Welcome to Gaia! ::

Mafia Maniacs

Back to Guilds

Frozen Mallet Fridays 

Tags: mafia, logic, forum games, chatting, video games 

Reply Archives
Papercuts (Town wins through luck and bullying!) Goto Page: [] [<<] [<] 1 2 3 ... 27 28 29 30 31 32 ... 137 138 139 140 [>] [>>] [>>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

SoThatAznGirl

PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 6:51 pm


dragn99
Sweet Amber Lynne
Zephyrkitty
Tonberry Crunch
Well since our cop can't PM any known Townie the proposition for an alliance, they'd have to post they're results in this thread, letting the mafia know that they are the cop, which is a dumb move. I believe we're basically blind for now.

They could still FoS if they investigated scum, though.


problem is, if they do FoS without a reason we can see in here, that would put the suspicion on them , which isn't wise either. But I do agree we need to do something..
Perhaps Zepyhr was hoping to draw out the cop by making them FoS someone?

Thats.... thats kind of suspicious, right?

Maybe, but that seems like the obvious thing for the cop to do, anyway. And it might not even be that dangerous. Wylr FoSd and he wasn't the cop. I'm FoSing ppl. Other players probably will eventually. The cop ought to just slip right in with and FoS so we can all discuss the suspect. :/
PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 6:52 pm


Harusame Mizukishi
I say we pick a random number and vote for the corresponding player.

For the lulz.

Harusame Mizukishi
Crew

Dapper Lunatic


SoThatAznGirl

PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 6:54 pm


Harusame Mizukishi
Harusame Mizukishi
I say we pick a random number and vote for the corresponding player.

For the lulz.

Or for serious if nothing helpful happens.

And hey, who's ILI again? Has s/he posted?
PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 6:56 pm


SoThatAznGirl
dragn99
Sweet Amber Lynne
Zephyrkitty
Tonberry Crunch
Well since our cop can't PM any known Townie the proposition for an alliance, they'd have to post they're results in this thread, letting the mafia know that they are the cop, which is a dumb move. I believe we're basically blind for now.

They could still FoS if they investigated scum, though.


problem is, if they do FoS without a reason we can see in here, that would put the suspicion on them , which isn't wise either. But I do agree we need to do something..
Perhaps Zepyhr was hoping to draw out the cop by making them FoS someone?

Thats.... thats kind of suspicious, right?

Maybe, but that seems like the obvious thing for the cop to do, anyway. And it might not even be that dangerous. Wylr FoSd and he wasn't the cop. I'm FoSing ppl. Other players probably will eventually. The cop ought to just slip right in with and FoS so we can all discuss the suspect. :/
Like Amber said though, unless we can see the reason for the FoS in the thread, it'll draw suspicion on the person who pointed said FoS.

dragn99

Aged Guildswoman

8,550 Points
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Guildmember 100
  • Dressed Up 200

Hashire Kazemeijin
Crew

Distinct Enabler

PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 7:02 pm


Hobo Scruffy
@Hash & Mizu- How about an opinion? Anything?


I don't really like making opinions. I prefer evidence, but we don't really have that as of now.

If I must say something, Zach/Wylr's death is noteworthy. Three possibilities that come to mind are:

A) Zach was right about Med and he was silenced for it. Not too probable unless an inexperienced person is the Mafia head.

2) The Mafia killed Zach in order to make us think Point A happened. Usually the most common strategy, since it's confusing regardless of it being almost always present.

III) The Mafia assume we would think Point 2 was enacted and disregard who was suspicious of Zach in the first place, in hopes of removing or clouding any suspicion against the person who would be the source normally. (In this case, Med)
PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 7:08 pm


dragn99
Like Amber said though, unless we can see the reason for the FoS in the thread, it'll draw suspicion on the person who pointed said FoS.

Gah, I don't like it. So we have to wait for a mafian to slip up so the cop can make the FoS? What if that never happens? What good is the cop role then?

SoThatAznGirl


Sweet Amber Lynne
Crew

Beloved Businesswoman

PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 7:08 pm


dragn99
SoThatAznGirl
dragn99
Sweet Amber Lynne
Zephyrkitty
Tonberry Crunch
Well since our cop can't PM any known Townie the proposition for an alliance, they'd have to post they're results in this thread, letting the mafia know that they are the cop, which is a dumb move. I believe we're basically blind for now.

They could still FoS if they investigated scum, though.


problem is, if they do FoS without a reason we can see in here, that would put the suspicion on them , which isn't wise either. But I do agree we need to do something..
Perhaps Zepyhr was hoping to draw out the cop by making them FoS someone?

Thats.... thats kind of suspicious, right?

Maybe, but that seems like the obvious thing for the cop to do, anyway. And it might not even be that dangerous. Wylr FoSd and he wasn't the cop. I'm FoSing ppl. Other players probably will eventually. The cop ought to just slip right in with and FoS so we can all discuss the suspect. :/
Like Amber said though, unless we can see the reason for the FoS in the thread, it'll draw suspicion on the person who pointed said FoS.


Exactly. Not to mention the cop is more then likely watching or will eventually see all the hints, but if they are role blocked, we are wasting our time waiting for them to help us out
PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 7:09 pm


SoThatAznGirl
dragn99
Like Amber said though, unless we can see the reason for the FoS in the thread, it'll draw suspicion on the person who pointed said FoS.

Gah, I don't like it. So we have to wait for a mafian to slip up so the cop can make the FoS? What if that never happens? What good is the cop role then?


It's just how the game is right now. Just because the cop hasnt shown themselves doesn't mean its a useless role. It means we need a better strategy to figure this s**t out

Sweet Amber Lynne
Crew

Beloved Businesswoman


badtzmaru

Adorable Waffles

21,700 Points
  • Waffles! 25
  • Noble Shade 100
  • Protector of Cuteness 150
PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 7:18 pm


Hashire Kazemeijin
If I must say something, Zach/Wylr's death is noteworthy. Three possibilities that come to mind are:

A) Zach was right about Med and he was silenced for it. Not too probable unless an inexperienced person is the Mafia head.

2) The Mafia killed Zach in order to make us think Point A happened. Usually the most common strategy, since it's confusing regardless of it being almost always present.

III) The Mafia assume we would think Point 2 was enacted and disregard who was suspicious of Zach in the first place, in hopes of removing or clouding any suspicion against the person who would be the source normally. (In this case, Med)
I didn't understand point 3, but I think it's point 2.

But yeah, the only clue we have right now is Wylr's death and I don't know how to use it to track down the mafia.
PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 7:25 pm


I swore I posted, but Wylr was Vig killed, right?

l-Kathulu-l
Crew

Versatile Man-Lover


Hashire Kazemeijin
Crew

Distinct Enabler

PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 7:29 pm


badtzmaru
Hashire Kazemeijin
If I must say something, Zach/Wylr's death is noteworthy. Three possibilities that come to mind are:

A) Zach was right about Med and he was silenced for it. Not too probable unless an inexperienced person is the Mafia head.

2) The Mafia killed Zach in order to make us think Point A happened. Usually the most common strategy, since it's confusing regardless of it being almost always present.

III) The Mafia assume we would think Point 2 was enacted and disregard who was suspicious of Zach in the first place, in hopes of removing or clouding any suspicion against the person who would be the source normally. (In this case, Med)
I didn't understand point 3, but I think it's point 2.

But yeah, the only clue we have right now is Wylr's death and I don't know how to use it to track down the mafia.


Point III is basically a "They know we know" situation. It suggests Zach was killed off because he suspected Med and was right, but the Mafia knew we wouldn't chase Med for it because it seems like the ever so common lure.
PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 7:30 pm


l-Kathulu-l
I swore I posted, but Wylr was Vig killed, right?

Oh, I thought we weren't gonna be told how. Or maybe it was that there just weren't gonna be hints in the stories. Idk.

So, who's ILI?

SoThatAznGirl


J of The Wind

Shirtless Phantom

9,975 Points
  • Beta Forum Regular 0
  • Gender Swap 100
  • Invisibility 100
PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 7:34 pm


Im banking on the fact that Glaru was mafia and leaned against Med NOT being killed and pushing for night phase, but then again so did LPS and several other people ( including myself. ._. )...

Thats all I got to go on...
= w=;;

*plays with Dusky*
PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 7:40 pm


SoThatAznGirl
l-Kathulu-l
I swore I posted, but Wylr was Vig killed, right?

Oh, I thought we weren't gonna be told how. Or maybe it was that there just weren't gonna be hints in the stories. Idk.

So, who's ILI?

Nvm, found a post from her while re-reading.

SoThatAznGirl


l-Kathulu-l
Crew

Versatile Man-Lover

PostPosted: Fri Dec 03, 2010 7:40 pm


SoThatAznGirl
l-Kathulu-l
I swore I posted, but Wylr was Vig killed, right?

Oh, I thought we weren't gonna be told how. Or maybe it was that there just weren't gonna be hints in the stories. Idk.

So, who's ILI?
I just assumed because only his cloud was left. Tubba Blubba eats people, so I just put them together.

And ILI is I_love_inuyasha1. I dunno if the _-_ things are right or not, but that's her.

And what J just said about pushing for Med not to be killed. Wylr was killed for suspecting Med of Mafia, so Med is suspicious of being affiliated with them due to Wylr's disappearance. But if he was Vig killed, then that's just kind of nothing. A random stab and a good direction for the Vig to take.

Unless Med is Vig, then oh s**t.

And LPS was Metakilled. Pussies.
Reply
Archives

Goto Page: [] [<<] [<] 1 2 3 ... 27 28 29 30 31 32 ... 137 138 139 140 [>] [>>] [>>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum