:09 pm


WatersMoon110
divineseraph
That's equivocation though, I meant in the form of living or dying, rather than certain personal choices such as careers or personalities. Problems with childhood should not be an issue, because again, being alive and having the choice of life is better than being dead, by default.

Allow me to put it a different way- The only person who should decide wether one lives or dies is the person his or herself. Nobody else. Not the parents, not a doctor, not a friend.
What about when the person in question is unable to make that choice for themself, like if they are brain dead and on life support? I know many people have legal documents (can't remember which one) to deal with situations like that, but in cases where they don't? Should the family be allowed to decide, or should it be assumed they would want to live in that situation if they haven't specifically said otherwise?


They should have legal documentation stating that they want to die, or it should be assumed they want to live.

I say, and I'm pretty sure I'm quoting this from someone else here, when in doubt, err on the side of life.
PostPosted: Sun Jun 22, 2008 1:18 pm


WatersMoon110
divineseraph
Jazzberry
I'm not sure about my mom... hmmm. I know she's extremely pro-choice, always has been, and had three kids happily. Maybe their family planning freedoms when she was starting a family helped reinforce her views? God only knows.


Yes, and my idea is- To think, had she willed it, any of you or your siblings could be dead.

Not trying to make an emotional appeal, but that is the fact of the matter- she could have killed one of you legally, and you would have supported it.

But, she didn't and for that I am thankful. And I hope to be thankful for the lives of many more.
It really doesn't bother me that my mother is Pro-Choice, and thus might have chosen abortion instead of having children. I mean, if my parents hadn't had sex that night, if they had sex a few minutes earlier or later, a different sperm might have fertilized the ovum and I wouldn't be here.

Personally, it worries me more that some women might only have children because they feel obligated to, or feel that they have no other choice than to do so. I hope that women who feel that way after carrying their pregnancy to term give the resulting children up for adoption instead of raising them but resenting them. And that those children get adopted into loving homes.

But, really, I think that most people do want to have children after they get pregnant (if not before). Even when it's a surprise. It doesn't seem to matter if they are Pro-Life or Pro-Choice, I think most couples are pretty happy about having a baby. And that is something that I think everyone can be thankful for!


Well, that depends on theologies, and wether individual sperm have souls. I believe that they do not, and that a soul is created at conception (Mind you, not in the evangelical sense that "zomg baby at conception!" idea, but a more loose beginning to who one is, unique to the conception and only after conception.) Basically, the soul waits until conception to appear. so minutes, days, whatever, you'd still be you, minus the time difference of course.

And that's just it- It's never about the fetus's life. It's always the woman. Not even her life, just her convenience, and her time, and her lifestyle. It's not an obligation to help someone, it's an obligation to not kill someone.

divineseraph


Jazzberry

PostPosted: Sun Jun 22, 2008 5:10 pm


divineseraph
Not trying to make an emotional appeal, but that is the fact of the matter- she could have killed one of you legally, and you would have supported it.


Yup.
I actually enjoy knowing that, considering her environment, family, husband, their political and religious views, etc., she could have chosen legal abortion and been supported for it, but decided to have a baby instead. heart I just feel nice knowing she wasn't forced into it or didn't feel obligated to have a kid and just resent it later.
PostPosted: Mon Jun 23, 2008 8:00 am


divineseraph
Tiadaria
WatersMoon110
And, Tiadaria, I hope that your life has been greatly improved by your daughter! I know that my sister's life has been by her son (and my nephew has improved my life too - he's such a great kid)! I think that you are totally wonderful, and that anyone who has called you names over your choice to give birth and raise your daughter is wrong!! *big smile*
¨*:·.♥.·:*¨


    It's amazing how much my life improved with my daughter. I got clean and stayed clean, I started being responsible, I left my jerk-face ex, and sought help for my emotional baggage.

    It's been crazy hard, but I can honestly say that I think things are a lot better with her in my life, than they would've been without her. She's fun. We laugh and talk and just enjoy ourselves. Sure, she's a kid...and that means projectile vomit in the middle of a Wal-Mart, and nail-polish on my carpet, and temper tantrums while I'm trying to take a shower. But, for me, the good outweighs the bad. But there's also mandatory hugs every day, compliments while I do my makeup, shared ice cream, and an excuse to watch Disney movies I loved as a kid. There's a little voice piping up while I'm reading, telling me to "follow my heart".

    I just can't see how my life is supposedly ruined. And if it is, I think I can live with that. xD


I'll never really understand how one can have good experiences with a child yet be for abortion.

The idea that she means so much to you, yet had she come at the wrong time, she could be dead... It's just a very disturbing thought to me.

Sorry if it's a sore subject, but that's one of my biggest things about abortion, the irony of loving someone that was just a few months ago disposable tissue.
¨*:·.♥.·:*¨



    No, no, I get it. It's something I've thought about as well, because I did consider all my options. And I think it's in my nature (perhaps everyone's) to consider the what ifs...

    It's just...for me at least, the difference between my daughter - who loves purple, makes up songs, and will cry if she forgets to hug me every morning before I go to work - and a fetus, simply floating and forming, completely unaware of anything. Yes, it -could- eventually turn into a child with its own personality who I would love...but if it never got there, it would just be "the road not taken"...it's just not the same to me, y'know?

    Of course, I believe that part of this stems from my belief on souls and when they enter the body. It would be hard for me to mourn an aborted fetus in the same sense that I would mourn a born child who died. I wouldn't consider them quite on the same level, and while both may be sad situations, the difference is great.

    But like I said, I do see what you mean. It's a strange concept at first glance, but I think those who hold the same position I do have many varied reasons for it. I only know mine, but now that you've brought it up, I'm actually curious about where others come from on it. <3

Purrly

Invisible Elder

8,800 Points
  • Invisibility 100
  • Mark Twain 100
  • Megathread 100

divineseraph

PostPosted: Mon Jun 23, 2008 5:47 pm


Jazzberry
divineseraph
Not trying to make an emotional appeal, but that is the fact of the matter- she could have killed one of you legally, and you would have supported it.


Yup.
I actually enjoy knowing that, considering her environment, family, husband, their political and religious views, etc., she could have chosen legal abortion and been supported for it, but decided to have a baby instead. heart I just feel nice knowing she wasn't forced into it or didn't feel obligated to have a kid and just resent it later.


Perhaps. But it was your life in her hands, and it was a matter of luck on your part.

I don't want to be able to meet only the lucky ones.
PostPosted: Mon Jun 23, 2008 5:53 pm


Jazzberry
divineseraph
Not trying to make an emotional appeal, but that is the fact of the matter- she could have killed one of you legally, and you would have supported it.


Yup.
I actually enjoy knowing that, considering her environment, family, husband, their political and religious views, etc., she could have chosen legal abortion and been supported for it, but decided to have a baby instead. heart I just feel nice knowing she wasn't forced into it or didn't feel obligated to have a kid and just resent it later.


You're very optimistic. biggrin If I where in your shoes I would count my blessings. "phew..."

Conren

Distinct Gawker

12,150 Points
  • Peoplewatcher 100
  • Contributor 150
  • Person of Interest 200

Conren

Distinct Gawker

12,150 Points
  • Peoplewatcher 100
  • Contributor 150
  • Person of Interest 200
PostPosted: Mon Jun 23, 2008 5:59 pm


WatersMoon110
I mean, if my parents hadn't had sex that night, if they had sex a few minutes earlier or later, a different sperm might have fertilized the ovum and I wouldn't be here.


Hehehe, how very patriarchy of you. XD
PostPosted: Mon Jun 23, 2008 6:05 pm


divineseraph
Not trying to make an emotional appeal, but that is the fact of the matter- she could have killed one of you legally, and you would have supported it.


I'm just glad I wouldn't have to worry about that, though my mom decided not to get pregnant again after me (though she was fine, she was scared that something bad could happen since she was told that long before she even had me). Though she seems to be against abortion (she never really talks about it).

Though I don't know when the soul enters the body, the embryo and fetus are still humans to me, developing and unable to do awhole lot at the time, it's still living. Maybe a death of a born person is sadder, I would still feel bad if I lost the child before it was born.

rweghrheh


WatersMoon110
Crew

PostPosted: Tue Jun 24, 2008 9:17 am


Conren
WatersMoon110
I mean, if my parents ... had sex a few minutes earlier or later, a different sperm might have fertilized the ovum and I wouldn't be here.


Hehehe, how very patriarchy of you. XD
Well, the sperm decides the gender, after all. And, if a different sperm had made it, it would have reached the same ovum that eventually formed into me. But it could have carried a Y instead of an X, and any sort of different genes than what I got (red hair or dark brown instead of light brown - slightly redder or darker skin - any number of traits that effect personality), the only "sure" thing was blue eyes since both parents have those.

There was, so far as I know, only one release ovum when my parents got pregnant with what grew into me (25 and some years later), since I had no twin. But there were millions of sperm released, and only one fertilized the ovum in question.

Just a basic biological statement, I feel.
Reply
Pro-Life/Pro-Choice Discussion

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum