Welcome to Gaia! ::

Alright so the new Supernatural in my opinion was good for the first half, then it kinda just fell off. I thought the opening was genius, that is the kinda of acting I love jarred doing, a little socially ackward, and funny. Jarred as an actor has great control over his body and can act very funny just in his movements which made the begining a joy to watch.

"Hello my good man i'd like to purchase an alcoholic beverage, i'm 26 as you can see by my lincence."
"Are we talking sex?" "Sure I'd love to have the sex with you"

I also enjoyed the few places where gary talked about how hot he was.

It also did me justice to see gary being sam, he fit so naturally with dean (As many of the charactors in supernatural do.) For a moment I wished a part of sam wanted to be more like dean. and You could see the look in deans eyes when he felt like he and his brother were not so different. Like there was no way this kid is evil, i mean he is eating a bacon cheeseburger with a fried egg on top, and hes drinking with me, not alone in some dark corner where he can sneak up on me in the night and talk to me in a drunken stuper about how sad everything is.

The Witch hunt was kinda pointless, all it did was give us doubt as to why this kid wants to kill dean, and it burned up and good 5-10 minutes time i think could have been used more intellegently

the episode pretty much died when sam was captured and that kid summoned the demon. the rest of the episode played out pretty boring, but the demon did do exactly want I said. The first thing i said when i saw that it was a body switch episode. (Could not tell from the preview) was "Man they should have put this episode further in the season cause right now that kid could give sams body away to Lucifer without even knowing what he did." And sure enough a demon tried to do with.

the episode did close pretty good, the kid didn't get hurt, he felt his crappy life was a little better, and dean realized he likes sammy just the way he is.

"Did he really have a good life?"
"No, that kids life sucked a**"

And so did the tail end of the episode.

Again I feel like so many possibilities were missed on this episode, being put in the position they were in so many worse things could have happened to the brothers and given us a chance to see where this season might be headed. So really two episodes have passed and we are no closer to advancing the plotline then we were before christmas. I just think that they could have used that demon the kid summoned to help further us on Lucifer and Sam, and maybe even tell us more about why Dean has a contract on his head.

All in all it was worth watching once, and i'll watch it again, at least the first part. Not the best episode of the season, nor the worst, it started great and had potential but turned out to be just alright.

6.75 out of 10

I totally loved Sam in the begining too. My mom was watching it with me and was like, "what the heck is going on with Sam?" haha.

But this one to me is my least favorite of the season so far. But like Indu said it did point out some good things like, the demons want Dean dead and so on.

I also agree that I want them to be more brotherly like they were in the first seasons but I mean who can blame them for how the act they now since they BOTH started the apocalypse.

Everyone in the show conveniently forgets that DEAN is just as responsible as SAM in the starting of all of it. Both of them didn't mean too but they did.

I was under the assumption that this ep was of Sam and Dean switching bodies, which I think would have been more effective. Those kids still could have tried to kill Dean but oops! Sam is really in Deans body and yada yada Lucy would have been mad if they killed Sam because Dean in Sams body would have told him 'HELL NO YOU AINT GETTIN' IN HERE!" and Lucy would have been out of luck.

I think I confused myself, if I confused anyone else sorry. I'm not too good at explaning things but hopefully you get what I sayin' lol.

But this episode was nice to show off Sam, we've been seeing a lot of Dean lately so it's Sammy turn. But I did miss Cas horribly.

BUT the preview for next weeks show was SWEEEEET because we know Cas will be there and Sammy gets to see his MOM!! Really excited about next weeks ep fo' sho'.

At first I was slightly apprehensive about the episode, but I liked it overall. I do think it wound down by the end, but yeah the "I would love to have the sex with you" was just Awesome. rofl

One thing, I was surprised that Dean didn't notice that it wasn't Sam right off. I mean, I know it's a little hard to believe that someone else could be in your brothers body, but come on!!

Oh and another thing... when they switched back into their normal bodies, does anyone else think it was a bit too simple... I mean they just smoked it out.

I don't think the witch thing was pointless, in fact it's very normal. They were working the job when this happened, it would have been weird if they were just randomly there.

I didn't like the conflict either... I mean that's what the entire last season was about... I'd like this to be were they're getting to be brotherly again.

And I miss Cas also! That's TWO episodes he hasn't been in!

And why was Sam saying the Garry's life sucked? Wasn't he as much of a geek as this guy?

I totally agree as well that Dean should have known that he wasnt Sam the minute he decided to order a burger instead of his healthy Shake salade..... and when he was all juiced up on killiing that ghost... This was not a good episode for Dean...

Are we actually criticizing Kripke? That's like....saying "Jesus was great and all but you know he could have done a better job staying alive." You just don't do it xp

I'm going to have to agree with you Vee. I really don't pay attention to who writes these ep's besides Kripke, if he does i'll notice.

But if she wrote those episodes then yeah, those are some of my NOT favorites, except the monster at the end of this book.

It's just this one dissapointed me in many ways because I think of what it COULD have been rather than what it was.

you guys complain and type alot -.-