How would you propose to the AAY?

[Quiditch]

Self explanatory. <3

Be creative.  

[Scope Gambler]

First invite her to a concert, Near the end of the concert I would come out with a guitar and started to play This. Then during the solo, walk down to the crowd while kneeling on one leg and ask for her hand in marrage.  

[Rainbow Queef]

♫And I'm not sleeping now, the dark is too hard to beat...

I would take you out to the largest war currently going on in the world and we'd rampage around! Once I found the best potential spot, I'd spell out "Will you marry me?" from the random bodies of our enemies littered around.

And I'm not keeping now, the strength I need to push me...♫

 

[Quiditch]

I'd take you to the beach at night where I had already set up a hugggee bonfire with a blanket and a few drinks. AND that is where I would pop the question.

P.s: Guitarists are hot. :3  

[I-x Fallen Hero x-I]

I would take you on a hot air balloon, and in the middle of the ride, I would point to the distance where a plane would spell out "Will you marry me?" in the sky. As you'd turn around, I'd be on one knee with a ring held out to you.  

[HolyShitItsJosh]

We'd be drinking all night long, and on one knee I'll open a small box with a crappy ring made of tape inside and say, "Fallen.... will you be my bro?" Then proceed with an awesome fist pump.  

[Angel of the End]

Throw a brick through his bedroom window in the middle of the night with an attached note written on a napkin, "Will you marry me?"  

[Designer Hobo Style]

I'd pick her up by the muzzle on her face and hang her over a building and just say "Marry me."  

[I-x Fallen Hero x-I]

She'd wake up in a dark, almost pitch black room. As she looks around lazily, she'd realize that her hands were chained to the wall behind her, as were her legs. A TV would buzz on, and as the picture would become clear, a puppet-looking man colored white with rosy red cheeks would be seen watching her closely. After a moment of silence, the puppet would open his mouth and she'd hear, "Will you marry me."  

[Designer Hobo Style]

Similar, actually. He'd be naked and I'd be humping him and every time he said no, I'd take a knife out and run it through his skin and repeat "Marry me" every time.  

[thesilentcrimsonknight]

throws a knife at her but misses with a ring and and note tied it saying marry me. o.o  

[Designer Hobo Style]

I'd kidnap myself in the name of an evil ninja that also happens to be your childhood rival.  

[Quiditch]

I'd give her a box of chocolotes with only one piece of chocolate inside, when she would take a bite she would realize that there was a ring in it and then I'd show up and ask her to marry me. |:  

[Banshee Cupcake]

Hire a few friends to kidnap her rescue her and when I save her it turns into a giant engagement party and thats when I ask her.  

[Amras Tasatir]

Take her somewhere freezing so that she was forced to use me for warmth, then propose. twisted