|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 7:14 pm
Of course, i enjoyed it. (White'd out by a ninja, highlight to read~) i especially enjoyed watching Castiel gorge himself with White Castle! : D "These make me real happy. " : ) Adorable. I liked how they named the episode after the movie dean was in. it reminded me of how in fallen idols they made a reference to 'house of wax.' : p. I wish dean would have had a hunger. that would have been interesting.... anyway, what would your hunger be for? unfortunately, i would be one of those losers who crave love : ( lol, ima tad lonely, but its cool. i will try not to drink anybody's blood this valentine's day. Xp Ohmigosh i have waited forever to see a zombie episode on supernatural, and i will not be able to see it until march freakin' 25th!!!! URGH! Dxx
|
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 7:41 pm
I LOVED this episode soooo much.
Cas was the comic relief but he was also on the serious side too. Perrrrfect balance for him. When he was on the phone with Dean, haha genius.
DEAN, OOOHMAHGOSH, I love him so much. "You're dead inside" eek
Sadness, and at the end when he pretty much brokedown...I was on the verge of breaking down too. So touching. I just wanted to give him a big ol'hug. and kiss.
Poor Sammy, he was doing so well with the whole not drinking demon blood thing, but I guess, in all fairness, it wasn't his fault.....per say.
And can I just say that the famine dude totally scared the holy hell outta me! He was soo creepy!
This episode was so well written, ahhh finally! One that I really enjoyed! Comedy, drama,...and other stuff that I can't think of right now!
WIN. heart
I still wanna kiss Dean and make him happeh.
EDIT: My bad! I thought this was titled, "My bloody valentine: Spoliers!" Just realized it wasn't. I whited out everything. sweatdrop redface
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 7:50 pm
*Covers eyes*
PLEASE READ OUR SPOILER POLICY. D:
We still consider this to be spoilers as it hasn't even shown
in areas of the states.
If you got a heart, please white it out~ ; 3;
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Thu Feb 11, 2010 10:30 pm
OKAY SO I'VE SEEN IT. AND HOLY SHITTTTTTTT-
white time~
OH s**t. This episode seriously brought out my squeamish side...
I couldn't even watch the first scene, I had to curl up and have
my little sister tell me when it was over. Ugh, remind me to stay away
from guys who are into biting. Yuck.
I LOVED Misha so much in this, but I don't think I'll be
able to eat red meat for a very long time. I really think watching this
episode while recovering from a stomach bug was a bad idea. 
What else? The angst was top-notch! JENSEN...
he never fails to blow my mind at his skills. Ho`damn!
I almost feel selfish knowing of his awesome-ness and not sharing it
with every single person I know.
Jared is on a roll! He does Sam so well, I couldn't imagine it any other way.
Gah, and here I thought we were finally over this demon-blood deal...
Poor Sammy though, he was a real trooper. Extra points for cute Castiel,
who was totally hovering over Sam at the end there.
Ah, the end... with Dean... I BAWLED. CRIED. SOBBED.
For me, as the oldest sibling, I feel like I can almost empathize with Dean.
Sometimes I feel like I have to do everything I can to protect my siblings,
and even though I don't have to fend off demons and the DEVIL,
I still feel helpless when I can't stop them from being hurt.
I want to take away their problems-! Much like Dean, I suppose.
So yup.... The 25th can't come soon enough.
Are there usually this many hiatuses? This is the first season
I'm actually watching on TV, since I just got into it over the summer... o:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Feb 12, 2010 3:10 am
No_eight Okay, this is like, really long and isn’t really about any specific scenes because I'm too tired to remember them right now. I'll get to that stuff tomorrow, but first:
IS JIMMY ALIVE OR NOT!? I SWEAR IT IS KILLING ME WITH THIS VAGUE ‘WE CAN GO EITHER WAY BECAUSE WE’RE NOT BEING SPECIFIC JUST IN CASE’ CRAP. MY BRIAN HURTS. I WILL PAY SOMEONE TO FIGURE OUT WHETHER OR NOT HE IS STILL THERE SO I CAN HAVE THAT INFORMATION AND MOVE ON. IF HE’S ALIVE I’LL FIGURE SOMETHING OUT TO SETTLE MY PROBLEMS WITH THAT. AND IF HE’S DEAD THEN LET ME MOURN AND CONTINUE ON WITH MY LIFE. I SWEAR, I LOVE THE GUY I REALLY, REALLY DO BUT IT WILL JUST MAKE EVERYTHING SIMPLE FOR MY BRAIN IF HE’S DEAD OR PERHAPS GOD FITTED CASTIEL WITH A REPLICA OF AN EMPTY JIMMY MEAT SUIT AND SENT (REAL) JIMMY BACK TO HIS FAMILY. THE FORMER MAKES ME REALLY HAPPY. I LIKE THAT ONE. GO WITH THAT. I KNOW I’M GOING OVERBOARD WITH CAPS BUT SERIOUSLY. BRAIN. HURTING. LOTS. FIX IT SHOW. JUST TELL ME!! D:
I want Jimmy to have a happy ending, true, but having him still within Castiel (naughty) makes things too complicated for me. That and from what he has said about it, being a vessel is happy-fun-times. From what we know it’s painful and very distressing. I want Jimmy to at least be at peace (if that’s what he truly receives) in death rather than that. And it pops up rather confusing plot holes for me as well. Whoever resurrected Castiel, why the hell (possibly literally) would they bring Jimmy’s soul along as well!? That seems a bit unnecessary. If Castiel’s powers are diminishing, how does he stay in a body already occupied? Wouldn’t that be rather complicated? Most of all, Castiel specifically stated that he’s mortal in 1214. “Practically human” as meaning as close to being human as he could be with not actually being born as such. Um…Jimmy? And I know that we can’t really take 1214 universe as complete continuality-wise cannon because of Michael and Dean and Sam and Lucifer and Zachariah just proving a point and saying “yes” and blah, blah, blah. But that timeline is still a timeline however alternate. Nothing really changed other then Dean not saying yes and Sam did. So Castiel becoming mortal in five years (hopefully not that much) seems to be the road he’s on. How is it that two people are occupying one body? CONFUSING SHOW IS CONFUSING! MAKE IT STOP!
That’s one of the biggies that set me off of a perfectly enjoyable hour that I ended up not loving as much as I should have. It really doesn’t have anything to do with the episode (well, mostly) because THAT I LOVED TO CANNIBAL BITS. But there was an awkward weight that settled on me during the watch. This was one of maybe two other times I was able to watch the show on our really good television. Most of the time I watch it in the dining room because Fringe and CSI (neither of which even compares to Supernatural in awesomeness but my parents disagree) are on at the same time and our DVR doesn’t record more than two at a time. So I was lucky tonight. Sort of. It just so happened to be the night my father had off earlier then normal, so not only did I have to wait an hour to watch it there was a very awkward atmosphere when I did. My father was in the other room but I knew he was listening in and my mom was on her laptop next to me and my brother was sitting at my other side, drawing. Everyone was watching my show. You’d think I’d be happy.
You ever pee in public? Yeah, neither have I but I hear it’s rather embarrassing and makes things very uncomfortable for ‘the performance’. That’s how it felt watching the show with my parent’s beady judgmental eyes and soft scoffing comments. I seriously could care less about what they think about my show, really- well except my mother but that has to do with being a hypocrite and her up-turned-nose, a whole ‘nuther conversation. But for some reason I feel like my show and the process of watching it shouldn’t be on display like that, it’s something a bit more private to me. Like porn.
It would be real fun to watch it with other people who actually want to, that I would love because I naturally love sharing things that I enjoy. However, I’ve been watching Supernatural alone, just me and the TV for so long that it’s become something private. I yelp and giggle and squee to myself, comment on things that I like and didn’t like and such but, like peeing in public, it gets really awkward doing that stuff when people are intruding their presence. Idk, perhaps I’m being a bit of a stickler, but I really didn’t like having to explain things to an exacerbated, half listening mom who is outwardly expelling her distaste or fast forwarding the really good parts because my little brother is in the same room. I DIDN’T CRY WHEN DEAN CRIED AND YOU KNOW SOMETHING IS WRONG WITH ME THERE! If I had been in the dining room, alone clutching my pillow I would have. If I had been at my computer in my room I would have. But because of the audience the mood just never hit me. I feel like I missed out on that. It makes me pissed. Not to say I didn’t feel like it or that I didn’t feel for Dean, the scene just didn’t sucker punch me like it should of. Would of, under different circumstances.
Other case in points. Castiel isn’t the same. This puts me in a weird place because I like and yet I don’t. I don’t know what to do with it. I want character development for sure but it feels like his whole personality is starting to change and I want my lil’ angel to stay the way he is! ; 3 ; Perhaps this is how parents feel when their children grow up. On the one hand: YAY! On the other: NO! I’m most likely being paranoid and doing that thing where I think I’m seeing into the writers minds but really not. I hope that’s the case because we’ve already lost head-tilting!Cas and I’m still morning him. I want him to grow but not at the cost of what made me love him to begin with. So, yeah, paranoid insecure moment that I needed to share.
Oh Sam. My love for you was going back to its endless reaches and bounds and then you did stuff. But I have to say they handled this much better than they did in season four. He was actually sympathetic with his addiction instead of being the stupid a*****e (sorry, Sammy I love you but it’s true) that he was for a year and a half that made me discontinue giving him cookies. I actually muttered “Oh, Sam.” too. Please don’t go darkside again, love. There’s a plushy Cas!teadybear in it for you! OH AND HE CALLED FOR DEAN AND CAS IN THE PANIC ROOM. IDK WHY THAT MAKES ME SO HAPPY BECAUSE THE WHOLE DETOX THING SHOULDN’T DO THAT BUT IT DID. HE CALLED FOR CAS TO HELP HIM BECAUSE THEY’RE BFFS NOW! < 3 (but Castiel isn’t an enabler so it didn’t work)
Dean. :sniff: That whole emo-your-dead-inside-crap was kind of crap and heart breaking all at once. Oh show how do you do that? Dean has his BFF angel and his brother getting along and Bobby’s his replacement daddy that beats out old daddy (sorry John, luvya but still) he has the perfect dysfunctional, co-dependent family right in front of him WHAT DO YOU MEAN HE’S EMPTY INSIDE!? This whole ‘Dean has no drive, no motivation, just apathy’ thing is bugging me because, while it works for the show, I don’t like it. I know it sound selfish but I don’t like Dean not giving a s**t anymore. And from a writers stand point, it’s going to bite them in the a** in the long run. The more Dean becomes apathetic the more apathetic an audience becomes to him. It was the same reason I stopped watching House and that I hate the Mentalist. Characters that don’t care aren’t relatable. They don’t inspire sympathy or empathy they just make me want to kick the s**t out of them. They become annoying and I never, EVER, thought that Dean would walk the possibility of being annoying to me. That’s why the end scene was important but at the same time it also had an inevitability about it. Like he’s at the end of his rope and if he goes any farther he’s really not going to be able to care anymore.
That sucks, major. 1214!Dean won’t carry a story. Addicted!Sam makes me bitchy. Human!Cas makes me sob over the loss of a character I loved. I don’t like where this is all headed. Now, I’m not saying that I’m going to quite the show THAT IS s**t TALK RIGHT THAR. I absolutely hate it when fans ditch the ship before it sinks and ya’ know what? Even if it does sink I’m going right down with it! I was there from the beginning I’m going to be there from the very end. I have never invested so much time and thought and emotion into a show before and ******** it if I’m letting that go to waste. All I’m saying is that the place that the characters are going is one I’m wary of and yet I’ll follow them there anyways.
Okay, well I know this isn’t a proper review or anything. It was just a ramble of thoughts that show made me think. Thinky-thoughts are now off my chest and I can dream of Team Freewill as I sleep in bliss. Tommorow I'll do it right. Oh and: NOM, NOM, NOM!!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Feb 12, 2010 8:02 am
I THOUGHT JIMMY WAS ALREADY DEAD!?
But anyway, I wish they picked another fast food place other than White Castle for Cas to gorge himself with. White Castle is horrible.
And I loved the first scene. I don't know why. I'm weird like that. I kind of wished all the other deaths were like that.
Also: I wanted to see that happy Cupid again. He was annoying but I liked him.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Feb 12, 2010 9:10 am
So, I guess everyone is in agreement, that this episode was OSSUM!
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Feb 12, 2010 10:38 am
I always assumed Jimmy was still in there. o:
I mean, we haven't really seen any of the body-wearing characters
be in vessels that are empty-
the closest was brunette Ruby, but the person was technically there,
just in a coma. Can they be in vessels that are empty?
I'm not even sure.
Eight is ttly right though- Sam calling out for Dean and Cas
was epic and ten kinds of adorable.
I think Dean's apathy is understandable,
he's so tired of caring so much, of having to be the strong one,
and he probably hates the fact that his world is slipping away
right in front of his eyes, his Sammy is suffering because of
the damn Apocalypse that they both helped bring into being.
Honestly, I was so scared for a second there at the end,
I thought Dean was going to say yes. ; 3;"
I think this will be temporary though, something will knock him out it.
(I'm hoping an intervention from Sam and Cas. <3)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Feb 12, 2010 10:49 am
Can I unwhite now as we have a spoiler warning up?
I think they chose White Castle for Cas on purpose.
Think about it.
Heaven, big white, fluffy clouds?
A big white castle in the sky type thing?
Or that's my thoughts.
I'm all for starting a campaign to get Ackles a damn Golden Globe/Emmy or what the hell ever else right now.
s**t, even an Oscar.
I don't care that it's not a movie.
He's absolutely incredible, continually blowing me away, it seems a crime that people don't get a chance to see how good he actually is, that he isn't being acknowledged for his performances.
His final scene was completely heartbreaking.
A DAMN good episode, dark, disturbing, funny and correct use of cast members.
Win.
I loved Cas in this as well.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Feb 12, 2010 10:59 am
Ok, this revfiew is kinda of incomplete, I dont really have the time to expand on this shorthand review i wrote, I'll come back later, and either adress peoples comments, or I'll edit it and expand it if people have not replyed to it.
I was not as happy with this episode as many of you were. Sure it had its moments, But my biggest, biggest problem with it was the introduced another horsemen and killed him in one episode. That really just gets on my nerves.
They gave little time for famine to really do his thing, Yes he was creepy, but his biggest plot advancing trait was, "Dean is dead inside" When I was wathcing the episode with my brother, and the normal crowd, my first comment was "Deans soul is gone" thats why he has no hunger. But instead they went with "your dead inside" What does that even mean? As we all know Dean is never dead inside he just keeps things bottled up, they always come pooring to the surface sooner or later, and so I really think the Whole being dead inside thing was really a coop out because the writters couldn't setlle on one thing dean was crave more then another.
I felt the episode was just to anti climatic, yes lot of rising action but the climax was kinda of lack luster, I dont blame this on the acting because it was good.
Dean played hardball like normal, Sam got back to his old evil roots, and Castiel Got to show more of his monotone humor, twas great.
There were a couple great lines that made me Lol, here they are:
"Thats how they greet."
"Well I don't like it."
"No one does."
"How could they do something like that, Eat each other...to death."
"Dude You just punched a Cupid."
"No I just punched a d**k!"
All in all I was not to happy with this episode, I just feel like they are going to crash way to much plot line on us in the last couple episodes, seeing as they are doing what seems like everything in their power to keep as much of it from us as possible for as long as possible.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Feb 12, 2010 11:03 am
Indulge [In Words]
I mean, we haven't really seen any of the body-wearing characters
be in vessels that are empty-
the closest was brunette Ruby, but the person was technically there,
just in a coma. Can they be in vessels that are empty?
I'm not even sure.
Technacally Ruby was in an empty body, they pulled the plug and she was flatlined for a few seconds meaning the body had no life. then ruby jumped inside, and she is even qouted as saying "There is no one in here but me."
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Feb 12, 2010 11:34 am
Draconous07 Indulge [In Words]
I mean, we haven't really seen any of the body-wearing characters
be in vessels that are empty-
the closest was brunette Ruby, but the person was technically there,
just in a coma. Can they be in vessels that are empty?
I'm not even sure.
Technacally Ruby was in an empty body, they pulled the plug and she was flatlined for a few seconds meaning the body had no life. then ruby jumped inside, and she is even qouted as saying "There is no one in here but me."
Hmmm. I don't know though. o:
Because demon-possessed people seem to live
through all sorts of impossible situations, like falling three stories.
I think it could be entirely possible that, when Ruby possessed the body,
she may have "healed" the girl.
What if they need the vessel to be alive?
Also, don't forget,
War was also conquered in one episode. o:
So, Famine being taken out this quickly isn't that odd.
The show does focus on being a different horror show each week-
they have some drawn out plots, but they still stick to that mentality.
Though it does bring up the question of if Famine is really gone or not.
Did they take his ring? Could he possibly come back if they didn't?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Fri Feb 12, 2010 11:48 am
a walking blasphemy Can I unwhite now as we have a spoiler warning up? I think they chose White Castle for Cas on purpose. Think about it. Heaven, big white, fluffy clouds? A big white castle in the sky type thing? Or that's my thoughts. I'm all for starting a campaign to get Ackles a damn Golden Globe/Emmy or what the hell ever else right now. s**t, even an Oscar. I don't care that it's not a movie. He's absolutely incredible, continually blowing me away, it seems a crime that people don't get a chance to see how good he actually is, that he isn't being acknowledged for his performances. His final scene was completely heartbreaking. A DAMN good episode, dark, disturbing, funny and correct use of cast members. Win. I loved Cas in this as well. yea for real. i forgot about the whole spoiler thing, i was just excited and tired.... my bad.
and i definitely see the connection now between white castle and heaven. lol X)
dean should win some kind of award. he is an amazing actor. i agree, his last scene was heart wrenching. maybe if he gets into more movies, you know, makes himself more public, he could definitely get an oscar. 3nodding
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Feb 13, 2010 11:07 am
Why is everything whited out? If you say there are spoilers in the title of the thread you don't have to white everything out in the content. It's pretty obvious there are spoilers if it's a freaking episode discussion.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Danielle Metallicar Chase Crew
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Posted: Sat Feb 13, 2010 12:25 pm
The thread title didn't originally say spoilers,
So things were white'd out. >>"
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Reply
![Indulge [In Words]'s avatar](https://a1cdn.gaiaonline.com/dress-up/avatar/ava/8e/25/2d29d7f550258e_flip.png?t=1435560232_6.00_01)
