Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply The Final Fantasy VII Guild
Sephiroth: Good or Bad? (Possible SPOILERS) Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Mero Miroki

PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 11:28 am


Well If you think about it, wouldn't sephiroth be more of a Good Guy than a bad guy? I mean really... His goal was to bring everyone to 'the promised land' by making and overflow of the lifestream, which he would absorb and create it. And then again, The Weapons were the protectors of the planet, and they were protecting Sephiroth, so wouldn't that mean they they knew he was doing whats best for the Earth?

What do you think?
PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 11:35 am


his clone killed a chick that was praying, hes bad

prowlingmonkey


Mero Miroki

PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 11:39 am


But that was only so that his Plan for good wasnt stopped by Holy, in which Aerith was praying for... He's a good guy im telling ya! xd xp

And what about Cloud and the other AVALANCHE crew? They killed a ton of people to get to sephiroth! isn't that bad too?
PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 12:13 pm


Sometimes you have to sacrifice something to get where you need to be.

Ishu


cynicalpie

PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 12:29 pm


Mero Miroki
But that was only so that his Plan for good wasnt stopped by Holy, in which Aerith was praying for... He's a good guy im telling ya! xd xp

And what about Cloud and the other AVALANCHE crew? They killed a ton of people to get to sephiroth! isn't that bad too?


she was praying for HOLY, that doesn't sound evil, and if you stop that, how is that good?

and they killed people in self defense, not because they got in the way, well sort of...

bleh, sephiroth is about as good as he is cuddly, after all didn't he want to sail on this dead planet through the cosmos, or was advent children just lying....

anyway, anyone who has wings coming out of their tush (as he does in Kingdom hearts) i debate on their levels of goodness...lol
PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 2:28 pm


azure.eyes.kairi
Mero Miroki
But that was only so that his Plan for good wasnt stopped by Holy, in which Aerith was praying for... He's a good guy im telling ya! xd xp

And what about Cloud and the other AVALANCHE crew? They killed a ton of people to get to sephiroth! isn't that bad too?


she was praying for HOLY, that doesn't sound evil, and if you stop that, how is that good?

and they killed people in self defense, not because they got in the way, well sort of...

bleh, sephiroth is about as good as he is cuddly, after all didn't he want to sail on this dead planet through the cosmos, or was advent children just lying....

anyway, anyone who has wings coming out of their tush (as he does in Kingdom hearts) i debate on their levels of goodness...lol


Well comeon... if you were evil do you think that the Planets PROTECTORS would be protecting you? So he was a little corrupt on the whole "Become a God and make the world a better place" Sceme, but if someone was going to stop you from acheiving your goal wouldn't you want to stop them? in sephi's case that would be killing Aerith.

Mero Miroki


soadshuyin

PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 2:37 pm


The WEAPONS werent protecting Sepiroth, they were protecting the planet. They werent revived until Meteor had been summoned which would threaten the planets safety. And who summoned Meteor to damage the planet in order to become God? Sephiroth.

I dont know about you, but I dont view someone who is knowing he is going to kill many people in order to become a God as a good guy.
PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 2:49 pm


soadshuyin
The WEAPONS werent protecting Sepiroth, they were protecting the planet. They werent revived until Meteor had been summoned which would threaten the planets safety. And who summoned Meteor to damage the planet in order to become God? Sephiroth.

I dont know about you, but I dont view someone who is knowing he is going to kill many people in order to become a God as a good guy.
Well, yeah they were awakened by the Meteor. But If they were protecting the planet, wouldn't they go right for Sephiroth?

See what i mean? They went for Shinra, instead of the guy that was going to make a Huge Meteor crash into the planet.

Sephiroth did kill a lot of people, so what... If Someone tried to stop Cloud from killing Sephiroth, dont you think that he would kill that person? This goes back to the Aerith thing. Aerith was going to stop him, so he got her out of the way; by means of killing her.

Mero Miroki


El Portablay

PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 3:05 pm


i think he's both xp
PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 3:08 pm


Depends.
In the eyes and mind of Sephiroth himself, he would be a so called "good guy". JENOVA would say the same.
In the eyes and minds of Cloud and the gang of AVALANCHE, he is a "bad guy".
The planet would also see him as a bad guy, for trying to hurt it, and then take advantage of it's life force.

I, for one, would say Sephiroth's a mad man and should be stopped.

And ShinRa was sucking the life force out of the planet, for the use of Mako. So the WEAPONs went to stop ShinRa aswell as trying to take down Sephiroth. And ShinRa did to resistance and attack the WEAPONs, so they also did self-defense.
But well, to tell the truth, three of the WEAPONs didn't really do much to stop anything, really.
Ruby is lodged down into the sand, doing nothing, Emerald is swimming around in the sea and Ultima is just flying around.

Jetzudan


My name is Zen

PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 3:28 pm


True true...But I like Sephiroth so I forgive him xp
PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 3:41 pm


I think he is good.

Elise of Darkness


soadshuyin

PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 5:09 pm


Mero Miroki
soadshuyin
The WEAPONS werent protecting Sepiroth, they were protecting the planet. They werent revived until Meteor had been summoned which would threaten the planets safety. And who summoned Meteor to damage the planet in order to become God? Sephiroth.

I dont know about you, but I dont view someone who is knowing he is going to kill many people in order to become a God as a good guy.
Well, yeah they were awakened by the Meteor. But If they were protecting the planet, wouldn't they go right for Sephiroth?

See what i mean? They went for Shinra, instead of the guy that was going to make a Huge Meteor crash into the planet.

Sephiroth did kill a lot of people, so what... If Someone tried to stop Cloud from killing Sephiroth, dont you think that he would kill that person? This goes back to the Aerith thing. Aerith was going to stop him, so he got her out of the way; by means of killing her.


They went for Shinra because Hojo was shooting the Northern Crater, therefore causing damage to the planet. Sephiroth wasnt directly attacking the planet, so therefore wasnt deemed as the first threat to be taken care of. The meteor hurling towards the planet as well as the madman shooting highpowered mako at the planet as well were deemed as much more immediate ad accessible threat, since when the WEAPONs were released, the dropped Sephiroth into the center of the planet.
PostPosted: Mon Aug 07, 2006 5:28 pm


Mero Miroki
azure.eyes.kairi
Mero Miroki
But that was only so that his Plan for good wasnt stopped by Holy, in which Aerith was praying for... He's a good guy im telling ya! xd xp

And what about Cloud and the other AVALANCHE crew? They killed a ton of people to get to sephiroth! isn't that bad too?


she was praying for HOLY, that doesn't sound evil, and if you stop that, how is that good?

and they killed people in self defense, not because they got in the way, well sort of...

bleh, sephiroth is about as good as he is cuddly, after all didn't he want to sail on this dead planet through the cosmos, or was advent children just lying....

anyway, anyone who has wings coming out of their tush (as he does in Kingdom hearts) i debate on their levels of goodness...lol


Well comeon... if you were evil do you think that the Planets PROTECTORS would be protecting you? So he was a little corrupt on the whole "Become a God and make the world a better place" Sceme, but if someone was going to stop you from acheiving your goal wouldn't you want to stop them? in sephi's case that would be killing Aerith.


stop, yes, incapacitate, no

she was a little girl praying, you could choloroform her and all is well, after all mr. first class soldier is probably a LOT stronger than her

cynicalpie


[[AlexBCDEFG]]

PostPosted: Thu Aug 10, 2006 10:50 am


Mero Miroki
Well If you think about it, wouldn't sephiroth be more of a Good Guy than a bad guy? I mean really... His goal was to bring everyone to 'the promised land' by making and overflow of the lifestream, which he would absorb and create it. And then again, The Weapons were the protectors of the planet, and they were protecting Sephiroth, so wouldn't that mean they they knew he was doing whats best for the Earth?

What do you think?


I THINK HES BAD HE WANTED HIM AND HIS MOTHER TO GO TO THE PROMISED LAND NOT ANY1 ELSE
Reply
The Final Fantasy VII Guild

Goto Page: 1 2 [>] [»|]
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum