Welcome to Gaia! ::

Deadest Warrior was okay when I watched it.

The only way something like that would happen is if we (fans) did it. 3nodding

I really like the idea of throwing out toku fights we would like to see and then discussing who we think would win. I used to be on a Toho forum that did that. A lot of the fight ideas turned into long and sometimes deep discussions.

Ah but what if its a kamen rider vs a kamen rider? Also there is one sentai that might win against any kamen rider..and that is Shinken Red.

It is kind of hard to figure out who would win in a grand battle like that.

Metal Hero has a lot of diversity but not enough to handle what the others can throw out and keep up with them.

Ultraman has power and size, but his time limit kind of screws him over since I can see many of these fights lasting longer than they are granted.

Super Sentai has power, but they need to work as a team to function on that level where as other toku can hold their own in most cases. Their best asset is the giant robots which stomp out the above two to me.

Kamen Rider wins, barely. To me they've always seemed more independent and slightly more creative in the workings of abilities, so they'd have an edge in most battles. The largeness of Ultraman and the mecha of Sentai are something riders don't really have consistently, but more and more they can handle giant monsters so I think they can take on the giants toe-to-toe and in some cases beat them.

Since Kamen Rider to me wins ground combat and can go on par with giant combat I think they'd win in the end.

I think i'll throw in my own cents here.... :
Even Super Sentai has "Basic Characters" that are potential powerhouses in fighting. I think those could take out most Kamen Riders, but would of course still be defeated Decade, and some of the other heavy-hitters.

Ultraman's moveability would indeed let him win over most over the big sentai mecha Robots, but a few of the later ones are really more agile in themselves, and they have firepower to boot.

Then, one might ask about the difference between Ultraman and Kamen Rider J.
Decade defeats J, could he do the same with Ultraman?

Speaking of wich, how would Decade fare against the Sentai Mechas? The answer might not be that obvious ..... ?

Essentially, it seems like Decade rules against all of the human-sized, but may be pawned by (some) Giant Robots.

Ultraman might pawn most or even all giant robots due to sheer greater mobility, but if he is too similar to J, he may still be pawned by Decade.

This may result in a Paper-Rock-Scissors effect, but with
Decade-Ultraman-Giant Mecha instead.

The way I see it with rangers having strong members is that they usually are only strong in conditions. Even the extra rangers who debut with strength behind them get swept up in needing the team eventually. I think they could take some riders, but in most cases a single rider from a show could be on par with a whole group of rangers so a group of riders from one show could take a group of rangers.

With the giant battles going on, Ultraman does have an edge but I still think his timelimit would screw him over in an extended fight and as Tiina said a number of sentai mecha can be quite mobile and strong themselves. I maybe just need to see newer ultramen who might not have it, but that timelimit just keeps coming back into my mind when picturing this sort of thing.

Kamen Riders might not have size and only a handful of late fight giant monsters, but I think a number of their stronger forms could handle it. Rising Mighty Kuuga's kick, Kabutos tachyon blast and a number of other attacks could really mess up a giant fighter, especially sentai mecha that need to be combined.
In turn, many giants just need simple attacks to knock out/destroy a rider. In my mind, however, if everyone's using their arsenal of abilities then riders have an edge. Almost every rider has a motorcycle which allows them to be speedy, powerful and a hard to hit target. So while a number of riders might get smashed to pieces by Ultraman and Mecha, I think enough of them have the firepower and speed to avoid attacks and take down large and easy to hit targets.

Tough call, however I agree ultimately with Itami

Size/Mecha
In terms of sheer size it would toss up between Sentai and Ultraman. However with Ultraman's time limit on Earth, Sentai would more then likely win a drawn out battle, however this is also one of their weaknesses which I'll address next paragraph. Kamen Riders aren't really included in this, since only a few have access to giant forms or abilities strong enough that can over come this obstacle. Metal Heroes are out since only a few of them had mecha were largely solitary fighters.
*Don't quote me on Metal Heroes, I've only know what I've learned form Beetleborgs and what I've read on Wikipeidia when I made this guild. sweatdrop

Diversity in Powers/Techniques
This is a tough one.

Sentai have multiple techniques/powers, usually with them having two piece. However like their mecha, they have to be together to be fully effective and when they're not, they usually are defeated if the opponent isn't a run of the mill grunt. Hesei-era Kamen Riders usually have multiple abilities even in their basic form(s). However, Kamen Riders usually work alone and even when two of them (maybe one more) work together, they can still be out numbered if their opponent is sufficently skilled/powerful/has numbers. However, when Riders use their more powerful forms or think strategically, the will often come out victorious.

Breakdown:
-Size-
Ultraman: Great power, short time limit.
Sentai: Multiple forms, no time limit.
Winner---Sentai

Technique/Abilites
Sentai: Have only a few abilities as individuals. Strong in groups.
Kamen Rider: Has multiple forms/powers.
Winner---Kamen Rider.



@Rider Punch: Good idea. Make it. mad