Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply Anita Blake Guild
Anita Blake...the Movie? Goto Page: 1 2 3 ... 4 5 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Coconut_Rei

PostPosted: Thu Sep 23, 2004 1:16 pm


I've heard from various websites and whispers from Anita Blake fans that people are dicussing with LKH of turning Anita Blake into movies (Whether they'd pull a Vampire Chronicles and only do some or go until it's too much (IE: basically until the aurder arrives)..). I don't know if it's true but has anybody else heard such things?

And do you wish for them to turn into movies?

And I can't remember if this was talked about on the guild or not, but I hope not o_o; Repeat topics are just......evil.
PostPosted: Thu Sep 23, 2004 7:16 pm


I'd love to see an AB movie, or anime. ^^ There's no way it could ever be a TV series here, and I think that if it became a movie, alot of the book fans would get disapointed with the changes they'd have to make. But, with the recent advances in computer animation, I think they could pull off the amazing effects they'd need.

If it was an anime, hell, anything goes. ^^ I think they could really do it justice, and stay true to the mood of it. Or, they could completely butcher it. One or the other. ^^;;;

Sikona


Rimbe

PostPosted: Fri Sep 24, 2004 6:23 pm


I don't want it to be turned into a movie. I know this sounds-- uh-- stupid in an Anita Blake topic, but I don't want them to butcher it with some slutty lead/overly pretty Anita/bad cast/bad acting. Let's face it-- Anita is bait for shitty sci-fi directing. (*cough*Underworld*cough*)

Sorry, it's just.. there have been too many great books that I have grown to dislike after seeing their movie recreations.

I swear, if I ever get published, I would never-ever-ever let anyone make a movie off my books. x_x

(Have any of you read Anne McCaffrey's Pern books? A couple of years ago WB began making a Pern television series-- but McCaffrey had it killed off because they were trying to make a Xena-Lessa. Dear god. xd )
PostPosted: Sat Sep 25, 2004 2:08 am


Rimbe
I don't want it to be turned into a movie. I know this sounds-- uh-- stupid in an Anita Blake topic, but I don't want them to butcher it with some slutty lead/overly pretty Anita/bad cast/bad acting. Let's face it-- Anita is bait for shitty sci-fi directing. (*cough*Underworld*cough*)

Sorry, it's just.. there have been too many great books that I have grown to dislike after seeing their movie recreations.

I swear, if I ever get published, I would never-ever-ever let anyone make a movie off my books. x_x

(Have any of you read Anne McCaffrey's Pern books? A couple of years ago WB began making a Pern television series-- but McCaffrey had it killed off because they were trying to make a Xena-Lessa. Dear god. xd )


I totally agree with you. Movie studio's have butchered many page-to-screen projects and they just want to make it the next big thing that'll draw crowds by adding s**t they don't need and taking important stuff out. They want to make a profit over staying respectful to the original text.

Same for me if I'm published - unless I can have a big say on the movie and seeing as I'm training in performing arts and have done film and tv studies and scriptwriting as part of it, I don't see why I shouldn't be able to!!

Elisabeth Braddock

Dapper Exhibitionist


Narniakat
Vice Captain

PostPosted: Sat Sep 25, 2004 11:44 am


I would love to see an Anita Blake movie if it was as true to the books as the first two Harry Potter movies were.
PostPosted: Sat Sep 25, 2004 5:15 pm


Narniakat
I would love to see an Anita Blake movie if it was as true to the books as the first two Harry Potter movies were.



Err, probably not the best statement. None of the Harry Potter movies have been terribly true to the books. There are holes that somene who's read the books would know and somene who's just seen the movie would be going, "huh?"
Kind of like the Lord of the Ring movies too.

FenrisVollmond

Aged Citizen


Neko_Kitsuni

PostPosted: Sat Sep 25, 2004 5:27 pm


FenrisVollmond
Narniakat
I would love to see an Anita Blake movie if it was as true to the books as the first two Harry Potter movies were.



Err, probably not the best statement. None of the Harry Potter movies have been terribly true to the books. There are holes that somene who's read the books would know and somene who's just seen the movie would be going, "huh?"
Kind of like the Lord of the Ring movies too.


Yup.

There are a lot of character descrepencies, which I find to be the most irritating point between movie and book.

For instance, I had a friend who hated the Lord of the Rings movies because of the fact that Faramir was tempted by the Ring in the films, and not in the books.
If you read the Harry Potter books, Hermione is much more extreme in her... particular attitude quirks.

However, I have to say, I thoroughly enjoyed the Lord of the Rings movies and thought (for the most part) that the editing didn't hurt the film. I was slightly less enamoured of the Potter films, but still, I thought they were decent movies. My concern is if the Anita movie(s) turned out like the Vampire Chronicles.

For those who haven't read the books and seen the movies...
Interview with the Vampire was decent, though Tom Cruise as Lestat was strange. Queen of the Damned, on the other hand, was the world's most thorough butchering of a book series ever. They tried desperately to cram two books into one film, and in the process deleted certain characters, left extreme holes in the plot, and made bizarre changes to the characters. Stuart Townsend and Aaliyah had amazing performances, but Antonio Banderes in a bad wig as Armand the cherub boy?
scream *shudders*

Anyway, to get to the poiht... an Anita film would really be hit and miss, depending on who worked on it. It has a lot of potential, but at the same time... think of all the things that they could screw up...
PostPosted: Sat Sep 25, 2004 11:37 pm


Oh, hell. You guys are so negative. Please god, not ALL vampire books-made-movies turn out horrible. Queen of the Damned was actually a good movie(in itself..I thought), just a horrible representation of the chronicals.

Do you REALLY think a woman such as Laurell K. Hamilton would let someone butcher the s**t out of her book? I'd put money on the movie turning out fairly well. Granted, it won't be awesome. You just CAN'T add everything that's in a book to a movie.

Here's a quote from her blog that may (or may not) interest some of you:

Movie's like Van Helsing help make me happy that I havn't signed a movie or t.v. deal. I do not want to leave the theatre to my book on screen, shaking my head, and saying, "Well, it was pretty." It's gotta be more than just visually pretty. Do not even get me started on how the vamps and werewolves walk and crawl up the walls. Everyone does it in the moves. I know it's stunning visually, but it's not logical. It's not good biology. Yeah, spiders, flies, bats, rats, mice, can climb walls, and sometimes across cielings, but not by magic. Their biomechanics allows it. They have claws or little spiny hairs on four limbs, or more. Geckos have sticky pads. You gotta have a way to stick to that wall. My vamps levitate and sometimes fly, but I see it as a type of energy use, that acts as lift to push against gravity. You don't just stroll along the wall and cieling. It is bad biology.

So many movies of late, just can't seem to resist a good visual, to hell whether it makes any sense. What happened to logic? What happened to research? What happened to thinking, why, or how, a thing works, not just can I do it. LORD OF THE RINGS were thinking man's movies. Of course, it was based on books where someone thought, but they could have been ruined so easily, and they weren't. I would love for someone to bring that kind of time and attention to my books. I would love to sit in a movie theatre in the dark and see my vision that closely followed on the screen. But I fear, greatly, that it will be like Van Helsing, pretty, visually appealing, and with the best of intentions, it will get away from the person who promised so much, who had every intention of doing the 'right' kind of movie, and I will come out of the dark, shaking my head, and saying, "Well, it was pretty." I don't think I could bear it.

There are only two ways to let Hollywood take your book and work it up to a movie or television show. First, you take the money and put the entire project out of your mind. It does not effect you. Second, you find someone that will put in writing in a contract what you want and need to feel secure. I've actually had one person willing to do that, but was told no studio would bank-roll it, because they wouldn't trust me, a writer, not to flake, and pull the plug if I had that much power. I am almost pathologically incapable of the first way, so number two, it is. But even if I could find someone to agree to it, and we could jump all the hurdles, it would mean that I would have to be much more involved in the movie process than any writer ever is, which no one will like, or allow, and I don't know if I could ride herd on a movie project and write my books. I might have to concentrate on the movie and put the books on hold while the movie got nursed into existence. My schedule doesn't really allow that kind of time off. I also don't know enough about the different jobs and skills that go into a movie. It's so much more complicated than most people relize. (Yes, I have started researching movies and how they are made, and how parts of them work. It's like writing a book by committee, but with other people doing the writing. Very odd.) I guess there is a third way. Someone in the movie business could convince me that they share my vision, will give me the written contract to prove that they can be trusted. It would have to be someone who had enough clout to protect the project all the way through the process. What I've learned is that no matter how sincere the movie people are, most of them do not have the clout to protect the baby. They mean well, and they will fight for it, for "our vision", but if they aren't a thousand pound gorilla, then someone else who is a thousand pound gorilla, will come along and force their vision on ours. Movies are ruled by the strong, or the lucky, or the rich. Strong is not the same as rich, though a lot of people in a lot of businesses mistake the two. I can't imagine how anyone would convince me to trust them. My background taught me at a tender age, to trust no one, and that the person smiling at your face, usually has something painful behind their back. More than a decade in the publishing industry sort of finished off my basic cynisim. Dealing with even the edge of Hollywood has sort of solidified it. Oh, well.

Tobitha


tankbbg

PostPosted: Sun Sep 26, 2004 4:18 pm


Well...yeah...I guess negativity isn't the way...
PostPosted: Sun Sep 26, 2004 4:20 pm


Well...yeah...I guess negativity isn't the way...

tankbbg


Neko_Kitsuni

PostPosted: Sun Sep 26, 2004 5:27 pm


Great quote! blaugh

Though I don't see how we're all being negative when we're saying pretty much the same thing she said... sweatdrop
PostPosted: Sun Sep 26, 2004 7:02 pm


I don't know that I'd want the Anita Blake series as a movie or tv series. If they did make a movie out of it, I think Alex Proyas should direct it. He was the guy who directed The Crow, and David J. Schow did the screenplay writing. I think they'd have to make it into an epic and run some of the books together though. Movies have a tendency to do a nosedive after the first one or two films leaving the others with massive plotholes, bad character development and whatnot. It's kind of like taking on Marvel's X-Men. They had to re-write a bunch of things to make the movie work that just didn't happen in the comic series. As a stand alone, I think X-Men is a well done movie series, but if you compare it to the comics then it becomes a headache.

If you turned it into a TV series it could either be really great or really horrible. You'd have the potential to do nice slow character development and really take your time with the stories. I think the guys that were in charge of Dark Angel the first year did a fairly good job and could really make the story work for that. If you turned it into an anime I think, Yoshiaki Kawajiri and Tai Kit Mak should be in charge of the project, they're the ones who did Vampire Hunter D: Bloodlust, and I think the animation team was excellent and could bring about the air of the AB series.

Those would be who I suggest, but I love the idea of keeping them as books better. I think my imagination and Hamilton's writing is a lot better of a match than TV/movies.

DravenAngel

Invisible Genius

10,200 Points
  • Invisibility 100
  • Bunny Hoarder 150
  • Alchemy Level 3 100

badlittlewashu

Wheezing Treasure-Seeker

7,850 Points
  • Peoplewatcher 100
  • Treasure Hunter 100
  • Signature Look 250
PostPosted: Wed Oct 06, 2004 7:31 am


I was talking to my friend about this the other day. We both agree that if they were turned into movies, then maybe some really good parts would be left out.

We both agree that her books would make a really good HBO series. I mean look at the shows they have on. Six Feet under, is a really good show and it has humor in it. I think that in a series they would have time to cover everything and still keep the good stuff wink wink left in the episodes.

Though I do agree that I would make a really cool anime. Well only with the right animation company.
PostPosted: Wed Oct 06, 2004 6:55 pm


Oh it would be great as an HBO series. That way the violence & sex wouldn't be cut out. It could be the sex of Sex & the City, the violence of the Sopranos, the paranormal activity of Carnival & the drama & comedy & death of Six Feet Under. It would be something for everyone biggrin .

Narniakat
Vice Captain


Rubyhawk

PostPosted: Tue Oct 19, 2004 2:11 pm


The only book of hers that I think they would be able to pull off would be Obsidian Butterfly. For some reason I can see that happening without it being terrible. All the rest I see easily falling apart.
Reply
Anita Blake Guild

Goto Page: 1 2 3 ... 4 5 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum