Welcome to Gaia! ::

Fire Emblem Forever

Back to Guilds

Together We Ride! 

Tags: Fire Emblem, Roleplay, Nintendo, Video Games, Anime 

Reply Plot, Character & Pairing Discussion Forum
Best/Worst in the Series Revamped Round 44 Goto Page: [] [<<] [<] 1 2 3 ... 9 10 11 12 13 14 ... 37 38 39 40 [>] [>>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

ThePersonInFrontOfYou

Wheezing Wench

PostPosted: Mon Jul 08, 2013 12:15 am


Manic Martini

Johan>>>>>Johalva because horses in FE4, but I'm not going to hold that against Johalva. It'd be like saying FE7 Karel is bad because getting Karel means not getting Harken, and Harken>Karel. Harken is definitely better, but that doesn't necessarily make Karel bad. Standard infantry movement is better than a Knight's movement, and you KNOW you use people with the same movement as him like Lakche and Shanan and such. Definitely not good, but I don't think he's too bad.

It's true. No one should give great units like Lakche or Shanan the shaft because they aren't mounted. We're not talking armor knights anymore. They're super good, and still able to move around, more worth the extra oomph. It's the choice that does make me leery of Johalva in addition to his horseless feet because of the game itself. Harken may be better than Karel, but in that case I'd say that the gap between them isn't as big. They're both fine, and can do similar jobs. Not to mention the choice isn't as conscious, unless you are trying to micromanage FE7 with behind-the-scenes things which I unfortunately did a while ago and was frustrated as hell doing it, but that's more opinion and I don't want my army and leveling choices to revolve around recruiting one guy. The choice between the two brothers in FE4 is right in front of you. No matter what you do before, during, or after, you have to put in a little extra to get a unit that won't serve you as well.
PostPosted: Mon Jul 08, 2013 7:03 am


I will admit, I was a bit confused about why we're talking about Axe Knight in this week topic, which it's about Fighter/Warrior because it made me feel like we're comparing apples and oranges. sweatdrop

But anyway... Not going to give my vote yet, but I will give my vote once my day off comes.

Jisen Meizuki
Crew

Stubborn Gifter


Nomad Rath
Vice Captain

Dedicated Guildsman

PostPosted: Mon Jul 08, 2013 10:18 am


Because basically, you're choosing whether to get an axe fighter or an axe knight. They're both there on the map for you to recruit, but the game only lets you take one. And then makes the other look like a d**k...
PostPosted: Mon Jul 08, 2013 1:09 pm


Nomad Rath
Because basically, you're choosing whether to get an axe fighter or an axe knight. They're both there on the map for you to recruit, but the game only lets you take one. And then makes the other look like a d**k...


Yeah...trying to kill your brother over Laeche/Radney is kinda being a d**k, putting is VERY mildly.

Chaotic Houndoom


Ninja Ryu11

Friendly Seeker

9,025 Points
  • Treasure Hunter 100
  • Autobiographer 200
  • Peoplewatcher 100
PostPosted: Sat Jul 13, 2013 2:07 am


I've been thinking about it for a pretty long while about this topic here so I thought I'd put my two cents on this week's topic.

Best: This is a really tough one for me. I've come between Othlin and Nolan. Both are great fighters in their own rights. Othlin is probably the best fighter imo you can get in FE5. He comes with the wrath skill and the special pugi axe which is pretty much a throwing killer axe of death to those that come in his way. xD Totally a great idea to give him Ambush to make him a monster. lol

And if for some reason you'd want to recruit Xavier(Which is extremely tedious to do), he's a pretty good candidate to use as a meatshield to keep those armors distracted. Due to that good build, speed, enough defense to take hits and all..

Nolan on the other hand is a great fighter too. And likewise one of the best fighters I've used in the game and one of the better members of the dawn brigade. But I'm going to have to give it to Othlin for this one. He's just a bloody murderer with that special Pugi axe of his. And FE5 is a game where having good build is a very good thing in so many situations. And of course it's also a game where capturing the enemies weapons is important, and he does it relatively well. He has a greater chance to capture because of the Pugi axe. Which has around 60 uses! His others stats are pretty darn solid too.


Worst: I think I might be the indifferent one in that I feel like Johalva isn't the worst here. He's not great, but I don't think he's that bad. Sure, I mean Johan might be the better one to choose because he has a mount. Though, Johalva does get bows upon promotion and he can at least fight somewhat with the hero axe. I think he at least has some merit to him, you do actually get Nosferatu for Julia if you choose him. And it's a nice tome to have instead of getting Aura in my personal opinion. -shrugs-

With that said, I'm gonna have to give the worst to Wade from FE6. You only get either Lot or Wade as fighters. I suppose like Dorcas and Barte in a sense.. Axes isn't very good in this game for starters. Probably as best axe users you might get is either Geese or Gonzales but that's really it. The problem with Wade is that he gets doubled very easily. Lot actually can get pretty decent speed even his bases is a heck of a lot better than wade. He only has good strength, luck, and okay skill. If you were going to use him, you'd need to give him some speedwings but that doesn't really help him all that much... He won't be able to double many enemies even with that extra boost.
PostPosted: Sat Jul 13, 2013 2:54 pm


Best: Nolan
Worst: Wade

Nomad Rath
Vice Captain

Dedicated Guildsman


Manic Martini

PostPosted: Sun Jul 14, 2013 7:59 am


Put me down for Nolan as Best as well
PostPosted: Sun Jul 14, 2013 8:23 am


Well, you got your vote in time FD. Glad to see you did.

This weeks topic is: Final Boss

Chaotic Houndoom


Nomad Rath
Vice Captain

Dedicated Guildsman

PostPosted: Sun Jul 14, 2013 11:14 am


Best: Ashera

I don't think I've had more fun fighting a final boss than I did with Ashera, so it's a shame that I absolutely HATE the ideology that the game tries to push on us at the end with "we don't need a god" because all they do is hurt us. Really, Ike? You think you're so deep and wise for saying that? Way to insult nearly the entire world with just a few words. Go home. And nobody better even think of telling me that the game isn't trying to say that. Ashera wasn't even a villain, but the game paints her in this horrific image where apparently we need to kill her even though she didn't do anything wrong- and the game doesn't even admit that she didn't. It was ******** Sephiran lying and manipulating things without even a good reason. Well, at least we defeat him- DID THAT THING JUST RECRUIT HIMSELF ONTO OUR ENDGAME TEAM?? You think a last minute 'what have I done?' is going to make us squee and accept him and his awesome stave? I just. Hate. It.

That said, the battle itself is intensely fun. Every single one of my units had a purpose. Some were on spirit reinforcement duty, others on ridding the surrounding guardians, others on Ashera herself to make sure Ike can finish her. I absolutely love when I can utilize my team to the best of their ability.

With FD, it was basically the main lords and Athos that could do significant damage. And he doesn't move, and there's no other enemies that are really of any concern. You don't have to move.. just stay out of range and you're fine forever. Attack, rescue, drop, heal, dance, attack, rescue, drop, heal... repeat. It wasn't very fun for me, honestly.... but I did love the atmosphere and hype of it all. If FD had the power to lift his legs and walk (u fatty)... he'd be a horrifyingly fun boss. Because then... you'd actually have to MOVE down that long bridge passageway and deal with the enemies with the status staves. Like.... it just seems like common sense that FD should have been able to move.

Grima is an awesome idea, but I am not a fan of fighting my evil twin as the final boss....... I'd much rather fight the dragon form. And you don't get to keep the exp from the chapter, so there's that middle finger as well. I love the choice we get to make, of course, and fighting on a dragon's back is something cool that FE has never done before. (..how are we able to stay on? Beats me.) I just think that there's either too much tedious reinforcement killing work or it's too easy to use those little tricks that FD knows with staves and stuff in order to beat him fast.

Ashnard makes you piss your pants, but let's face it, only Ike and maybe your laguz royal can do s**t to him.

Julius reserves a special place of awesome in the FE history books, but doesn't allow me to utilize my units the same way Ashera does.

Worst: Idoun. And it still miffs me how much of a joke it is to fight her.

I don't know my FE5 yet, so idk who this Veld dude is, womp womp.
PostPosted: Sun Jul 14, 2013 12:29 pm


Best: Grima. The whole situation and fight is just fun.
Worst: Medeus. Boring and easy to kill. I know there are difficulty levels for both Shadow Dragon and Awakening, but Medeus is pretty easy for the most part. Shadow Dragon was actually pretty boring for me anyway ..

DazedClarity

Supreme Flatterer

9,500 Points
  • Flatterer 200
  • Supreme Supporter 500
  • Battle: Mage 100

Grimalkenkid

Dedicated Gekko

11,550 Points
  • Timid 100
  • Grunny Rainbow 100
  • Jack-pot 100
PostPosted: Sun Jul 14, 2013 1:16 pm


Best: Fire Dragon
I almost couldn't decide between the Fire Dragon from FE7 or Ashnard, but the Dragon won me over for a few reasons. One, the Fire Dragon has an attack range of 3, which ensures that anyone who attacks is going to get countered. It also makes it risky to have someone go up to heal the attacker, as the healer is also in danger of being attacked. Two, you don't even know how much HP the Fire Dragon has initially and it's a lot more than Ashnard has. I ended up chipping away at the Fire Dragon's health, hoping that the weapons I was using wouldn't break before I could kill it. Last, even with healers using physic, I spammed the rescue mechanic to get my characters out of range since I couldn't heal everyone in one round.
Ultimately, I just felt like the Fire Dragon was a bigger threat, where even one slip-up would result in a game over. (But I still think Ashnard's theme is more epic.)

Worst: Idoun
I just finished FE6, and it took me 3 rounds to beat the Final chapter. And that was just to get Roy close enough to strike. Idoun went down after Roy got a double attack on her with the Sword of Seals. It was so anti-climatic that I groaned when I saw the battle forecast.
It doesn't help that she has such low movement (though I don't know if she moves or not) and only a 1-range attack. Even if she had more HP, it would still be easy to use 2-range Divine Weapons to attack without incurring any risk of losing the attacking character. Ultimately, I didn't feel that Idoun was any threat whatsoever. I was more worried about the War Dragon reinforcements than I was about her.
PostPosted: Sun Jul 14, 2013 1:18 pm


Best: Julius, badass mofo who vomits a dragon out of his mouth after his defeat, which is of course so badass that the game crashes shortly afterwards. Granted his fight is kind of one way: 1.) Julia destroys him forever and ever, or 2.) Daisy or Patty put him to sleep with the Sleep Sword forever and ever for Celice to play with, it sure is a journey to get to him. Not to mention he has the twelve warlords, a dark cult, his girlfriend, and her bitchy mother protecting him, which gives the feeling that Julius is not one of those boring, easy macho final bosses who think they can do everything alone (which he probably could anyway), and paints the picture of the remaining remnants of the Grandbell Empire in their last, frantic stand against the Prince of Light.

Worst: Veld- That one guy who stones Evayle, goes away for 95% of the game, only to reappear as the final boss before getting pegged in one hit by Sety spaghetti? Whoever's idea it was to install automated electric doors in his safe spot needs to be shot.

The Lolwut Pear

Mega Fatcat

12,650 Points
  • Invisibility 100
  • Megathread 100
  • Elocutionist 200

ThePersonInFrontOfYou

Wheezing Wench

PostPosted: Sun Jul 14, 2013 1:36 pm


Best: Ashera. She's a bit more involved than your average FE final boss. The fact that she comes with her counter-attacking auras and the need to be beaten down but not to zero (unless you are Ike), helps distinguish her more from the crowd and put in a little extra thinking.

Worst: Going with Idoun for now. I have yet to beat FE6, but I saw a friend of mine go through the final chapter a while back. Roy of all people should not be able to end her in one turn.
PostPosted: Sun Jul 14, 2013 9:03 pm


Best: Ashera.

I want to put Fire Dragon and Julius for this SOOOO badly, but they're unfortunately pushovers by comparison. Julius is a total badass, but unfortunately, Naga existing prevents him from claiming this title. And Luna is a thing in FE7, and Athos is a person. 'Nuff said.

Worst: Veld.

One of very few negative consequences of being a midquel.

Manic Martini


Chaotic Houndoom

PostPosted: Sun Jul 21, 2013 10:14 am


Well looks like a dragon can't beat a goddess...I'm not sure if you guys will get that.

This weeks topic is: Myrmidon/Swordmaster
Reply
Plot, Character & Pairing Discussion Forum

Goto Page: [] [<<] [<] 1 2 3 ... 9 10 11 12 13 14 ... 37 38 39 40 [>] [>>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum