Welcome to Gaia! ::

The Gaian Summer WriMos Guild

Back to Guilds

Home of the Gaian Summer Writing Months, based off NaNoWriMo 

Tags: Writing, NaNo, Stories, Novels, Summer 

Reply SuWriMos 2009 Novels (Archive)
Kosmos: Genesis - Prologue posted! Feedback please! - Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

People Eater
  +1 (nom nom)
View Results

Psychotic Maniacal Sanity
Captain

Chatty Pumpkin

8,800 Points
  • Elocutionist 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Somebody Likes You 100
PostPosted: Thu Jun 25, 2009 4:54 am


.:The Artificial:.


Aha! I finally got around to reading your prologue. Sorry it took so long, I've been real busy recently. :3

Anyways:

Do the characters seem believable? As in, do they seem like real people?
I think Vladimir is particularly believeable so far. I thought he brushed off the threat of public danger quite quickly, but then his thoughts turned to his wife and it all made more sense. As for the other characters, there isn't really any way to tell yet since there hasn't been a great deal of interaction yet. I look forward to seeing more between Vladimir and the others with him, though.

Are the scene set-ups well developed or lacking?
At some points the scene can be a bit confusing to a sc-fi novice like me ( rolleyes XD) but more than anything I think it's because I just woke up. The conversation about M.A.G.I.C. was a little much in one go, but again, I think it's because I just woke up. =P

How does the dialogue flow? Well or clumsy?
Overall I thought the dialogue flowed really well. It seemed realistic, and that was a good part of the flow. =P One thing, though, it got a little confusing as to who was speaking in the middle. Again, it imght have been me, but I couldn't really work out who said "M.A.G.I.C." Was it Vladimir? Other than that, there were no problems. :3

Grammar and Spelling?
I wasn't really looking for anything like this, since often it disrupts how I read something if I'm trying to find errors. The only error I noticed whilst reading isn't grammar or spelling, but more like a word missed out, maybe?


Quote:
There are none wounded, and one-thousand three-hundred and thirty-four.

Should there be something after the second figure? Living, maybe? I dunno. XP

Word choices? Should it be more varied or are some words not needed?
I have to say, I really like your word choices. So, no.

What do you feel about the story? The characters? The setting?
I'm really enjoying it so far, even though it's not usually my kind of thing. I'm especially intrigued by the importance of this "Genocide" business, and the whole Cancer thing. =O I like the idea that his wife is dead (not to sound morbid, but it gives Vladimir that bit more realism I think). I look forward to it all.

Do you think you can predict the outcome of this story? If so elaborate.
I genuinely don't think I can. It might be because of my lack of experience with the genre, but I also think it's a bit early to tell what's going to happen anyway. =P

Lastly, are there any style tips you wish to share?
Nope, I like your style. :3


I hope that helps in some way. Like I said, I only just woke up so.... XD


.:Roboto:.
PostPosted: Thu Jun 25, 2009 5:15 am


She's in my blood, and like a fire inside me...


Yay! rofl Thank you so much, PMS! I'm glad you liked it.

@threat: Yeah, maybe he did brush it off a little too quickly...maybe I should add just about a sentence in there to clarify, because even though it evokes memories of his wife, he's still the leader of the galaxy. XD He should be a little calmer in that situation.

@M.A.G.I.C.: I was wondering if it would be information overload, but I'll wait and see if someone else makes a comment about it, since you were half aasleep while reading this. rofl

Thank you so much! smile And since I've finished DayhawK's first chapter, you're next on my list to give feedback to. biggrin

Consumes the air then leaves me blindly...

[.Snow.White.Queen.]

2,750 Points
  • Member 100
  • Dressed Up 200
  • Gaian 50

Psychotic Maniacal Sanity
Captain

Chatty Pumpkin

8,800 Points
  • Elocutionist 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Somebody Likes You 100
PostPosted: Thu Jun 25, 2009 5:26 am


.:The Artificial:.


You're welcome. I'm glad I could in some way help. And, I really do like it. :]

Ooooh, feedback. I'm not sure you want to do that, though: my story is baaaaaad. emo


.:Roboto:.
PostPosted: Thu Jul 02, 2009 7:46 pm


sorry this took me so long, oy my job is crazy. Anyways.

Do the characters seem believable? As in, do they seem like real people?
Well as of now they seem pretty flat, however Vladimir is shaping up nicely. The only thing is though is that I felt like he was fitting into too much of a steriotypical anti-hero/wolverine-meets-the guy from 24. So I would try to either give him more edge so that we see more anti than hero, or you give him more heart so that we see more hero than anti. If that made sense lo.
Are the scene set-ups well developed or lacking?
Hmmm well there seems to be a lot of background dump that, usually, prologues tend to leave out so that there is an heir of mystery. I wouls suggest that his disdain for religion be explained later, that there should be less of the wife plot and more into what they are doing right then, right now. Pretty much just focus on the main plot and let the sub plots enter a bit later.
How does the dialogue flow? Well or clumsy?
Some parts I found it to be interesting, others I felt were either not needed or just flat. Now flat doesn't mean that the words were flat, rather the way they were presented seemed too stilted. The first dialogue for example could have really been shortened and more impactful. hmmm let me try something:

"What were the casualties?" Vladimir asked the vigilent looking soldier projected by the video feed.

"It was my fault sir," he answered frantically, "It was a cargo ship, but I misjudged it sir. The logo, I thought, was a passenger's ship. Even the flight records afirmed it, saying it was going from Xiang to Ialu. But I errored in judgement."

"Mach, it's not your fault. Vaughn would have been on either ship, he knew how to do his job right. Come on, what's the count."

"Five-five hundred sir," he said, and for the first time, ever, Vladmir saw his soldier slightly twinge with remorese, "so far."

See how that was shorter and to the point but still affective? I don't know, really, if that stayed true to the characters, but it shows that it could have been less wordy and to the point.

Also the terms are quite confusing. Even if this ever gets published and you have a glossary, it still would be wise to explain what they stand for before giving the term, like M-A-G-I-C. PLus, even with the glossary, the reader would like to remember what it all stands for without having to referance all the time.

just a thought, I write sci-fi too and many people like it better when I give easier terminology.


Grammar and Spelling?
Oy...ugh geese I wish I could help more with this one. But my grammar-station is closing and the janitor is scrubbing the floors. Hopefully the squad will be back tomorrow. lol
Word choices? Should it be more varied or are some words not needed?
I would mix it up a bit with more flavorful words, more non-traditional. Like "and the screen disappeared" could be "causing the screen to evaporate". You can see the action of evaporating, sorta like a poof and its gone or the screen shrinking into nothing. With disapear there isn't a lot of how the screen went away. If that makes sense...lol.
What do you feel about the story? The characters? The setting?
Well I'm only connected with Vladmir and th others I dont really care about, however I wish I did. Usually, but this is just me, I like to get at least some glimpses of other characters' thoughts and not focusing too much on the MC. Like what is Torq thinking in all of this? Valkeri? Zhao? We know their praying, but what are they feeling? Also, as far as names go, some of them seem too mushed together. Vladmir, Valkeri, Vaughn. All with Vs and As, it gets a bit confusing.
Do you think you can predict the outcome of this story? If so elaborate.
Hmmm not quite yet, too early to tell. But Genocide doesn't look good.
Lastly, are there any style tips you wish to share?
Just spruce it up a bit, go with non-tradional things like making adgetives into verbs, or nouns into adgetives. It gets interesting, coming up with things like that.
Try to eliminated was, were, to be, had, and words like that. Instead of "She was smart," it could be "She beamed with intelligence,"

also, get and got and all its forms are clumsy words. For sirst person its not so bad, but for third it tends to sound uninspiring. Like "She got up and ran", "She jerked out of her chair and ran"


And well that's it! Cant wait for more, Im curious of where this is going.

DayhawK68
Crew

Romantic Hunter

7,950 Points
  • Forum Sophomore 300
  • Signature Look 250
  • Dressed Up 200

Jasper Riddle

PostPosted: Thu Jul 02, 2009 7:54 pm


I am completely and perfectly aware of how much my review is going to suck, but I read the chapter, like, a day after you put it up and I don't have the time to reread it now and give you a proper crit. I'll try and keep on top later ifwhen you post more.


I liked it, and would read this for fun.
PostPosted: Fri Jul 03, 2009 5:44 am


She's in my blood, and like a fire inside me...


@Dayhawk: Thank you so much. smile I'll try to keep that all in mind.

@Jasper: Haha. It's fine, and I'm glad you liked it. I'm going to try and read "Glitch" once things in my real life settle down a bit.

Consumes the air then leaves me blindly...

[.Snow.White.Queen.]

2,750 Points
  • Member 100
  • Dressed Up 200
  • Gaian 50
Reply
SuWriMos 2009 Novels (Archive)

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum