Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply Card Discussion
Best all-around Counterspell? Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

froszen

PostPosted: Tue Apr 04, 2006 4:33 pm


sorrow89
Variant_Theory
i'm suprised no one mentioned last word. the uncounterable counterspell.


one problem if someone last words or something in a counter war...you just counter the original spell again while its on the stack

but if the person with the last word is countering the original spell then a counter war dousnt even occur
PostPosted: Wed Apr 05, 2006 1:30 pm


Last Word's flavour text pwns face

I <3 Force Spike, always fun.

I hate Force of Will cause it's such a good card and I don't have a playset >.<

big711fan


Skunch
Crew

PostPosted: Wed Apr 05, 2006 6:49 pm


sorrow89
Variant_Theory
i'm suprised no one mentioned last word. the uncounterable counterspell.


one problem if someone last words or something in a counter war...you just counter the original spell again while its on the stack


That doesn't work, you can't counter a spell twice.
PostPosted: Thu Apr 13, 2006 5:23 am


Skunch
sorrow89
Variant_Theory
i'm suprised no one mentioned last word. the uncounterable counterspell.


one problem if someone last words or something in a counter war...you just counter the original spell again while its on the stack


That doesn't work, you can't counter a spell twice.


You're right. You can target it twice, but it is impossible to counter anything twice.

Take this.

Nasty Spell (1), Counterspell (targeting Nasty Spell)(2), Counterspell (Targeting (2))(3), Last Word (Targeting Nasty Spell (1))(4), Counterspell (targeting (3))(5).

This is slightly confusing, but whatever. Counterspell (5) would resolve, countering Counterspell 3, then Last Word would resolve, countering Nasty Spell, THEN the original counterspell would FIZZLE for lack of target, making you right IN THEORY, but you can target the same spell 1,000,000 times. You'll waste 999,999 of those counters, but you'll counter the spell smile .

Best counter ever - Counterspell
Standard - Remand, Mana Leak, or Hinder

Samyueru_UK


Dyshidrosis

Shameless Dog

PostPosted: Sat Apr 22, 2006 11:19 pm


Counterspell. Lets break this down

Color: Blue

Casting Cost: UU

Ability: Counter Target Spell

That's it. No frills, all power. How can people NOT see that is beyond me. For how good FoW is, yes, you do have to commit potetially more than CS. Removing a blue card and 1 life. What if FoW is all you have? Then it's a counterspell for 3UU, a lot more than regular Counterspell. It doesn't cost one mana, but then again there's nothing short of another counterspell that an opponent can do about it.  
PostPosted: Sun Apr 23, 2006 7:11 am


Obersturmbannfuehrer Chii
Counterspell. Lets break this down

Color: Blue

Casting Cost: UU

Ability: Counter Target Spell

That's it. No frills, all power. How can people NOT see that is beyond me. For how good FoW is, yes, you do have to commit potetially more than CS. Removing a blue card and 1 life. What if FoW is all you have? Then it's a counterspell for 3UU, a lot more than regular Counterspell. It doesn't cost one mana, but then again there's nothing short of another counterspell that an opponent can do about it.
Mana Drain> counterspell

DustErrant


sorrow89

PostPosted: Sun Apr 23, 2006 7:58 pm


froszen
id have to say rewind, purely for the fact that it works with so much els.
anything before those turns i would say force of will or daze. im also a fan of power sink, just because its more versatile and your aponent looses their mana if they dont pay the X.

in order id say
1 rewind
2 force of will
3 power sink
4 daze



what about drain? no drawbacks...
PostPosted: Sun May 07, 2006 8:01 am


Early game-- Force of Will or Mana Drain
Mid--- counter spell
Late game-- SPELLJACK!!!!

2345676543gfer


2345676543gfer

PostPosted: Sun May 07, 2006 8:04 am


WAIT STOP THE PRESS!!!
WHAT ABOUT SWIFT JUSTICE!!!!!

Oh wait i forgot its.... swift justice.... crying

Some bad
PostPosted: Sun May 07, 2006 12:58 pm


Rewind is good for decks with a lot of instants or creature abilities.

JamesVonJames


sorrow89

PostPosted: Sun May 07, 2006 1:42 pm


Samyueru_UK
Skunch
sorrow89
Variant_Theory
i'm suprised no one mentioned last word. the uncounterable counterspell.


one problem if someone last words or something in a counter war...you just counter the original spell again while its on the stack


That doesn't work, you can't counter a spell twice.


You're right. You can target it twice, but it is impossible to counter anything twice.

Take this.

Nasty Spell (1), Counterspell (targeting Nasty Spell)(2), Counterspell (Targeting (2))(3), Last Word (Targeting Nasty Spell (1))(4), Counterspell (targeting (3))(5).

This is slightly confusing, but whatever. Counterspell (5) would resolve, countering Counterspell 3, then Last Word would resolve, countering Nasty Spell, THEN the original counterspell would FIZZLE for lack of target, making you right IN THEORY, but you can target the same spell 1,000,000 times. You'll waste 999,999 of those counters, but you'll counter the spell smile .

Best counter ever - Counterspell
Standard - Remand, Mana Leak, or Hinder


its not countering the spell twice...its on the stack...the way it works is first on last off...if a spell is played its the first on the stack and the last to resovle...it works the same way as it does on a computer, first info in last to go through the whole way...so when you counter that spell again the other counter card used fizzles and is just removed from the stack with no effects used on it
PostPosted: Sun May 07, 2006 2:16 pm


You cannot counter a spell that is already being countered. That is why there is a stack, and why the last-in, first-out resoloution rule is in place.

as for best counterspell:
Absorb and suffocating blast.

Now before you tell me they suck (and the do) hear me out.

Sunforger.

That is all.

Skunch
Crew


sorrow89

PostPosted: Sun May 07, 2006 5:32 pm


Skunch
You cannot counter a spell that is already being countered. That is why there is a stack, and why the last-in, first-out resoloution rule is in place.

as for best counterspell:
Absorb and suffocating blast.

Now before you tell me they suck (and the do) hear me out.

Sunforger.

That is all.


they dont suck theyre fun to use, almost any card can be good in retrospect, everyone has their own opinion and thoughts and should be welcomed into an invironment that is open to everyone lol
PostPosted: Mon May 08, 2006 7:05 pm


sorrow89
Skunch
You cannot counter a spell that is already being countered. That is why there is a stack, and why the last-in, first-out resoloution rule is in place.

as for best counterspell:
Absorb and suffocating blast.

Now before you tell me they suck (and the do) hear me out.

Sunforger.

That is all.


they dont suck theyre fun to use, almost any card can be good in retrospect, everyone has their own opinion and thoughts and should be welcomed into an invironment that is open to everyone lol


You're right, they aren't terrible- at least absorb isn't. With Suffocating Blast, there HAS to be a creature in play. That can cause some issues.

Skunch
Crew


animedude_chu

PostPosted: Thu Jun 01, 2006 6:48 pm


froszen
id have to say rewind, purely for the fact that it works with so much els.
anything before those turns i would say force of will or daze. im also a fan of power sink, just because its more versatile and your aponent looses their mana if they dont pay the X.

in order id say
1 rewind
2 force of will
3 power sink
4 daze



i agree with the rewind only because it untaps 4 mana to recast another rewind or some other spells, like two counterspells afterwards.. its my personal favorite combo...
Reply
Card Discussion

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 6 7 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum