Welcome to Gaia! ::

If you need a judge, post your requests here. If you are a judge, watch this thread and post when you go off to help someone with their fight (to prevent multiple judges from flocking to one fight, and so I can keep track of who does what later on).

Requests should include: The parties involved and a link to the page where it's all happening.

Please note that you are never required to have a judge. Judges are a backup you should call when arguments pop up. This is fast-moving, so even if you think a judge is making an unfair call, as long as it's not absurdly biased, please go with it. That said, judges should never judge their own or teammate's fights.

Also, please don't call judges if you are fighting a robot. Robots have full authority over their own fights.

I Want a ******** JUDGE NOW! Brennsa engaged in an illogical course of action, used his technology in ways in which it wouldn't work and just left without bothering to see what counter arguements we could come up against his point. That is in any consideration dishonest role playing. From the begining you will see that we of Knights of Fortune are taking things as realisticly as we can possibly be in this rp, we expect similar from those we rp with. And in order to do so the actions of people must make logical sense considering what abilities and equipment they have. Brennsa has denied us that.

Sorry, forgot to include the link, it begins to the bottom of the second page and spills over to the third.
http://www.gaiaonline.com/guilds/viewtopic.php?t=1788228&page=2

Free reign to powergame you mean.

Dude, I don't know what you're complaining about. You were unclear with your descriptions, but that doesn't really matter, seeing as Macro has a radar. I included my leaving post, and I clearly said where I was going. I put two posts in that thread, and you didn't follow.

Stop this, you completely abused player knowledge, or else are willing to use abilities you don't have. Radar is not capable of detecting from the angle the bottom of the stairs would mean.

In my opinion, I'd say Brennsa just doesn't understand the principles of sonar, and didn't pay close attention to the layout of the room. If robots didn't have full authority to judge their own fights, I'd say that Brennsa would have to decide if he wanted to climb up the stairs to see them and get shot at, or if he just didn't go in to look. Feel free to tell him I said so.

I was wondering if anyone said anything to this yet, but...

Sonar doesn't quite work like that. But if he didn't climb up the stairs, he'd still be able to tell that they were there because they were moving about. And sonar operates on sound, moving produces sound, and so on...

Still, he has no idea how sonar works. Just drop it and go.