Welcome to Gaia! ::

lol true. I forgot that.

Well, Sonic is pretty soft on his opponents. Shads is semi-friendly and doesn't even want to kill. Yeah...but take that away, Shads would win, despite his immortality.

I'd vote Sonic. Shadow, Although everyone claims he is 50 years old, He's really only like... 4 at the very most. He was held in Cryogenic suspension, That is the reason for the 50 years, This gives time for his musles to somewhat deteriate, making him weaker. He's had some time to build it up, but Sonic's had alot more time.

Going by Experiance, Shadow has fought four times in his life. Sonic? Countless times.

Weapons: Shadow uses Guns. Sonic has been dodgeing bullets forever. There fore Shadow's weopons are near obsolete, Except he may be able to get a pistol whip in.

Sonic rarely has any trouble controlling himself in battle, while Shadow can be swayed either way with a blink of an eye.

Sonic has friends to support him, and only Omega may support Shadow. Rouge would side with Sonic, sence she knows Whatever Sonic's Cause is, It's for the best.

So all in all.... Tails wins! 3nodding

>> OR Sonic.

Should Sonic and Shadow ever fight to the death... I believe that {Insert random alien race here} would reanimate Maria. This "Zombie Maria" would then be able to distract Shadow long enough for either Sonic or herself to kill Shadow. Then Sonic.

Therefore~ tie.






And then the planet blows up.

Shadow Easily, you dont get the name 'Ulitmate life form' For no reason, Plus, his use of the Chaos Emeralds are a lot more effective

Why thank you
and to all of those who say shadows attacks are better and sonics are wimpy you are retards

1.They have more than two attacks

2.Attacks- Sonic has two or three super forms that have special attacks just for them(Sonic games over the years) shadow has no special in his one super form just his normal ones(Sa 2, Riders, STH)

3.Chaos control-Is teleportation so take the energy out of them positive and negative(SA) by having chaos around then turing sper both time would make shadow really weak he can't teleport and there are two sper powerful being coming at him oh snap:

Example: Super shadow vs. Hyper sonic and Chaos a god of water and destruction

4.If any of you played sonic rider and sonic heros you know that sonic and shadow have a boost attack and triangle jump but sonic is the only one with golden flash and he used one emerald to turn super and shadow the hedghog the game let me reinact some shadow responses
(welw DUSSD SHADOW BBQ UR MOMN HAHAH LOL SONIC SUKCS CAUSE SONICS WIND THINGY SUCKS OLOOLOLO!!!111 and shdow roks cuz he can do cAhocontol and Chas spER hahah ownage) now I may have lost brain cells during that writing but it proves that alot of you do not look at the big picture take every thing away form both of them rings friends and shadow armbands of power emralds plus shoes and sonics shoes and let them go at it shadow becomes slow sonic is still fast but he may chatch on fire shadow has no more powers sonic wind just come from sonics ability to run so fast he creates wind

All in all sonic wins on sheer physical skill plus he has had more practice than shadow in 15 year than shad has had in 50(That rhymed yay rofl )

Ok He is not 50 ok jeez. BUT you said "He was alive for one, frozen, then set free by Eggman. He's only 2 to 4 years old."
So he died in suspended animation And that is why he could not age hmmm. I still belive he has been alive for 50 years bu thas not aged for many of those 50 years. 50 Litteraly 3-4 cronilogically

And on your second note SA2 is not the only game where people have moves also all you point are based off of SA2 name a few more games besides that one and weigh the pros and cons