New New Evergreen Goblin
Ah. I'll take option one for both, then - Oddball is first four rolls, Savage is the second four rolls. (It is four rolls per team for the reward recruit, right? Three as normal + the extra die mentioned?)
That is correct. This means your rolls for Oddball are: Dark, Fighting, Bug Steel. For Savage, that would be: Fairy, Steel, Fighting, Normal. You're free to incorporate your chosen recruit into the chapter in a story-appropriate manner (ie: as a victim or an aggressor) but you won't get to keep them unless you get through all the writing.