Welcome to Gaia! ::

The question is simple, which one of these do you like better?
(They're grouped)

Trapper or BJ?

Frank or Charles?

Henry or Potter?

You don't have to answer for all three groupings, but give a small (one sentence at least) explanation for why that character was better than the other one?

I likel BJ Charles and potter much better then the people they replaced But henry was pretty good

tell ya what ... i'll answer all three mrgreen


Trapper or BJ? BJ, no doubt about it. he was not only a great character because of his family back home, but he was also a great character because he was one of the few people who could out-prank hawkeye!!!! 3nodding

Frank or Charles? my vote goes for Mr. Charles Emmerson Winchester the III. wink he had a hard time trying to get out from under frank's reputation ... not to mention he was a lot better in the OR. *besides ... i hated feret face with a burning passion* twisted

Henry or Potter? this one is tough ... both of the CO's were awesome ... but i have to say that potter was more endearing and a generally more enjoyable character. no one else could have made saying "horse hocky" funnier mrgreen

Henry or Potter? While I don't dislike Henry, Potter's my favorite. He was kind and understanding, yet he wouldn't take any nonsense. (And the fact that he's from the same state I am can't be overlooked) wink

I like BJ. I don't really know why, but I think he and Hawkeye make a better team than Trapper and Hawkeye. I also agree with Vampire Alice. He has a nice voice, and is loyal to his wife, 'cept for one episode...

Well, I have to say Frank, because I haven't seen any episodes with Charles yet. I think that's going to change though, from what my Dad and sister say.

I like Potter more. He has a little more control over some parts of the 4077th, but he also gets along with Hawkeye and BJ very well. xD And he doesn't seem to like Frank.

I perfer BJ to Trapper because of BJ's sensitivity. BJ seems like the kind of guy you would want to marry and have scads of kids with. I also really like his sense of humor.

I perfer Charles to Frank because Charles is a much deeper character. Frank is a sniveling farret face. Charles is a pompas windbag with a heart of gold, sort of like a Gobstopper.

I perfer Potter to Henry because of how good of a leader Potter was. Don't get me wrong, Henry was a good man. The first time I saw "Abysyanara" when Henry was supposed to go home but tragically died, I cried my eyes out. Potter is just such a caring person who takes a genuine interest in everyone's well fare and works damn hard to make things great. Besides, who can not enjoy the Potterisms?

Cow cookies!
IEditYourWorld

I can't choose between Trap and B.J. They both brought a lot of happiness to my life.

Frank or Charles? Hummmm.........
Well, they both annoyed me in different ways, Frank with his prejudice towards Koreans and his overbearing, dictatorial nature; Charles with his condescending and pompous personality.

Of course, Charles had a definite warm, loving side that he showed as the months went by. One thing after another changed him, altered him; the time he went to the a batallion aid station close to the front lines to stare death in the face, and wound up talking to a soldier as he slipped away, the time he stood in the O.R. while a patient (a North Korean) threatened everyone with a live grenade, the time he fought the pencil pushers in the Army for a Korean baby's chance to go to America and have a better life, it all wound up having a humanizing affect on him.



I'll have to pick Charles as a favorite.




Blake or Potter? They were both lovable in their own special ways. No comment.

I love BJ. XD He has some really nice emotional moments, way more than Trapper had, though I will give you that Trapper's more attractive. But BJ had some cute little slashy moments with Mulcahy, so.....winner: BJ.

I'm fond of guys with hair. Though Winchester gets points for DOS playing someone in Myst 5: End of Ages....still, Frank is Frank is Frank, he's got the most unbelievable blue eyes, and he's the second-best character in the show next to Mulcahy, (plus Charles is bald and bald people traumatize me) so...winner: Frank. biggrin

Henry and Potter is a toughie. I haven't seen as many eps with Henry, though the ones I've seen are amusing. XD; Plus, dorky always scores points in my book. So I guess winner: Henry.

YAYE.