Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply The Abortion Debate Guild
I don't get it... Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Diadema

PostPosted: Mon Dec 20, 2004 1:16 pm


Xanaphia00
Diadema
Mistress DragonFlame
Diadema
MistressDragonFlame
Just like there is no factual evidence that a glob of gook inside me is a baby.


Would you be so kind as to define "glob of gook"?


Glob: a bunch of, a cluster, usually having to deal with something that is wet or moist.

of: belonging to, realted.

Gook: not really anything yet. Could be the begining of a dinosuar, could be a new plague, but all it currently is, is a bunch (see glob) of cells.

3nodding Need anything esle explained?

Yeah. Why do you think that pro-lifers don't care about women after they've had abortions or after they've had the baby? Pro-lifers are actively involved in crisis pregnancies and other difficult child-raising situations. There is a program called The Rachel Ministries for abortion after-care that pro-lifers have created. Pro-lifers are actively involved in helping unwanted children and the other "disposable people" in this world. It's abortion providers who don't provide help for women choosing anything other than abortion.


Have you heard of Planned Parenthood? it is an "abortion provider" that provides other services and even the alternative to abortion as well. The provide prenatal care at lost costs, adoption referrals, pregnancy test, contraceptives and other medical care for women (mostly).

Most "Abortion centers" must legally lay out every option for the women, give her counseling, and make her wait a certain amount of time before having an abortion.

Except they kinda don't. I know that at some abortion centers, they'll take any pro-life literature out of the woman's hand when she walks in the door. I know the doctors sometimes say that, 'abortion is the only option,' and I've never heard of abortions centers waiting at all. All I've heard of is teenagers coming in, maybe having to wait a day because the procedure takes that long, and coming out.
PostPosted: Mon Dec 20, 2004 1:18 pm


Scion_Of_Balance
Diadema
True, we're all products of conception, we're all blobs of cells. As dehumanizing as that is, it's true.

I'm an adolescent, my little brother is a toddler. My friend's sister is a fetus. They're all just different names for different developmental stages for the same person, the same human.


the fingernail I have just bitten off is human, human means nothing, person however has an influence on abortion
The fingernail you just bit off has human DNA, yes, but is not a human. Let's nope we can distinguish that.

However, the baby is a human. Not part of a human, a human. Person and human are fairly synonomous in this particular argument.

Diadema


Veled

Quotable Conventioneer

8,000 Points
  • Person of Interest 200
  • Conventioneer 300
  • Forum Sophomore 300
PostPosted: Mon Dec 20, 2004 3:28 pm


Diadema
Xanaphia00

Have you heard of Planned Parenthood? it is an "abortion provider" that provides other services and even the alternative to abortion as well. The provide prenatal care at lost costs, adoption referrals, pregnancy test, contraceptives and other medical care for women (mostly).

Most "Abortion centers" must legally lay out every option for the women, give her counseling, and make her wait a certain amount of time before having an abortion.

Except they kinda don't. I know that at some abortion centers, they'll take any pro-life literature out of the woman's hand when she walks in the door. I know the doctors sometimes say that, 'abortion is the only option,' and I've never heard of abortions centers waiting at all. All I've heard of is teenagers coming in, maybe having to wait a day because the procedure takes that long, and coming out.


Sources? This doesn't seem like more than propaganda...
PostPosted: Mon Dec 20, 2004 4:38 pm


Sources: My own experience in front of abortion clinics.
The experiences of other sidewalk counselors.

Diadema


Lelas

PostPosted: Mon Dec 20, 2004 4:52 pm


Veled
Diadema
Xanaphia00

Have you heard of Planned Parenthood? it is an "abortion provider" that provides other services and even the alternative to abortion as well. The provide prenatal care at lost costs, adoption referrals, pregnancy test, contraceptives and other medical care for women (mostly).

Most "Abortion centers" must legally lay out every option for the women, give her counseling, and make her wait a certain amount of time before having an abortion.

Except they kinda don't. I know that at some abortion centers, they'll take any pro-life literature out of the woman's hand when she walks in the door. I know the doctors sometimes say that, 'abortion is the only option,' and I've never heard of abortions centers waiting at all. All I've heard of is teenagers coming in, maybe having to wait a day because the procedure takes that long, and coming out.
Sources? This doesn't seem like more than propaganda...
Not to mention the fact that an abortion doesn't take longer than maybe ten minutes.

The counseling may take a bit longer, however.

And also, I've found that it is much more common for U.S. clinics to bombard women with guilt trips, than for them to act like abortion is the only option.

There is an abortion clinic in my state, the only one I know of, and its website assures that the clinic provides counseling and dicussion of alternatives. http://www.wa-wc.com/services.htm

But that's just what I've heard. Of course, since you, Diadema, are a pro-lifer, you have heard differently. Propoganda, most of it--on both sides.
PostPosted: Tue Dec 21, 2004 7:34 pm


Diadema
Mistress DragonFlame
Diadema
MistressDragonFlame
Just like there is no factual evidence that a glob of gook inside me is a baby.


Would you be so kind as to define "glob of gook"?


Glob: a bunch of, a cluster, usually having to deal with something that is wet or moist.

of: belonging to, realted.

Gook: not really anything yet. Could be the begining of a dinosuar, could be a new plague, but all it currently is, is a bunch (see glob) of cells.

3nodding Need anything esle explained?

Yeah. Why do you think that pro-lifers don't care about women after they've had abortions or after they've had the baby? Pro-lifers are actively involved in crisis pregnancies and other difficult child-raising situations. There is a program called The Rachel Ministries for abortion after-care that pro-lifers have created. Pro-lifers are actively involved in helping unwanted children and the other "disposable people" in this world. It's abortion providers who don't provide help for women choosing anything other than abortion.


I have never heard of any child-rearing care provided by Pro-life people only. My Aunt, a pro-lifer sadly, has three kids and is just above the 'poor' line. If there was something to help her children in our area, she would have found it. But there isn't, so I base my facts off of that; not something I have never heard of before, nor had the knowlage of its existance. (did I repeat myself there?)

Mistress DragonFlame

Wealthy Werewolf

8,950 Points
  • Brandisher 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Full closet 200

Mistress DragonFlame

Wealthy Werewolf

8,950 Points
  • Brandisher 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Full closet 200
PostPosted: Tue Dec 21, 2004 7:37 pm


Pandali
Quote:
Glob: a bunch of, a cluster, usually having to deal with something that is wet or moist.

of: belonging to, realted.

Gook: not really anything yet. Could be the begining of a dinosuar, could be a new plague, but all it currently is, is a bunch (see glob) of cells.

Need anything esle explained?


So, we are globs of gook too then? We're a bunch of cells, are we not? And everything is something, otherwise it would be nothing. So a "glob of gook" is a something. Aside to that, you have never actually specified what you are refering to as a "glob of gook."


No, as you see: 'gook' isn't anything yet. We are fully developed and are also not normally 'glob', since we are not wet in that sence.

And I said it was a glob of cells, not really forming anything solid, or set, yet.

I was refering to the potential child; give or take an incubation of 7 or more months.
PostPosted: Tue Dec 21, 2004 7:40 pm


Diadema
True, we're all products of conception, we're all blobs of cells. As dehumanizing as that is, it's true.

I'm an adolescent, my little brother is a toddler. My friend's sister is a fetus. They're all just different names for different developmental stages for the same person, the same human.


You can not dishumanize humans, as we are the lowest creaters already. You would be contemplenting them if you dishumanize them. At least, to my thinking. And yes, I do realize I am human, sadly.

It isn't a sister until it's born. And if we're all the same, then why the hell are we arguing with ourselves?

Mistress DragonFlame

Wealthy Werewolf

8,950 Points
  • Brandisher 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Full closet 200

Mistress DragonFlame

Wealthy Werewolf

8,950 Points
  • Brandisher 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Full closet 200
PostPosted: Tue Dec 21, 2004 7:45 pm


Diadema
Xanaphia00
Diadema
Mistress DragonFlame
Diadema
MistressDragonFlame
Just like there is no factual evidence that a glob of gook inside me is a baby.


Would you be so kind as to define "glob of gook"?


Glob: a bunch of, a cluster, usually having to deal with something that is wet or moist.

of: belonging to, realted.

Gook: not really anything yet. Could be the begining of a dinosuar, could be a new plague, but all it currently is, is a bunch (see glob) of cells.

3nodding Need anything esle explained?

Yeah. Why do you think that pro-lifers don't care about women after they've had abortions or after they've had the baby? Pro-lifers are actively involved in crisis pregnancies and other difficult child-raising situations. There is a program called The Rachel Ministries for abortion after-care that pro-lifers have created. Pro-lifers are actively involved in helping unwanted children and the other "disposable people" in this world. It's abortion providers who don't provide help for women choosing anything other than abortion.


Have you heard of Planned Parenthood? it is an "abortion provider" that provides other services and even the alternative to abortion as well. The provide prenatal care at lost costs, adoption referrals, pregnancy test, contraceptives and other medical care for women (mostly).

Most "Abortion centers" must legally lay out every option for the women, give her counseling, and make her wait a certain amount of time before having an abortion.

Except they kinda don't. I know that at some abortion centers, they'll take any pro-life literature out of the woman's hand when she walks in the door. I know the doctors sometimes say that, 'abortion is the only option,' and I've never heard of abortions centers waiting at all. All I've heard of is teenagers coming in, maybe having to wait a day because the procedure takes that long, and coming out.


Of course they take it out! It's goes to say that abortion is murder, and she just walked into that place! It'd be like, I dunno, going into a jewish temple with a christan bible and start reading it in the waiting room. stressed

And they probably have an apointment. Ever think of that?
PostPosted: Tue Dec 21, 2004 7:47 pm


Diadema
Sources: My own experience in front of abortion clinics.
The experiences of other sidewalk counselors.


OK, please explain how you 'counsel' people going into the clinics. ~sits back into a chair~ This outta be good...

Mistress DragonFlame

Wealthy Werewolf

8,950 Points
  • Brandisher 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Full closet 200

Pandali

PostPosted: Thu Dec 23, 2004 8:06 pm


Quote:
No, as you see: 'gook' isn't anything yet. We are fully developed and are also not normally 'glob', since we are not wet in that sence.

And I said it was a glob of cells, not really forming anything solid, or set, yet.

I was refering to the potential child; give or take an incubation of 7 or more months.




I'm afraid this is where you haven't researched enough. It is a proven, scientific fact that a fetus is a living human being, not a glob of gook.
PostPosted: Thu Dec 23, 2004 10:52 pm


Pandali
Quote:
No, as you see: 'gook' isn't anything yet. We are fully developed and are also not normally 'glob', since we are not wet in that sence.

And I said it was a glob of cells, not really forming anything solid, or set, yet.

I was refering to the potential child; give or take an incubation of 7 or more months.


I'm afraid this is where you haven't researched enough. It is a proven, scientific fact that a fetus is a living human being, not a glob of gook.


True, and a chicken egg yoke is a glob of gook too when exposed, and it is scientifically proven to be a living chick. That doesn't stop it from being a glob of gook.

Also, I once (Wow, I almost spelled once with a 'w'. o.O) watched a program where they took the brain of a late 2nd early 3rd trimester quail and chicken chicks and switched them to see what would happen. Both the animals developed characteristics of the other spesiese, dispite their DNA and parents. whee So it is not really set as anything.

Mistress DragonFlame

Wealthy Werewolf

8,950 Points
  • Brandisher 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Full closet 200

Pandali

PostPosted: Sat Dec 25, 2004 8:43 am


Chicken eggs are different. Most have not been fertilized and so are not live chicks. That is why they do not apply to this case and are not substantial evidence for your argument.
PostPosted: Tue Dec 28, 2004 4:46 pm


Pandali
Chicken eggs are different. Most have not been fertilized and so are not live chicks. That is why they do not apply to this case and are not substantial evidence for your argument.


In case with human eggs. Most are not fertialized, and are ejected from the body every month or so. But, there will every so often, compaired to the amount of un fertailized ones, will be one that is fertailized that is forcibly ejected. Just because it's rare doesn't mean it doesn't happen. So yes, it is the same. And, we don't eat the eggs we bleed out. domokun Unless you're taking a bath and a partical goes into your mouth or something, but that's just discusting. gonk

Mistress DragonFlame

Wealthy Werewolf

8,950 Points
  • Brandisher 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Full closet 200

Grip of Death

PostPosted: Wed Dec 29, 2004 12:05 am


Pandali
Quote:
No, as you see: 'gook' isn't anything yet. We are fully developed and are also not normally 'glob', since we are not wet in that sence.

And I said it was a glob of cells, not really forming anything solid, or set, yet.

I was refering to the potential child; give or take an incubation of 7 or more months.




I'm afraid this is where you haven't researched enough. It is a proven, scientific fact that a fetus is a living human being, not a glob of gook.


LOL, you have to excuse me, the whole "glob of gook" name is funny. Also, Ms. Pandali's post here was funny. xd (I guess it's the whole seriousness applied to a silly-willy name)... um... no offense. *off topic*

...

Back on topic!

Okey Dokey, I don't think any pro-choicer is saying that it ISN'T human. Yes, it CERTAINLY has human DNA. Yes, it certainly isn't a monkey, or an elephant growing in there. I think what is being contested is personhood. Yes, that definition is a bit subjective, isn't it? But, you see, some elements of personhood involve consciousness, sentience, the ability to feel, etc. There is a big difference between "something" containing human dna, and that same "something" actually containing self-awareness. Hold your horses, I'll explain more in a little bit.

I think MistressDragonflame's emphasis on the word "glob of gook" described her conclusions about a first-trimester embryo/fetus (of which 91% of abortions are performed at that stage). It doesn't think. It doesn't feel. While I may be underemphasizing some parts of development in my conclusion- it's little more than a mass collection of cells. I find it ridiculous that that tiny little mass of cells is supposedly of more worth than... me. Furthermore, I find it absolutely bat-s**t insane that some people think that one cell made from a conception is supposedly worth more than me. Me, a multi-celled, eukaryotic, sentient organism that has experienced consciousness for over 2 decades.

...Because all in all, whether we like to think about it or not, a decision for the fetus, or for the woman is made. You can value both forms of life if you so desire, but both forms of life arn't going to get the equal treatment, or equal rights here.
Reply
The Abortion Debate Guild

Goto Page: [] [<] 1 2 3 ... 4 5 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum