Welcome to Gaia! ::

http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=7682383&page=6

Basically two people both completely focused on my team mate, so I fired two shots at both of their heads. I think this warrants a critical roll, because I fired while they're busy attacking my ally. Since it's a gun, I don't think they have the time to defend. I'd like a judgment on this please.

EDIT: Resolved.

Second EDIT: Arc already made a judgment on this, but they aren't satisfied with his judgment.

Arc is a judge. He judged. Go with it.

I'm not going to set a precedent for people running to another judge when one judge makes a ruling they don't like. Arc made a judgement call, so go with it.

It was actually recommended by Arc that we get a second judgement if we couldn't resolve the issue, and by not weighing both sides properly (Like each of us gets one post to defend our case) it takes a player out of the game because another player said he should get a crit roll for something bogus (which I can prove).

And you got a second judgement. Mine, telling you to stop arguing and go with the first judgement. I've read through the thread; there is NO reason for you to still be arguing. Arc's judgement was fair, and final.

Brennsa needs to roll when he gets back online. It's not guaranteed the shot will take him out of the game. If it does take him out of the game, well, that's the way it goes.

Bryces...you haven't killed Brennsa until a defense roll is made for him. He can make it, or, if you wish to speed things up, AP or I can roll for him.

You'll have to wait till Arc comes back to find out the details of the boss and the marbles. Until then, note how many marbles you got and keep going.

It dosent matter what Brennsa rolls. The attack roll was for 35, the highest defence Brennsa can get is a 28 (20+6+ cool
Owle beat me to it.

In this case, Jacknife nabs at least two marbles. Brennsa's and boss-boy's.

Alright. Owl can go ahead and roll for Brenn, but I'm not going to be active for a good long while. Assume the rock explodes, leaving you guys with your escape time, but the marbles would still go kablooey. If Brenn's character lives, he's back at the headquarters with me, assuming we ran at the explosion as well. Both of us will be in super stealth mode after that, since I'm getting my a** back to bed for a few hours.

EDIT: Nevermind Brenn's roll then. I'm back at base, super stealth style.

Brennsa is dead, but you don't get his marble. Xallen is far away (or at least farther away then Alm is) and Zen is running from an exploding rock or something.

Jacknife can pick up the marbles the boss dropped, but Alm gets to keep the marble Tormenta had.

Since Alm knew the explosion was coming, he'd be able to recover from it faster than Zen or Xallen could find Tormenta's marble. Therefore, he can drag Brennsa's whole corpse back to the base with him...or just the marble, whichever he prefers.

I'm going with this one.

I have been keeping up with the posting there and from what I've seen Fen kept on driving past the group fighting, turned a corner, and is coming around.

Impact did not get the grenades until asked. They were already gone past the group at that time.

This not including the obvious facts that cars are not transparent.

There is no way to 'peer into the windows' of a car that drove past and see something that was not even pulled out yet. Also from how I read it Cerberus did not drive right through you people close enough to get near the window.