Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply Death Note Guild
is it really murder Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

so is he really a murder if he does that?
  no
  yes
  i dont know
View Results

Tokay-Spirit

PostPosted: Sun May 14, 2006 12:49 pm


Inane Whimsies
AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel
AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel

Yeah, but he knows the book will kill the peoples. Its like your saying if someone stabs someone else...its the knife thats killing the victim...not the actual person.

The knife did kill the person... your hand just happened to be holding it.

So, your saying its just a coinsidence that Raito's writing down the names?

no. I'm just saying that he didn't kill them by himself. He just helped.
Just like a knife; you need to move the knife to kill somone, but it wasn't your hand that killed the person, it was the blade.
Get my meaning?


I get your meaning... There was no 'helping though' on Light's part. The Note helped him. Without Light the Note would just set there doing nothing.

So basically you're just making an inane argument to prove a point that is moot.

XD yeah, basically.
PostPosted: Sun May 14, 2006 6:17 pm


Alastor-Lifuliel
Inane Whimsies
AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel
AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel

Yeah, but he knows the book will kill the peoples. Its like your saying if someone stabs someone else...its the knife thats killing the victim...not the actual person.

The knife did kill the person... your hand just happened to be holding it.

So, your saying its just a coinsidence that Raito's writing down the names?

no. I'm just saying that he didn't kill them by himself. He just helped.
Just like a knife; you need to move the knife to kill somone, but it wasn't your hand that killed the person, it was the blade.
Get my meaning?


I get your meaning... There was no 'helping though' on Light's part. The Note helped him. Without Light the Note would just set there doing nothing.

So basically you're just making an inane argument to prove a point that is moot.

XD yeah, basically.

I know that my arguement is pointless... *is trying to make Raito sound... not bad* sweatdrop

Visual_Kiva


Tokay-Spirit

PostPosted: Mon May 15, 2006 2:23 pm


AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel
Inane Whimsies
AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel

So, your saying its just a coinsidence that Raito's writing down the names?

no. I'm just saying that he didn't kill them by himself. He just helped.
Just like a knife; you need to move the knife to kill somone, but it wasn't your hand that killed the person, it was the blade.
Get my meaning?


I get your meaning... There was no 'helping though' on Light's part. The Note helped him. Without Light the Note would just set there doing nothing.

So basically you're just making an inane argument to prove a point that is moot.

XD yeah, basically.

I know that my arguement is pointless... *is trying to make Raito sound... not bad* sweatdrop

Yeah...good luck with that.
PostPosted: Mon May 15, 2006 4:55 pm


Alastor-Lifuliel
AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel
Inane Whimsies
AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel

So, your saying its just a coinsidence that Raito's writing down the names?

no. I'm just saying that he didn't kill them by himself. He just helped.
Just like a knife; you need to move the knife to kill somone, but it wasn't your hand that killed the person, it was the blade.
Get my meaning?


I get your meaning... There was no 'helping though' on Light's part. The Note helped him. Without Light the Note would just set there doing nothing.

So basically you're just making an inane argument to prove a point that is moot.

XD yeah, basically.

I know that my arguement is pointless... *is trying to make Raito sound... not bad* sweatdrop

Yeah...good luck with that.

Shut up, you! *points finger menacingly*

Visual_Kiva


Inane Whimsies
Crew

PostPosted: Mon May 15, 2006 6:12 pm


AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel
AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel
Inane Whimsies


I get your meaning... There was no 'helping though' on Light's part. The Note helped him. Without Light the Note would just set there doing nothing.

So basically you're just making an inane argument to prove a point that is moot.

XD yeah, basically.

I know that my arguement is pointless... *is trying to make Raito sound... not bad* sweatdrop

Yeah...good luck with that.

Shut up, you! *points finger menacingly*


ninja ... -has her kitten Mello bite Aku-kun's finger-
PostPosted: Tue May 16, 2006 1:49 pm


Yes, it's murder. Without no doubt.
A Death Note let you think you have only to write a name in it. But that's not all. If you WANT to kill somebody then you KILL somebody. DN is maybe the force, but the will is the direction.
The book is evil, without no doubt. But it is also evil to want someone dead, isn't it?


Moonchild0


Feline Sweetheart

18,525 Points
  • Cool Cat 500
  • Cat Fancier 100
  • Unleash the Beast 100

Tokay-Spirit

PostPosted: Tue May 16, 2006 2:15 pm


Inane Whimsies
AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel
AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel
Inane Whimsies


I get your meaning... There was no 'helping though' on Light's part. The Note helped him. Without Light the Note would just set there doing nothing.

So basically you're just making an inane argument to prove a point that is moot.

XD yeah, basically.

I know that my arguement is pointless... *is trying to make Raito sound... not bad* sweatdrop

Yeah...good luck with that.

Shut up, you! *points finger menacingly*


ninja ... -has her kitten Mello bite Aku-kun's finger-

*points and laughs*

...*is going to regret this later*
PostPosted: Wed May 17, 2006 3:44 pm


Alastor-Lifuliel
Inane Whimsies
AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel
AkuGensho

I know that my arguement is pointless... *is trying to make Raito sound... not bad* sweatdrop

Yeah...good luck with that.

Shut up, you! *points finger menacingly*


ninja ... -has her kitten Mello bite Aku-kun's finger-

*points and laughs*

...*is going to regret this later*

I know where you sleep...

Visual_Kiva


Tokay-Spirit

PostPosted: Thu May 18, 2006 2:21 pm


AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel
Inane Whimsies
AkuGensho
Alastor-Lifuliel
AkuGensho

I know that my arguement is pointless... *is trying to make Raito sound... not bad* sweatdrop

Yeah...good luck with that.

Shut up, you! *points finger menacingly*


ninja ... -has her kitten Mello bite Aku-kun's finger-

*points and laughs*

...*is going to regret this later*

I know where you sleep...

Ah, yes you do, but in turn.. I know where YOU sleep as well.
PostPosted: Sun May 21, 2006 6:40 am


WELL what i say is under light yagami's understanding ,He kills anybody who threats him,and also kill cmrinals,soooooooo if you were to piss him off not knowing how he gets then its probably light yagami's fault which means MURDER!buttttt if you knew him prtty wel and know how he gets then its like killling your self if you get him mad or do somehting to him to make him made which is not MURDER. I rest my case

akirakurosawa111


Tokay-Spirit

PostPosted: Mon May 22, 2006 3:14 pm


akirakurosawa111
WELL what i say is under light yagami's understanding ,He kills anybody who threats him,and also kill cmrinals,soooooooo if you were to piss him off not knowing how he gets then its probably light yagami's fault which means MURDER!buttttt if you knew him prtty wel and know how he gets then its like killling your self if you get him mad or do somehting to him to make him made which is not MURDER. I rest my case

so...you're saying its the peoples fault that they die. And by pissing off Raito-kun, they... basically..commit suicide?
PostPosted: Mon May 22, 2006 3:28 pm


If Light hadn't used the Death Note, all of the people he killed wouldn't have died. Whether his killings are justified is a whole other topic.

Nights1stStar


akirakurosawa111

PostPosted: Tue May 23, 2006 4:04 am


Alastor-Lifuliel
akirakurosawa111
WELL what i say is under light yagami's understanding ,He kills anybody who threats him,and also kill cmrinals,soooooooo if you were to piss him off not knowing how he gets then its probably light yagami's fault which means MURDER!buttttt if you knew him prtty wel and know how he gets then its like killling your self if you get him mad or do somehting to him to make him made which is not MURDER. I rest my case

so...you're saying its the peoples fault that they die. And by pissing off Raito-kun, they... basically..commit suicide?


well i am saying part of it is that they are basically commit sucising because they anger light(which ticks him off)
PostPosted: Tue May 23, 2006 4:35 pm


akirakurosawa111
Alastor-Lifuliel
akirakurosawa111
WELL what i say is under light yagami's understanding ,He kills anybody who threats him,and also kill cmrinals,soooooooo if you were to piss him off not knowing how he gets then its probably light yagami's fault which means MURDER!buttttt if you knew him prtty wel and know how he gets then its like killling your self if you get him mad or do somehting to him to make him made which is not MURDER. I rest my case

so...you're saying its the peoples fault that they die. And by pissing off Raito-kun, they... basically..commit suicide?


well i am saying part of it is that they are basically commit sucising because they anger light(which ticks him off)

So... its not the notes fault...its not Raito's fault.. its... the victims fault. lol Maybe we should go to the source of it all, and you know what you get?

THE SHINIGAMI!! They kill everyone ^.^

Tokay-Spirit


akirakurosawa111

PostPosted: Tue May 23, 2006 5:20 pm


Alastor-Lifuliel
akirakurosawa111
Alastor-Lifuliel
akirakurosawa111
WELL what i say is under light yagami's understanding ,He kills anybody who threats him,and also kill cmrinals,soooooooo if you were to piss him off not knowing how he gets then its probably light yagami's fault which means MURDER!buttttt if you knew him prtty wel and know how he gets then its like killling your self if you get him mad or do somehting to him to make him made which is not MURDER. I rest my case

so...you're saying its the peoples fault that they die. And by pissing off Raito-kun, they... basically..commit suicide?


well i am saying part of it is that they are basically commit sucising because they anger light(which ticks him off)

So... its not the notes fault...its not Raito's fault.. its... the victims fault. lol Maybe we should go to the source of it all, and you know what you get?

THE SHINIGAMI!! They kill everyone ^.^


OH CRAP soryr excuse my langueage i had forgotten about the shinigami yes!! yes!! if we track it down to the main source it would be the shinigami i agree^^
Reply
Death Note Guild

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum