Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply The Versus Debate Guild
Pre-Mace General Grievous versus Darth Vader

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

What?

PostPosted: Wed Jun 28, 2006 3:47 pm


I'm trying to figure out which character (at their strongest) could come out on top.

"Pre-Mace" for the two of you that hasn't seen the Clone Wars, means before Mace crushed Grievous' chest, causing him to be the wheezing kitty cat that he was in Episode Three.
PostPosted: Wed Jun 28, 2006 5:07 pm


grivous never had the power of the force on his side as i remember, just by that darth should probobly win, even if he is only wielding one lightsaber.

your tight


Aona

PostPosted: Wed Jun 28, 2006 8:24 pm


Grievous is good - good enough to slaughter even Jedi Masters.

Vader is good - also good enough to slaughter Jedi Masters.

Grievous, however, does not have the force. Vader does. Since this is pre-Mace Grievous, Vader does the exact same chest crushing thing and whaddya know - it works just as well!
PostPosted: Thu Jun 29, 2006 2:05 pm


I understand where you're coming from when you mention Grievous' lack of force powers...

But he's taken on a number of Master Jedi at once and came out on top almost effortlessly.

He was trained by Duku to use fear and intimidation tactics to get the edge over a Jedi.

He also said that if he lost that edge, to retreat immediately. Grievous learned that the hard way against Mace.

So...

Could Grievous "get the drop" on Vader and shake him up enough to pull the win?

What?


Aona

PostPosted: Thu Jun 29, 2006 7:20 pm


Vader? Shaken?

rofl rofl rofl rofl rofl rofl rofl rofl rofl rofl
PostPosted: Sun Jul 02, 2006 11:04 am


if we are using post mace grevious, which vader do you mean? do you mean post burning vader (aka anakin skywalker with 3 limbs) or big black (im the jugernaut biatch!) vader with zero limbs?

MyRO sinX


hacker0102

PostPosted: Tue Jul 04, 2006 7:35 pm


Couldn't Vader just do the same thing that Windu did, rendering the General as weak as he was in the movie? I mean he does like to use the force, even on his own subordinates. So I'm gonna have to say Vader wins do to his power over the force.
PostPosted: Wed Jul 05, 2006 10:22 pm


hacker0102
Couldn't Vader just do the same thing that Windu did, rendering the General as weak as he was in the movie? I mean he does like to use the force, even on his own subordinates. So I'm gonna have to say Vader wins do to his power over the force.


well think about it people......... what did mace do BEFORE the chest crushing?........ thats right he had to expose the pretty lungs and heart and such...... I'm thinking the general's armor has some anti-force spray coating on it or soemthing.

StrikerCrimson


MyRO sinX

PostPosted: Mon Jul 10, 2006 1:34 pm


StrikerCrimson
hacker0102
Couldn't Vader just do the same thing that Windu did, rendering the General as weak as he was in the movie? I mean he does like to use the force, even on his own subordinates. So I'm gonna have to say Vader wins do to his power over the force.


well think about it people......... what did mace do BEFORE the chest crushing?........ thats right he had to expose the pretty lungs and heart and such...... I'm thinking the general's armor has some anti-force spray coating on it or soemthing.


im not sure you can get anti force spray coating lol.
PostPosted: Sat Jul 15, 2006 1:13 am


gunyo89
StrikerCrimson
hacker0102
Couldn't Vader just do the same thing that Windu did, rendering the General as weak as he was in the movie? I mean he does like to use the force, even on his own subordinates. So I'm gonna have to say Vader wins do to his power over the force.


well think about it people......... what did mace do BEFORE the chest crushing?........ thats right he had to expose the pretty lungs and heart and such...... I'm thinking the general's armor has some anti-force spray coating on it or soemthing.


im not sure you can get anti force spray coating lol.

That would be a little too convenient. There are, though, certain materials that cannot be affected by the force, though they are extremely rare and hard to find.

Aona


StrikerCrimson

PostPosted: Sun Jul 16, 2006 8:28 pm


Aona
gunyo89
StrikerCrimson
hacker0102
Couldn't Vader just do the same thing that Windu did, rendering the General as weak as he was in the movie? I mean he does like to use the force, even on his own subordinates. So I'm gonna have to say Vader wins do to his power over the force.


well think about it people......... what did mace do BEFORE the chest crushing?........ thats right he had to expose the pretty lungs and heart and such...... I'm thinking the general's armor has some anti-force spray coating on it or soemthing.


im not sure you can get anti force spray coating lol.

That would be a little too convenient. There are, though, certain materials that cannot be affected by the force, though they are extremely rare and hard to find.


well maybe thats what his body is made out of........ cause it would make sence........ and lets not also forget that the after mace general took on obi kanobie and nearly killed him! it was dumb luck that obi got his hand on a blaster and ALSO had to rip apart his armor.... I think greavis wins.... I mean he took on...... 3 or 4 jedi at the same time!
PostPosted: Fri Jul 21, 2006 8:47 pm


StrikerCrimson
hacker0102
Couldn't Vader just do the same thing that Windu did, rendering the General as weak as he was in the movie? I mean he does like to use the force, even on his own subordinates. So I'm gonna have to say Vader wins do to his power over the force.


well think about it people......... what did mace do BEFORE the chest crushing?........ thats right he had to expose the pretty lungs and heart and such...... I'm thinking the general's armor has some anti-force spray coating on it or soemthing.
A... what? "anti-force spray coating" I don't remember any comics or movies stating that Grievus had such a thing... So as far as I'm concerned, Vader wins with the force.

hacker0102


MyRO sinX

PostPosted: Wed Aug 02, 2006 12:38 pm


Aona
gunyo89
StrikerCrimson
hacker0102
Couldn't Vader just do the same thing that Windu did, rendering the General as weak as he was in the movie? I mean he does like to use the force, even on his own subordinates. So I'm gonna have to say Vader wins do to his power over the force.


well think about it people......... what did mace do BEFORE the chest crushing?........ thats right he had to expose the pretty lungs and heart and such...... I'm thinking the general's armor has some anti-force spray coating on it or soemthing.


im not sure you can get anti force spray coating lol.

That would be a little too convenient. There are, though, certain materials that cannot be affected by the force, though they are extremely rare and hard to find.


while i know there are materials which cancel out lightsabers i didnt know that there were materials that wernt effected by the force. well we know for sure that grevious isnt made of anti lightsaber alloys as he had 2 hands chopped of by kenobi
PostPosted: Wed Aug 02, 2006 2:43 pm


I think if Grievous got the drop on Vader then it would be over.

Grievous doesn't stand a chance against a Jedi/Sith when the element of surprise and intimidation are lost.

What?


hacker0102

PostPosted: Fri Aug 04, 2006 2:20 pm


What?
I think if Grievous got the drop on Vader then it would be over.

Grievous doesn't stand a chance against a Jedi/Sith when the element of surprise and intimidation are lost.
Though Grievous successfully got the drop on several jedi I doubt he could catch Vader off gaurd. Vader has a very good sense of awareness or danger... or whatever you want to call it. One example was when Anakin was talking to Obi 1, he sensed that Padme was in trouble from two large poisonous millipedes in Episode 2 (I think she was in the room below them).

I'm still convinced that Vader easily wins with the force on his side.
Reply
The Versus Debate Guild

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum